Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sorry Xenia...

588 replies

duchesse · 02/02/2008 16:58

...for starting that thread when I didn't believe you existed (and I genuinely didn't). I've done some proper research now, and realise that you are real person with fantastic real achievement. I apologise unreservedly for my previous thread, which was genuinely not designed to get at you since I did not believe you existed. I am aghast and incredibly impressed at how much you have achieved, and look forward to sparring with you again some time...

OP posts:
alittleone2 · 06/02/2008 12:36

Message withdrawn

chocolatedot · 06/02/2008 12:35

I agree with that, lennygrril, it's fairly unusual to not do anything at all work-wise after having children. A lot of people do end up doing interesting unpaid work though as well as raising chickens, growing vegetables and so on.

lennygrrl · 06/02/2008 12:21

Message withdrawn

Rosylily · 06/02/2008 12:19

hee hee Xenia, nope, I really don't wish I had an interesting job.
I wouldn't mind loads more money so that I can hire a chef though...
I'm not certain staying at home with children is a dying out thing, is it really?

chocolatedot · 06/02/2008 12:17

"They might think they are but they really inside wish they had an interesting job". Xenia, you bring to mind Homer Simpson's admiring remark "Gee, Rock Stars, they know everything".

I have never come across anyone in my entire life who lives in such a complete bubble and is so convinced that they know everything. I can't help but wonder if it's a tad lonely and sad inside that bubble.

Judy1234 · 06/02/2008 12:07

They might think they are but they really inside wish they had an interesting job.

But alittleone's situation is interesting. It's how people "get on" and make their lives easier for their children. It's what my mother did to some extent and it was amazing at her funeral to see a side of her family we didn't know (she had 52 first cousins!! mostly very working class in the NE) and how different we had ended up. It showed what class mobility there could be in a generation. Now I'm not saying we're any happier than the poor working class cousins in the NE because happiness is a very different issue and also I'm not saying one life is better than another in moral terms but in terms of this capitalist working world we all live in it shows what you can achieve if you give your children clever genes (my mother's best inheritance although she gave me her good looks and that's been quite nice too), time - all working parents who are quite clever like to talk to their children and educate them at home as well as school and by paying for education.

I am sure you're not crass compared with your colleagues. I do think some people know more in terms of general education, what they learned at school, even things my parents taught me at home which not all children from all backgrounds get.

I suppose that's a different topic from staying ad home or working but women working and earning and making a better life for their children which women have always done and always will do is a very instinctive thing. Now there may be a very very narrow sub set of women in the country who can afford not to work 9there are very few of them either married to rich men or on benefits where it doesn't pay to work) but they are not very common and are dying out. A lot of men don't like all the earning stuff to have to fall on them for a start and why should they?

ComeOVeneer · 06/02/2008 11:57

"If you love being a housewife more fool you but carry on and don't feel threatened by working women. If you hate it change it. If you hate working do something about that too or change jobs."

Why xenia are there always those little jibes in you comments? The "more fool you" comment is unecessary, and gets people's backs up. Is it really so hard to belive that someone can have a fullfilled life without having a paid job?

duchesse · 06/02/2008 11:52

This is the sort of thing I meant the other day. This woman could do with some advice btw from anyone who knows their way around employment legislation and contracts.

OP posts:
Rosylily · 06/02/2008 11:24

What I mean is the person you marry does have an influence on your choices for various reasons.

Rosylily · 06/02/2008 11:12

If my dh was selfish and spent his wages gambling or something then I would be a working mother.
Precisely because he is keen to be 'the provider' that freed us up to have 4 children with their mum at home.
I do want to bring in money eventually for my own satisfaction and it isn't always easy to be low lying humdrum mum but all choices have pros and cons.
I chose to be this person and I'll choose to change in time. I realise that having that choice is a brilliant thing.

I hope my daughter will have such choice.

MrsMattie · 06/02/2008 11:10

Xenia, you completely lost any shred of credibility you had with some of your most recent comments.

alittleone2 · 06/02/2008 11:06

Message withdrawn

Judy1234 · 06/02/2008 10:50

O, it certainly didn't benefit me. Huge huge cost on the divorce. I don't know how any higher earners can risk it. And the children's father doesn't really see them or pay anything. Another reason to work as so many men are so unreliable particularly after divorce.

I would not like to mix with women who think I should have married better. I don't think most people are very happy living off male earnings. It's a chattel like status most women don't suffer in 2008.

