Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sorry Xenia...

588 replies

duchesse · 02/02/2008 16:58

...for starting that thread when I didn't believe you existed (and I genuinely didn't). I've done some proper research now, and realise that you are real person with fantastic real achievement. I apologise unreservedly for my previous thread, which was genuinely not designed to get at you since I did not believe you existed. I am aghast and incredibly impressed at how much you have achieved, and look forward to sparring with you again some time...

OP posts:
LilianGish · 05/02/2008 13:31

The thing is Xenia posts from a very particular perspective. Her marriage failed, she had to pay her husband a huge sum of money as a settlement, he pays her no maintainance and she has five children to support. I'm not sure choice really comes into it anymore. Good for her that she embraces it rather than moaning about getting a raw deal. I sometimes think her posts are to reassure herself as much as anyone else - after all she can hardly turn the clock back and spend more time with her kids even if some mumsnetters were to persuade that that would have been the best thing to do.

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 13:26

In response to sprogger - can I just say, over the months (years?) I have composed many a reasoned argument opposing Xenia's narrow view of the world, as have many other MN-ers. I think it is actually Xenia who is most likely to be found rambling on in a highly subjective way about 'my five kids, my nanny, the rich woman who lives next door to me...' and so on. Her arguments are very rarely based on anything other than her own incredibly privileged life.

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 13:22

Elffriend - very true. Xenia certainly does polarise opinion!
I actually think most people are like you - muddling along, not entirely sure what they are doing is right, but making the best of the (often limited) choices they do have.

lucyellensmum · 05/02/2008 13:19

excellent post sprogger

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 13:18

And I'm not sure how us all (men and women) working flat out, full time and pretending that our childcare responsibilities aren't actually responsibilities, can help the situation, either@sprogger....?

The whole WOHM vs SAHM 'debate' is false, and irrelevant to most people's lives. People like Xenia only perpetuate the myth that there are two types of women - career-obsessed women who find children boring vs. bread-baking 1950s housewives who sponge off their husbands and give feminism a bad name. None of the women I know fit either description. It's not quite as black and white as the Xenias of this world would have us believe.

Elffriend · 05/02/2008 13:16

Don't get me wrong - I love the morphing - I just find it fascinating! Funnily enough, I think I am far more wary of posting my own opinions on here (about important stuff anyway)than I am in real life! Most people here seem so definite and clear about their own choices. I have the horrible paranoia that everyone else is happy and secure that they have the right approach whilst I drown in guilt and wonder what I'm doing wrong...

Xenia is a fascinating catalyst for all of that. I find some of what she writes breathtaking but with a horrible ring of truth about the way the world actually works. Some of it reads like pompous bo**ocks. Some of it is funny.

If Xenia was not real - someone would need to invent her!

sprogger · 05/02/2008 13:12

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

chocolatedot · 05/02/2008 13:02

As has already been said, it is precisely Xenia's inability to grasp the phrase "vive la difference" that is so baffling to many of us!!.

I don't think any of her choices are wrong as such, what I object to is her pronoucements on other people's.

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 12:59

Oh, I don't know@Elffriend - I quite like the way threads morph into something completely different than the original along the way .

Personally, I feel the same as mrsruffalo. I don't feel the need to defend my life to others, but I am riled by certain posters comments and I do like to put my own opinions forward.

karen999 · 05/02/2008 12:57

MrsR and Mrsm, I agree. I actually am full of admiration for SAHM's. And I applaud the fact that for some women this is a choice they can make. For some women there is not much choice but to work.

Tbh I am a rubbish SAHM. I feel guilty for saying this, but I am bored. This is the reason for me working. I will be fulfilling my desire to be out earning a living and my own money. I do not like being financially dependent on someone and I like the freedom that earning my own money gives me.

I would love for every woman to be in a position to have the freedom and ability to be able to pursue whichever avenue they desire...

mrsruffallo · 05/02/2008 12:54

Lillian- I know what you mean, I try not to get drawn into this because it really has all been said before.
But I just can't let certain remarks go unchallenged..
I really do feel equal to all the men in my life. But then maybe I am not around the macho misogynistic types who like to earn loadsamoney and have trophy wives. Do people like that still exist?

Elffriend · 05/02/2008 12:54

I've read some odd threads in my (short) time, but this one is most impressive, if laughable. A thread arguing about the views of one mumsnetter - who did not even start the thread and has appeared only fairly briefly on it.

Xenia - my hat off to you for being such a beacon for those dying to wrestle again with the SAHM/WOHM curse and defend their own choices to you people who don't know them and who therefore should not really matter/care.

