Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to expect my siblings to help care for our elderly parents

186 replies

Windleberry · 18/12/2022 18:11

What to do? I think I just wanted to vent really and gather opinions, thoughts, advice.

My parents are 88 and 93 - mother has advanced dementia, doubly incontinent, can no longer converse, can no longer walk. Father - memory now pretty bad but physically okay, has phases in denial that mother is as ill as she is.

I have 5 siblings. We all live over 100k away from our parents and in different directions to each other. Only 2 of my siblings drive. Our parents live in countryside, 7k from a railway station with a very scant bus service from the rail station to their village.

During covid my husband and I, completely by chance, ended up living, temporarily, just 30k away from them so we popped in to them once or twice a week and, as their care needs grew, we got more involved in helping them over the next 2 years.

During this time, even after lock down was lifted, my siblings rarely visited them and when they did it was just for lunch and a chat - nothing practical like laundry, cleaning, bill paying - they left that all to me and my husband. However they demanded to know everything that was going on with them so I updated them on everything we did or planned to do.

In March 2022 my husband and I had to return return home, 100k away from my parents, therefore my husband and I arranged a daily carer to help my parents for an hour a day (they refused more than that - accepting care is and was a huge struggle so it was extremely difficult to put in place).

More recently, with mother's condition ever declining and now needing two people to lift, wash and change her we increased care to two carers for 3x1 hour visits a day. Imo my father also now needs help with houshold things as he can no longer drive to the shops for food etc and often forgets to make meals for them both, yet will not allow the carers to prepare meals for them. My husband and I organised delivery of microwaveble meal and deal with their finances. I asked the carers to contact any of us if/when necessary. Me and my siblings have equal health and financial POA but I am the only one who has bothered to use them.

Due to a disability I can no longer drive and am off work long term sick so rely on my husband to drive us when we visit my parents. I have been by train a dew times but it's a difficult journey because of my disability, lack of buses and my finances won't stretch to taxi fares.

Fast forward, since moving away from my parents my siblings have started a visiting rota but still look to me as lead. If something doing is needed by the carer it is either me doing it or it is met with a silence - I've tried to stand down hoping they will take initiative but it doesnt happen and my parents are thr ones who suffer. My siblings pretend to miss the carers' calls, pretend they have no internet, pretend they're suddenly working full time plus late into the night and/or are "too busy", too tired, too everything.

Recently the carers have taken some days off on which some of us took turns to cover them. The care is mainly getting my mother up from bed, her incontinence pants changed and clean up where she's spread faeces around. It's unpleasant having to deal with changing and cleaning mother and age hates it too. Despite her dementia she is aware and doesn't like her children doing it and besides she's physically stronger than me puts up a terrific fight and my husband and I are afraid of hurting her in the process.

The Carers are taking 5 days over Christmas off. Nobody volunteered to cover for them, all kinds of excuses, so eventually my husband (who is an angel) and I said we would cover Christmas eve, Christmas day and Boxing day. Another sibling stepped up for the other 2 days.

However, yesterday, my husband's elderly mother has been rushed into hospital and is in intensive care, reason unknown. My husband's parents live 200k away in the opposite direction to my parents.

Obviously my husband needs to be available for his mother now and, because the rail network is on strike over Christmas, there are no trains running so I find myself unable to get to my parents and can no longer cover for the carers.

I told my siblings that my husbands mother was urgently rushed into hospital in a critical state, cause unknown, and that as there were no trains over Christmas I could no longer cover care of our parents over Christmas.

So far - days later - not one of my siblings has offered to step in to help our parents. One has said she'll phone the carer, so I expect she plans to ask the carers to cancel their holiday!

I am angry and resentful that not one of them has stepped forward to help their parents, parents that have helped them enormously over the years.

What really rankles is that I've found out from doing my parents finances that every single one of them has had huge financial handouts (one was even bought a house, another a new car etc!) from my parents over their lives but, when I asked for help to pay a dental fee, my parents declined. Yes, I am bitter, yes it is an ugly feeling, and yes I feel resentful that my husband has done more for my parents than my siblings have.

I am waiting to see what they come up with to help our parents now that I'm unavailable. Minute by minute it seems increasingly likely that they're happy to let our mother fester in her bed of urine and faeces while they enjoy their Christmases.

What would you do? Respite care in a home is not an option and I've been unable to find respite carers - so it is down to me and my siblings.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bunnycat101 · 28/12/2022 19:45

The problem is people often don’t live
close to parents, have jobs and small families of their own. To the posters saying it is selfish not to provide care, how the hell do they think it would work if you’re 2 hours away, working full time with your own children. Our modern lifestyles just aren’t set up for that and people are living longer with arguably a lower quality of life.

OP If your siblings are keen for parents to stay at home they need to do much more. It sounds like the needs have gone beyond the max 4 carer visits to a point where residential care would be better for dignity etc. unless they’re offering to move in they need to justify how on earth she can stay at
home safely.

AreOttersJustWetCats · 28/12/2022 18:56

You need to point to this as an example of why that simply isn't possible. They need more care than family can give.