I think when you're over 20 years into being a parent as I am you get a better idea of the over all picture and long term which when you've a small child you don't.

Anna may be right and we all know people of both sexes who are never happy with what they have (working or not working). The grass is always greener syndrome. But it's better grass if you've the money to pay for someone else to fertilise and mow it and you bought the grass with your own money. It's easier being miserable if you earn a bit of money than in poverty. I think my mother did very very well from where she started (poor widowed mother in the 1920s when she was a baby) to pass the 11+, get her teacher training certificate and it was partly because she was very clever. She completely moved class actually and I suppose after 13 years teaching she chose to give up work and I think she was quite happy when we were tiny although she was the only woman on the road without a nanny and cleaner in those days. That's the trouble put yourself amongst people with more money than you and you feel fed up (lots of studies on that), surround yourself with people a bit worse off and you feel better.

I believe she resented how things ended up - answering the door to my father's psychiatric patients twice a week and yet I don't think he would ever have stopped her going back to teaching. She was often unhappy about lots of things, having done 3 loads of washing that morning when he'd been on TV or whatever. But she never effected change so it was her own fault. Women who moan but don't change things (and men) annoy me most. If you love being a housewife more fool you but carry on and don't feel threatened by working women. If you hate it change it. If you hate working do something about that too or change jobs.

I just pass on the wisdom that most women are glad they keep their careers going and many who haven't are deserted by their men in their 40s or 50s for the younger model, get little money and have lost the chance to earn a lot more simply because many career paths (but not all) are age based.

pankhurst · 06/02/2008 10:01

(thump)

That'll larn you, Ordinaria.

Oooh, sorry. That was a mistake. I meant to be highly emotionally intelligent and sympathise, but with this low social classification by the nice demographic people based on job title, I just can't.

ordinariaindissimula · 06/02/2008 09:46

After lots of soul-searching and agonising about what would be best for my DD I decided to stay at work after I was head-hunted back when she was 10 months old. Every time I finished I got another call and ended up doing something 'for just 3 months'.

The money I earn has given me such huge freedoms and choices that I decided DD would be better off with the flexibility my income brings/brought. I've managed my employment for the last two years to enable me to work from home, do the school run/ballet/swimming/violin lessons and still earn my income (in the top 1% of my country).

DP doesn't contribute and I pay for the house/nanny/school fees/car etc etc. Although DP has asked me to marry him (admittedly 5 years after he reneged on our engagement) I have the confidence to say no, I don't want to be married. I don't really see how it would benefit me.

I feel awkward about all of this and never mention it online (have namechanged). Oddly enough in the circles I move in I don't feel particularly rich because everybody else is inherited wealth and I earn mine. I see jaws drop when I can't make coffee at 11am because I'm working. The feeling is (I suspect) that I should have married better

duchesse · 06/02/2008 09:06

I think what is key to anyone's happiness, man or woman, is self-determination. If you feel forced into doing or being anything life-changing against your will, you are going to be stressed and unhappy. For some, that might mean staying at home when they would rather be back at work, or going back to work when they would rather be at home. Likewise being stuck in a crappy job with few prospects, chances for decision making, or alternatives.

OP posts:
Anna8888 · 06/02/2008 09:00

"My mother's unhappiness was directly related to her ceasing to work after 13 years in a career she enjoyed like many women." Fine, Xenia, but you cannot extrapolate from your mother's experience that all women would be happier working .

I think the reverse also happens pretty often - women working unhappily when they would rather be at home with their children.

Actually, what I really think is that there is no perfect solution - every choice is going to be a compromise somewhere along the line - and it is best to be upfront about what that compromise is, rather than pretending that one has oneself found the perfect solution to life.

Judy1234 · 06/02/2008 08:39

Yes, it was easier that he taught although the school day ended at 5.40pm every day by the way and because of what he did he was in school after school a few nights a week and he worked most weekends teaching all day Saturday and then playing the organ on Sundays. It certainly wasn't the normal state school teaching and he also did school summer camps to earn more money in school holidays.

I don't want to be identified and there's nothing to know. I'm not famous in that kind of way. It's not interesting who I am.

SpeckledHen · 06/02/2008 07:56

Xenia I am intrigued now to know who you are. I admit I have gooogled to no avail. I cannot read all your posts there are too many. You bear striking resemblances to Nicola Horlick but you cannot be her since you have not lost a child to leukaemia. Pu me out of my misery!!???

chocolatedot · 06/02/2008 07:51

Xenia, don't you think the fact that your ex was a teacher made a huge (if not all) the difference in terms of you being able to maintain a career? For those of us married to fellow City professionals, it is not the fact that one parent is working a 60 - 80 hour week with frequent travelling and night time entertaining, it's the fact that both are doing it. Unless you get 2 Nannies, it is virtually impossible to get childcare to cover that, leaving aside the issue of how much time children get to spend with their parents.

As far as £100k being a big or attainable salary depending on your point of view is concerned, I'm not sure I go along with that. Those who live in grinding poverty are all too aware that they are worse off than the majority, is it too much to expect recognition from those on more than £100k that they are in a tiny minority?

Judy1234 · 06/02/2008 07:25

Pl, it gets easier and your mother is probably right. Ity gives women a lot more choice and power if they work. It is better for their children. The biggest predictor of child outcomes is family income. 23 year years ago I went back to work when our first one was a baby (the one now at law school). I remember particularly when I was breastfeeding at first it was hard to go back (I expressed milk at work which is not ideal) but as we had 3 under 4 having a nanny living out at home was cheaper and better. I do hope it's all arranged that if ever then ursery lets you down your student husband is number two. I hope you ensure he has more time with the child at weekends than you do. |I hope you rid yourself of any sexism in the marriage.

My ex husabnd (we were married fro 19 years) is a teacher, he always earned less and we knew that before we married. We discussed it. He's pretty feminist himself so he mever had any silly macho problems over that and we always agreed if the nanny didn't work out then he would give up work. He was around to help the nanny in school holidays. He did more than I did with the children although as we had a nany not massively more.

I am sure your husband can be as good as you with the baby and should be allowed to get better at it. I really hink this is the key issue for most working mothers, not work, not discrimiantion at work - it's having equality at home. You see it on MN threads all the time - all those husbands who are supportive and don't help - a dreadful word - but do their fair share. As he is the student he should fetch and take to the nursery for example. That will also spare you the trauma of dropping off too.

Also when you're older as I am you get better perspective over it. As teenagers children do their own thing, need you less and can actually admire their mother and her career. It feeds into their attitudes too - my daughters will talk about being surprised at sexist relationships they see because they aren't used to that norm. Being a housewife with a low family income is just dire. Continuing to work is fine. you get used to it, children benefit from different adults in their lives. My children saw their mother, father and nanny regularly and bonded with them all. I think they were enhanced by that exposure beyond the family. Also let's not forget the money. 20 years on we live in a lovely house, go skiing, they've been to good private schools, they are benefiting themselves now.. obviously women who marry rich men also get those things but it's on the back of a man and not really very morally sound or such a good example to daughters. Most women nowadays and in the past have always worked.

All I can say is it would be a lot harder, worse for your family and your relationship if you stayed home. If your husband has a problem with women earning more he needs therapy, not a housewife.

chipmonkey · 06/02/2008 00:55

Pls, it does get easier! When I went back to work after having ds1, I truly felt as though I was giving him up for adoption! But he was fine, he didn't miss me at all so long as he was looked after, he was happy And he loved being with the other children in the nursery. Also, after you get back to work you fall into a routine, you do have to be more organised but after a while it runs in a more clockwork-like fashion. I am now expecting no. 4 and am still working 4 days a week and will be going back to work after this baby too. I, too, was shocked at the level of guilt and desolation I felt going back to work. Nothing had prepared me for it. I do think that perhaps we are built that way for a reason, namely so babies don't get abandoned! But you are not abandoning him, you are making sure he is well looked after. It is very much a juggling act but we are now beginning to see the light at the end of the tunnel. Ds1 is getting older and more responsible and we are at the point where he can be left home alone for short periods of time. And in the end, when all 4 have grown up, my career will still be there and I will be in a better position to help them out financially.

PlscanIwinthelottery · 06/02/2008 00:12

I didn't mean to rant about me having to go back to work. In short, what I meant was, I always said I'd go back v soon after the baby, and in reality, its harder than I ever thought it would be, and I am in total admiration for all who have done it.

duchesse · 05/02/2008 23:46

Just to clarify- the eleven months passed without me returning to work...

OP posts:
duchesse · 05/02/2008 23:44

Pls (read your name properly now!)- I was convinced I'd be back at work a month after the birth of my first. Eleven months later I got a different job working for a lady who was setting up her business from home, and nanny-shared with her (it was a little flukey, but sadly didn't last beyond the birth of my second...).

OP posts: