Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I might well be unreasonable but here goes.....

262 replies

cocktailclub · 18/12/2022 21:20

It seems that a lot of the working age population now are snowflakes or incompetent or just don't care enough to do a good job. It's rare to manage people who actually work reliably the hours they are paid to.
I just wonder what would happen to the economy in general if
A) employees turned up and worked hard for the hours they were paid
B) employees only took sick leave when they were really unwell
C) employees did not regard the usual ups and downs of life as 'mental health' but reserved that for people with actual mental illness like clinical depression, schizophrenia etc
D) employees just genuinely cared about doing a good job and tried hard

Also would the NHS thrive if we weren't all so dependent on referrals for minor issues and just took a bit of ownership and responsibility for staying well.

If people stopped blaming social workers for child abuse and looked at the parents.

Sorry a bit of a rant but I'm disillusioned

OP posts:
cocktailclub · 19/12/2022 06:13

Morielle · 18/12/2022 22:48

OP may I ask your opinion on Boris Johnson - just curious

I don't support him. I'm not really a conservative however I also don't think Labour offer a credible alternative and fear they would make things worse.

OP posts:
cocktailclub · 19/12/2022 06:05

It's not just about management though. A manager cannot change people's personalities or values. Although the poster who said it's about systems not individuals makes a good point

In a non work context it's so rare to get good customer service and get a job done as per contract or get what you paid for. Standards everywhere seem to have declined

OP posts:
RegularNameChangerVersion21 · 19/12/2022 05:52

Ridiculous post.

Especially your point about blaming social workers for child abuse. So you think we should just allow children to be abused and then assign blame to parents afterwards? The point is to protect children not assign blame.

People should be paid a living wage to work and the NHS and education system shouldn't rely on the god will of nurses and teachers (who often can't afford to heat their homes) to function. People should expect to pay for public services not vote in a government that will deliberately starve them of funding then act surprised when they don't function well anymore.

JoanOfAllTrades · 19/12/2022 05:33

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 04:52

Hit post too soon.

So now we're all high paid workers, how are you going to manage inflation?

What are you going to do to make capitalism start working again?
Because I can assure you that us all simply refusing low paid work & being able to walk instantly into high paid work has just broken capitalism.

Have you never realised it's a pyramid scheme, totally dependent on 90% of people being at the arse end of the pyramid? There's only X amount of that odd construct 'money' to go round. That's why the rich can only get richer if the poor get poorer. That's why capitalism is deliberately constructed to keep wages low.

Now we are all comfortably off, where are the poor people whose poverty ensure that the rich keep getting richer? Gone. So who do you think the pyramid scheme owners are going to come after now? Yeah - the comfortably off. They don't even need guns, though they're not afraid to pay other people to use them - they have inflation. Inflation doesn't bother them, they have enough money to ride it out, & even make more money by playing rigged markets & investing in unholy practices.
But it will now bother the comfortably off, who become the new poor. And are forced to take up the shitjobs, because inflation has caused enough businesses to go bust that it's an employer's market again.

You haven't thought this through have you OP?
This is where you thank me for doing it for you btw. You're welcome. Hmm

You are correct!

And OP has overlooked one small, yet highly relevant fact - that this utopian society where we are all equal and no one is poor or goes without, has already been tried. It’s called communism! And it doesn’t bloody work! Not when the Russians tried it. Not when the Chinese tried it. Not when the North Koreans tried it. Because there will always be inequality, whatever system is trialled.

JoanOfAllTrades · 19/12/2022 05:29

Good grief, I can only assume that you are not being serious with this post @cocktailclub and this was meant to give everyone a bit of a laugh to take some of the pre-Christmas stress away!

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 04:52

Hit post too soon.

So now we're all high paid workers, how are you going to manage inflation?

What are you going to do to make capitalism start working again?
Because I can assure you that us all simply refusing low paid work & being able to walk instantly into high paid work has just broken capitalism.

