Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sorry Xenia...

588 replies

duchesse · 02/02/2008 16:58

...for starting that thread when I didn't believe you existed (and I genuinely didn't). I've done some proper research now, and realise that you are real person with fantastic real achievement. I apologise unreservedly for my previous thread, which was genuinely not designed to get at you since I did not believe you existed. I am aghast and incredibly impressed at how much you have achieved, and look forward to sparring with you again some time...

OP posts:
MrsMattie · 07/02/2008 16:01

Good post@Elffriend (pours her a cup of Bovril and offers her a mossy log to sit on ...)

Elffriend · 07/02/2008 15:51

Xenia this is definitely the most mellow thread I've read from you! To be fair, you HAVE in the past intimated that plenty of us have done things wrong - or done things that have betrayed a stunning lack of intelligence, or a sell-out of wimmin power etc. You're sounding a bit more like the rest of us! You even wrote about compromise!

I think of the things that may well mark you out as unusual is not so much the early focus (I had VERY clear ideas about my life from when I was about 9) but the fact that the focus stayed pretty consistent and you have had the good luck and determination (and yes, brains etc.) to stick with them through good times and bad. You did have a DH in a career that allowed there to be more of a back seat taken, you did not have fertility problems or children with disabilities etc.

So far, I have achieved some of my ambitions, failed in others, changed some of them (decided not to become an astronaut for example...). I'm hoping good things for my next decade (milestone birthday coming up - eek!)but I'm still trying to work out my real long term plans and start mapping a path. I have the basic shape, but having a child has shaken some of the timings and potentially the finer details - there is another variable that was not there before. - and that is assuming nothing (else) goes pear shaped.

As an aside, I can supply head torches and some damn fine insect repellent for the camping and am good at removing leeches should the occasion demand. Crap at singing kum byah though (not even sure how to write it - wasted youth, clearly)

MrsMattie · 07/02/2008 15:45

lennygrrrl, I have a long standing issue with Xenia's amnesia when it comes to her previous posts. How can she say she has never dismissed, nay, condemned SAHMs / PT workers? I cannot be faffed to drag up old posts to demonstrate (although I'm sorely tempted), but it does rile me a little.

lennygrrl · 07/02/2008 15:38

Message withdrawn

MrsMattie · 07/02/2008 15:34

I nominate you as Jester and myself as Scribe@pankhurst (ie. we can sit around drinking tea and wittering).

Xenia is clearly over qualified for rabbit hunting, but I think she'd be ideal for stoking the fire.

duchesse · 07/02/2008 15:32

bagsy I kill fennel.

My alter ego is oh so different from my rl persona...

OP posts:
duchesse · 07/02/2008 15:32

and @ pankhurst

OP posts:
duchesse · 07/02/2008 15:31

rabbit and fennel? < shudder >

OP posts:
MrsMattie · 07/02/2008 15:26

(MrsM gets the tea on, sneakily injecting hers with a large splash of 'ye olde rhum' from her hip flask to fire her up again...)

pankhurst · 07/02/2008 15:26

would we set up a rota for doing the dishes?

(wonders if this is now a new thread or another way of looking at the same question)

would some of us be better suited to staying and tending the campfire and others to killing the rabbits/fennel?

would we be able to maintain a flat structure with love and goodwill or is it inevitable that the fennel killers want the fire tenders to clean the boots as well?

GColdtimer · 07/02/2008 15:18

have I missed something. I don't think anyone is saying she can't lennygrrl.

lennygrrl · 07/02/2008 15:07

Message withdrawn

pankhurst · 07/02/2008 14:46

(starts looking for the old tent, and that sleeping bag the cat gave birth on)

pankhurst · 07/02/2008 14:45

hmmmm, I detect a mellower and more intelligent thread today.

(Mrsmattie, do not underestimate the power of a good debate.)

We may all yet end up as the best of friends, and YOU shall write the story of our adventures.

On an island provided by one of the gang

MrsMattie · 07/02/2008 14:33

Xenia, I'm sorry, but you have absolutely slated any woman who chooses to stay at home or work part-time on numerous occasions. Don't go all 'dementia' on me, now.

Judy1234 · 07/02/2008 14:29

I don't think I've ever said anyone has done anything wrong. Some people become nuns or give their life to looking after elderly parents or go and found a commune. None of those choices are wrong but if you want to earn a decent living and find life a bit easier earning a reasonable sum of money helps. We certainly had some career sacrifice in our home too. Everyone does to some extent with a child. My children's father moved to follow my career and I am sure my leaving work reasonably early probably had an impact too but all parents even those who work full time make those compromises all the time.

What was may be different for me was the early focus, wanting to buy an island when I was 10, going to university at 17, wanting babies when I was 13 ... but I waited until I was 22.... clear things I wanted and a large family so I suppose I started younger whereas my siblings were nearer 40 when they had their children so their lives are a different way round - nearly 20 years of work/freedom or whatever you want to call it and now 40s bringing up children, although we all do work.

I'm not sure I really got myself back into that 1987 mind set. I'd have to look out my diaries to get a better picture. Then 1988 we had baby number 3. Not long after that we bought 2 buy to let flats and spent a lot of time decorating, plumbing, doing all the letting arrangements etc ourselves so that was busy - babies, flats, 2 full time jobs and then there was the theme of getting the girls into good competitive private schools when they were 5. So my 20s were full of buying properties, changing jobs, breastfeeding, dealing with nannies and nursery school and school entrance. It was a busy decade. I thought the 30s were easier, more money, more time, even when I had the twins. Better draw a veil over the 40s, abuse, divorce, deaths, dementia.....it's certainly a bundle of fun around here in the last few years.

totalmisfit · 07/02/2008 13:30

work outside the home. or stay at home. or work from home. if it suits you, do it. that's really all i have to say on the matter.

karen999 · 07/02/2008 13:18

Gosh MrsMattie, did Xenia call you stupid and lazy...

