Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sorry Xenia...

588 replies

duchesse · 02/02/2008 16:58

...for starting that thread when I didn't believe you existed (and I genuinely didn't). I've done some proper research now, and realise that you are real person with fantastic real achievement. I apologise unreservedly for my previous thread, which was genuinely not designed to get at you since I did not believe you existed. I am aghast and incredibly impressed at how much you have achieved, and look forward to sparring with you again some time...

OP posts:
mrsruffallo · 05/02/2008 19:01

sure is, spankhurst

Quattrocento · 05/02/2008 18:59

PW - egregious shite - LOL - what a fabulous expression - didn't know a SAHM could be either funny or intelligent - imagine that

pankhurst · 05/02/2008 18:59

is this a come on, mrsruffallo?

we've already got bondage going on

(looks down at mrsmattie and gives a little wave of the carrot)

mrsruffallo · 05/02/2008 18:55

What's wrong with being sexy?

karen999 · 05/02/2008 18:53

Actually Xenia has a point. I have spent the last year on maternity leave. Some days I did find it hard to get dressed, go to the shops and was often miserable when DP got home. It was he who pointed out to me that I needed to go back to work.

I work better under pressure and when I have loads to do/needs doing. I was a far better mother when I was working and studying. The more I have to do the easier it is for me to organise everything and set aside time for everyone.

I have spend the last year on ML and what it has taken me to do in that year I could have done in 1 week when I was working/studying.

I think the point about how much you earn = how intelligent you are is a bit simplistic. I have known women who have earned a great deal of money but are not that intelligent. In contrast I know women who earn little but who are extremely intelligent. I think it comes down to what you want from life. If you want to stay at home, brilliant....equally if you want to work then why not?

As long as you are happy and satisfied in what you do then I cannot see a problem.

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 18:47

(Chains herself to pankhurst's leg, Suffragette style)

Yes, yes, we demand answers!

pankhurst · 05/02/2008 18:44

(waves carrot madly)

pankhurst · 05/02/2008 18:43

(leaps up at the sound of sexist orthodoxy being challenges and runs back into room waving half-dried carrot that she found under the SMEG)

OK.

Challenge the sexist orthodoxy by asking why the vast majority of people earning over 100K have a dick, not greater intelligence, higher education, more insight into child psychology or anything else that better qualifies them.

Challenge why the majority of debates between women are about which woman is better than the other, rather than why we are still paid less than the XYs for doing work of equal or far more impressive value.

Once you've done that, challenge the sexist orthodoxy that says you're doing it wrong whether you stay at home or go out to work.

By not promoting one side of that coin over the other.

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

policywonk · 05/02/2008 18:35

Thank you IB. I think I should be getting paid too...

LOL at Pankhurst, esp. tillworking titwit

Xenia, you really are talking the most egregious shite.

Judy1234 · 05/02/2008 18:32

They are important issues to consider. I do think with a few exceptions women who earn over £100k are less likely to give up work and tend to be better educated than those on £12k. Now you can obviously find examples where that is not so but a general survey of most would show those over £100k probably better educated and probably higher IQ than most of those on £12k.

If you are organised to earn that and to work and manage child care with your husbnd then you are probably reasonably emotionally sorted, not suffering from PND, depression or have other mental health issues. If you can just about get dressed at home and the trip to the shops is a challenge with the baby you might be having more emotional problems and be less able to cope with the children and not be in general as "sorted" and organised and able to cope with life in general if you are a housewife.

But it's a fairly pointless debate. It just annoys me you never see those points put - that working mothers may well be a lot better mothers than housewives. It's good to challenge orthodoxy particularly when it's sexist orthodoxy designed to keep women at home.

pankhurst · 05/02/2008 18:16

"...just as I don't care if women say to me I ought to be home with my children."

(sighs and wipes an eye).

You've been telling this woman that she ought to stay at home with her children, MrsM, haven't you? Come on, be honest? THAT's exactly what you think they need, isn't it?

You spotted her superior emotional intelligence from her paypacket, didn't you? Just admit it.

(sighs)

Oh, me!

(chortles her way back to wiping under the fridge muttering under breath)

'Surely it's common sense...'

(dissolves again)

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 18:06

She is funny. Hilarious.

lucyellensmum · 05/02/2008 18:05

I have a friend who is just about to have her second child. She will be a WOHM on a relatively (well very) low wage. But she enjoys her job, and is bloody good at it. She tells me she would rather stay at home but cannot afford too. I cannot see how she works that out tbh - two children in childcare will just about take ALL of her wages. I guess she is made to feel guilty too for her choice. It would be nice if she could say - my career is important to me, i dont want to give it up, as i think that is a fair decision.

pankhurst · 05/02/2008 18:02

MrsMattie,

If you are going to carry on stating the obvious, you are going to spoil the fun! Of course that's what's hapening, but she's making a joke out of the emotional intelligence thing and the better with children

it's self-deprecatory humour

(tuts and mutters to self)

god, some people on this thread just don't get it, do they?