Have you never realised it's a pyramid scheme, totally dependent on 90% of people being at the arse end of the pyramid? There's only X amount of that odd construct 'money' to go round. That's why the rich can only get richer if the poor get poorer. That's why capitalism is deliberately constructed to keep wages low.

Now we are all comfortably off, where are the poor people whose poverty ensure that the rich keep getting richer? Gone. So who do you think the pyramid scheme owners are going to come after now? Yeah - the comfortably off. They don't even need guns, though they're not afraid to pay other people to use them - they have inflation. Inflation doesn't bother them, they have enough money to ride it out, & even make more money by playing rigged markets & investing in unholy practices.
But it will now bother the comfortably off, who become the new poor. And are forced to take up the shitjobs, because inflation has caused enough businesses to go bust that it's an employer's market again.

You haven't thought this through have you OP?
This is where you thank me for doing it for you btw. You're welcome. Hmm

ShandaLear · 19/12/2022 04:52

This isn’t a new thing. There have always been people like this this in work, public and private sector and there always will be. If you have a lot of staff like that it’s more likely to be your fault though - poor pay, poor conditions, poor recruitment practices, lazy management, poor work culture, etc.

Morestrangethings · 19/12/2022 04:48

MiniTheMinx · 19/12/2022 04:27

Why are so many adults and children now mentally ill?

Imo,

  1. people aren’t so afraid to admit it now- less shame around it. Shame still a problem though.

  2. mental health issues generally increase when it’s harder to make a living, house and feed yourself and your kids etc.

  3. the pandemic - enormous stress fear and isolation.

Also, we are more aware of mental
health issues as a topic because accessing help for mental health has become more difficult.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 04:39

cocktailclub · 18/12/2022 22:07

If you're paid a low wage in a job accepted then you still need to do the job you are paid to do or leave and do another job.
It's not up to individuals to say oh I'm not paid well so I will do a poor job! Don't take the job in the first place, take a higher paid job.
This is exactly the attitude I'm talking about

Ok. every single one of us, every member of the UK workforce os going to take your advice & do exactly this - take a higher paid job.

This is BRILLIANT. We are all now high paid workers.

Except ... who is now doing the low paid jobs? The shitwork, the McJobs, the zero hours & minimum wage jobs? Will you volunteer, OP?

Virginiaplain · 19/12/2022 04:39

cocktailclub · 18/12/2022 21:48

Of course the child should not suffer
But parents should be accountable

How do you make the drunken/ drug taking/ mentally I’ll/ themselves from an abusive and damaged home accountable?

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 04:34

theswoot · 18/12/2022 21:32

WELL, everyone did all the things you listed for years and years and it produced the society we have now, so doesn’t seem that great if you ask me.

👏

Lemonlady22 · 19/12/2022 04:32

RunnerBum · 18/12/2022 21:35

Ok 🙄

Let's be honest - it's a two-way street.

A) employees turned up and worked hard for the hours they were paid

I am just about the strongest believer in the world of the idea that if you do a job then you should do it well. However, there should be recognition for working hard. In my experience, in a huge number of workplaces, people are actually punished for working hard - if employee A works hard but employee B doesn't work hard, employee A will be given more workload to do. So, you're punished for doing well. People who perform well in a role are denied promotions in order to ensure they stay doing well in a department - that's unfair.

B) employees only took sick leave when they were really unwell

Many employers refuse to accommodate people's lives. People are then left needing to lie about illness to cover other aspects of their lives - like children's nativity plays or taking a dog to the vet. If employers were more open to employees having a life outside of work then it would mean employers get more notice of time off being needed and employees can get the flexibility that's required.

C) employees did not regard the usual ups and downs of life as 'mental health' but reserved that for people with actual mental illness like clinical depression, schizophrenia etc

Everyone has mental health just like everyone has physical health. Your comment is ignorant and ridiculous. If you don't maintain your mental health then you can become mentally ill. Attacking people for looking after their mental health is exceptionally ironic considering your rant goes on to complain that people need to take "a bit of ownership and responsibility for staying well".

