Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want a stranger at Christmas?

816 replies

Oneeyedreindeer · 18/12/2022 22:15

My mother and brother were due to come to my house for Christmas. I am married with 3 DC, one of who is a young baby. Last week he randomly said he has a friend from abroad coming to stay for a month and if I don’t invite him he will be alone on Christmas Day.

i explained I don’t want a stranger there and it changes the dynamics with small children/breastfeeding etc. he is insisting I could meet the friend beforehand. He is like a dog with a bone and won’t drop it and keeps bringing it up/poor friend will he all alone etc etc. I’ve been clear that if he can’t come as he needs to be with his friend that’s fine and now I feel very mean indeed. But AIBU? I just think it would be very awkward indeed and I do also think there’s an element of my brother wanting to park up for some free/food drink with his friend - he suggested bringing his games consoles “for DC to play” although DC are 4 and under.

OP posts:
Flapjackquack · 19/12/2022 11:33

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 11:27

You'll be waiting a long time, I'm afraid. I have nothing to apologise for; it's ok to disagree with people.

Of course it is, but you don't get to pass off your stonking rudeness & condescension as a difference of opinion @INACGMOOH

You blatantly called @LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet a liar & told her she'd made up the facts she know were correct because ... OP had said so.

Doubling down by refusing to apologise for that personal attack makes you look stiff-necked, not right. And less credible, not more, because it just shows that clinging to a mistaken position is more important to you than understanding OP's actual words & situation.

Being prepared to call people liars for knowing stuff you didn't isn't a good look. I bet if you'd been able to say a quick "oops sorry mate" you & Lydia could have found common ground.

Wow just wow. Are you a school teacher by any chance because you sound like you are lecturing a child. @INACGMOOH has been no ruder than Lydia you just happen to agree with Lydia. You don’t get to police the thread.

Coucous · 19/12/2022 11:28

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 11:27

You'll be waiting a long time, I'm afraid. I have nothing to apologise for; it's ok to disagree with people.

Of course it is, but you don't get to pass off your stonking rudeness & condescension as a difference of opinion @INACGMOOH

You blatantly called @LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet a liar & told her she'd made up the facts she know were correct because ... OP had said so.

Doubling down by refusing to apologise for that personal attack makes you look stiff-necked, not right. And less credible, not more, because it just shows that clinging to a mistaken position is more important to you than understanding OP's actual words & situation.

Being prepared to call people liars for knowing stuff you didn't isn't a good look. I bet if you'd been able to say a quick "oops sorry mate" you & Lydia could have found common ground.

Coucous · 19/12/2022 11:26

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

poefaced · 19/12/2022 11:25

INACGMOOH · 19/12/2022 11:09

The wife work thing is a red herring IMO. Food and effort-wise this is just one plate of food from an already groaning table. And it's just a roast. Not a six course tasting menu with wine flights.

If it's just a roast, why can't DB make one for his friend?

INACGMOOH · 19/12/2022 11:23

Thereisnolight · 19/12/2022 11:22

Ah - thought I’d get away with it since it’s Charrrisstmasss.

🤣🤣 Nicely styled out!! 👏

Thereisnolight · 19/12/2022 11:22

Ah - thought I’d get away with it since it’s Charrrisstmasss.

Pothoswithasparkle · 19/12/2022 11:17

Thereisnolight · 19/12/2022 11:16

You’re being precious I think.
if it’s important to your DB.
Are you close to your DB?
Could this “friend” be your DB’s partner?

Tell me you didn't read the yhread without telling me you didn't read the thread😂

Thereisnolight · 19/12/2022 11:16

You’re being precious I think.
if it’s important to your DB.
Are you close to your DB?
Could this “friend” be your DB’s partner?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/12/2022 11:16

INACGMOOH · 19/12/2022 11:14

Because I'm guessing he'd rather be with his family. Coz it's Christmas.

Does this mean that anyone being a guest at Xmas is freeloading?

And I imagine the OP would rather be WITHOUT stranger. Why does the DB get what he wants? he chose to invite a month long guest over the Christmas period, it’s up to him to sort the Christmas Day hosting

INACGMOOH · 19/12/2022 11:14

Because I'm guessing he'd rather be with his family. Coz it's Christmas.

Does this mean that anyone being a guest at Xmas is freeloading?

Loics · 19/12/2022 11:13

INACGMOOH · 19/12/2022 11:09

The wife work thing is a red herring IMO. Food and effort-wise this is just one plate of food from an already groaning table. And it's just a roast. Not a six course tasting menu with wine flights.

Yes, just a roast and a plate - easy enough for the brother to do by himself then. 🙂

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 11:12

INACGMOOH · 19/12/2022 09:50

Let's take this ridiculous thread onto a sillier level.

Anyone else noting irony the fact that the OP's kids are probably being told that they might be visited alone in their rooms on Christmas Eve by a foreign man; a stranger as they've never met him who will leave them presents, and that's ok. But to have a different foreign man sit at a table with them the very next day isn't ok. Mixed messages.

What mixed messages?
If it's not ok for DB friend to come, he won't be at the table.

So unless you're suggesting that OP is going to do a Show & Tell about how they MIGHT have had DB's friend round, but didn't, & segue neatly into a branch of comparative reasoning they're not yet old enough to comprehend, about how they DID have santa round, I reckon they'll be safe enough from ... whatever you think you're implying is unsafe or wrong in your sillier level.

Lesserspottedmama · 19/12/2022 11:12

It’s hard because it’s a gamble on what the friend is like! He could be lovely and in that case it would be such a nice thing to do, it is awful to think of someone alone at Christmas and it is a lovely thing to be welcoming. I wouldn’t begrudge the food and drink, we are on a very tight budget but I feel like we’d have to practically be on the streets before I’d be tight enough to begrudge someone a meal.
However he could be quite dreadful and then you are bound to resent your brother for foisting someone on to his family who brings the tone of the day down. Does your brother have good judgement and taste in people? I would be very unimpressed with the games console comment, but it could just be down to his lack of experience with children, it is odd he would suggest parking toddlers in front of a games console while you entertain his unknown friend. It would have been better if had reassured you that he and his friend would be very helpful in terms of playing with your older kids, food prep, washing up etc, asking what they could bring. I wouldn’t care about breastfeeding in front of people as I breastfeed in front of everyone and if they feel awkward that’s their issue. But you should do what feels right to you, why can’t your mum, brother and friend cook the lunch and bring it round? You shouldn’t be doing it all.

VestaTilley · 19/12/2022 11:12

Just say no. I wouldn’t want a stranger around my children and/or while I’m breastfeeding either.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/12/2022 11:10

INACGMOOH · 19/12/2022 11:09

The wife work thing is a red herring IMO. Food and effort-wise this is just one plate of food from an already groaning table. And it's just a roast. Not a six course tasting menu with wine flights.

So if it isn’t about wifework why can’t the DB do that at his own home?

CaitoftheCantii · 19/12/2022 11:10

well, what a coincidence! My neighbour has just told me his Xmas plans have fallen through. If any of the posters who have said they are happy to host ‘a waif or stray’ could DM me, I’d be happy to pass on their kind invitations to my neighbour. He’d be overjoyed at the kindness of strangers (and is a dab hand at washing up)

We’d have offered to have him here but my children are feral and likely to ask if they can eat him instead of the nut roast..

INACGMOOH · 19/12/2022 11:09

The wife work thing is a red herring IMO. Food and effort-wise this is just one plate of food from an already groaning table. And it's just a roast. Not a six course tasting menu with wine flights.

Emotionalsupportviper · 19/12/2022 11:07

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/12/2022 11:04

But why would that be your first thought before ‘the man could cook Christmas dinner himself’. As a PP said he has an oven and two hands.

Wasn't my first thought - it's just knowing how arsey families can be, it was an alternative. That's what I said. "at a push".

I absolutely agree that anyone could get a couple of frozen dinners at least, and bung them in on 200 degrees for however many minutes and feed themselves and a friend.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/12/2022 11:06

My favourite claim was the one that this man was ‘stranded’ rather than just on holiday 😂 I’m so pleased the OP seems immune to this BS emotive language problem are trying to use to blackmail her into hosting a guest she doesn’t want at her house who can have a perfectly good day at the place he’s actually staying.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 11:05

gannett · 19/12/2022 09:48

"Men expect women to perform free emotional & domestic labour for them & rarely reciprocate" IS a feminist issue.

Sure but if OP's family expect her to perform all that labour by herself and don't volunteer any help, the problem is within her pre-existing family dynamics, and the brother's friend is irrelevant.

"I know it's unfortunate you got mugged by a stranger, but your own family beat you up at home anyway, so the mugger is irrelevant."

