Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sorry Xenia...

588 replies

duchesse · 02/02/2008 16:58

...for starting that thread when I didn't believe you existed (and I genuinely didn't). I've done some proper research now, and realise that you are real person with fantastic real achievement. I apologise unreservedly for my previous thread, which was genuinely not designed to get at you since I did not believe you existed. I am aghast and incredibly impressed at how much you have achieved, and look forward to sparring with you again some time...

OP posts:
Iota · 05/02/2008 20:36

Salary facts from "What Britain Earns":

Nearly 6m were in the lowest pay bracket of less than £10,000, including cleaners and hairdressers. The average British salary is £24,907, but two-thirds of the population still earn under the national average, while fewer than 5,000 earn more than £1m.

And to be in the top 10% of earners, you need to be on a salary of just £46,000. The findings were revealed last night on the BBC2 TV programme What Britain Earns.

link here

Quattrocento · 05/02/2008 20:35

What bit? Missed that. Am still fond of Xenia even though world view small.

Janni · 05/02/2008 20:34

I was quite fond of Xenia till the bit about milk in the fridge.

chocolatedot · 05/02/2008 20:32

I don't accept that women over earning £100k are proportionately more likely to continue working after having children.

For some time now the graduate intake for Accounting Firms, Law Firms and Investment Banks has tended to average 50/50 between the sexes. However, women remain a small minority at Partner / MD level while women with children are an even smaller minority (a handful at most firms). Do you really believe this is due to discrimination or is it rather that many professional women find the pressure of combining a city career with children too difficult? Particuarly as in most cases their other half is a similar high earner with accompanying pressures and complete lack of flexibility.

Out of around 50 high earners I know, only one has continued full throttle and she does the whole 2 nanny thing.

karen999 · 05/02/2008 20:29

Who the hell would pay attention to statistics? As DisRaeli once said there are "lies,damn lies and statistics"

fortyplus · 05/02/2008 20:25

'Average' wage of £23K (I think that's the current figure) is actually a mean rather than a median figure. Therefore it's artificially high - the 'average' person earns less - according to friend who used to work in Central Statistics Office. (Public Sector so presumably no brains at all )

karen999 · 05/02/2008 20:24

LEM..if yu were clever you would know....

lucyellensmum · 05/02/2008 20:19

will someone please tell me if cleverer is a word??? Really, im getting befuddled now

duchesse · 05/02/2008 20:13

Goodness, go out for 3/4 of an hour to try to track down idiot boy who's forgotten his mobile phone, and this thread explodes. I'm sure I shouldn't be laughing quite so much though. I ought to be ashamed.

Fwiw though, having suffered from depression myself in my dim and distant past (ages 13-24), I do actually think that keeping busy is key (learned from my mother in law, who kept herself going through the deaths of her son and her husband in three years- impressive lady). I also think that physical exercise is crucial to overcoming depression. I do not however believe that post natal depression can possibly be lumped in with "standard" depression. It is very different in origin and needs very different treatment.

OP posts:
lucyellensmum · 05/02/2008 20:11

MrsMattie, that was me and to be fair, she did make some pretty constructive comments on my thread. Very blunt and too the point but i did appreciate it, i wont be getting a job just yet, although it seems my DP would agree with her. I dont get a job because i don't want to get a job, for my own personal and very complicated reasons.

Habbibu · 05/02/2008 20:11

Xenia - you have chosen someone to take on much of the parenting of your children who doesn't fulfil the criteria you outlined earlier. Your nannies were not as highly educated and highly paid as those clever women you say will be better parents. My mother is NNEB trained, and is a fabulous, inspiring woman, and so I can well imagine you may have chosen a similar person.

I think a lot of what you say here is intentional hyperbole. I believe that you love your children very much, and would not "outsource" most of their daily parenting to someone you didn't think would be great at it, so surely that points out a fairly hefty flaw in your argument?

Judy1234 · 05/02/2008 20:03

Don't quote me out of context. My family spends their lives treating depression and there are a range of things that work from pills, therapy, diet, sunlight, exercise and yes sometimes having work you enjoy.

TheFallenMadonna · 05/02/2008 20:03
Grin
Judy1234 · 05/02/2008 20:01

Take other jobs then - the girl managing Tesco is morelikely to return to work than the girl on the till and she will usually be cleverer. Surely this applies across all sectors. The university cleaners will earn less and probably not be as clever as the senior academics earning the starting salaries of some new graduates. Of course at the bottom end the graph would change again because they you're both working to feed the children even it's the night shift at the local care home.

I don't know what % of women earn £100k. It's not a massive sum. It's only what most GPs earn but obviously I appreciate that the average wage is £22k or something and many people earn less than average. Nothing to stop women aiming to earn a lot more however. It's fun and as someone said can be sexy too.

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 19:57

I'm pretty sure Xenia recently told someone who was suffering from clinical depression to 'get a job'. PMSL. It's like the Thatcher years all over again.

TheFallenMadonna · 05/02/2008 19:42

Clam - eh?

Xenia's stock response to most problems is "get a job", or "get a better job".

Which is fine. Everyone's entitled to their opinion blah blah.

But to say she doesn't tell other people how they should live their life is just plain wrong.

Indeed the word "duty" is often wielded I think.

karen999 · 05/02/2008 19:38

I am not fitting into a mans world. I am fitting into mine. Tbh I never compete with men. Whats the point? They are not me. Other women are not me. I compete with myself. It is really the only worthwhile person to compete with, and it is competition in the healthy sense.

I dont see how it always comes down to the men/women argument......

Piffle · 05/02/2008 19:38

But also Xenia women who earn £100k have more to bloody miss if they do not go back, if they and their hubs have a whacking mortgage, then they cannot afford to have her quit without SERIOUSLY downsizing their lifestyle, which at that income level would be a big comedown.

clam · 05/02/2008 19:35

I'm sure Xenia doesn't need or care about my support here. She seems more than able to look after herself. However, I can't see why some of you are getting so heated about what she's saying. Even if you don't agree, so what? I don't recall ever reading anything she posted that "told" any woman how to live her life. X works, very successfully it seems (although I appear to have missed all the googling you lot have done on her). Good on her. It works for her, with her set-up, and her kids clearly have thrived. Other posters are SAHMs and their kids thrive on that. Others of us do a bit of both. Some of our kids are OK and others might be out vandalising bus shelters. I can feel another glass of wine coming on........

Walnutshell · 05/02/2008 19:28

Why does the debate always seem to end up forcing women to choose to fit into a man's world - whether by working according to male rules (and the subsequent disadvantages) or staying home according to the same rules but different disadvantages...

If we can't beat em join em?

Surely there is something more to hope for? We are not asking enough and are denying all that women might really offer and gain if the world truly operated on equal terms.

chocolatedot · 05/02/2008 19:22

Xenia, what percentage of the population do you think earns £100k and what percentage of the female population do you thinks earns £100k??

As it happens, I earnt a multitude of that number and I was perfectly happy to walk away from it, like a lot of my peers. Life goes in stages, right now we are all happy with me being at home. That will obviously change at some point and I'll go back to money making.

karen999 · 05/02/2008 19:16

Actually there is nothing like busting balls in the Boardroom to make me feel sexy...

Judy1234 · 05/02/2008 19:10

I never said there was anything wrong with being sexy. In fact that's another thing I've got against some housewives on MN when they seem to assume it's fine not to have sex with your husband for month after month. It is never fine.

Quattrocento · 05/02/2008 19:08

Xenia

You have a simple equation:

The cleverer you are = the more money you make

This is so far from being true. Lots of clever people do stay on at university, do doctorates, post-doctorates, teach etc. They are all pretty clever people who are going to spend their lives working for what for you would be diddley squat cubed.

Many local business people (chain stores, bingo hall owners etc) tend to be really pretty wealthy despite having little in the way of natural intelligence (I am speaking of two people I know btw) they have considerable natural shrewdness so they can do well in business.

I think that to do well in a professional career (law, medicine, accountancy) one does have to be pretty clever. If you are in those professions, that are well-paid, then you would not give them up to be a SAHM because the chances are that if you are over 35 you will be earning over £100k a year - time out means time getting de-skilled - etc.

From your perspective in your niche area what you say is largely accurate, but the trouble is that it ignores the world outside Xenia's world.

pankhurst · 05/02/2008 19:03

shhhhh that's my naked prozzy webalias!!!!

don't OUT me or I'll go down the hierarchy