Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sorry Xenia...

588 replies

duchesse · 02/02/2008 16:58

...for starting that thread when I didn't believe you existed (and I genuinely didn't). I've done some proper research now, and realise that you are real person with fantastic real achievement. I apologise unreservedly for my previous thread, which was genuinely not designed to get at you since I did not believe you existed. I am aghast and incredibly impressed at how much you have achieved, and look forward to sparring with you again some time...

OP posts:
chocolatedot · 05/02/2008 17:37

Quite frankly, in terms of sheer stupidity the "cleverer" remark just says it all.

Judy1234 · 05/02/2008 17:37

It's common sense. You earn £100k a year and have a baby. You love your work. It is interesting and challenging. You spent years getting to that level. You don't want to tidy the house and child mind so you carry on working and you can afford child care.

You work the till at tesco on £12k a year. You have a baby. Of course you'll stay home.

So surely the cleverer better qualified mothers with better education are the ones who continue to work and are better with children too because of their brains, education and coping abilities.

pankhurst · 05/02/2008 17:23

ROFL! NO-ONE could believe that, MrsMattie!

xx

(wipes tears of laughter out of her eyes and holds her aching sides)

It's the funniest thing I've heard all WEEK.

Oh, Xenia, you are such a character! You've made my day.

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 17:03

lol@pankhurst

Xenia: 'Surely working mothers are cleverer and better with children anyway as they are the ones with careers who want to work so they are bound to be better at bringing up children than stay at home mothers who probably didn't have much of a career in the first place, not so clever etc'

Yeh, you sure are cleverer than me!

FFS, Xenia. Read the above out loud. It is utter claptrap. Do you truly believe this shit?

pankhurst · 05/02/2008 16:59

I think there should be more hierarchy amongst women:

Fully-conscious feminist
then
WOHM (unconscious feminist but obviously high EQ)
then half-conscious feminist
then SAHM (who can't fill the fridge with milk)
then half-dressed prozzy
then naked prozzy
then...

I think it is GOOOD to have more women slagging each other off. COME ON!

lucyellensmum · 05/02/2008 16:57

Is cleverer a word?

Anna8888 · 05/02/2008 16:53

"A fully-conscious feminism would celebrate child-rearing and home-making as being among the most significant, powerful, important things that a person can do, rather than perpetuating the lie that only out-of-the-home work is valuable."

Very well said, policywonk

pankhurst · 05/02/2008 16:44

"Surely working mothers are cleverer and better with children anyway as they are the ones with careers who want to work so they are bound to be better at bringing up children than stay at home mothers who probably didn't have much of a career in the first place, not so clever etc therefore you would expect the working mothers to be better with children than stay at home mothers as their education and emotional intelligence are higher and their ability to work and have a family is obviously better than those who can just about cope with ensuring there is enough milk in the fridge."

I've just joined this thread. Haven't read any of the preceding posts, but this is really good - haven't laughed so much in ages!!!!

mrsruffallo · 05/02/2008 16:27

There's a surge in women who would rather serve at home than rule the nation..that's what you posted this am 07:25 and that is what I responded to.

Judy1234 · 05/02/2008 16:21

I'm not sure there is a swing to mothers at home. I think more and more work. So I am the norm and housewives are dying out etc.

I think I was asked quite a few things above., lucye's comment is the most interesting - her very different background and problems over a bad state school. Yes, if you had gone to that really good local public school I am sure you might well be in a different position now. It's why need to take those clever council estate children to good state grammars at 11 or free assisted places at private schools so they can achieve their potential.

I have been out and busy working and I'm not sure I want to argue about stay at home mothers and I've said it all before anyway. If you're consent with it then what anyone says doesn't matter. Same with me as a full time worker - I've always known it was right so anyone saying babies need a blood parent attached to them 24/7 doesn't bother me at all.

"How did you manage to be available to your children if they were having a hard time at school and needed to talk about it, or if they were sick or injured (eg broken limbs) or needed trips to the hospital, or if they got into trouble at school or stopped doing homework and needed you to keep a closer eye on them or go into school to talk to their teachers, etc..." I think Qu answered that. We don't move to a different planet as fathers and mothers when we work. A man I know took Monday and Tuesday off work this week to deal with a 15 year old daughter with problems. Working parents have to do those kinds of things all the time. I might have been out today but sometimes I work in the house which obviously makes it easier in terms of physical access to me. My 5 have rarely been sick in 23 years - whether that's because of the diet they are fed or because we're reasonably well off or because they have good genes or good luck I don't know. But we rarely in 23 years have any sorts of crises of the kinds many families sadly have. If they've had problems they want to talk about we talk about them. Surely working mothers are cleverer and better with children anyway as they are the ones with careers who want to work so they are bound to be better at bringing up children than stay at home mothers who probably didn't have much of a career in the first place, not so clever etc therefore you would expect the working mothers to be better with children than stay at home mothers as their education and emotional intelligence are higher and their ability to work and have a family is obviously better than those who can just about cope with ensuring there is enough milk in the fridge. But I've never said I had any kind of a perfect life. People jump to conclusions because of various physical things I might have but none of that is really the essence of what makes people happy as we all know.

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 14:19

PMSL. Shall we go and get mrs ruffalo and form a mutual appreciation society?

You write well (runs off apologising profusely for being patronising, slightly scary weirdy woman...)

policywonk · 05/02/2008 14:18

Bless you. No, but I think I love you.

GColdtimer · 05/02/2008 14:17

You are right policywonk, it is all about respecting one's choices.

I remember when I was an angsty teen berating my mum for not voting with the "woman tied themselves to railings" speech. She amazed me when she said that those women did that to give other women the right to vote, not to force women to the polling stations if they did not so wish. Different context but same kind of point I think.

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 14:17

Are you a writer?@policywonk (in awe of pw's ability to stick her head in and wham!bam! write something clear, concise and intelligent in the blink of an eye)

policywonk · 05/02/2008 14:16

Sometimes I am INSENSIBLE

policywonk · 05/02/2008 14:15

Thank you MrsM. Don't suppose you'd be willing to pay me for it?

V much agree with your and MrsR's posts on this thread.

lennygrrl · 05/02/2008 14:12

Message withdrawn

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 14:11

What a sensible post@policywonk

policywonk · 05/02/2008 14:00

My understanding of feminism is that women's free choices should be treated with respect, not that all women should be forced down certain avenues.

Given the biological imperatives of recovery from pregnancy/birth and breastfeeding, I'd say that women staying at home with young children is, in some ways, the obvious solution to the early-years childcare conundrum.

Childrearing and home-making are regarded with derision not because they have no value (I'd say they have incalculable social value), but because they have always been regarded as women's work, and thus undervalued by male-dominated societies.

A fully-conscious feminism would celebrate child-rearing and home-making as being among the most significant, powerful, important things that a person can do, rather than perpetuating the lie that only out-of-the-home work is valuable.

This is not to say that mothers should always stay home, or that fathers cannot do most of these things just as well - breastfeeing being the obvious exception (and the elephant in the room if you ask me).

MrsMattie · 05/02/2008 13:52

blows kiss at mrs ruffalo

(sticks out tongue and scarpers)

sprogger · 05/02/2008 13:49

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

chocolatedot · 05/02/2008 13:42

I'm a bit confused about the "reasoned debate" sprogger. Isn't the point that there is no right or wrong in the whole SAHM/WOHM debate, rather that people make their own decisions based on their own circumstances and that each individual's decision is perfectly valid.

mrsruffallo · 05/02/2008 13:38

MM, I love you post of 13:18. I nfact, I agree with all you have posted. Give us a kiss

sprogger · 05/02/2008 13:36

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

mrsruffallo · 05/02/2008 13:32

I didn't go into details with a more reasoned argument because I couldn't be bothered tbh.