Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sorry Xenia...

588 replies

duchesse · 02/02/2008 16:58

...for starting that thread when I didn't believe you existed (and I genuinely didn't). I've done some proper research now, and realise that you are real person with fantastic real achievement. I apologise unreservedly for my previous thread, which was genuinely not designed to get at you since I did not believe you existed. I am aghast and incredibly impressed at how much you have achieved, and look forward to sparring with you again some time...

OP posts:
Anna8888 · 07/02/2008 11:15

"No one is forcing parent to use poor nurseries or unqualified nannies".

There is, however, not much in the way of alternatives unless you have very devoted grandparents around...

blueshoes · 07/02/2008 11:01

Elffriend, Xenia is a BRAND on mn!

Anna, the answer about being able to afford quality children under current circumstances in UK is a high income. No 2 ways around that. That is why Xenia keeps banging on about our dds going for high paying jobs and thus having choices.

As for low quality childcare in France, no one is forcing parent to use poor nurseries or unqualified nannies. I grew up in Southeast Asia where it is not unusual for working couples to employ Filipino maids to do a combination or housecare and childcare. Where the children are young, parents tend to use maids with a combination of nursery and grandparent or one parent at home.

Yes, the maids are part of the landscape. But that does not necessarily mean society will end up using them as ft childcare for littles - people are sensible after all. And I don't look down on these ladies. It makes financial sense for them to do this, as it does for your cleaner to work for you. Some of them are damn good, even better with children than the parents they work for, being mothers at home, and highly qualified as well. They want a better life.

Elffriend · 07/02/2008 10:47

Ah well, that goes back to Xenia's argument that we should all be earning £100k - in other words make the good quality chidcare affordable to you.

It would be interesting if we could converse with the younger (and, presumably, less affluent)Xenia. There MUST have been a time she had to juggle like us mere mortals. Someone, somewhere, must have sacrificed something in order for it to all work.

Xenia - sorry to talk about you in third person but you have become a morality play figure - your views are becoming larger than you!

Anna8888 · 07/02/2008 10:40

blueshoes - but how on earth does society get around the fact that good quality childcare costs a lot of money (and is therefore only available to the few)?

Sure, you can have a cheap childcare economy (like France) - but then you have, as a society, to be prepared to leave your children with people with very little education and unable to command a better wage elsewhere.

Elffriend · 07/02/2008 10:37

"Of course a lot of women don't have the get up and go or the brains or even the luck to do well but if you have a choice then surely pick better paid work you love rather than low paid work you love"

This is undoubtedly true (just as it is for men) but it does not tell the whole story. One of the logic blind alleys of this discussion is dividing roles into those at £12K and those at £100K - and leaving people there.

You might, for instance, have all the requisite motivation, brains, luck and to be on a "sensible" career path but find yourself hijacked by life when you are only earning a paltry £40K. Such hijacking might well be linked to aspects of your life that you also consider a priority. Take, for example, an individual who starts on her career but then chooses to marry and have children. She continues to work but chose to marry a soldier who moves around with his job frequently and is away from home for prolonged periods. She decides that her marriage is important and chooses to support his career choice becase that has always been non-negotiable. She decides to restrict the level of job/hours commitment she takes in order not to be away from home a lot as she feels this would be unfair on her children. Does that count as a silly choice or a pragmatic one? I guess it depends on the goal. If the goal is to be as rich as possible a an individual then yes, she has screwed up. If the goal is to to stary with her husband and provide a particualr environment for her children then she has not. Is she entirely happy? Nope. Struggling with the choices like most of us. I suspect Xenia is right in the many of us doubt that we are doing the right thing and worry that we are not fulfilling our potential but I cannot beleive that one path is the ony path and I do beleive that it is more complicated than some Brave New world model. Society would not work terrbly well if we all earned £100K plus. The world needs Xenias - but it needs the support mechanisms that allow her to succeed and exist in varied society. End of essay!

blueshoes · 07/02/2008 10:31

Pitchouette, amidiawish, I think it is a great shame that women like you who want to work, find they do not have the choice or find it not worth their while, because of the high cost of quality childcare.

Most couples are both in paid employment pre-children and using it a big chunk of their joint income to pay for a joint mortgage and expenses. Once a child arrives, if one parent is forced to stay at home because of their wages do not or barely cover childcare, then it is double-whammy for that family: the parent at home is SAHM-ing, when they would prefer to be at work, and their household loses one income, lowering living standards.

The same thing applies for a parent who is forced to work despite wanting to SAHM. Though again, childcare would eat up a big chunk of their wages.

People are happiest when they are doing what they want to, whether WOHM or SAHM. Despite the financial sacrifices or childcare hassles, at least they have the choice and are doing what makes them happiest.

duchesse · 07/02/2008 10:23

My "Thai sister" incidentally has a full-time household help person who also does childcare and babysitting on occasion, for £400 a month.

OP posts:
duchesse · 07/02/2008 10:21

amidai- I know! My London (to distinguish from my Thai sister and French sister) sister's 4 yr old is full-time in a relatively cheap nursery. Costs her £900 a month.

There was another nursery attached to her son's school but the deposit alone was more money than she had spare at the time (and she earns a fair amount just shy of 40% tax band), and the fees were twice the cheaper nursery's.

OP posts:
Anna8888 · 07/02/2008 10:18

Plus you can deduct money from their salary for lodging/food etc.

Anna8888 · 07/02/2008 10:17

Ah, but Pitchounette - they are not subject to the same hours restrictions as people employed in companies. Wherein a huge difference.

Pitchounette · 07/02/2008 10:16

Message withdrawn

Anna8888 · 07/02/2008 10:15

Pitchounette - those nounous are everywhere and entirely part of the official system - their salaries are tax-deductible precisely to encourage the employment of those people.

Pitchounette · 07/02/2008 10:14

Message withdrawn

duchesse · 07/02/2008 10:13

Anna- it's probably bad in Paris, but I think from what my sister says that it is rather better out in the provinces. Wages are low enough out in Basse-Normandie where my sister lives that people see childcare as a viable job choice (I hesitate to say career).

OP posts:
Anna8888 · 07/02/2008 10:13

Some, but not all (by far), French crèches are run by the state. All are subsidised. At crèche you pay fees on a sliding scale depending on family income.

amidaiwish · 07/02/2008 10:11

and Duchesse, totally agree with you too. I have 2 DDs in nursery, 1 full day and 2 half days per week. This costs over £900 a month. To work 4 days/week (as i was doing before i left my old job) costs over £2000. My job also demanded some travelling / evenings too - which had an additional childcare cost/arrangement. It became impossible with dh's demanding career too and his frequent long distance travelling.

Pitchounette · 07/02/2008 10:11

Message withdrawn

Anna8888 · 07/02/2008 10:11

spokette - the women providing the childcare are badly paid. Many of the nounous are foreigners living in France without their families - they tend to live in very small rooms with a shower in a cupboard and no kitchen.

And of course they often have no education to speak of (they often share no language fluently with the children they care for) and no specific childcare training. This is why they do not know not to hit the children or not to punish them when they are not misbehaving, just learning.

spokette · 07/02/2008 10:09

Pitchounette I had not realised that childcare in France was centrally subsidised so my second paragraph is probably irrelevant

Pitchounette · 07/02/2008 10:09

Message withdrawn

spokette · 07/02/2008 10:07

Pitchounette "In France where childcare is much more affordable, about 80% of women are working, most of them full time. For that reason, very few women ask themselves whether they will be SAHM or going to work."

What about the women providing the childcare though? Is it affordable in France because they receive much lower pay than in the UK? If they are receiving lower pay, what happens to them once they decide to have children?

This is the conundrum with affordable childcare. We all want it but it means that somebody will be earning a low wage and then be berated as less intelligent by those who claim to know better (not you Pitchounette).

That is why I chose a nursery for my DTS that paid above average wages. The staff are loyal, it has a low staff turnover rate and DH and I just spend less on other things.

Many low paid jobs allow many of us to have the lifestyle that we want and for that reason, we should never look down on them or the people doing them and should certainly never regard them as less intelligent. Only a fool would do that.

amidaiwish · 07/02/2008 10:06

ecoworrier, i have been drafting and re-drafting a comment, and have deleted it as you have said it all! (and far more eloquently than i).

thank you!

Anna8888 · 07/02/2008 10:04

Pitchounette - actually the crèches are less worrying a form of childcare than the nounous - every day I witness conversations between the nounous waiting at the school gate, and shudder at their comparisons of their childcare techniques

GColdtimer · 07/02/2008 10:04

I am actually to think that anyone could question the intelligence of SAHMs when the ones on this thread have pretty much shown themselves to be reasonable, logical and very intelligent people.

I think that argument, ridiculous as it was has been shot down in flames.

Pitchounette · 07/02/2008 10:02

Message withdrawn

Swipe left for the next trending thread