And for the island. Never googled you. Did not know. Coo.

mrsruffallo · 05/02/2008 12:50

Karen, I am not suggesting you can't. I am trying to explain that the recent swing towards more mothers staying at home is as much a concious decision as a need to fulfill a traditional role.
I am not the sahm equivalent of Xenia and would never suggest that working mothers were less fulfilled than me.

LilianGish · 05/02/2008 12:50

Yes sorry MrsR - or argue back. I just find it a bit tedious that any thread featuring Xenia almost invariably turns into a SAHM V WAHM debate in which case following my own advice I usually switch off (damn it I've broken my own rule here!)

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 12:49

Yes,you can@karen999 - but why on earth should Xenia or anybody else judge what should and shouldn't make others happy? Honestly - my mind boggles at this.

karen999 · 05/02/2008 12:46

Mrsruffallo, your last post was good. However, I think you can earn money and still realise and cherish the important things in life....

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 12:43

(Applauds mrsruffalo)

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 12:42

Vive la difference. - Exactly. And this is exactly what Xenia fails to grasp. She would have us believe that women who do not delegate all childcare to a nanny and pursue a career 60 hours a week are 'sell outs' to the cause of feminism and, well, a bit thick, really.

I also think that getting away from saying nice things to each other all the time is all very well - but not if it means swinging drastically to the opposite way of doing things and making sweeping and often incredibly scathing judgements about (the majority of) other women (a la Xenia) NO. Bollox to that. I happen to think that supporting other women in their choices is important. You don't have to be a 'hun' to respect other women and not talk down to them. Anyone would think Xenia is the only successful, educated woman on MN [pah! emoticon]

mrsruffallo · 05/02/2008 12:38

So if you don't like what a particular poster says turn off the computer? I'd rather have a debate and let my own opinions be known.
I think it is perfectly valid that posters get angry with Xenia's remarks. I have read lots of intelligent and heartfelt replies to her insults, hardly any of which are acknowledged.

Her view just sems so old fashioned to me. I worked hard until I had children. I had always known that once I had them I would stay at home if at all possible because that is what I wanted to do.
I find hiding behind the feminist cause by demanding all mothers should work quite clever but ultimately futile.
I believe the swing in mothers staying at home is more a movement against materialism and more about spending precious time with your children- no, you don't get paid, no,you don't get respect from a consumerist society or from bosses who expect you to sacrifice aeverything for your job. TBH I don't really pander after respect from these things anyway.
But I realised a long time ago that things have taken a wrong turn if you just live to make money and don't realise that there is joy and happiness and passion is priceless.

duchesse · 05/02/2008 12:36

I actually have no fixed opinions on whether or not anybody else should go back to work or stay at home. I elected to stay at home when my children were small after a series of abortive attempts to find nannies with enough intelligence to read a story without stumbling over two-syllable words or telling them to shut up if they asked questions, and investigating local nurseries where they spent half the morning in front of the telly. I felt in the end that it was best if I stayed at home with them.

I do not regret that time with them at home at all, and will always look back on it fondly, but I will say that I have panicked on occasions about being completely marginalised in the workplace, about missing the boat career-wise, and bluntly about wasting my youth away bringing up babies when I could have been forging a career. I do not think the time was wasted for them, but if I'm honest, it hasn't been an intellectual success for me in many respects, and has (let's face it) been an economic disaster. I have had the moral and financial support from my husband to do a PGCE and an MA within the last ten years, and I went back to work when my youngest was just about 2.

One of my lasting memories though of that time is of returning home from a school one afternoon to find my MIL waiting on the doorstep with toddler daughter in her arms, handing her to me, and climbing into her car and screeching away without saying a word to me. I felt guilty every single moment I was out of the house while the children were so small, not knowing what I would find when I got home.

My husband had no real idea what I was doing during the day, tbh, and however theoretically supportive, he still expected to do exactly the same as he was doing before I returned to training. So for two years I worked 5am (getting up to prepare lessons etc) got one child to school, went to my full time teaching post, picked child up from school, went home, worked till 6:30, cooked and went to bed at 9pm. Tbh we were barely on speaking terms for this time, not because he expected me to do this and look after him like another child, but because he simply didn't consider what I was doing all day and made no allowances. Because my MIL was a fairy significant part of our childcare arrangements, I couldn't really ask for any more time from her, and couldn't actually afford to employ a nanny who would have cost more than I was earning.

My question to Xenia was more about the practicalities of managing all this using the often patchy combination of family, wraparound and ad hoc friendly childcare many women must use. If I could have afforded a nanny, I jolly well would have done. Captive childcare is not however the norm for most families, and nurseries will often not take a sick child. So how does one manage a child with a broken limb requiring weekly trips to the orthopaedic clinic, or stays in hospital, and still be credible in the workplace?

