Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to send my DD only to private school because she has special needs?

104 replies

Cookiecrumblepie · 18/12/2022 20:22

My daughter will be starting reception next year, and she's just been diagnosed with autism. At the moment she is fine at her small nursery but she doesn't like busy environments and lots of stimulation etc, so I'm thinking a private school with small class size would be perfect for her.

However I can't afford to send both my children to private school, and my other younger daughter I would have to send to a public school.

Will this create resentment in future? Has anyone grown up with a sibling with special needs (and required extra help). Were you resentful? Or did you grow up understanding why your parents treated each child differently?

OP posts:
thefuturesnotourstosee · 18/12/2022 20:54

If you're going to do this choose VERY CAREFULLY

DS has some SEN and is in a private school. One of the reasons we chose them ks that they were known for a nurturing environment. They still get superb results but it's a school run along the lines of - if we care academic success will follow.

DS has had a lot of 1 to 1 support where required, they've pushed hum at what he's good at ( he's in year 6 and doing year 9 maths) and supported him where he struggles. It's worked. Hes now in waiting list for an excellent school and has scholarship for another.

However 2 schools close by manage out children with "issues" around year 3. Some of them have ended up at DSs school and their parents have told me their DC was just left to drift and constantly berated for not laying attention, poor hand writing etc. etc. They were also sold the nurturing environment story. Ask a school how many children left at the end of years 1, 2 and 3 and reasons given. Theirs answers or lack of the. could be very revealing..Ask other parents What they think ESPECIALLY of you know any whose children left school before end. Trust your gut. Ask to look round during school day (if they say no forget it)

The small.class.sizes combined with good support can be brilliant but the wrong choice could end in a horrible mess probably in year 3

Cookiecrumblepie · 18/12/2022 20:52

Thank you - yes I just want to provide the best I can for each to thrive, within the means that I have. I could send DD to a state school/free, but I worry that she will struggle more.

OP posts:
Cookiecrumblepie · 18/12/2022 20:51

I am in the UK, but I'm not from the UK originally hence mixing up my wording with public/private schools!

It's really useful to hear opinions as I'm still at a point where I can change my decision. I did speak to her nursery teacher who said at the moment DD doesn't need any SEN support. But we saw a specialist doctor who said DD is definitely autistic, with social/emotional challenges. I suspect her learning may be okay but socialisation will be the difficult. If course I can't be sure, am discovering things day by day.

OP posts:
Andsoforth · 18/12/2022 20:51

I chose to send my SN dc to a private secondary - and it’s been an excellent choice. But my younger do has completely different needs that I feel will be better met in the local school. She’s also more likely to go on to university and need our financial support at that point.

I think you just have to try and meet each individual child’s needs as best you can.

CouldYouGetRid · 18/12/2022 20:50

2 of my siblings went to private school, me and my other 2 siblings went to the local state school. This was because my parents had more money when my youngest siblings came along. Plus they felt one of those siblings might have struggled in state secondary school.

I don't resent my siblings or my parents for that decision.

However, I'm a professional who supports autistic children in schools. State schools are generally much better resourced, experienced and set up for autistic children.

lifehappens12 · 18/12/2022 20:49

We were considering this but for a child with speech delay. We thought he would be left behind in state school by the lack of attention and big classes sizes.

So we thought he would be better at a private primary school. We have a great private speech therapist who works at the local schools and she put us off. Her reasons were that the schools are very academic and if he start to fall behind and struggle that will be very difficult for him.

What we have done instead is kept our private therapist and she goes to the school and helps us and helps him. So rather then pay for private education we will look to see what we can add with additional help.

So I know speech delay is different but my son gets overwhelmed by the large group learning but his therapist is working with him and school to put strategies in place.

Sorry for the ramble but this is what we are doing

SeenAndNot · 18/12/2022 20:47

My sibling went to a private secondary and I didn’t, for valid reasons. I was happy in my school. They couldn’t join me there. I don’t resent them one bit. Made no difference on what we achieved at uni & post uni.

Twoshoesnewshoes · 18/12/2022 20:46

You potentially have at least a decade of private school fees - is it possible to consider investing that money in a different way and moving?
we have lived in two areas of England, hundreds of miles apart, but similar in that we were in small villages about 20/30 minutes drive from a large city.
our DC all went to village schools that had v small class sizes and still do, good SEN provision too.

saraclara · 18/12/2022 20:44

My brother went to a private school for similar reasons (though due to frequent hospitalisation meaning that he missed a lot of primary school and it was clear that he'd struggle in secondary.

I didn't mind one bit. But his school was a Steiner school and I found it freaky. No way would I have wanted to go there, so there was no jalousy at all.

gliiterryballs · 18/12/2022 20:43

Why don't you home educate?

Testina · 18/12/2022 20:42

Are you in the U.K.? Just you talking about public schools… if you’re not in the U.K. we may give you bad advice about keeping her in state schools.

BedTaker · 18/12/2022 20:41

I don't have tonnes of anecdata of this, but what I do have tells me that private schools aren't great at helping children with autism.

lunar1 · 18/12/2022 20:39

You don't know what your second daughter will need in the future. You can't invest so much in one child and not the other.

You certainly can't tell at two years old.

mangoesaretheonlyfruit · 18/12/2022 20:34

I know a family that did this OP. It did cause resentment for a long while until the child who went to the state school became an adult and gained some perspective.

I would send each child to the school that best meets their needs, but I understand your predicament.

DontSpeakLatinInFrontOfTheBooks · 18/12/2022 20:33

As others have said, what happens if your younger child also has additional needs and would benefit from private education?

That’s assuming private school is even the answer. Just because there are smaller class sizes it doesn’t mean your child will be ok there and some private schools reject applications from children who have additional needs for whatever reason.

Sirzy · 18/12/2022 20:33

Ds didn’t show signs of autism at 2 really. He is 13 now and has full time 1-1 in school to allow him to come close to accessing the curriculum.

NuffSaidSam · 18/12/2022 20:32

Also, just FYI public school also essentially means private in England. You mean a state school (free).

Sirzy · 18/12/2022 20:31

Many private schools aren’t brilliantly set up to deal with children with additional needs.

what will you do if your younger child also has additional needs?

NuffSaidSam · 18/12/2022 20:31

I think you should probably look at the specific schools available in your area and then make a decision about which school is best, there's no guarantee that a private school would be better (often worse!).

Cookiecrumblepie · 18/12/2022 20:30

Younger daughter is 2, she hasn't displayed any signs of autism. School runs and different holidays will be fine, I live very close to both a private school and an outstanding rated public school, and I have family support.

Currently medical assessment and nursery say my DD doesn't need a specialist school, but she would benefit from smaller class sizes, more 121 attention. I've visited the public school and it's a very busy environment that I think DD would struggle with. I think she could cope, but she wouldn't thrive.

I am very aware of creating jealousy between siblings, but I just can't afford the same opportunities for both. However I think providing the best I can for each, given their different needs should hopefully be understood by the when they're older?!

OP posts:
golfwidow88 · 18/12/2022 20:30

Also; re younger sibling. DD is still a baby but if she has any signs of ASD etc then we can afford for her to go to private. If not I'm not sure we will bother? Unsure at the moment! See how she gets on.

Fedupnowhadenough · 18/12/2022 20:30

Private schools aren’t great with kids with special needs

sadsomeone · 18/12/2022 20:30

I considered sending my DD who has autism to a private school. They said they wouldn't accept her as they don't offer 1:1 help and she would need to fit in with them.

I know they would need to make reasonable adjustments but they seemed very very reluctant. It wasn't the sort of environment I wanted my DD to be in.

golfwidow88 · 18/12/2022 20:29

I agree with above poster; some private schools are shocking.

My son is nearly 11; ASD and ADHD. The ADHD is much more prevalent though.

We moved him out of state to private in Year 2. First school was amazing and his SENCO was great but it unfortunately it closed down.

He then went to a second private school and it was awful. One teacher actually said to us that he was just naughty and to take him back to be retested!!

We pulled him out after that comment and refused to pay a months notice. It was appalling.

We then had found a new school which has been okay. He's off to senior next year and the two schools we like have great provisions. So we shall see.

Sometimes I wish we just didn't move him at all. But hoping senior school may be better.

Macaroni46 · 18/12/2022 20:29

When I taught in a private schools there was an unusually high number of children with autism/ADHD etc because lots of parents thought the same as you OP. Their needs were not necessarily well met either.