Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want a stranger at Christmas?

816 replies

Oneeyedreindeer · 18/12/2022 22:15

My mother and brother were due to come to my house for Christmas. I am married with 3 DC, one of who is a young baby. Last week he randomly said he has a friend from abroad coming to stay for a month and if I don’t invite him he will be alone on Christmas Day.

i explained I don’t want a stranger there and it changes the dynamics with small children/breastfeeding etc. he is insisting I could meet the friend beforehand. He is like a dog with a bone and won’t drop it and keeps bringing it up/poor friend will he all alone etc etc. I’ve been clear that if he can’t come as he needs to be with his friend that’s fine and now I feel very mean indeed. But AIBU? I just think it would be very awkward indeed and I do also think there’s an element of my brother wanting to park up for some free/food drink with his friend - he suggested bringing his games consoles “for DC to play” although DC are 4 and under.

OP posts:
Coucous · 19/12/2022 12:37

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

ArabianLeopardCub · 19/12/2022 12:33

I have always tried to be the 'have you eaten yet?' type of person. My parents were always very welcoming inclusive hosts. It results in so many rich and diverse relationships and experiences. In this circumstance I would be welcoming to the friend. Put yourself in his shoes. I cannot imagine going to stay with a friend and not being welcomed in this scenario. It is so cold.

SpicyFoodRocks · 19/12/2022 12:29

OP I don’t think you should have to host at all. Your brother should host at his.

I am quite surprised at how scared people are on here though. When I think of a stranger, the mental image I have is somebody that walks in off the street or a random person in the shop. Whilst I do not know all the friends of my parents or family or other friends, I do not view them in the same way as a ‘stranger’. I would see their friendship with somebody I know as a kind of ‘reference’ which means they are less likely to be a serial killer or paedophile or thief.

What I find bizarre are the comments that assume a friend of their brother would be putting their young children and possessions at risk. I am so glad I do not live with this level of fear, anxiety and paranoia and no regrets that I have not subjected my children to this level of overprotectiveness and claustrophobic existence. They are now confident young people who can talk well to ‘strangers’.

Anyway, my main reason not to have the brother there is that it would alter the relaxed dynamics of the day. Many of the other reasons on here are valid too. Don’t feel guilty if you decline OP. You are doing nothing wrong.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 12:28

INACGMOOH · 19/12/2022 11:58

🤣

I'm on the app. It shows in the filters.

Oh. Tidy!

Flapjackquack · 19/12/2022 12:27

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 19/12/2022 12:03

I have to say my favourite part was your incredulity that the friend would book a holiday knowing full well it was CHRISTMAS, despite him coming from a country that doesn’t particularly celebrate it.

I’m pretty sure it’s quite well known that Christmas is a big event in Britain though, right? And if you’re thinking of visiting a country for an entire month, it’s the kind of thing you might check out first?

Well yes but to what extent? I am going to a European country to stay with friends next year. I know that there is a festival specific to that region of the country and there is a two day celebration with food and most shops will be shut. I haven't researched the minutiae of how every family celebrates as I have assumed my friend is ok with us coming over those dates having agreed them. The onus was on OP's brother to check it was ok before telling his friend he could come but I wouldn't expect a foreign guest to know the ins and outs of a UK Christmas which just from this thread is different for everyone. The whole world isn't tuned into the UK, we even celebrate on a different day to most of Europe. The Chinese friend will also have restricted internet in China too.

Pothoswithasparkle · 19/12/2022 12:26

Legallypinkish · 19/12/2022 12:20

It’s a tough one. When my brother was a student he brought his two housemates to the family Christmas as they we’re going g to be alone. It was all a bit uncomfortable to be honest (for them not for us), they didn’t speak any English and I think they were really overwhelmed by the amount of people there and the general chaos around the table. Does the friend actually want to come?

Two people are not alone.
1 person is alone

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 12:26

Flapjackquack · 19/12/2022 11:33

Wow just wow. Are you a school teacher by any chance because you sound like you are lecturing a child. @INACGMOOH has been no ruder than Lydia you just happen to agree with Lydia. You don’t get to police the thread.

Quoth @Flapjackquack, busily donning her very own WPC cap. 🙄😂

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 12:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

May I ask you to pm OP's DB & ask her to email your comment to him?

