Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother in law not getting in touch when my mother died

85 replies

Belins · 18/12/2022 21:20

When my mother died it took my mother in law 2 weeks to reach out to me directly. She had spoken to my husband twice in that time but never to me directly, or even texted me or my father directly. She had a good relationship with my mother. When she eventually phoned me 2 weeks after my mother died I told her how we all felt, that it was too little, too late. My mother had been dead and cremated within 3 days. My mother in law thinks I'm being unreasonable. Am I? Please help with your thoughts

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Stripedbag101 · 18/12/2022 23:44

Op I am so sorry about your mum.

it sounds like your MIL is not a very warm or caring person. And it doesn’t like you have a particularly close relationship.

i absolutely agree that most people in her situation would have reached out to give emotional support. but that isn’t who this lady is.

my therapist once told me to stop expecting
people to behave how I would. People are different , people are disappointing. It’s unlikely she will change, or ever see this from tori perspective.

but you are right. She is wrong.

dontknowwhatisbest · 18/12/2022 23:35

Hi OP, I had to reply because we have just had pretty much the same situation occur in my family, but the other way round (my DM not acknowledging the death of DH's DM). It was upsetting and frankly bizarre l. DH and I have been together 25 years, more than half our lifetimes. DM has spent a great deal of time with us over the years, and also had an independent relationship with MIL - they got on well, talked from time to time, we had all travelled together on holiday etc.

When MIL died unexpectly, DM barely wanted to acknowledge it even to me, and changed the conversation if it was mentioned. She didn't even send a card or a WhatsApp message to DH, and said she "couldn't face" the funeral. I was so upset with her, and even my normally sanguine DH was hurt, that she basically made it more about her feelings that his.

DM is a very difficult person though (I suspect BPD) and I think she has an actual phobia of death. I know that sounds weird - after all, no one exactly loves talking about it - but for her it is on another level.

Anyway, that doesn't really help does it, but just wanted to say that I sympathise. I'm sorry for your loss.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 18/12/2022 23:34

Unforgiveable. I'd cease making any effort in regard to her and let your "D" husband deal with her for the rest of her life.

Any person with a shred of decency, let alone a relative, would express condolences as soon as possible, not to mention offering assistance.

Sorry for your loss of your mum. It's rough.

Belins · 18/12/2022 23:33

Mariposista · 18/12/2022 23:22

My 91 yo gran was extremely unwell a couple of months ago with heart failure, unwell enough that I flew home from abroad to be with her. We all, including the doctor, gave her days to live. However to cut a long story short, gran is a stubborn old thing and rallied, surprising everyone, and she is still with us (not recovered exactly, but she's here). However I was shocked at how all her neighbours, who saw all the cars come and go and who are apparently a 'close knit neighbourhood' all went to ground. They didn't ask, didn't call, nothing. A lot of mums friends the same. And we had the old BS 'we didn't know what to say/we were giving you space. Load of BS. It's cowardice. All you need to say is 'I am thinking of you/ I am so sorry. We were not asking for psychology services/ practical help. Just a bit of care. And the fact this is your MIL, your FAMILY, makes this unacceptable in my eyes.

Sorry, rant over. I am so so sorry about your mum. Please take care of yourself, especially at this usually happy time when you will feel sad. I hope you have support, and not too much of this 'giving you space' crap. ughhh boils my blood (yes I know I said rant over)

Thanks for your message. Glad to hear your granny is still going strong - wonderful!

To everyone else - thanks so much for taking the time to respond. What a great community. ❤

OP posts:
Namechange600 · 18/12/2022 23:33

OP you are not being unreasonable.
my brother died last year and I heard nothing from my in-laws and nothing from their daughter/SIL too. Whenever they have had bereavements over the years I would always send a text or card to say thinking of them. I think they can’t cope with any challenging emotions. I feel sorry for them actually. It’s so alien to me as I was brought up with a big family and very empathetic and giving and didn’t shy away from death.
so sorry for the loss of your Mum OP - it’s especially hard at this time of year Xx

greenerfingers · 18/12/2022 23:33

Don't think you're being unreasonable at all. If she wanted to give you space a simple 'thinking of you' text would have done. She's not some neighbour down the road, she's your mother in law. She should have reached out.

Motheranddaughtertotwo · 18/12/2022 23:30

I’m sorry for your loss. I’d have been gutted too. When my dad died my FIL who wasn’t that close to my dad called me the next day and made sure my husband knew he was there for all of us if he we needed anything. My SIL who had spent most Sundays at my mums house for the best part of 20 years sent me a message a few weeks later saying how sorry she was and she was thinking of me, our relationship has never recovered. I think people can be selfish and awkward and it’s disguised as politeness, when you are grieving some people’s silence feels very loud. I hope you have lots of other support OP.

sunnyliveshere · 18/12/2022 23:24

Yanbu.
A text is all it takes. I know how much silence hurts. So sorry for your loss

Mariposista · 18/12/2022 23:22

Belins · 18/12/2022 23:10

Totally agree and thanks. An acknowledgment costs nothing but a minute of your time.

My 91 yo gran was extremely unwell a couple of months ago with heart failure, unwell enough that I flew home from abroad to be with her. We all, including the doctor, gave her days to live. However to cut a long story short, gran is a stubborn old thing and rallied, surprising everyone, and she is still with us (not recovered exactly, but she's here). However I was shocked at how all her neighbours, who saw all the cars come and go and who are apparently a 'close knit neighbourhood' all went to ground. They didn't ask, didn't call, nothing. A lot of mums friends the same. And we had the old BS 'we didn't know what to say/we were giving you space. Load of BS. It's cowardice. All you need to say is 'I am thinking of you/ I am so sorry. We were not asking for psychology services/ practical help. Just a bit of care. And the fact this is your MIL, your FAMILY, makes this unacceptable in my eyes.

Sorry, rant over. I am so so sorry about your mum. Please take care of yourself, especially at this usually happy time when you will feel sad. I hope you have support, and not too much of this 'giving you space' crap. ughhh boils my blood (yes I know I said rant over)

Belins · 18/12/2022 23:21

Onthecuspofabreakthrough · 18/12/2022 23:14

I've read another thread on here today that had people saying they didn't want a text when they suffered a bereavement as they thought they then had to reply to this and weren't ready to - you can't get things right sometimes. She spoke to your dh, was this not about your loss of your mum?

Yes - her contact with my husband was about my mum. I do understand maybe no direct contact in the first day or two. It was the fact that it took 2 weeks for there to be direct contact from her....which just felt too late. I had thought maybe she would have felt sad herself but that certainly wasn't mentioned.

OP posts:
RunnerBum · 18/12/2022 23:20

I'm Irish too but lived in the UK a very long time.

If you'd posted this in Ireland about an Irish woman then YANBU, but in England YABU. In Ireland, family is family is family. In England, not so much. I think, in England and under English values, it's quite normal to think she doesn't want to intrude on you grieving your DM because she's sort of a proxy/replacement DM role. It's almost a salt-in-the-wound type thing.

She probably went out of her way to actually do a nice thing for you. I understand you're grieving and you're obviously hurting but it's not her fault - she did what she thought was best. I think she probably feels really awful that she's hurt you when she absolutely tried to help - and that hurt is coming out as anger (just as your hurt at your loss is coming out as anger).

This isn't a battle worth having - for either you or MIL.

Onthecuspofabreakthrough · 18/12/2022 23:19

People are pretty shitty in dealing with bereavement/illness/depression/miscarriage etc in general.
or maybe that's just (almost) all the people I know!

mikado1 · 18/12/2022 23:17

Belins · 18/12/2022 23:08

I'm sorry to hear you didn't get the message or support you needed from your SIL. You a certainly a bigger person than me to be able to get in touch with her when her DD died.

Her DDad died two years previously. I can't tell you how many times I was in touch with her that year..she wasdecastated, I sent a Christmas Mass bouquet etc. Now I get some satisfaction at seeing her discomfort when I am v short tho polite with her at get togethers. And of course she's all be Kind on her FB. I'm sure you can tell I'm well over it 😂 Fuck em, I say!

saraclara · 18/12/2022 23:16

Belins · 18/12/2022 22:31

I'm Irish too but not living there. For us it is common for everyone to get involved in a bereavement no matter how tenuously you knew the person. Because it shows love and empathy and helps those who are grieving. I'd assumed it was like that for everyone.

That explains what would be a huge gulf between what you'd expect from her, and what she thought was okay. Irish funeral etiquette is massively different from English.

I read your OP and, introverted Englishwoman that I am, thought 'MIL was just giving her space and sending her thoughts via her son. It doesn't mean she doesn't care'. But if you were brought up with the expectation that everyone however remotely connected should get in touch personally, I can see how you felt it quite differently.

She wasn't 'disrespecting' your Mum. She's just a bit socially inept and didn't know what to do. If she sent a message via your DH, that was her caring.

I do get that it hurt, and I think she could have done a bit better. But I think picking a row over it was a bit unnecessary.

Belins · 18/12/2022 23:15

mikado1 · 18/12/2022 23:06

Unfortunately OP, going on my own experience above, you're not going to get satisfaction from her. All I'll say is overtime the hurt will fade. Don't put yourself out for her again.

Thank you so much and I'm sorry you've been hurt too.

OP posts:
Onthecuspofabreakthrough · 18/12/2022 23:14

I've read another thread on here today that had people saying they didn't want a text when they suffered a bereavement as they thought they then had to reply to this and weren't ready to - you can't get things right sometimes. She spoke to your dh, was this not about your loss of your mum?

Belins · 18/12/2022 23:13

blubberyboo · 18/12/2022 23:01

I do think you can give someone space but still send a text or note to say you are thinking of them and at the end of the phone.

there could be a cultural difference as in Ireland and NI everyone definitely attends a funeral or wake or sends a message to the deceased’s relatives even if they didn’t know the deceased. Colleagues and everything.. It’s rude not to. But I think a MIL is close enough to her daughter in law and grandchildren that you rightly expected that from her regardless of culture.