Windleberry · 28/12/2022 18:02

@AreOttersJustWetCats it's my siblings that want my parents to stay in our parent's own home.

OP posts:
AreOttersJustWetCats · 28/12/2022 14:52

Your parents need permanent residential care, and you have been propping up an utterly unsustainable state of affairs through your interventions. It may feel like kindness, but you're actually perpetuating a situation where your parents aren't having their (substantial) needs met.

Sometimes you need to let things fail to demonstrate what changes are needed - could your siblings be doing this?

Momscarer · 28/12/2022 14:44

I didn't come on here to get into arguments with strangers. I didn't refer to nursing care in my post - I cannot do nursing care and it seems self explanatory to me that expecting people to do nursing care when they are not qualified would be ridiculous and unsafe for all involved. I'm sorry you cannot visit your parents. My response was referring to people who can visit their parents but don't.

LindorDoubleChoc · 28/12/2022 14:39

@Momscarer - I was referring to your assertion "we don't have an obligation to sacrifice our own lives and finances to do but being there and caring is something everyone can do".

Jade1334 · 28/12/2022 00:26

More than birth here. Did you read the post?

Momscarer · 27/12/2022 11:51

What are you talking about? I have never proposed anything to you and I don't know who you are or what your situation is. I hope you find help for your mother.

LindorDoubleChoc · 27/12/2022 09:31

@Momscarer. How do you propose I care for my almost completely immobile 91 year old mother with severe copd when I live a 2.5 hour drive away and work 4 days a week?

cptartapp · 27/12/2022 08:43

Noneyabizness · 27/12/2022 00:00

I know this was posted a long time ago. I just wanted to say that people who insist it isn't children's responsible to care for aging parents are the most selfish and entitled people. Seriously since the beginning of time the young take care of the old...except now in a select few "advanced" societies. Getting help from in home care givers is great but extremely expensive and facilities are horrendous. I don't care how nice they are and most aren't that nice. If you don't agree with me. I dare you to get a job at one and just work there for six months. Then tell me how you would feel about living there, especially when you can't help yourself. I'm sorry that your siblings are selfish and can't help. If they are "too busy" to assist someone that gave them life, then they should each pay for one day of care. Best of luck.

The selfishness lies with anyone at the end of their days prioritising their own wants and denying the life opportunities of their own children in the prime of theirs, by allowing the burden of 'caring'.

countrygirl99 · 27/12/2022 05:49

Since the beginning of time a lot less people lived to.advanced old age with severe needs. Certainly 3 of our 4 par3nts would have died many years ago. And very few people would have been trying to care for 2 sets of parents each an hour away with 24 hour care needs determined to staying their own homes which are 1 bedroom bungalows while trying to pay their own bills. So maybe you should think abut what's actually involved in what you think people's should be doing before you criticise.

Noneyabizness · 27/12/2022 00:00

I know this was posted a long time ago. I just wanted to say that people who insist it isn't children's responsible to care for aging parents are the most selfish and entitled people. Seriously since the beginning of time the young take care of the old...except now in a select few "advanced" societies. Getting help from in home care givers is great but extremely expensive and facilities are horrendous. I don't care how nice they are and most aren't that nice. If you don't agree with me. I dare you to get a job at one and just work there for six months. Then tell me how you would feel about living there, especially when you can't help yourself. I'm sorry that your siblings are selfish and can't help. If they are "too busy" to assist someone that gave them life, then they should each pay for one day of care. Best of luck.

SocialLite · 26/12/2022 15:56

Windleberry · 19/12/2022 12:39

Thank you everyone for your replies at this busy time. Your comments and suggestions are invaluable and have helped me to see the situation more clearly. I will post the outcome as soon as there is one.

Thank you all wonderful people. ❤

Hi! Did you manage to get anything sorted over Christmas?

countrygirl99 · 26/12/2022 15:40

@Momscarer that very much depends on the level of need, geographical proximity and whether they are prepared to accept other help.

Momscarer · 26/12/2022 15:21

One does not have to be a matyr to help their parents.

Renata79 · 26/12/2022 05:58

justasking111 · 25/12/2022 16:43

Happened with our neighbour during covid lockdown. She went down hill frail, falling over, incontinent, one son came when he could 100 miles away but his health was poor, he didn't have POA though. The brother who did refused to visit or consider a home. Her panic button used to go off and neighbours informed. They were older too. One day four times she fell and soiled herself. She had to be lifted cleaned up. They called an ambulance. Height of covid. Paramedics advised against it. Neighbours phoned son and said enough. He then arranged carers with the council. One day she finally broke her hip. Went into hospital, got covid, recovered. She then refused to go home, her son wouldn't consider a care home. She died there.

The following week the son who had control of her estate turned up, moved into her house telling everyone he was retiring here. No mention of the other brother who visited regularly. He's a loathsome man. But considerably wealthier now.

It's all about the money for some folk

OMG! Having kids is a worthless & thankless job! Can't blame some ppl for now having them!

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/12/2022 19:19

Having gone through dementia with both a parent and and in law, I do know how very hard it is. But really, I do agree with pps, that it’s time for a care home. You need to get social services involved say they are at risk and vulnerable - the buzzwords - and that you are absolutely no longer able to supply anything approaching their care needs.

Refusing care, except from family, is unfortunately all too common, but at some point, very often, a person’s needs have to override their ‘wants’.

If you aren’t already aware, the Alzheimer’s Society has a forum for carers (and despairing relatives!) of people with dementia. For too many years it was a lifeline for me. Whatever you’re going through, someone will have been there.

There are rarely any easy answers, but at least you can offload to others who know exactly what it’s like. Too often people who haven’t been there even for a week, have not a clue, but think they do, and offer facile answers that make you want to scream!

Good luck!

Dontlikeveg · 25/12/2022 18:59

YellowTreeHouse · 18/12/2022 18:12

YABU. They are not obliged to help care for their parents just because they gave birth to them.

WOW!

Seasider2017 · 25/12/2022 18:46

This situation is similar to mil
she lived in an apartment with communal lounge
over time she needed more care
sil lived about 6mls from her, so she did most things. Other Sil hardly any, excuses anxiety, can’t get out, can’t drive that far etc(she had car) my dp we lived 27mls away, dp could I felt do more imo, when there he’d do lot of talking to her and knew how to make her laugh
further down the line, mil became forgetful
incontinent although would insist she was fine and could go to the shop & cook !!! No no she couldn’t . She had carers 3x daily, really didn’t want them, but eventually didn’t even know how many were coming
Nearest Sil (we found out) was POA and handled everything(sis&bro not informed) things became too much for Sil and we think she contacted SS and a home was found
sis&bro got a text to say she was now in nursing home and apartment was being sold

mil memory is bad now, we get the same 3 repeated questions over & over repeatedly
she won’t walk anywhere, won’t go in the lounge
stays in her room with her tv.
She is in very good spirits when talking and visiting her and still has a very good sense of humour, which is good
she doesn’t remember her apartment or where she lived.

so what I would suggest is
the less people involved the better, you & dh just do it. Your sister don’t really have the right to say “ stay in their home”
As I mentioned mil at beginning was adamant there was No way she was going in a home
and even said to nearest dd not to put her in one.
She now say, it’s nice in here, the food is good and lovely people. 😊

bruce43mydog · 25/12/2022 18:19

You need to find a nice care home. The care assistants will be on hand day and night 24/7. Your parents will be looked after, and kept feed, encouraged to drink plenty, they will be kept clean and warm. They we still be together. You can visit as much as you want and get to enjoy the time with your parents. Your siblings can visit and enjoy time with your parents too.

At the care home where I worked some residents and family's were apprehensive about going into a care home. Some residents use to come for 2-4 weeks just to try settle in with the option of going back home if things didn't work out.

If I were you I would at least try to see if it would work for you, your Husband, your parents, siblings etc...

I've said to my family if ever i'm ill or to frail to look after myself then I have no hesitation in going to live in a care home where I will be looked after.

Good luck with what ever you all decide to do.

Beautiful3 · 25/12/2022 18:07

They really need to be going into a care home. You cannot expect anything from your siblings. It cannot continue as it is. They will become unwell at home. Get the ball rolling.

countrygirl99 · 25/12/2022 17:25

Momscarer · 25/12/2022 15:02

I was also quite horrified by the viewpoint that we have no obligation to care for parents. So crazy. Unless your parent was an abuser or a murderer, we do indeed have a connection to the people who brought us into the world and raised us, even if they screwed up. We don't have an obligation to sacrifice our own lives and finances to do but being there and caring is something everyone can do. The elder abuse and neglect in the modern world is catastrophic. Elderly people have a lot to give and contribute if they are supported.

The trouble is sacrificing your own life is too often what's expected.

IToldYouAmillionTimesAlready · 25/12/2022 16:48

I worked as a carer for 20 years, and saw lots of families like yours - some would do everything to help, and some would do nothing. Caring for someone in the later stages of Dementia is such hard work - physically, as well as emotionally draining. If it were MY mum, I'd seriously be thinking about long-term care in a home. I'm sorry for your situation.

justasking111 · 25/12/2022 16:43

Happened with our neighbour during covid lockdown. She went down hill frail, falling over, incontinent, one son came when he could 100 miles away but his health was poor, he didn't have POA though. The brother who did refused to visit or consider a home. Her panic button used to go off and neighbours informed. They were older too. One day four times she fell and soiled herself. She had to be lifted cleaned up. They called an ambulance. Height of covid. Paramedics advised against it. Neighbours phoned son and said enough. He then arranged carers with the council. One day she finally broke her hip. Went into hospital, got covid, recovered. She then refused to go home, her son wouldn't consider a care home. She died there.

The following week the son who had control of her estate turned up, moved into her house telling everyone he was retiring here. No mention of the other brother who visited regularly. He's a loathsome man. But considerably wealthier now.

It's all about the money for some folk

Renata79 · 25/12/2022 16:18

I'm so sorry you're dealing with this! Kids are becoming so ungrateful & selfish!

Swipe left for the next trending thread