Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want a stranger at Christmas?

816 replies

Oneeyedreindeer · 18/12/2022 22:15

My mother and brother were due to come to my house for Christmas. I am married with 3 DC, one of who is a young baby. Last week he randomly said he has a friend from abroad coming to stay for a month and if I don’t invite him he will be alone on Christmas Day.

i explained I don’t want a stranger there and it changes the dynamics with small children/breastfeeding etc. he is insisting I could meet the friend beforehand. He is like a dog with a bone and won’t drop it and keeps bringing it up/poor friend will he all alone etc etc. I’ve been clear that if he can’t come as he needs to be with his friend that’s fine and now I feel very mean indeed. But AIBU? I just think it would be very awkward indeed and I do also think there’s an element of my brother wanting to park up for some free/food drink with his friend - he suggested bringing his games consoles “for DC to play” although DC are 4 and under.

OP posts:
Howyiz · 19/12/2022 08:54

gannett · 19/12/2022 08:47

What a batshit thread. MN really is a hub for profoundly inhospitable, hostile people who disguise that under a veneer of fake feminism.

My family would always readily welcome a lonely stranger at a loose end at Xmas (and not one of those strange men or women was remotely a danger to me as a child). I've hosted waifs and strays at Xmas. I've been a waif and stray hosted by others at Xmas. It's not just what Xmas is about, it's what community and society should be about. Not retreating into our exclusive nuclear family bubbles and making a cat's bum face at anyone who doesn't have the same.

The feminism aspect is absolutely the most disingenuous part of the thread because I'd bet cash money that if OP had a sister asking to bring her friend or if OP's brother's friend was a woman there'd STILL be the same reluctance. It's just inhospitability, plain and simple. Own it. "I don't care if someone else is on their own at Xmas" is not a feminist issue.

Also bizarre: the whole "he might be weird, racist, I might dislike him". How do you even meet new people if your default assumption is that they're awful? A friend of a friend is always welcome at a party I host because I trust my friends to have good taste in other friends. It's thoroughly bizarre to assume as your default reaction that your loved one's friend is likely to be a cunt.

God this place. OP you obviously don't want to have this guy over and ultimately you're in charge of that, I'm sure he'll survive, but you're thoroughly inhospitable and if you were my relative I'd lowkey think a bit worse of you.

You do you boo!

jenny38 · 19/12/2022 08:52

Friend could be lots of fun. Tricky situation, but I would just go with the flow. We are in a similar situation, MIL is hosting, she has an acquaintance who has no family, so she will be there on Christmas Day. None of us are big fans of this person, but we will be welcoming. It must be awful to have nobody to spend Christmas with. I would put your brother and friend in charge of entertaining the kids while you are cooking. Tell him in advance. Put a time limit on how long they are with you if you want to.

Aposterhasnoname · 19/12/2022 08:52

Tothemoonandbackx · 18/12/2022 22:22

So some of you on here are completely fine with inviting a complete stranger over into your home with young children when you know zero about them.....yeah, of course you are 🤨🤨🤨🤨

What? I genuinely don’t get this. There’ll be a house full he’s not going to be alone with them, and in this case OPs brother knows him, he’s not dragging a randomer off the street. Yes I’ve had strangers round for Christmas, and my parents insisted on inviting all manner of waifs and strays when we kids, season of goodwill to all men etc.

bloodyplanes · 19/12/2022 08:52

gannett · 19/12/2022 08:47

What a batshit thread. MN really is a hub for profoundly inhospitable, hostile people who disguise that under a veneer of fake feminism.

My family would always readily welcome a lonely stranger at a loose end at Xmas (and not one of those strange men or women was remotely a danger to me as a child). I've hosted waifs and strays at Xmas. I've been a waif and stray hosted by others at Xmas. It's not just what Xmas is about, it's what community and society should be about. Not retreating into our exclusive nuclear family bubbles and making a cat's bum face at anyone who doesn't have the same.

The feminism aspect is absolutely the most disingenuous part of the thread because I'd bet cash money that if OP had a sister asking to bring her friend or if OP's brother's friend was a woman there'd STILL be the same reluctance. It's just inhospitability, plain and simple. Own it. "I don't care if someone else is on their own at Xmas" is not a feminist issue.

Also bizarre: the whole "he might be weird, racist, I might dislike him". How do you even meet new people if your default assumption is that they're awful? A friend of a friend is always welcome at a party I host because I trust my friends to have good taste in other friends. It's thoroughly bizarre to assume as your default reaction that your loved one's friend is likely to be a cunt.

God this place. OP you obviously don't want to have this guy over and ultimately you're in charge of that, I'm sure he'll survive, but you're thoroughly inhospitable and if you were my relative I'd lowkey think a bit worse of you.