Emotionalsupportviper · 19/12/2022 11:04

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 10:30

Gosh if Christmas isn't a time to be welcoming and have empathy, I don't know what time is.

IKR?
Its such a shame this simple concept hasn't occurred to the chap from China's host.

Who has already guilt-tripped his sister by informing her that if she fails to comply with his demands, he will leave his friend AllAloneTM.

And PP reckon his decision to leave his own friend, if he can't force compliance from OP is on HER, & not the man coldly planning to ditch his friend if he can't get his own way?

I would NOT leave my own guest alone on xmas day because I couldn't wangle a free pass for him at my sister's, but was too selfish to stay home with him, & too lazy to cook our own bloody dinner.

It's genuinely bewildering how many PP are (wilfully?) failing to perceive this.

"OP - you CANT leave him alone!"
Well funny that - 'cos her brother can, & has threatened to.

He's got no compunction about doing that AND using it to manipulate OP with.

THIS ⬆

No ones leaving anyone alone except the brother.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/12/2022 11:04

Emotionalsupportviper · 19/12/2022 11:01

I think that might have been me.

I wasn't suggesting that anyone's festivities should be curtailed - just that if it made everyone feel better a couple of dinners could be plated up and taken home by the mother, when she went home at whatever time that happened to be and they Jolly Christmas Gamers could stick them in the oven and warm them through.

I am totally onside with OP refusing to have them to the house. Brother's guest, brother's responsibility.

An I don't think that any woman should have to sit on her own in the bedroom/bathroom and breastfeed a baby, either - that's a bliddy appalling suggestion.

But why would that be your first thought before ‘the man could cook Christmas dinner himself’. As a PP said he has an oven and two hands.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 11:02

"Her flaky, childish lazy brother who has a knack for keeping dodgy company"

You literally know nothing about these people yet you write stuff like this about them. What on earth is your problem?

We know what OP has told us all @INACGMOOH & the PP you quoted made a decent summary. Here are OP's own words:
I do like my brother. But again this thread has made me think as a number of his friends are extremely strange and not people I would have around my children - smoke weed etc.

also I like my brother but he is a huge man child and it is one of those situations where, for example, he has been to my house 50 times this year and I’ve been to his 0. So perhaps this is just an extension of me feeling a little used?

Brother offers to bring consoles is most likely to be his way of saying they don't want to be any trouble. Yes, it's clumsy and misjudged but I doubt it comes from the feckless standpoint you're promoting here.
Disagree. It was a disingenuous ploy.
He offered to bring the console round "to help entertain the kids" knowing damn well that the games are totally useless to the kids as they are too young for them.
If he doesn't want to be any trouble he could act like a proper uncle & play games DC can actually enjoy with him. You know - the boring, repetitive ones we all grit our teeth & pretend to be delighted by.

As for dodgy company. WTAF? There is absolutely zero evidence that this friend is "dodgy". What about the fact that he's likely to be lovely? Your stranger danger is off the chart.
See above.
Manchild with dodgy weed-toking mates.
That's not stranger danger, that's "DB's got form for hanging out with folk who like getting off their tits, maybe this chap I've never met is like that too."

This thread makes me sad. The milk of human kindness is well and truly sour.
It's ok to be sad.
You're just sad about the wrong thing.
It;s sad that in an attempt at brinkmanship, DB has threatened to leave his mate home alone if OP won't give him what he wants.
Leaving YOUR OWN MATE behind because you are too selfish & lazy to host them yourself, but expect your sister to do it, is much sadder than being irritated that your manchild DB is manipulating you to perform womanwork for him.

Emotionalsupportviper · 19/12/2022 11:01

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 19/12/2022 10:13

The GileadNet comment was an attempt at humour after someone said the solution was a woman should take a grown man his meal round on Christmas Day. Which IS a ridiculous and sexist suggestion.

Never once claimed OP is out upon by her OH.

HTH.

I think that might have been me.

I wasn't suggesting that anyone's festivities should be curtailed - just that if it made everyone feel better a couple of dinners could be plated up and taken home by the mother, when she went home at whatever time that happened to be and they Jolly Christmas Gamers could stick them in the oven and warm them through.

I am totally onside with OP refusing to have them to the house. Brother's guest, brother's responsibility.

An I don't think that any woman should have to sit on her own in the bedroom/bathroom and breastfeed a baby, either - that's a bliddy appalling suggestion.