He really needs to see it.
Because he has no intention of missing his sister's xmas dinner, let alone caring & sharing for his friend.
Instead, he is cheerfully manipulating OP by telling her he'll leave HIS GUEST home alone, & come solo.

#BeKind DB!

Legallypinkish · 19/12/2022 12:20

It’s a tough one. When my brother was a student he brought his two housemates to the family Christmas as they we’re going g to be alone. It was all a bit uncomfortable to be honest (for them not for us), they didn’t speak any English and I think they were really overwhelmed by the amount of people there and the general chaos around the table. Does the friend actually want to come?

hiyaqwerty · 19/12/2022 12:18

I know what you mean by changing the dynamic by having a stranger over when you have young kids. In my household my kids take a while to warm up to a stranger, sometimes won't even warm to them at all, it ends with them misbehaving, refusing to go in to the main room, sit at the table, eat their food and just stresses me out.
I think your brother wants a cooked meal by someone else which is why he is insisting on you inviting his friends. they both can cook a Xmas meal for themself and then play Xbox instead of coming round to yours.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 12:17

INACGMOOH · 19/12/2022 11:23

🤣🤣 Nicely styled out!! 👏

Seconded.

Brava, @Thereisnolight!

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 12:16

INACGMOOH · 19/12/2022 11:14

Because I'm guessing he'd rather be with his family. Coz it's Christmas.

Does this mean that anyone being a guest at Xmas is freeloading?

No.

It means anyone who invites a guest to stay WITH HIM for December, totally fails to plan for how xmas day might go, waits until a week before xmas to instruct his sister that if (she doesn't)/I don't invite him he will be alone on Christmas Day, refuses to accept her 'no', continues the pressure, assumes he can sit around gaming all day, never contributes food, money or effort, is freeloading.

The clue is in your own word - "guest". ie invited, not imposed.

Funnily enough, I'm already keener on chap from China than DB. If forced to choose ... 😁

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 19/12/2022 12:13

If her brother would like to spend all day gaming with his mate, he can stay at his house and sort his own bloody food out.

Since when did people become such doormats?

I'd take an educated guess in suggesting they're not. They can nominate a stranger online for doormattery as a bit of a spectator sport as that's not involving any time and effort for them, other than the keystrokes it takes to type them.

It's a bizarre pastime around here to A) put women back in their boxes toute suite if it seems one is taking too independent a stance against traditional women's obligations, or B) to give OPs a good kicking, just for the hell of it and because they can. This, in the same tone as telling them their Christmas spirit is defunct and that they need to Be Kind (chortle).

It can take a more sinister turn on threads about VAWG, domestic and sexual abuse, though. But it's all the same noise.

Dragonskin · 19/12/2022 12:07

Iseepalmtrees · 19/12/2022 00:21

@Oneeyedreindeer I do think it's a tough one,mainly because if having the small kids, without them I would say absolutely fine, if it were me and depending on how sentimental your brother is about it being Christmas day , I would say no to the Console, maybe all your brother wants is to game for the day with his mate and have dinner handed to him, could you offer to drop off dinner to him and his mate at his place would he actually prefer that option? I know thats extra work but could be the simplest option!

WTAF? Please tell me that isn't a serious suggestion, she doesn't run a sodding takeaway! It's bad enough he invited himself round to OPs on Christmas Day and then tried to add a random, but to expect to take over OPs house like two overgrown teenagers for the day is not on.

If her brother would like to spend all day gaming with his mate, he can stay at his house and sort his own bloody food out.

Since when did people become such doormats?

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 19/12/2022 12:04

gannett · 19/12/2022 08:47

What a batshit thread. MN really is a hub for profoundly inhospitable, hostile people who disguise that under a veneer of fake feminism.

My family would always readily welcome a lonely stranger at a loose end at Xmas (and not one of those strange men or women was remotely a danger to me as a child). I've hosted waifs and strays at Xmas. I've been a waif and stray hosted by others at Xmas. It's not just what Xmas is about, it's what community and society should be about. Not retreating into our exclusive nuclear family bubbles and making a cat's bum face at anyone who doesn't have the same.