Absolutely this 👏👏

chaosmaker · 19/12/2022 08:51

SnowStupid · 18/12/2022 22:34

I can't imagine saying no to that. My childhood Christmases were full of strangers. My grandad would invite anyone and everyone if he heard they would be alone. The more the merrier and those gatherings really were merry.

DS is at Uni and has a Syrian friend who is a refugee and can't go home for Christmas. I've invited him.

Yes, you've invited him. Someone else hasn't and there's the ddifference. @Oneeyedreindeer I'm sure your brother can cook for his friend as he is the one with the visitor. Then you can relax and enjoy your day.

Teakind · 19/12/2022 08:50

I don’t think a friend of her brothers is a ‘stranger’. I think YABU.

I would let him come (and I’ve also got three young kids and am breastfeeding).

SpicyFoodRocks · 19/12/2022 08:50

You should absolutely not host if you can’t or don’t want to. Your brother can look after him. It isn’t your responsibility.

Though I find some of the safeguarding type comments on here verging on the ridiculous.

gannett · 19/12/2022 08:47

What a batshit thread. MN really is a hub for profoundly inhospitable, hostile people who disguise that under a veneer of fake feminism.

My family would always readily welcome a lonely stranger at a loose end at Xmas (and not one of those strange men or women was remotely a danger to me as a child). I've hosted waifs and strays at Xmas. I've been a waif and stray hosted by others at Xmas. It's not just what Xmas is about, it's what community and society should be about. Not retreating into our exclusive nuclear family bubbles and making a cat's bum face at anyone who doesn't have the same.

The feminism aspect is absolutely the most disingenuous part of the thread because I'd bet cash money that if OP had a sister asking to bring her friend or if OP's brother's friend was a woman there'd STILL be the same reluctance. It's just inhospitability, plain and simple. Own it. "I don't care if someone else is on their own at Xmas" is not a feminist issue.

Also bizarre: the whole "he might be weird, racist, I might dislike him". How do you even meet new people if your default assumption is that they're awful? A friend of a friend is always welcome at a party I host because I trust my friends to have good taste in other friends. It's thoroughly bizarre to assume as your default reaction that your loved one's friend is likely to be a cunt.

God this place. OP you obviously don't want to have this guy over and ultimately you're in charge of that, I'm sure he'll survive, but you're thoroughly inhospitable and if you were my relative I'd lowkey think a bit worse of you.

Flapjackquack · 19/12/2022 08:47

We have beef with Christmas dinner because turkey is shit so Yorkshires are appropriate but I am unashamed to say we have Yorkshires with any meat when cooking a Sunday lunch because why would you deny yourself Yorkshire pudding goodness for the sake of tradition?!

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/12/2022 08:43

Oneeyedreindeer · 19/12/2022 06:18

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet

your Christmas cooking attitude is a lot like mine! I don’t want anyone doing the cooking but me / I want everyone else pitching in with the children/keeping the house relatively free of wrapping paper/stopping the children from tipping the tree over!

I’m laughing at the poster describing my husband, mother and one brother as “many other adults to help”.

i also can’t get over the idea I cook lunch and take some to my brother’s place for him!

Honestly this place is bathshit sometimes. Should be called GileadNet

LillianGish · 19/12/2022 08:42

Your brother wants to sit and play Xbox with his mate and have his Christmas dinner handed to him.
This is how I’m feeling
No one would be playing Xbox if they came to my house for Christmas (or at any other time for that matter). If that's what your brother plans to do, he can stay at home with his friend and order a takeaway.
I thought this was perhaps a student friend who couldn't go home in the holidays, but in fact this is a grown man who has chosen to visit over Christmas (I'm guessing that as he's Chinese he doesn't celebrate himself as a rule so the dates are no big deal to him) and your brother - also a grown man - has chosen to host him.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/12/2022 08:42

ADifferentKindofChristmas · 19/12/2022 02:19

I'm simply here to say that I am aghast at how many people have Yorkshire puddings with Christmas Lunch.

All kinds of wrong!Xmas Grin

What!!!! It’s a key part of the meal!

Then again I am from Yorkshire. People round these parts call 101 if you don’t have Yorkshires with a roast.

Crayfishforyou · 19/12/2022 08:40

YANBU
It seems the brother would like to spend Christmas gaming with his friend, whilst being waited on hand and foot.
Screw that.
I hated breastfeeding in front of strangers, even when I’d got the hang of it.

Anothernamechange1010 · 19/12/2022 08:40

Your brother is being a major CF:

firstly by expecting it to be ok to bring a random stranger to YOUR house for Christmas dinner

and secondly by not accepting your first answer and continuing to harass you to change your mind

I’ve had my fill of CFs

Brother can cook and host for his own damn guest in his own house on Christmas Day

If he chooses to leave guest alone and come for dinner at yours then that’s on him

And another vote for NOT offering a lunch on Boxing Day, fuck that, you deserve to put your feet up after all the cooking on the 25th

I hope you can put this to bed asap and enjoy the run up to Christmas and the day itself without this cheeky-fuckery hanging over you

Flapjackquack · 19/12/2022 08:39

Whilst I fully acknowledge there is often an expectation on women to do everything, in this case the OP is insisting she does the cooking because her husband is terrible. Pure martyrdom. My husband was shit at cooking when I met him, he certainly isn’t now. How do you ever expect anyone to get better if they don’t get to practise?!

Still doesn’t mean OP has to invite the brother’s friend blah blah blah, but it certainly is not the same as inviting a complete stranger into your house and definitely not the same as inviting a random homeless stranger off the street who are likely to have mental health/addiction issues ffs. That’s such a hyperbolic argument - oh you think the brother’s friend should come? Well why don’t you just pick a random person off the street to come to your house. It is not the same!

Liz1tummypain · 19/12/2022 08:32

Spambod · 18/12/2022 23:28

Is this directed at the brother of the op or is this rule just for breastfeeding women with two other small children to care for as well?

Anyone

Emotionalsupportviper · 19/12/2022 08:32

PortiasBiscuit · 19/12/2022 08:06

Like so many threads, this one is pointless. The OP has made up her mind and is looking for validation. She will not pay attention to anything that does not confirm her POV, so we are all wasting our time posting on here.

I think she's looking for moral support - I don't consider it a waste of my time to back her up and I hope she isn't emotionally blackmailed and bullied into giving in.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 19/12/2022 08:30

I'd let him come without a second thought and he'd be very welcome. He's your brother's friend, not a total random!

I was in Australia one year by myself without obvious christmas plans and actually got a few invites to people's houses. I went to my friend's mum's house with the whole family and multiple young children and was made very welcome, it was a fantastic Christmas.

Emotionalsupportviper · 19/12/2022 08:29

Oneeyedreindeer · 18/12/2022 22:15

My mother and brother were due to come to my house for Christmas. I am married with 3 DC, one of who is a young baby. Last week he randomly said he has a friend from abroad coming to stay for a month and if I don’t invite him he will be alone on Christmas Day.

i explained I don’t want a stranger there and it changes the dynamics with small children/breastfeeding etc. he is insisting I could meet the friend beforehand. He is like a dog with a bone and won’t drop it and keeps bringing it up/poor friend will he all alone etc etc. I’ve been clear that if he can’t come as he needs to be with his friend that’s fine and now I feel very mean indeed. But AIBU? I just think it would be very awkward indeed and I do also think there’s an element of my brother wanting to park up for some free/food drink with his friend - he suggested bringing his games consoles “for DC to play” although DC are 4 and under.

YANBU.

If you will be uncomfortable in your own home because there is a stranger there, then you are right not to invite his friend. And as the friend is your brother's guest, then he should stay with him. Your mum can take a plated meal for the two of them at a push.

It sounds, as you say, that your brother and his mate intend to just sit and play on the console all day, eating and drinking and not interacting with the family. Bugger that!

Will your DH and DM back you up? I mean, stick to your guns, obviously, but it would help to have them onside.

I'll bet your DM is sick of the two of them already.

Tulipomania · 19/12/2022 08:22

@TarasHarp55 My family has done this a few times. Not homeless people, but friends of friends or distant relatives who were away from home at Christmas. It has always been a positive experience.

Tulipomania · 19/12/2022 08:20

As for, 'it's about the children', I would also want my children to learn not to be so insular and unwelcoming.

What if one of your DC was stranded somewhere alone at Christmas when they grow up. How would you want others to respond?

And I don't see what the gender of the guest has to do with anything, would the OP be more inclined to welcome a female friend of her brother's at the family Christmas. I don't think so.

SinnerBoy · 19/12/2022 08:19

Yes, but that would be her choice and her decision. Not one foisted on her by someone presumptuous.

TarasHarp55 · 19/12/2022 08:18

To all those who think the Ops being mean not wanting a stranger in her house, I'm sure there's plenty of strangers you could host for the day.

Plenty of homeless people would love an invite off you.

Tulipomania · 19/12/2022 08:16

YABVU.

This comes up every year on MN and every year I am shocked at the bitterness and closed minds of many posters.

ACynicalDad · 19/12/2022 08:16

Really sad not to welcome someone in on Christmas Day who is away from home unless they are 100% going to ruin the day. It doesn’t sound like there is anything particularly worrying about this person.

Swipe left for the next trending thread