Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sorry Xenia...

588 replies

duchesse · 02/02/2008 16:58

...for starting that thread when I didn't believe you existed (and I genuinely didn't). I've done some proper research now, and realise that you are real person with fantastic real achievement. I apologise unreservedly for my previous thread, which was genuinely not designed to get at you since I did not believe you existed. I am aghast and incredibly impressed at how much you have achieved, and look forward to sparring with you again some time...

OP posts:
karen999 · 05/02/2008 11:52

I am starting a new job in March. It will be the first time I have worked full-time in the last 8 years. Previously I have worked part-time to fit in with my daughter. I was married and whilst married to my ex decided that I wanted to do something for myself. I knew that as my daughter got older I would want a career, so I went to uni and studied part-time for 5 years. I did it at night and it became quite apparent quite quickly that my husband was resentful about the time and money which was being spent on me persuing my goal. Needless to say he was not my husband for much longer and we eventaully divorced. I then met a new partner and now have an 11month dd. My new partner has supported and encouraged me to continue and this is what I am doing. I always thought that I would never be able to work full-time, build a career and have children but I have worked very hard for the past five years and even though my dd2 is still very young, I know she will be well looked after (my mum is a CM) I actually dont feel guilty about going out now to get where I want to be. My DP and I both want to move house and have a good standard of living and this is what we are now both working towards. I have enjoyed being at home for the past year with dd2 but I personally need to get back to work and hopefully work towards my career. I realise it will be hard work trying to have it all but I believe that if you are committed and really want it, then you can. I realise not all people want the same things....but personally for me, I think I will be much happier as a person and hopefully this will have an impact on my children. Some of my friends have asked why I am returning to work as my DP earns a decent salary. And tbh I feel like I really need to be out working and earning my own money....

Rosylily · 05/02/2008 11:49

The trick is definately to make a really good go of whatever you do.
My mother was one heck of a sahm.... baking and cooking on the aga,raising chickens/goats/turkeys, fostered children, sewed us clothes and toys, phew, I'm tired just thinking about it.

I must work on being a highly successful sahm and stop moaning at least I don't have to go out to work! (Yikes)

Really glad my sister is doing it for womankind (blah blah,blah). She is a no half measures girl. So obviously to be extremely good at anything you have to be really committed to that mindset.

chocolatedot · 05/02/2008 11:27

Oh I love that old chestnut "I have to go back to work because I need the intellectual challenge" (unlike you who are obviously thick). Funnily enough I continue to get my intellectual stimulation from the same places I always got it, challenging books, plays and films, intelligent debate with friends, Radio 4 and so on.

lucyellensmum · 05/02/2008 11:21

I think the main reason why I personally get upset at Xenia's posts is that i don't think that she is a lone campaigner against the SAHM. There are plenty of other WOMEN (thankfully not all) who do make SAHMs feel inadequate for not doing it all. I come across it an awful lot. The "oh i just couldnt stay at home all day with the children, i would simply go mad - it must be so dull" Yeah yeah, my job was pretty dull at times too. Ironically, no man has ever made me feel that way, regardless of my choice. I have been a working mum in the past and i was never made to feel guilty about it (why should i) but as a SAHM i am made to feel like a selfish, unproductive, useless couch potato. Why does it have to be that way? I'm not an earth mother, i dont thrive in front of the aga (quite envious of those who do to be honest) but my DD is two and a half and will be starting school next september - what is so bad about me wanting to be with her while i can?