D) employees just genuinely cared about doing a good job and tried hard

Most do. See point A.

Also would the NHS thrive if we weren't all so dependent on referrals for minor issues and just took a bit of ownership and responsibility for staying well.

Minor issues become major issues. Almost no one on the NHS is getting any help at the moment - people are dying of heart attacks and being denied emergency care. What planet are you on?

If people stopped blaming social workers for child abuse and looked at the parents.

Both can be to blame. Both are to blame. Do you think we should just eradicate social workers? Again, this point is exceptionally ironic in the light of your rant about people needing to do their jobs well - why do social workers doing their job poorly get a pass?

Surely you can see both sides of the coin on all your points? (Like any rational person).

People pull a sickie for a school nativity play? Heard it all now!

MiniTheMinx · 19/12/2022 04:27

Why are so many adults and children now mentally ill?

MiniTheMinx · 19/12/2022 04:24

WreckedUmbrella · 19/12/2022 00:27

I wish the bloody Labour Party would get back to basic socialism, "From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs." And fuck the "his" - women need equity too.
Instead of Labour just farting while sitting on various fences, blubbing and farting.

The last election......head in hands. Everyone had the opportunity right there to vote for a better and fairer society.

Stompythedinosaur · 19/12/2022 01:27

This is a very simplistic way of looking at things.

Companies are systems. Employees do not show up deciding to skive and do a bad job. The system makes them that way.

If employees are happy in their job they are sick less often, they work harder and they achieve more. This involves fair pay, respect and control over their work to some extent.

Dibbydoos · 19/12/2022 01:20

Some people have always swung the lead. It doesn't mean they're snowflakes etc, just arseholes.

The rest of us actually get on with our work - during the pandemic I regularly put in 70 hour weeks cos there was nothing else to do.

The NHS has been starved of funding to improve things by successive tory governments who are ppissed off the nhs was introduced by Labour. Noone gets to see anyone via triage without being ill these days so no idea what you mean. And frankly mental.ill health has been ignored for far too long, thankfully people are more aware of it and hence are trying to gauge what's normal and what isn't. That will take time.

Angel75 · 19/12/2022 00:30

Just wondering if it's ok to leave my son's at home from 9.30 til 2.30 while I go to work. They are 14 and 9 and sensible. I work 5 mins drive away and they can call me if needed. I can't decide... Thanks everyone

Domino20 · 19/12/2022 00:30

MiniTheMinx · 18/12/2022 21:35

I wonder what life would be like if we had true equality. If people had a fair share of the profit from their labour, if people had free education at degree and post grad level, if children had happy unstressed parents and we had fully funded fully functioning social welfare, infrastructure and an NHS that kept us all healthy and productive.

More than anything I wonder what life would be like if we had leaders who represented both the will and welfare of the people, instead of representatives of the elite and the capitalist pig dog exploiting fuckers that are destroying our planet, our lives, and our future.

Beautiful!

HotChoxs · 19/12/2022 00:29

WreckedUmbrella · 19/12/2022 00:15

Businesses still need to provide favourable conditions for their workers, and adequate wages. If they don't then they lose their workers to better employers,

Isn't this how capitalism is supposed to work?

Yes which is why when the Government doesn't allow our businesses to provide favourable conditions and adequate conditions for workers, GBP goes from $1.70 to $1.20 and everyone becomes poorer.

That's also capitalism.

WreckedUmbrella · 19/12/2022 00:27

I wish the bloody Labour Party would get back to basic socialism, "From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs." And fuck the "his" - women need equity too.
Instead of Labour just farting while sitting on various fences, blubbing and farting.

Morestrangethings · 19/12/2022 00:16

RunnerBum · 18/12/2022 21:35

Ok 🙄

Let's be honest - it's a two-way street.

A) employees turned up and worked hard for the hours they were paid

I am just about the strongest believer in the world of the idea that if you do a job then you should do it well. However, there should be recognition for working hard. In my experience, in a huge number of workplaces, people are actually punished for working hard - if employee A works hard but employee B doesn't work hard, employee A will be given more workload to do. So, you're punished for doing well. People who perform well in a role are denied promotions in order to ensure they stay doing well in a department - that's unfair.

B) employees only took sick leave when they were really unwell

Many employers refuse to accommodate people's lives. People are then left needing to lie about illness to cover other aspects of their lives - like children's nativity plays or taking a dog to the vet. If employers were more open to employees having a life outside of work then it would mean employers get more notice of time off being needed and employees can get the flexibility that's required.

C) employees did not regard the usual ups and downs of life as 'mental health' but reserved that for people with actual mental illness like clinical depression, schizophrenia etc

Everyone has mental health just like everyone has physical health. Your comment is ignorant and ridiculous. If you don't maintain your mental health then you can become mentally ill. Attacking people for looking after their mental health is exceptionally ironic considering your rant goes on to complain that people need to take "a bit of ownership and responsibility for staying well".

D) employees just genuinely cared about doing a good job and tried hard

Most do. See point A.

Also would the NHS thrive if we weren't all so dependent on referrals for minor issues and just took a bit of ownership and responsibility for staying well.

Minor issues become major issues. Almost no one on the NHS is getting any help at the moment - people are dying of heart attacks and being denied emergency care. What planet are you on?

If people stopped blaming social workers for child abuse and looked at the parents.

Both can be to blame. Both are to blame. Do you think we should just eradicate social workers? Again, this point is exceptionally ironic in the light of your rant about people needing to do their jobs well - why do social workers doing their job poorly get a pass?

Surely you can see both sides of the coin on all your points? (Like any rational person).

Great answer. I’d stick something in there about liveable wages, but kudos to you.

WreckedUmbrella · 19/12/2022 00:15

Businesses still need to provide favourable conditions for their workers, and adequate wages. If they don't then they lose their workers to better employers,

Isn't this how capitalism is supposed to work?

AdventFridgeOfShame · 19/12/2022 00:10

WreckedUmbrella · 19/12/2022 00:04

If the business fails to pay enough, so that people don't want to work for it, then that is a failed business model.

Basically yep.
It is however, rather tough for businesses at the moment. Brexit, pandemic and war have all had an effect. Businesses are having to do big adaptations to keep clients and staff. These adaptations require good management.

The Government could attempt to appear strong and stable to help with these adjustments or they could just keep doing what they do.

HotChoxs · 19/12/2022 00:09

AdventFridgeOfShame · 18/12/2022 23:59

So are all the problems in the UK caused by Kayleigh quitting as a waitress because she was well pissed off with not knowing whether she was working 2 or 5 shifts this week?
She is now happy shuffling spreadsheets for a regular income.
Meanwhile her ex boss, Sunak and Hunt are crying because she took 3 days off with Noro last year?

No the problems were caused by piss poor management of the banks. Which - weren't allowed to fail causing years of austerity which lead to a poorly skilled workforce.

Apparently if businesses don't do x y and z they deserve to fail, but if the Government prevents them doing x y and z then, ha! Let them fail and we'll just use some US companies instead.

Turkeys and xmas.

Vanillapot · 19/12/2022 00:09

AdventFridgeOfShame · 18/12/2022 22:11

Managers need to figure out that doing well at interview and doing well at the job are two different things.

I once took a job only to discover I was person number 13 to have that job in a year. At my three month review I mentioned that there were a few issues with being able to do the job and staff retention. Well that got me blacklisted. I did two years, they have yet to get someone else who has lasted 6 months. This is all the fault of the dreadful employees.

One of my lovely colleagues sent me the EOY stats, I was the second most productive employee, management hated me.

Employees also need to understand a job can be drastically different from a job description and the probation period is to decide if the job is a good fit for you.

Wish I actually knew and practiced this during my first professional job. I was the 12th person to join a team that only required 3 FT employees. Only 1 person survived our horrendous manager that had created a terrible working environment upheld with bullying.

I was not a star employee towards the end of my employment because why should I be motivated to be. Treat people like shit you get shit.