IorekByrnison · 05/02/2008 18:02

Policy what a brilliant post. Mrs M is right. You should be getting paid for this.

lucyellensmum · 05/02/2008 17:59

No, Really, shoudlnt it be "the more intelligent woman?" or the "more clever"...i'm not entirely sure about cleverer.. saying it out loud to see if it works...hmmmm.

I think you summed it up there Xenia - 100k a year and i would find that hard to give up, not in the least because i would have thought if your income is at that level, your outgoings will match, you're bound to have bigger house, higher mortgage etc. So in a way, being on a lower wage is almost easier to make the decision to be the SAHM. I think that has been the bone of contention for me. My "career" for what it is worth, is academia. I think the average wage for a first time post-doctorial position is 25K, which is a fair wage. But not enough to make me want to not be a SAHM. In the long term i guess i am being short sighted, and my decision is also influenced by personal circs and the fact that i am probably not going to stay in science, at least in university based research. It isn't just the whole, "but DD needs me" argument. Its also the whole thing of having to be ultra organised, have issues with childcare when it goes wrong, there is a problem at nursery, DD is ill and cannot attend etc etc. I just don't want that level of stress in my life thankyou very much. My salary wouldnt cover a nanny, and im not the sort of person who could have another person in my house. I would be uncomfortable. Thats just me.

If i were to earn double that, then i would, i suppose re-think, as we do struggle financially but my getting a job at this stage would make little difference to the overall picture. I also do DPs admin for him so would have to do that on top of everything else. In a few years time when DD is at school, i may well go back, depending on what happens with our business, as i may need to do that full time (fingers crossed).

pankhurst · 05/02/2008 17:59

ha ha

(pauses) er, hang on.

(stops confused mid snigger)

wasn't there a hierarchy of mothers a minute ago?

12k a year tillworking titwit was at the bottom.

100k a year EMOTIONAL GENIUS was at the top.

Where's EDUCATION coming into this? (wonders out loud) Now where do I put SAHM mum WITH EDUCATION?

?Under titwit???

Or just above?

[hmmm]

IorekByrnison · 05/02/2008 17:56

Xenia your posts are full of such extraordinary assumptions.

The ability to earn £100,000 a year might well indicate good organisational skills and a keen desire for material security, but I'd love you to explain how it indicates a high degree of emotional intelligence.

Can you provide one shred of evidence that this is the case?

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 17:55

Are you trying to convince yourself, Xenia?

Anna8888 · 05/02/2008 17:54

I know plenty of women who earned over £100k (sometimes very much more) who gave up work to bring up their children. It is precisely the level of education that enabled them to earn those sums that afforded them the ability to recognise that they would put their education and skills to better use at home and with their families than in the workplace .

TheFallenMadonna · 05/02/2008 17:52

Well, I'm going to deal in stereotypes here I guess, but no more than you Xenia.

Surely it is a matter of household income (as you so often point out - a child has two parents).

Generally I would reckon that higher income women would also have higher income partners. And vice versa.

And two people on a lower income are more likely to require a dual income. So giving up one would be a much bigger deal than giving up one salary where both partners were higher earners.

And this is (anecdotally of course) is what I tend to see in real life. Beibg a SAHM is a bit of a luxury really, financially anyway. And not everyone can afford it.

How that works with your idea that intelligence is directly proportional to income I don't know.

Judy1234 · 05/02/2008 17:51

Education, reading about childcare, better knowledge of psychology and childrearing, better knowledge about good foods but more importantly how to handle children's emotional issues. I am sure anyone with any level of education and even an IQ of 90 can be a very loving mother and yes children need love most of all but in terms of bringing on children, being able to deal with conflict with them, handling their lives and education more educated women do it better. You see the biased media in the UK never puts these points about why working mothers are better in case they hurt the easily hurt feelings of the stay at home mothers who cannot cope with challenge and views different to theirs and who are upset by it but those who are secure that they made the right decision to stay home have nothing to fear from counter arguments just as I don't care if women say to me I ought to be home with my children.

karen999 · 05/02/2008 17:47

I agree with Xenia in that if you earn £100k and love your job, can afford childcare, then you are going to go babk to work......however I cannot see the connection that this makes you better with children??

pankhurst · 05/02/2008 17:44

(cannot hold her own wee...)

100k! (chortle)

12k! (howl)

oh, stop stop! You're killing me!

Better with children!!!!!

Hah hah hah hah !!!

(rolls under the table and stuffs an old trainers in her mouth)

Judy1234 · 05/02/2008 17:40

The 7.25am poist I just read - I said we "and we don't want to lose it all now because there's a surge in women who'd rather serve at home than rule the nation." I didn't say there was such a surge. I meant if there were (heaven forfend if there should be) then it would be a disaster but thankfully there isn't and more and more women choose to work.

Swipe left for the next trending thread