MrsMattie · 07/02/2008 13:14

Ok, so that's your life, Xenia.

I got my degree and did my journalistic training (by the way, I came from a working class background and went to a bog standard secondary school, but still managed to get a good degree from a good university). I got my first job on a magazine. I very quickly worked my way up to Deputy Editor. I was head hunted by a broadcaster and became a radio journalist. Again, from age 25-28 I rose very quickly, and was a senior producer by age 27. At 28, I had a baby, went on maternity leave, went back to my old job for a few months afterwards, didn't want to be away from my child for such long hours - jacked it in.

After 2 yrs as a SAHM (with occasional freelance work - could have been more if I'd wanted it, but I didn't) I am now thinking about working again - only this time more flexibly, on my own terms, and in a way that can (hopefully) fit better with my other concerns - namely my family, and secondary to that, my writing. I have a 3 yr plan , which involves setting up my own business. I am still only 30.

I don't feel that my staying at home with my son for a couple of years has disadvantaged me in the slightest. If anything, it has enriched my life and that of my husband and son.

So - what am I doing wrong? Because it seems to me that you lump every woman who doesn't follow your exact model in with each other and label us as unambitious or stupid or subservient or lazy.

Please - explain.

Elffriend · 07/02/2008 13:05

Thank you for sharing that Xenia - both your experiences and the observation that you are probably a mixture of views in real life .

There was no way the me aged 20 something wanted babies and I never had any question that flat out career was what my life was about. I liked the loose living ! I still want (and have) the career but I am also still getting used to the changed dynamic of now feeling responsible for a baby. Perhaps I will be more in control and focused again once the baby/adjustment phase has passed. Perhaps I will find a more fulfilling role closer to home and be able to return to a full time role without feeling that I am letting down DS. Perhaps I'll let DH become a house husband (not likely. Been there, resented that. And he's a messy git.). Who knows. Life throws you wobblies (like an expensive divorce for example). You are lucky to have forged a lucrative career you clearly love and at which you excel. I admire that and your tenacity (and patience on here!) even if some of your views are slightly different to mine!

lennygrrl · 07/02/2008 12:44

Message withdrawn

Judy1234 · 07/02/2008 12:31

I present one view but I am sure I am more of a mixture of views in real life. Let's look at the younger me. Let's take me at 24, 2 children - a baby and a 2 year old. We are just moving from a little terraced house to a semi in outer London. My ex husband and I are working full time. The new house cost £80k if I remember rightly. We were pleased to have a bigger garden. It's 1987. I would guess I was earning about £14k. I know it was £11,500 in 1985 or 86ish. It had doubled from 1983 because of the nature of the work that I did so that although in 1983 the cost of the nanny was 100% of either my salary of my husband's salary we knew that period of working for nothing, that one year would soon be over. This by the way is exactly how my daughter will be - will start on one salary and it will double within 2 years if she passes her exams etc. Only difference with her is she is 23 and doesn't have children.

So financially we just about managed. We couldn't yet afford a cleaner and we knew we wanted a third child very soon. It was probably the most tiring hardest time of our lives - both working full time with 2 soon to be 3 children under 4. I think whether you're a housewife or work that is often so - having lots of small children is very tiring but it's a phase you get out of in due course.

What did I feel if we go back to the 1987 Xenia? Much less career security obviously if you're young. So concerns about how I was doing at work (and I am sure I left earlier than lots of people). I felt I had a lot in common at work with people 10 years older which isn't a bad thing as I had the babies so much younger. Also if you go from student to mother paying a nanny then you don't get used to money. So it's less hardship than years of loose living and foreign holidays and coupledome followed by age 35 suddenly babies. We had no affluence to lose so buying all the children's stuff in oxfam and buying things like orange juice being an impossibility were just normal for us.

Did I want to work - absolutely. I certainly remember when I was breastfeeding the leaving of a baby can be hard but it was all working reasonably well. I think I saw a very long term picture that in my mid 20s yes every penny was hard to come by but that in my 30s or 40s there was all that hope that things could be easier. I did not anticipate an expensive divorce after I was 40 however.

amidaiwish · 07/02/2008 11:52

"the answer about being able to afford quality children under current circumstances in UK is a high income"

pre children i was earning £60k - taking into account general rises in salaries, that would now be nearer £70k

that was not enough to put 2 children into nursery, pay for travel and the other associated costs with working out of home.

it is truly ridiculous.

Anna8888 · 07/02/2008 11:33

blueshoes - I have visited what are supposed to be the very best private nurseries here in Paris and I would not leave a child there.

No qualifications for nannies exist here.

There are childminders. I don't know much about them, tbh, because people I know don't use them much - crèches and nounous are the usual solution, or students who do after school care (this is a big, growing industry).

blueshoes · 07/02/2008 11:19

But there are good nurseries in France surely? And qualified nannies? Are there equivalent of childminders?

Not everyone is able to afford it, as in the UK, but just because nounous are available does not mean it is all-or-nothing between poor quality childcare or grandparents.

I know a Parisian couple, both working, who were posted to the London office of my company. They had a small baby and hired a nanny to look after her at great expense. The fact of nounous did not blind them to appropriate childcare for a baby.

Swipe left for the next trending thread