OP posts:
Quattrocento · 05/02/2008 12:20

I'll answer this if I may - being a fellow career gal with small children.

How did you manage to be available to your children if they were having a hard time at school and needed to talk about it. DD WAS IN TEARS LAST NIGHT BECAUSE SOMEONE HAD CALLED HER A LESBIAN - WE SNUGGLED UP IN BED AND CHATTED FOR NEARLY TWO HOURS ABOUT SEXUALITY, UNKINDNESS AND HOW IT HELPS PEOPLE TO GROW UP AND DEVELOP A CARAPACE

or if they were sick or injured (eg broken limbs) MINE HAVEN'T BROKEN ANYTHING YET BUT IF THEY DO I WILL CANCELL ALL MEETINGS AND BE THERE. IN FACT WHEN DD HAD TO GO TO HOSPITAL FOR KIDNEY APPOINTMENTS I TOOK HER EVERY TIME or needed trips to the hospital, or if they got into trouble at school MINE HAVEN'T DONE THAT YET THOUGH I DID HAVE A BIT OF AN ALTERCATION ABOUT SWIMMING - EASY TO RESOLVE OVER THE PHONE ONCE YOU TRAIN THE TEACHERS TO RETURN CALLS or stopped doing homework and needed you to keep a closer eye on them or go into school to talk to their teachers, etc...WE HAVE AN AU-PAIR WHO HELPS WITH SCHOOL PICKUPS

YOU CAN MANAGE IT ALL. IT'S NOT EASY AND IT IS TIRING BUT YOU CAN DO IT.

Rosylily · 05/02/2008 12:19

Well my high flying sister has a supportive husband and a supportive sister (me) who can go to school concerts/ have the children when they are sick if they can't get out of work commitments.
But I really think in family set ups there needs to be some one who is there and available, who has spare time. Because nowadays everyone's time is always filled to the brim. It's hectic!

LilianGish · 05/02/2008 12:12

"What we need to get away from is women who say nice things to each other all the time at the school gates etc behind very very fake smiles whilst thinking completely the opposite of what they say and avoiding confrontation at all costs. It doesn't serve them well in life or at work and it's a form of dishonesty - this pretending we agree with everyone thing. The less you see it on mumsnet the better." Spot on Xenia. One of the great things about MN is you can post for advice and hopefully get an honest reply without worrying that the person giving the advice is just saying what you want to hear for fear of giving offence. Xenia has an unusual perspective - she's almost certainly in a minority, but her experience and opinions based on that experience are as valid as anyone else. You don't have to agree with her, I'm sure you don't have to apologise to her and if you don't want to hear what she has to say switch off the computer. Vive la difference.

karen999 · 05/02/2008 12:11

Duchesse - I realise you wanted Xenia to answer the question you set but I hope you dont mind if I give you my answer. I am going to work and it is a job where I will be earning a lot more money than I ever have. This is because I put my self through university. I am lucky as my mum is a CM so I have total peace of mind leaving my children with her. I can afford to pay her as I myself am now going to be paid a lot more that I ever have been. I think you can have it all.....you just have to be very organised and work together as a couple.

As for being able to talk to your children about problems etc, well I already do this a nights when my dd gets in....we chat when she is in the bath, watching TV etc....this is also what we have weekends for. Our weekends are really focused on the children and this is when we really spend time as a family.

duchesse · 05/02/2008 12:04

One of my friends went to a GPDST (wuite high flying bunch of girls' schools), and had a talk in the sixth from a former pupil who had become very successful. (this was back in the late 80s in teh middle of the "have it all" mantra)

Her message was this: "Yes, you can have it all, just not all at the same time." Which I think is very empowering.

Hats off to you Xenia for managing to do it at the same time. However, for most averagely-paid parents, the cost of childcare alone precludes a quick return to work. Who can honestly put aside £25000 a year for a full time nanny, or even £12000 a year (per child) after tax for full time day nursery? Answer: Not very many people.

And because women physically give birth and breastfeed, they tend to become the more stay at home parent. Until someone has discovered a way of getting men pregnant and making them lactate, that is fairly unlikely to change.

What I would like to know from Xenia, is this: How did you manage to be available to your children if they were having a hard time at school and needed to talk about it, or if they were sick or injured (eg broken limbs) or needed trips to the hospital, or if they got into trouble at school or stopped doing homework and needed you to keep a closer eye on them or go into school to talk to their teachers, etc...

Because it is this sort of crap that makes it difficult to return to work in any meaningful way once your child is at school, or makes employed parents seem less reliable and marginalises them if they have to take time off work. These are just a few examples of what I would consider jobs that nobody but a parent can sort out (unless you have a very close nanny type person who has known them from birth and can be truly in loco parentis and more like a member of the family)

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread