Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I might well be unreasonable but here goes.....

262 replies

cocktailclub · 18/12/2022 21:20

It seems that a lot of the working age population now are snowflakes or incompetent or just don't care enough to do a good job. It's rare to manage people who actually work reliably the hours they are paid to.
I just wonder what would happen to the economy in general if
A) employees turned up and worked hard for the hours they were paid
B) employees only took sick leave when they were really unwell
C) employees did not regard the usual ups and downs of life as 'mental health' but reserved that for people with actual mental illness like clinical depression, schizophrenia etc
D) employees just genuinely cared about doing a good job and tried hard

Also would the NHS thrive if we weren't all so dependent on referrals for minor issues and just took a bit of ownership and responsibility for staying well.

If people stopped blaming social workers for child abuse and looked at the parents.

Sorry a bit of a rant but I'm disillusioned

OP posts:
Swg · 19/12/2022 09:51

I’ve taken nearly a year’s sick leave at this point.

I’ve had cancer. And gall stones. At the same time.

What I actually need is probably another year’s rest from work to build my strength back up. And this should be financially possible because I took out critical illness cover. But… critical illness cover relies on a consultant report to pay out. And without it I couldn’t afford to resign. So on the sick I stayed, providing extra work for HR and my manager - who have both been very nice.

The request for a report went in in June. But the NHS is snowed under and no one has time for nonessential stuff, particularly as people keep thinking nonclinical work is unimportant. I chased it regularly until I finally raised it with PALS a few weeks ago out of bare desperation - I hate being a pain but I literally am running out of money.

Phone call came in to say it was signed off by insurance came through last week - so now I can finally resign and stop worrying about needing to force myself back ill. Just one example of how when systems back up everyone loses.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 19/12/2022 09:43

Computersaysno123 · 19/12/2022 09:29

Couldn't agree more. I own a restaurant and honestly can't believe the shit I have to put up with with my staff. It was always a thing to have respect (maybe a little fear haha) for your boss and work your ass off and at least pretend to if they're around. My guys do not give a shit, and it's not really their fault I just don't think kids are taught the same anymore

Maybe people are just sick of being managed by fear, and workplaces haven't quite caught up to treating staff with a modicum of respect.

Shutthegatepeter · 19/12/2022 09:38

To all the employers on here who are moaning about your minimum wage staff, maybe if you paid your staff a living wage rather than having the tax payer pick up the bill, as most of your staff who are minimum wage will rely completely on tax credits to survive because your wage is so poor, you might actually get decent staff that respect you? Nobody is interested in bending over backwards to earn you a packet, to pay off your third holiday home, when you pay them barely enough to pay their rent and bills. It’s not rocket science.

Computersaysno123 · 19/12/2022 09:29

Couldn't agree more. I own a restaurant and honestly can't believe the shit I have to put up with with my staff. It was always a thing to have respect (maybe a little fear haha) for your boss and work your ass off and at least pretend to if they're around. My guys do not give a shit, and it's not really their fault I just don't think kids are taught the same anymore

SnowlayRoundabout · 19/12/2022 08:58

If people stopped blaming social workers for child abuse and looked at the parents.

OK, so we take away the child protection function from social services and tell parents they must stop abusing their children. Do you want to be one of the children involved?

ThisGirlNever · 19/12/2022 08:53

I'm saying that any system that rewards 'needs' will result in people exaggerating their needs and playing the system, whilst simultaneously demotivating people that do work.

Socialism has never worked, doesn't work now and will never work (until we live in a completely automated society).

MiniTheMinx · 19/12/2022 08:49

ThisGirlNever · 19/12/2022 08:41

So it's best to have 'needs' rather than 'abilities' then?

Everyone has needs and abilities, unless you are now suggesting children with SEN, adults with disabilities and the elderly or sick are simply a waste of oxygen? Not a good look!

ThisGirlNever · 19/12/2022 08:41

WreckedUmbrella · 19/12/2022 00:27

I wish the bloody Labour Party would get back to basic socialism, "From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs." And fuck the "his" - women need equity too.
Instead of Labour just farting while sitting on various fences, blubbing and farting.

So it's best to have 'needs' rather than 'abilities' then?

SleeplessInEngland · 19/12/2022 08:23

This post was tongue in cheek to promote a debate and discussion

Yeah, sure it was.

SleeplessInEngland · 19/12/2022 08:22

I work in a large organisation and the older cohorts are by far the biggest piss-takers. The younger ones are much more eager to please.