The feminism aspect is absolutely the most disingenuous part of the thread because I'd bet cash money that if OP had a sister asking to bring her friend or if OP's brother's friend was a woman there'd STILL be the same reluctance. It's just inhospitability, plain and simple. Own it. "I don't care if someone else is on their own at Xmas" is not a feminist issue.

Also bizarre: the whole "he might be weird, racist, I might dislike him". How do you even meet new people if your default assumption is that they're awful? A friend of a friend is always welcome at a party I host because I trust my friends to have good taste in other friends. It's thoroughly bizarre to assume as your default reaction that your loved one's friend is likely to be a cunt.

God this place. OP you obviously don't want to have this guy over and ultimately you're in charge of that, I'm sure he'll survive, but you're thoroughly inhospitable and if you were my relative I'd lowkey think a bit worse of you.

The thread is batshit, alright.

This is one hell of a level of over-investment in what a complete stranger does on Christmas day in her own home, in a manner that's not affecting anyone else in the slightest. Not least involving a guest who isn't 'going to be on his own on Christmas Day' because most eastern spiritual traditions don't celebrate Christmas in the first place.

Cuckoo!

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 19/12/2022 12:03

I have to say my favourite part was your incredulity that the friend would book a holiday knowing full well it was CHRISTMAS, despite him coming from a country that doesn’t particularly celebrate it.

I’m pretty sure it’s quite well known that Christmas is a big event in Britain though, right? And if you’re thinking of visiting a country for an entire month, it’s the kind of thing you might check out first?

INACGMOOH · 19/12/2022 11:58

🤣

I'm on the app. It shows in the filters.

Loics · 19/12/2022 11:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Exactly, OP's brother should "be kind" and cook a lovely meal for him and his friend, not threaten to leave his guest alone on Christmas day.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 11:54

INACGMOOH · 19/12/2022 10:22

@ShoveAHollySprigUpYourBum - Amen! Lydia has 94 posts in this thread at the last count. 😅

And ... you are COUNTING them?!

Why? 😂
Is it for a special project, or something you just find relaxing to do?

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 11:49

Swimmingistoocold · 19/12/2022 10:18

I’d find you mean OP. It’s only one more person. And the person on here who assumes every man must be a secret paedophile needs to get some counselling. Jeez!

I find the DB mean. It's only one person. And his own guest. Why is he not treating him to a home-cooked xmas dinner of his own making?

You seem to imagine that OP is obliged to comply with her DB's demand because ... Reasons? But don'seem to feel DB is not obliged to look after his own guest.
The guest, btw, who he is threatening to leave on his own, in an attempt to guilt OP into accepting him, instead of looking after him himself.
THAT's where the mean is situated.
In the DB's manchild selfishness.

"Morning, mate from halfway round the world. It's the 25th, but as I can't get a woman to cook for the pair of us, I'll leave you here on your tod & go & get just my own dinner from her.
You know the 25th is special over here right? No need for you to experience any of it though, its not like you came here with any interest to see & taste another culture or expected to be included in my major holiday festival, right?
And obviously I can't be expected to cook this traditional dinner for you myself. Or keep you company. I know I invited you over the xmas period & you're my houseguest, but this is basically my sister's fault, not mine.
How can it be? I expected her to roll over. Not my fault the uppity bitch said no. It's not my responsibility to treat you like an honoured guest, don't come that Chinese cultural expectations malarkey with me. There a twix in the fridge - laters!"

INACGMOOH · 19/12/2022 11:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/12/2022 11:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Shouldn’t it be the OP’s DB who should ‘be kind’ and host Christmas Day for the guest he chose to have?

CaitoftheCantii · 19/12/2022 11:44

@Coucous just the person! My neighbour is in need of company and food for Xmas day!! He’s willing to travel too…

Pothoswithasparkle · 19/12/2022 11:36

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

But the friend needn't be alone. Brother and girlfriend can spend time with him since they were the ones arranging the trip and brother didn't think to mention it until week before Christmas with an added cherry on top of emotional blackmail.

Be kind, not stupid

coconutpie · 19/12/2022 11:34

YANBU. If brother doesn't want his friend being alone on Christmas Day, then you brother will spend the day with him. It's completely unreasonable for him to expect you to host a friend that you have never met nor will ever see again. You have 3 young DC. Stick to your guns.

Swipe left for the next trending thread