You are also right to have said your piece. Don’t let it fester, be pleased you’ve said it and move on and try and keep things civil but you’ve nothing to apologise for and your husband should be mending bridges not flaming the fire

Thank you.... it's definitely the Irish way not to ignore something like this or try and be discrete ...that only comes across as uncaring.

OP posts:
Belins · 18/12/2022 23:10

Mariposista · 18/12/2022 22:50

I wish people would stop this 'giving space' rubbish. It is uncaring to keep your distance automatically when someone is going through something bad. At the very least send a text or card, then if that person wants space they have the option to ignore it.

Totally agree and thanks. An acknowledgment costs nothing but a minute of your time.

OP posts:
Belins · 18/12/2022 23:08

mikado1 · 18/12/2022 22:57

I have texted people I barely know, say from work or my hobby, when I've head of a loss fgs. It costs nothing but means a lot. It is rarely the right thing to say nothing and even if it is for a certain person, at least a good intention is clear. My SIL did this OP, when my DM died...and has never ever mentioned it since! 🤯 I won't ever forgive her. Conversely, when her DDad I was in touch in minutes and she was so grateful etc. Some people! 😡

I'm sorry to hear you didn't get the message or support you needed from your SIL. You a certainly a bigger person than me to be able to get in touch with her when her DD died.

OP posts:
mikado1 · 18/12/2022 23:06

Unfortunately OP, going on my own experience above, you're not going to get satisfaction from her. All I'll say is overtime the hurt will fade. Don't put yourself out for her again.

Belins · 18/12/2022 23:04

ClaryFairchild · 18/12/2022 22:43

I would never have expected my ILS to attend the funeral for someone on my family or vice versa - they just don't have and never had that type of relationship. However there are other in-laws whose family member's funerals I would do all I could to attend, because we DO have that sort of relationship with them.

Given that your MIL did have a relationship with your DM YANBU. However, what do you want from this? Is this a "cut offable offence"? Would you prefer to distance yourself from her? Would an apology from her make any difference?

You need to give some thought as to what your expectations are and whether she has any hope of ever fulfilling them. Because she is who she is, you can't change her. But you can put in your own boundaries and set out your expectations clearly.

Don't know what I want from her...an apology or recognition that she has hurt our feelings would be nice but I know that will never come. Maybe I just need to let it go...I said my piece, I stood up for my mum when I thought she deserved more and that's all I can probably do. Will it be possible to maintain a relationship with her after this - I don't know, but I doubt it.

OP posts:
blubberyboo · 18/12/2022 23:01

I do think you can give someone space but still send a text or note to say you are thinking of them and at the end of the phone.

there could be a cultural difference as in Ireland and NI everyone definitely attends a funeral or wake or sends a message to the deceased’s relatives even if they didn’t know the deceased. Colleagues and everything.. It’s rude not to. But I think a MIL is close enough to her daughter in law and grandchildren that you rightly expected that from her regardless of culture.

You are also right to have said your piece. Don’t let it fester, be pleased you’ve said it and move on and try and keep things civil but you’ve nothing to apologise for and your husband should be mending bridges not flaming the fire

Belins · 18/12/2022 22:59

thelionthewitchtheaudacityofTHISbitch · 18/12/2022 22:42

Sorry I think your expectations are far too high. In-laws are mostly at best good acquaintances, and you mention your mum being buried in another country and quickly. One of my best friends lost her mother this year unexpectedly. We spoke at the end of the 1st week after the mother's death. Funeral plans still being arranged, difficulties with getting all the relatives over - Irish funeral. I wrote my card, took time to think about my message, was trying to sort out sympathy flowers which didnt work, sent the card. Called the following week - didnt want to be overly pushy. Funeral had already happened - I was shocked. So much faster than perhaps a typical English funeral. My card would have arrived afterwards. I love this friend to bits - I apologised for the lack of flowers - her comment was time to return to normal and not be like a funeral parlour! But I also think your DH has perhaps not done the best job of navigating cultures.

I suppose I expected of her what I know she would have received from my parents or me had it been the other way around. In that respect my expectations weren't too high or too low...just we're about doing the right thing. But your point about in-laws being at best good acquaintances is not just what we thought of her but probably what she thought of us 😳

OP posts:
mikado1 · 18/12/2022 22:57

I have texted people I barely know, say from work or my hobby, when I've head of a loss fgs. It costs nothing but means a lot. It is rarely the right thing to say nothing and even if it is for a certain person, at least a good intention is clear. My SIL did this OP, when my DM died...and has never ever mentioned it since! 🤯 I won't ever forgive her. Conversely, when her DDad I was in touch in minutes and she was so grateful etc. Some people! 😡

Belins · 18/12/2022 22:52

BMrs · 18/12/2022 22:41

My MIL did the same when my grandmother died. I found it extremely hurtful and difficult to forgive. YANBU

Thank you and sorry you've had the same feelings.

OP posts: