Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I might well be unreasonable but here goes.....

262 replies

cocktailclub · 18/12/2022 21:20

It seems that a lot of the working age population now are snowflakes or incompetent or just don't care enough to do a good job. It's rare to manage people who actually work reliably the hours they are paid to.
I just wonder what would happen to the economy in general if
A) employees turned up and worked hard for the hours they were paid
B) employees only took sick leave when they were really unwell
C) employees did not regard the usual ups and downs of life as 'mental health' but reserved that for people with actual mental illness like clinical depression, schizophrenia etc
D) employees just genuinely cared about doing a good job and tried hard

Also would the NHS thrive if we weren't all so dependent on referrals for minor issues and just took a bit of ownership and responsibility for staying well.

If people stopped blaming social workers for child abuse and looked at the parents.

Sorry a bit of a rant but I'm disillusioned

OP posts:
ThisGirlNever · 18/12/2022 22:09

Pumperthepumper · 18/12/2022 21:56

So then the actual problem is ‘weak management’.

A combination of weak management, unions and employment laws.

I previously worked a shift job in IT. Due to the shift pattern, I had a full week off every five weeks. When I returned, I would regularly find that my shift 'buddy' hadn't done a single thing in a week - and I mean absolutely nothing, nadda.

I once took a five week summer holiday and returned to a work queue of sixty fault tickets (there were usually 7 or 8). Done hadn't been updated in weeks. On my first nightshift, I closed down 40 tickets just by conducting basic system checks.

We were all hired together and were all on exactly the same money. Why was that, when any statistical analysis would show that I was carrying a team of five?

I left and now earn twice what I did in that job.

There are far too many people that are content to do nothing and be carried and there are too many managers and workplaces that allow them to do it.

susiesuelou · 18/12/2022 22:08

I think you mean, OP, that in the public sector we are entitled to take 6 months sick leave on full pay. Doesn't mean we all do it 🙄

cocktailclub · 18/12/2022 22:07

If you're paid a low wage in a job accepted then you still need to do the job you are paid to do or leave and do another job.
It's not up to individuals to say oh I'm not paid well so I will do a poor job! Don't take the job in the first place, take a higher paid job.
This is exactly the attitude I'm talking about

OP posts:
HotChoxs · 18/12/2022 22:07

Sapphire387 · 18/12/2022 21:57

Let's hear some examples then, OP. Rather than just a general 'holier than thou' rant.

Just two examples this week

  1. I couldn't find out what the christmas opening times were for a local gym because the young person's attitude was why are you bothering me with this
  2. People are having to walk down to the checkout to get a basket at my local supermarket because the young people are too busy having a natter to bother to bring them back to the front of the store
RunnerBum · 18/12/2022 22:07

rwalker · 18/12/2022 22:02

There attracted by the salary make all the right noises
but when it comes to being outside all day in the cold and the rain there not prepared to do it

I repeat "Then you need to adopt a better recruitment process. How are you so consistently selecting such poor candidates?". If you're that easily persuaded by bullshit then get a better system. Clearly whoever's in charge of hiring needs to do their job properly (and stop complaining about the repercussions of doing it badly).

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 18/12/2022 22:06

In the public sector they take sick days
6 months of them
On full pay

Gosh I wish I’d known that was what we all did! Or perhaps it’s just the odd person. Who is actually sick.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 18/12/2022 22:05

Your A-D is what most people do do, I’d have thought.

Postgraddope · 18/12/2022 22:04

Iam4eels · 18/12/2022 21:28

Anyone who uses the word "snowflakes" automatically has nothing to say that is worth listening to.

Agree !

cocktailclub · 18/12/2022 22:03

tillytown · 18/12/2022 22:00

People don't take enough sick days as it is, why ask them to reduce them even more?
Also, most people don't earn enough money to live even though they work full time or more, so why would they "work harder" when they get nothing from it?

In the public sector they take sick days
6 months of them
On full pay

OP posts:
HotChoxs · 18/12/2022 22:03

@cocktailclub
It seems that a lot of the working age population now are snowflakes or incompetent or just don't care enough to do a good job. It's rare to manage people who actually work reliably the hours they are paid to.

Yes

rwalker · 18/12/2022 22:02

RunnerBum · 18/12/2022 21:54

Then you need to adopt a better recruitment process. How are you so consistently selecting such poor candidates?

There attracted by the salary make all the right noises
but when it comes to being outside all day in the cold and the rain there not prepared to do it

5128gap · 18/12/2022 22:01

I wonder what would happen to the economy if:

  1. All employers paid people fairly for all their hard work

2)People took sick leave when they were unwell rather than being too frightened to lose their jobs or unable to manage without their pay, and so stopped spreading illnesses around workplaces.

  1. People received support so the ups and downs of life didn't effect their mental health and that they weren't made to feel guilty because they weren't as mentally ill as other people.

  2. Employers genuinely cared about their employees and understood the importance of this to them doing a good job.

Also would the NHS thrive if we were all able to get referrals at a time when our problems were minor rather than sitting on waiting lists until they become life threatening and expensive to treat?

JamSandle · 18/12/2022 22:01

nearlyjarv · 18/12/2022 21:29

minimum wage = minimum effort. you get what you give

This.

Swimmingistoocold · 18/12/2022 22:01

But yeh, I think you are being goady in painting everyone with the same brush.

frostyfours · 18/12/2022 22:00

theswoot · 18/12/2022 21:32

WELL, everyone did all the things you listed for years and years and it produced the society we have now, so doesn’t seem that great if you ask me.

Touché!

Well said Grin

MiniTheMinx · 18/12/2022 22:00

Bard6817 it's called socialism. I didn't dream it up and I'm not some green meanie glued to a road either.

tillytown · 18/12/2022 22:00

People don't take enough sick days as it is, why ask them to reduce them even more?
Also, most people don't earn enough money to live even though they work full time or more, so why would they "work harder" when they get nothing from it?

Swimmingistoocold · 18/12/2022 22:00

i see this a lot in my current public sector role, and is one of the reasons I am looking to go back into the private sector. Too many people are too hard to sack, and there is no easy way to recognise and reward hard work - payscale, no bonuses - so many don’t bother striving, or working in a professional manner. The maximum reward they can offer is some shopping vouchers up to a value of £500, and endless forms would need to be filled in to get this ‘reward’. I’ve told my manager it’s not worth the effort.

workplaces are far more productive and efficient where employees have the incentive of seeing their hard work financially rewarded.

RunnerBum · 18/12/2022 21:59

ThisGirlNever · 18/12/2022 21:55

This is a massive problem and it results in the hard working people leaving. The workshy dregs remain.

I've experienced this in multiple jobs. Some people are allowed to do absolutely nothing, because they're too much hassle, whilst more and more work is piled onto a handful of people - but everybody gets paid the same.

Ironically, it's one of the reasons that the NHS is being run into the ground. 50% work shy who expect to be treated like saints and Gods. 50% desperate to help people and relentlessly picking up the slack for the other 50% (running themselves to another profession, sick leave with stress or suicide as a result).

Sapphire387 · 18/12/2022 21:57

Let's hear some examples then, OP. Rather than just a general 'holier than thou' rant.

MushMonster · 18/12/2022 21:57

Interesting... we already do all these things at my current and past workplaces. Also, most of the people I know, bar some snowflakes here and there, so from my point of view, the present situation is what you get when you apply all your points.
But, the present system does not work. The strain due to the gas prices is proving that our finantial and political landscape needs full on remodelling and hard hard work. UK and likely most of the world.
We cannot carry on with a system that gathers all the money in a few pockets and all the hard labour on the rest.

Pumperthepumper · 18/12/2022 21:56

ThisGirlNever · 18/12/2022 21:55

This is a massive problem and it results in the hard working people leaving. The workshy dregs remain.

I've experienced this in multiple jobs. Some people are allowed to do absolutely nothing, because they're too much hassle, whilst more and more work is piled onto a handful of people - but everybody gets paid the same.

So then the actual problem is ‘weak management’.

ThisGirlNever · 18/12/2022 21:55

RunnerBum · 18/12/2022 21:35

Ok 🙄

Let's be honest - it's a two-way street.

A) employees turned up and worked hard for the hours they were paid

I am just about the strongest believer in the world of the idea that if you do a job then you should do it well. However, there should be recognition for working hard. In my experience, in a huge number of workplaces, people are actually punished for working hard - if employee A works hard but employee B doesn't work hard, employee A will be given more workload to do. So, you're punished for doing well. People who perform well in a role are denied promotions in order to ensure they stay doing well in a department - that's unfair.

B) employees only took sick leave when they were really unwell

Many employers refuse to accommodate people's lives. People are then left needing to lie about illness to cover other aspects of their lives - like children's nativity plays or taking a dog to the vet. If employers were more open to employees having a life outside of work then it would mean employers get more notice of time off being needed and employees can get the flexibility that's required.

C) employees did not regard the usual ups and downs of life as 'mental health' but reserved that for people with actual mental illness like clinical depression, schizophrenia etc

Everyone has mental health just like everyone has physical health. Your comment is ignorant and ridiculous. If you don't maintain your mental health then you can become mentally ill. Attacking people for looking after their mental health is exceptionally ironic considering your rant goes on to complain that people need to take "a bit of ownership and responsibility for staying well".

D) employees just genuinely cared about doing a good job and tried hard

Most do. See point A.

Also would the NHS thrive if we weren't all so dependent on referrals for minor issues and just took a bit of ownership and responsibility for staying well.

Minor issues become major issues. Almost no one on the NHS is getting any help at the moment - people are dying of heart attacks and being denied emergency care. What planet are you on?

If people stopped blaming social workers for child abuse and looked at the parents.

Both can be to blame. Both are to blame. Do you think we should just eradicate social workers? Again, this point is exceptionally ironic in the light of your rant about people needing to do their jobs well - why do social workers doing their job poorly get a pass?

Surely you can see both sides of the coin on all your points? (Like any rational person).

This is a massive problem and it results in the hard working people leaving. The workshy dregs remain.

I've experienced this in multiple jobs. Some people are allowed to do absolutely nothing, because they're too much hassle, whilst more and more work is piled onto a handful of people - but everybody gets paid the same.

Bard6817 · 18/12/2022 21:54

MiniTheMinx · 18/12/2022 21:35

I wonder what life would be like if we had true equality. If people had a fair share of the profit from their labour, if people had free education at degree and post grad level, if children had happy unstressed parents and we had fully funded fully functioning social welfare, infrastructure and an NHS that kept us all healthy and productive.

More than anything I wonder what life would be like if we had leaders who represented both the will and welfare of the people, instead of representatives of the elite and the capitalist pig dog exploiting fuckers that are destroying our planet, our lives, and our future.

So what do you call this system?

Fair share of the fruits of their labour? That’s wages/salary. If they want to be an owner, or a shareholder, they have to take on risk. That’s the fairest system.

Theres no such thing as free degrees…. Someone has to pay…. Do you make everyone pay for everyone else, or is it the person who benefits who pays?

We have an extensive welfare system - it’s not perfect and encourages people to work - but bear in mind, people who work make it possible and there’s no finite supply of tax.

I think you might need to disengage from social media for a bit, you’ve been listening to Greta a bit too much.

We do need better leaders…. I don’t know how to fix that.

Nhs is dying…. It’s a money pit. It’s far too politicised for it to be fixed.

RunnerBum · 18/12/2022 21:54

rwalker · 18/12/2022 21:50

Mine does and we have the issue OP listed

Then you need to adopt a better recruitment process. How are you so consistently selecting such poor candidates?