LumpyandBumps · 19/12/2022 08:19

I would have said I had a good work ethic, and was lucky to be well enough to do A to D for my long career in a government department.

When it came to the staff levels being drastically reduced I applied, with many others, for voluntary redundancy with a fairly generous package.

My application was refused due to ‘needs of the business’

I understand the logic of course, but at the end of the day being a hardworking, productive member of staff isn’t always beneficial to the employee.

As well as not getting a decent package those of us who were regarded as very productive, therefore business critical, just ended up with even more work, as the workload didn’t reduce to match the staffing levels.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 07:53

cocktailclub · 19/12/2022 07:33

@luckylavender I wouldn't want to work with you either if you can't be bothered to explain

Oh piss off. You can't even be bothered to represent your opinions honestly. You've got no business coming it the high & mighty, you tone deaf twit.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 07:51

cocktailclub · 19/12/2022 07:35

Anyway

This post was tongue in cheek to promote a debate and discussion

It doesn't represent all my true views but things I hear around me

I do think the systems are broken

Oh. A goady fucker then.

Because you're sure as hell not Jonathan Swift.

KettrickenSmiled · 19/12/2022 07:49

Pumperthepumper · 19/12/2022 07:34

Christ. Your argument is essentially ‘all of these public services the Tories have cut to the none are no longer fit for purpose!’ Welcome to 2022.

Cheers @Pumperthepumper. Saved me an angry rant.

OBVIOUSLY it's all those highly-paid GP's fault that the govt has slashed funding, cut auxillary services, deliberately understaffed to the point appointments can't be accommodated, & put obstacles in the way of GP surgeries for over a decade.

Maybe these GP's need to start putting in more than 70 hours a week, the lazy bastards.

I thought you approved of high earners @cocktailclub - wasn't your OP predicated on the notion that you'd be living in glorious nirvana if people would ALL only apply for better paid jobs?

This is a bit of a puzzling U-turn but I'll give it a shot for you. Maybe you'd prefer to be treated by a GP on minimum wage? They'd have no medical training, obvs, because study & resident hours wouldn't be affordable to someone not earning enough to heat & eat, by by jove that should fix it.

Well fuck my old boots I just ranted anyway.

Eyerollcentral · 19/12/2022 07:45

@cocktailclub ‘tongue in cheek’ to provoke debate? Do you mean what you have typed there? Doesn’t seem tongue in cheek, just goody.

What kind of a/hole comes on here first thing on a December Monday morning when a lot of people are under serious financial pressure and yes off sick (mainly because of over work) and starts winding people up??? The kind that goes by @cocktailclub.

Maybe ask Santa for a life

cocktailclub · 19/12/2022 07:35

Anyway

This post was tongue in cheek to promote a debate and discussion

It doesn't represent all my true views but things I hear around me

I do think the systems are broken

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 19/12/2022 07:34

cocktailclub · 19/12/2022 07:31

@Eyerollcentral
Don't get me started on GPs....yes I do hold them responsible for signing off sick certificates without even offering a face to face appointment or any treatment.
I think GPs are an example of how employees are playing the system. Of course I'm talking in general terms but they no longer provide an effective service yet get highly paid.
The money would be better spent on allied professionals like physiotherapists, CBT practitioners, dieticians and such who could advise on treatment of minor issues

Christ. Your argument is essentially ‘all of these public services the Tories have cut to the none are no longer fit for purpose!’ Welcome to 2022.

cocktailclub · 19/12/2022 07:33

@luckylavender I wouldn't want to work with you either if you can't be bothered to explain

OP posts:
cocktailclub · 19/12/2022 07:31

@Eyerollcentral
Don't get me started on GPs....yes I do hold them responsible for signing off sick certificates without even offering a face to face appointment or any treatment.
I think GPs are an example of how employees are playing the system. Of course I'm talking in general terms but they no longer provide an effective service yet get highly paid.
The money would be better spent on allied professionals like physiotherapists, CBT practitioners, dieticians and such who could advise on treatment of minor issues

OP posts:
luckylavender · 19/12/2022 07:28

cocktailclub · 18/12/2022 21:20

It seems that a lot of the working age population now are snowflakes or incompetent or just don't care enough to do a good job. It's rare to manage people who actually work reliably the hours they are paid to.
I just wonder what would happen to the economy in general if
A) employees turned up and worked hard for the hours they were paid
B) employees only took sick leave when they were really unwell
C) employees did not regard the usual ups and downs of life as 'mental health' but reserved that for people with actual mental illness like clinical depression, schizophrenia etc
D) employees just genuinely cared about doing a good job and tried hard

Also would the NHS thrive if we weren't all so dependent on referrals for minor issues and just took a bit of ownership and responsibility for staying well.

If people stopped blaming social workers for child abuse and looked at the parents.

Sorry a bit of a rant but I'm disillusioned

I could argue with this but I can't be bothered. I'll just say I wouldn't want to work with you. And for the record, I'm 60 and have been managing people for years.

Eyerollcentral · 19/12/2022 07:24

@cocktailclub what do you do for a living?
Social services have been asked to explain themselves where children have been killed by neglectful or murderous parents. Usually after the parents have already been tried, that’s usually how the failure to spot the abuse is revealed. What exactly is your problem with that?
Re wages, jobs and effort you want people earning the least to what work themselves to the bone?? People should do what’s required of them to meet the contractual terms set out by their employer. In my experience if they don’t, they get fired.
Finally, you know it’s medical professionals who sign off on sick leave? So it’s their professional opinion as to whether or not someone is fit to return to work? Does your gripe extend to the medical profession or is only reserved for those of a more lowly position?

Pumperthepumper · 19/12/2022 07:20

Remember too that we’re now seeing over a decade of SS cuts - so the primary-aged children who lived with abuse are now approaching the age where they will be having their own kids. And we know abuse is cyclical.

I don’t work in social services but for anyone who does: have we seen any changes in policy since the last child was murdered?

Pumperthepumper · 19/12/2022 07:18

cocktailclub · 19/12/2022 07:12

But that's your opinion

I am saying that everyone turns on social workers when there is a tragic child abuse case. However often there is a parent who has walked away from any responsibility (a dad who separates from the mum whose new boyfriend abuses the child).
Everyone has a role to play in preventing abuse not just social services.

I actually don’t think that’s true any more. It’s generally accepted that the government have cut social service funding so brutally and so relentlessly that there will be children who are missed. Then when those children die, after years of neglect and abuse, everyone just nods and says ‘something must be done’. Then vote the Tories in for another go.

cocktailclub · 19/12/2022 07:12

RegularNameChangerVersion21 · 19/12/2022 05:52

Ridiculous post.

Especially your point about blaming social workers for child abuse. So you think we should just allow children to be abused and then assign blame to parents afterwards? The point is to protect children not assign blame.

People should be paid a living wage to work and the NHS and education system shouldn't rely on the god will of nurses and teachers (who often can't afford to heat their homes) to function. People should expect to pay for public services not vote in a government that will deliberately starve them of funding then act surprised when they don't function well anymore.

But that's your opinion

I am saying that everyone turns on social workers when there is a tragic child abuse case. However often there is a parent who has walked away from any responsibility (a dad who separates from the mum whose new boyfriend abuses the child).
Everyone has a role to play in preventing abuse not just social services.

OP posts:
Thehonestbadger · 19/12/2022 06:20

cocktailclub · 18/12/2022 21:20

It seems that a lot of the working age population now are snowflakes or incompetent or just don't care enough to do a good job. It's rare to manage people who actually work reliably the hours they are paid to.
I just wonder what would happen to the economy in general if
A) employees turned up and worked hard for the hours they were paid
B) employees only took sick leave when they were really unwell
C) employees did not regard the usual ups and downs of life as 'mental health' but reserved that for people with actual mental illness like clinical depression, schizophrenia etc
D) employees just genuinely cared about doing a good job and tried hard

Also would the NHS thrive if we weren't all so dependent on referrals for minor issues and just took a bit of ownership and responsibility for staying well.

If people stopped blaming social workers for child abuse and looked at the parents.

Sorry a bit of a rant but I'm disillusioned

I wonder what would happen if

  • employees could afford to own a home based on their wage
  • employees could afford to feed their families based on their wage
  • employees could afford childcare so they could work the hours they were supposed to.
  • employers were held accountable for their own hours/work load.

Maybe if those things were true ‘mental health’ wouldn’t be such an issue and young people would be more motivated to work.

I’m a very young end millennial (almost 30) and have given 110% to every job I was in since been a teen. I have a very good degree and work very hard, turn up on time an punctual…etc

Every job I ever had offered a £25-35k salary for a 40 hour week but had workloads that required 50+ hours a week just to keep your head above water…and they expected you to be available at all times of day.
Im now a SAHM to 2 toddlers because the childcare costs were more than my ‘decent’ salary.