chrissnow · 05/02/2008 11:12

I think I am setting my daughter's a fine role model thank you very much. Wealth and success can't always be judged by money, possesions and corporate success. We have a wealth of love and laughter, we have the possessions we need and a few we just wanted. Corporate success for now is my DH's bag. Mine can wait. Surely you are doing women a huge disservice to suggest that they can't be successful past 40? If I so choose to pursue it when the girls are at school then I damn well will. As yet I'm undecided. SAHMism can sometimes be a sacrifice (on the bad days) but generally not. If I am giving my children love, confidence and they are learning stuff I don't think they would at nursery then I am giving them a gift for the future. They will be strong independent intelligent women more than capable of being astronauts, prime ministers, doctors lawyers or whatsoever they choose. Or maybe (god forbid) they'll too fall in love, have children and wait a while. What I will have given them is the self confidence to listen to their hearts and not somebody elses opinion.
Sorry if I can't feel ashamed of that (maybe I'm just too thick and put upon)

sophiewd · 05/02/2008 11:06

I would much rather my daughter sees me albeit as a homemaker then doesn't see me at all because I am out working all hours in a high pwered job. My mother didn't work, didn't stop any of us going on to university and now we run a very successful business from home that enables us to have a fantastic quality of life and see and do an awful lot of our child soon to be children.

chocolatedot · 05/02/2008 11:00

Lucyellensmum, your post just SO sums up why I actually get rather upset by Xenia's posts. Even though my background is an awful lot closer to Xenia's than yours in terms of wealth, opportunity and education, I just find her views extraordinarily blinkered, ill-informed and, I can imagine to many people, hurtful.

I send two of my 3 kids to private schools but it isn't without angst and I make damn sure they understand the circumstances in which most people live.

Piffle · 05/02/2008 10:44

I am amused that you think I'm settling Xenia. And that I may in some way be putting my daughters future choices and ambitions back.
I chose to stay at home, I find that liberating. My relationship with DP does not take a his money approach at all.
He is special, I have seen many husbands who do take this attitude.

I applaud women that work hard and succeed, at the expense of their familes and marriages or not, because as you say Xenia, rightly, they are putting women (in general) ahead in the view of the world.
But I know it's not for me, just now. I am contemplating retraining in a profession which will bring me a reasonable income, proide me with job satisfaction and that accomdates my main and most important job as a mother to three spectacular kids.

As quoted in Judaism, (and on Terry Wogan this morning)
True wealth is being satisfied with what you have.
I am truly satisfied

lucyellensmum · 05/02/2008 10:41

Xenia, im sorry for this but, you brought it up - "On women getting good jobs I would like to see girls from council estates wanting to be prime minster, surgeons, running companies and I hope we can make all our daughters feel those choices are open to them and they should go for them rather than them saying women become housewives and men work because that's the role model they see at home. Once it is as likely a woman as man does a lot of things as is increasingly so then we don't need to worry so much.

Some very clever children are artistic and do well at academic schools. Some children are good at art and music and not very clever and I am sure parents try to pick the right schools for them. I have never said human beings aren't all entitled to equal rights under the law. I believe they are entitled to that but I do think we're all born very different and that any system which thinks they can make us all clones with the same IQ, same level of good or bad looks, same income, is doomed to failure. "

WTF???? All the while we have a teired education system then it is highly unlikely that children (boys or girls) from council estates, average working class families, etc will EVER be prime minister, or even get a foot into parliment. I am reasonably intelligent, and have a PhD to prove it. I was raised on a council estate, my mother was a cleaner and my father a railway worker. I went to the local comprehensive school (albeit a catholic one), was systematically bullied for being well spoken and a bit of a swat. It didn't take me long to find every excuse i could not to go to school. I left school having not sat my O levels even. I wonder if it would have been different if i had gone to the local private school (a very high profile public school). Whether i wouldnt have been bullied or the school would have dealt with it appropriately instead of my being labelled a pain the arse because my parents were always at the school tittle tattling to the head!
So there is already a divide, regardless of whether my mother worked. If she had a better job than she did they still wouldnt have been able to afford private school - so what, must I blame my mother now?

I feel so very strongly about private school - why Xenia are your children entitled to a better education than mine, simply because i have less money? I know that is a simplistic argument, but that is fundamentally what it boils down to. It is reasonable to expect that a child with less intelligence but a better education will do better than a child with high intelligence and poor education.

Also, expectations are not just set by our parents, its society. I AM an intelligent woman. I am a SAHM, and whilst my DD is little that is my choice. But i still don't have the confidence to chase that high flying job that im more than qualified to do. But we both know i have issues, so i cant really use myself as an example here.

Your last paragraph made me die laughing (well almost)"I do think we're all born very different and that any system which thinks they can make us all clones with the same IQ, same level of good or bad looks, same income, is doomed to failure" But isnt that exactly what you want us to do - we should all go out and get high powered high paying jobs in order to send the right message to our daughters about what is expected of them. If we don't do this, not only have we let our daughters down, we have let the whole of the human race down and any human suffering lies at our lazy SAHM feet!!

I think that is the key word here EXPECTATIONS, i think a truly happy person will only listen to their own expectations. Not their parent's, not societies, but to their own heart.

The toilet has to be cleaned, someone has to do it - i tend to be the chief toilet cleaner in this house - even when i worked beyond full time. I honestly don't think my DP has ever done it. I'm not sure why that is, he does pretty much everything else (i do it mostly now because im home). Thing is, i do actually quite like cleaning the toilet - its cathartic. I like the shineyness of it all. Do i feel put upon? No, not at all - often i can be on mnet being bone idle and DP will be running me a bath!! I just think it worked out that way, i hate housework and if i could afford it i would hire a cleaner. Toilet cleaning is just one of the household chores that i hate the least. I know plenty of men who clean the toilet though - its not a valid argument. I think feminism has (or at least should have) moved on a little since then.

Now im cross with myself, i said i woudlnt get involved, i said i woudlnt post an argument with you on this thread, because i hate that this has become personal. I like you, honestly i really do.

But don't you tire of the same old argument again and again and again? The problem with doing that is, you end up contradicting yourself. I'm going to go and clean the toilet now as a form of self punishment (good catholic girl that i am)

Rosylily · 05/02/2008 10:41

My sister who struggles with the juggling can't bare to be stuck at home with children, she thinks I'm mad and I think she is mad but I am not sitting serenely and smugly enjoying sahmhood, it is doing my head in and I am longing to pursue my own things but I just know that I can't do it all at the same time, I don't have that much stamina!
It would be good if more men did some staying at home stints I think.

chocolatedot · 05/02/2008 10:14

At times my mum was a SAHM, at other times she was a brilliant high-flying businesswoman. I worked for 20+ years in the City, at the moment I am a SAHM, next year that will change again into something between the two. Surely the point is that nothing in life is set in stone and it's frankly ludicrous to be so prescriptive about what is "right".

I'd also like to see girls on council estates wanting to be Prime Minsiter etc, as indeed I would boys!

Rosylily · 05/02/2008 09:38

My mum was a sahm totally and now in turn I am a sahm (and artist and reasonably intelligent) but one sister has a brilliant career and juggles it really brilliantly with family, my other sister works part time and is run ragged by the juggling.
I know I couldn't hold down a job but I have a vocation and I'll chase it up more as the children get to school stage.
Having choice is key.

karen999 · 05/02/2008 09:19

We do all have the same sort of problems in life. When I got divorced I did not feel any sense of failure at all. I just picked myself up and moved on. But then I have never put any pressure on myself to always be the best and to be a success at everything....some things work out, some things dont. As for being a role model, I hope I am for my daughters. I will encourage and support them all the way in whatever they choose to do, whatever that may be. However, I dont believe that if I were a SAHM that this would discourage them from wanting to go out and have successful careers. It didnt do that for me or my sister, but tbh I loved the fact that my mum was a SAHM mum.

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 09:16

I don't know if it is because we are such hugely different people, but I find it really hard to relate with your model of the world, Xenia. It's like we're talking about two different planets. Perhaps it is because you are vastly wealthy?
I mean - Who are all these 'housewives' you speak of? I don't know any of them.

Judy1234 · 05/02/2008 09:08

It's certainly reasonably humbling - you go from smug married to public failure in a sense and particularly if people have said you're their role model -happy long marriage, loads of children, successful work... I'm just really saying underneath everyone has the same problems as anyone else in terms of life, relatinoships, death, illness.

On women getting good jobs I would like to see girls from council estates wanting to be prime minster, surgeons, running companies and I hope we can make all our daughters feel those choices are open to them and they should go for them rather than them saying women become housewives and men work because that's the role model they see at home. Once it is as likely a woman as man does a lot of things as is increasingly so then we don't need to worry so much.

Some very clever children are artistic and do well at academic schools. Some children are good at art and music and not very clever and I am sure parents try to pick the right schools for them. I have never said human beings aren't all entitled to equal rights under the law. I believe they are entitled to that but I do think we're all born very different and that any system which thinks they can make us all clones with the same IQ, same level of good or bad looks, same income, is doomed to failure.

lennygrrl · 05/02/2008 08:52

Message withdrawn

karen999 · 05/02/2008 08:46

Xenia, sorry may have misunderstood one of your posts...are you saying being/getting divorced is the most humbling experiences ever??

chocolatedot · 05/02/2008 08:29

Xenia, whilst in your corner of North London most women can probably reasonably expect well paid jobs and interesting opportunities, can't you see that sadly that isn't the case for the vast majority of the female poulation?

I can't understand how you can say you don't think you're right about things in your life. Unlike other people who might say things like "public sector jobs aren't for me as I'm more interested in making money" you declare that anyone working in the public sector is effectively an idiot. Likewise, with certain schools, rather than acknowledging that they may be suited to children who are perhaps more artistic and creative rather than academically brilliant in the narrow sense, you label them "thick" for going there.

I am genuinely flummoxed as to how you get along in RL if you really are so black and white in your views. We are well off but I do my absolute utmost to ensure that my family understand that the way we live isn't how 99.9999999% of the population live. It's very important to me to instill respect in my children for other people's choices and decisions in life.

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 07:57

Over simplistic claptrap, Xenia, I'm sorry. If you think women who clean toilets / stay at home with their kids / aren't all out working 60 hour weeks are to blame for the fact that the workplace (society?) is generally an unfriendly place towards mothers, you have completely missed the point. It's like saying black people are to blame for racism. Ridiculous.

Judy1234 · 05/02/2008 07:25

It's amusing because I never saw the other thread anyway which was supposed to be a bit critical. I don't think I've ever said I was right about things or my life. How can anyone who is divorced ever say that? It's the most humbling experience there is surely? But I do think it's important we have more women in better jobs and if anyone is going to make career sacrifice it should be men for now as we are in historical terms still consolidating some gains which women really haven't had for very long and we don't want to lose it all now because there's a surge in women who'd rather serve at home than rule the nation. YOu only have to get on with this work thin for say 50 years and then we'll all be pretty much more equal and you can go and clean toilets if you really think that's the calling of women. So make that sacrifice for the good of your daughters today and go back to proper full time job in well paid area - don't settle for less.

mrsruffallo · 04/02/2008 23:11

I agree MM- What is all this backslapping? I think her arguments are usually ill-thought out and offensive to sahm to say the least.
Xenia- don't mean to have a go at you, I actually enjoy debating with someone so radically different from myself, but this fawning is quite unbelievable.
lennygrrl- no has asked Xenia to apologise for her success! What a strange notion!

MrsMattie · 04/02/2008 23:04

I am successful in my career - extremely successful. I don't feel the need to 'succeed' in my family life, personally. I'm happy enough, my family are happy enough - that's all we need, surely? I don't apologise one bit for my stance on things. Why on earth should I? Xenia is not the onlky one who couldn't give a flying monkey's fuck what anyone thinks of her.

lennygrrl · 04/02/2008 22:51

Message withdrawn

MrsMattie · 04/02/2008 22:41

I'm chilled, honestly :-) I just can't stand all this 'Let's celebrate that woman who curses all SAHMs and part time workers, in fact, anyone who is not her' malarkey. Puke.

lennygrrl · 04/02/2008 22:40

Message withdrawn

Swipe left for the next trending thread