Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sorry Xenia...

588 replies

duchesse · 02/02/2008 16:58

...for starting that thread when I didn't believe you existed (and I genuinely didn't). I've done some proper research now, and realise that you are real person with fantastic real achievement. I apologise unreservedly for my previous thread, which was genuinely not designed to get at you since I did not believe you existed. I am aghast and incredibly impressed at how much you have achieved, and look forward to sparring with you again some time...

OP posts:
duchesse · 07/02/2008 10:01

I agree with you Pitchounette- in France, childcare is seen a whole country issue and thus centrally subsidised. In the Uk, children are generally seen as the "burden" of the person who gave birth to them. Even though the high dependency stage is not very long across an entire career and the value of retaining highly and expensively trained people, industry seems perfectly happy to throw out the proverbial bathwater for ever. This is essentially what happens if childcare solutions are made unaffordable to the vast majority of families.

And it actually makes economic sense, if you work in an environment where you are likely to be booted out of your job or sidelined professionally if you take two days out to nurse your kid through chicken pox, for one parent, usually the one with the highest income or most stable employment, to keep working while the other takes more of a back seat career-wise.

Some people have the backup of a close and loving extended family member to be the second carer to their child, including during sickness, but most people do not. And while it seen as a retrograde step professionally to have children, and childcare is seen as the problem of the individual person rather an issue that a whole nation needs to tackle, women (in the main it is the mothers) will never have equal status in the workplace.

OP posts:
ComeOVeneer · 07/02/2008 09:59

Chocolatedot, your last post is as if you have read my mind

Anna8888 · 07/02/2008 09:58

"In France where childcare is much more affordable" - I agree, Pitchounette. But unfortunately the quality is also, often, abysmal .

Pitchounette · 07/02/2008 09:51

Message withdrawn

chocolatedot · 07/02/2008 09:46

Xenia, I for one would appreciate an acknowledgement from you that although you may not understand their choices, women can be trusted to know their own minds.

You, like me, seem to view women as wonderfully gifted and intelligent creatures with the ability to avhieve great things in life. Yet, as soon as a woman, no matter how successful or long her previous career has been, decides to stay at home with her kids for a bit, you assert that while she may think she's happy, she doesn't know her own mind and in fact, you know better. (Remember the "deep inside she wishes she had an interesting job" comment?.)

I find this "poor little dears" attitude incredibly patronising and paternalistic and of course, it is exactly the way men have been treating women for 100's of years. Coming from a woman, I find it a really sad betrayal of feminism.

GColdtimer · 07/02/2008 09:41

Referring back to spokette's point at 9.05, do you not value the people who provide an important input to the lives of you and your children - nurses, midwifes, teachers. Do you really think these people are less intelligent than you because they earn less money? What would our world be like if everyone simply chased after a large pay packet?

Its a genuine question.

Iota · 07/02/2008 09:39

hear hear ecoworrior

ecoworrier · 07/02/2008 09:37

Actually, my experience has been that the more educated women are the more choices they have, and often that choice can include staying at home or taking a lower-paid or lower-status job.

I'm still in touch with a couple of dozen female university friends. All but one now have children. All of us went on to have what you would call 'graduate jobs', some more ordinary than others, some really quite high-flying.

Out of all of us, only two went back to work during or straight after their maternity leave. One of those two then gave up work completely after her second child was born, and was much happier and relaxed because of that.

The rest of us all CHOSE to stay at home while our children were young. The fact we have had this choice is partly due to the fact that we are all educated, had good jobs and managed to get onto a decent financial footing before having children. In addition, we have all married men with a similar education and who have good jobs, thus making the financial aspects of losing one salary easier.

Virtually all of us have since gone back to work at some stage and in some way - some when their youngest child went to school, some when their youngest child started secondary school and the rest at various points in between. Some have returned to their original careers, although generally part-time (their choice), some have moved onto other jobs - yes, some of these jobs have been much worse-paid or lower-status than they previously had, but it has allowed them a much more relaxed life and better balance of work and home life.

So where is this artificial divide of 'women who work' and 'women who stay at home' that Xenia seems to see everywhere? Virtually all women I know do work or have worked and will probably work again at some stage. It's all about the many different stages of our lives and the choices we make to suit those stages. What works for one family at one particular stage will not necessarily work for them at another stage, so it's quite possible for a woman to work, not work, and then work again, and for that to be the right decision each time for her and her family.

Saggarmakersbottomknocker · 07/02/2008 09:34

Absolutely spokette.

spokette · 07/02/2008 09:26

I think the intelligent people are the ones who realise that there is more to life than just work and earning a high salary.

I use to be work fiend, earned high salary, all consumed by my ever so important career. Jetted off here and there, travelled business class to the USA etc. I always thought that I would work full time once I had children because they were going to fit around me. DH thought the same.

Then discovered I was pregnant with DTS and before they were born, I told my boss that I was going to take 7 months maternity leave, work part-time 3 days a week on my return and move away from management into a technical role. I have never regretted that decision because once I was pregnant, I knew my life would change for the better.

DH and I always laugh now at how self-important we were to think that our DTS would fit around us. That has never been the case and we would not change it for the world.

Judy1234 · 07/02/2008 09:25

The zippib example is an interesting one. My oldest daughter is the same age and she got to a point she reached (which is different from z's daughter) for various reasons too. I suppose my other point is if we as women work in well paid careers then our children tend to have the comfort of that too. Of course a lot of women don't have the get up and go or the brains or even the luck to do well but if you have a choice then surely pick better paid work you love rather than low paid work you love given how important in this kind of life we lead money is - as I say look at all the other MN threads which often come down to problems over lack of money.

I never have started a thread about me. If people want to email on to 21 pages that's fine but I don't court it. I'm not particularly interesting.

As mothers we have huge influence over our children and perhaps most of all we want to ensure they have sufficient choices whilst also having the emotional intelligence to handle choice (not everyone actually finds choice helpful) that they leave fulfilling lives.

blueshoes · 07/02/2008 09:21

zippi, that's fine

anna, I would tend to agree about high paying professional jobs being of being all-consuming. My take is that if one is good at their job, an organisation will be able to find a niche for you which will allow you to leverage your skills but allowing flexible working arrangements subject to a sometimes significant pay discount.

But because you were earning so much pre-discount, the final pay, after discount and pro-ration for reduced hours, is still very rewarding.

All or nothing professional roles tend to be client-facing, front-office, profit-centred roles, hence the difficulty with allowing flexible arrangements. But if you move into a different role within the same organisation, usually middle office or support, you find these flexible roles.

For example, in my legal field, there are scores of flexible roles within my law firm for ex-fee-earners, ranging from knowledge support, IT analysis, compliance. Some even go into marketing, HR.

So I would not necessarily be advising my dd to go for a lower paying flexible job, but to aim as high as she wants but be good at it and love what she does.

ordinariaindissimula · 07/02/2008 09:15

Xenia - I can see where your argument is coming from but in general once women have had children they choose a job that fits around them, and that generally means a lower paid job.

Also, not everybody is motivated by money (think Maslow's hierarchy). Take a nurse for example, they might not like to move up the management chain because they like looking after people, not pushing paper.

Choosing a lower paid role doesn't mean you are less intelligent. It means it suits your life. In my early 30s I was interviewing for directorships, with a young child now I wouldn't take one - in my 30's that was about status. Now I try to balance work/life/children.

In my case as an unmarried mother, whose partner had multiple affairs, I chose work as I felt it gave me and DD the best opportunity. That's my circumstance. Other people in my NCT group who didn't know the big picture may have judged me for this, but they didn't know what was going on.

Anna8888 · 07/02/2008 09:12

Actually, I am often envious of women who picked lower paid work than I did.

When you go for very high-paying professional jobs, you often end up in an all-or-nothing scenario in the type of job that cannot be done part-time or cannot support a career break.

ZippiBabes · 07/02/2008 09:12

blueshoes that is a very complex question..i won't answer it on this thread...but i'm not averse to answering or attempting to

spokette · 07/02/2008 09:05

From Xenia

"why do women pick low paid work when they could pick higher paid work? Surely they made silly choices and can't I say that so they don't allow their daughters to make the same silly choices?"

So how much do you pay your nanny, cleaner etc?

When you were pregnant, how much do you think the midwives who cared for you earn?

How much do the teachers who taught your children earn?

I bet these were mostly women and I bet they don't earn the vast sums of money that you proclaim that they should, only if they were intelligent enough.

The services you buy and rely on to conduct your lifestyle rarely pay huge salaries and therein lies the flaw in your argument. Whats more, to infer that many of these women have lesser intelligence than those who earn large sums of money is insulting, idiotic and quite frankly misguided.

blueshoes · 07/02/2008 09:05

zippi, your dd sounds admirable. She is really trying to improve her circumstances.

I hope you don't mind me asking, zippi. It is so hard for her now to play catchup. Could you explain why, with her determination and your support, did your dd leave school with few qualifications? I am genuinely interested to know.

Saggarmakersbottomknocker · 07/02/2008 08:57

I chose my low paid work. I left I highly paid job in finance to look after my sick child. We've spoken of this before Xenia - why I chose to give up work as opposed to my husband who, at the time, had a lower earning capacity than me. It was because I considered the emotional and physical impact on the family to be of higher importance than the financial one.

It seems to be a concept which you have difficulty grasping. That choice doesn't make me a fool or an idiot. Just makes me different to you.

MrsMattie · 07/02/2008 08:34

Most women are just stupid, eh, Xenia?

ZippiBabes · 07/02/2008 08:30

people take low paid work because it is the only work they can get...my dd worked in a house of fraser cafe when she was 15 as a saturday jib worked there full time then moved to a pub kitchen and had a baby at just 19 went back to work at the end of maternity leave

then worked as a cleaner still on les than minimum [ay she eventual;y managed to get some local authority workj through an agency in spetmber but walked out after a ciuple of weeks as tyhey treated her like shite (rather like her previous employers) she then managed to get an another agency job which she has been doing since and she has the chance to apply for the job she has been doing..at the mo she is on minimum pay but if she gets the job she will be on 15k on a scale rising to 17.5k I hope she gets it Her son is full time with a child minder She is 23 in a few weeks time The job she is now doing iunvolves figures and she is thi nking of trying to get accountancy exams

No one has tried harder to make a go of things

geordiemacminx · 07/02/2008 08:28

People dont "choose" low paid work.. most have no choice. If ou have no qualifications, limited numeracy/literacy then I dont suppose there are a huge amount of employers banging down your door with job offers of £100k a year. They take low paid work as in some cases it is slightly better than being on benifits, in the hope that it will lead to better opportunities in the furture.

Its easy to say that they can improve their skills but if someone struggles to read or write confidently then the prospect of getting a job in an office where they would have to use a computer and deal with people is about as frightening as it gets.

I used to contract in a very lucrative industry prior to having ds, for now I'm staying at home to look after him. I dont see it as a "choice" - I actually see it as an honour. There is nothing better than seeing him grow up - he's 9 months,and has changed so much since he was born its unbelievable. He is a pleasure to have, and when the time is right I will go back to work.

MrsMattie · 07/02/2008 08:27

'Why do women 'pick' low paid jobs?'

And you are the beacon of feminism and female success, the leading example we should all be following? Do me a fucking favour.

Anna8888 · 07/02/2008 08:21

Xenia - no-one will be able to explain to you why many women feel a great and overwhelming urge to care for their children themselves. But maybe one day you yourself will reach a higher level of understanding of human relationships that will enable you to empathise

Tutter · 07/02/2008 08:14

xenia, whilst i respect your views, i am surprised at just how many times you have to ask this. it makes you appear dim or, at the very least, forgetful

i consider myself fortunate (yes, fortunate) in that i can afford not to work while my dcs are small. i enjoy - yes enjoy - being around them all day . i have a degree and used to work int he city, earning a reasonable salary

each to her own, surely?

Judy1234 · 07/02/2008 08:10

I don't understand how anyone wants to be a housewife but may be one day someone will explain it to me.

Also given the number of MN threads about lack of money, cost of child care, mortgages etc why do women pick low paid work when they could pick higher paid work? Surely they made silly choices and can't I say that so they don't allow their daughters to make the same silly choices? Okay if they like Oxfam clothes and living in a mobile home great, let them go off and work in the call centre or local authority.