Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being too harsh on my 5yo?

91 replies

PizzaPlease7 · 18/12/2022 12:52

DD is 5.5 years old and such a messy eater it drives me nuts. I’m not talking a few crumbs on the table when she gets up but all down her front, all over the floor and the table. If it’s something with a sauce or runny I have to put a large bib on her. I have tried to show her so many times how to eat without making a mess but she just doesn’t get it. I’m pregnant and it’s getting harder for me to be on my hands and knees after every meal/snack tidying up after her.

I do compare her to my eldest DD who is now 7 and at 5 years wasn’t making so much of a mess. My parents and DH think I’m being unreasonable and my expectations are too high, that it’s ‘just who she is’. I do lose my cool often because it gets so tiring constantly tidying up after her and then I feel guilty afterwards wondering if it’s normal for her age or not.

YABU - she’s only 5.5, cut her some slack

YANBU - by now she shouldn’t be making so much of a mess

OP posts:
cestlavielife · 18/12/2022 18:07

Bib overall apron or old larger t shirts to eat then tgrow in washing machine
Thick handled cutlery
Ask school to arraNge an o t assessment

ABC movement battery is useful assessment

RegularNameChangerVersion21 · 18/12/2022 18:04

PizzaPlease7 · 18/12/2022 15:12

Mess in general triggers me, I often get described as a ‘neat freak’ and I can’t stand mess/dirt/unorganized spaces. However with young DC I have obviously had to adjust the way I am. With DD’s messy eating I genuinely didn’t know if it’s normal or not for her age. I only have my older DD to compare to who wasn’t messy which is why I get frustrated at younger DD. However this thread has made me realise this isn’t her fault and I need to change, not expect her to!

It sounds like this is a particular trigger point for you OP. I get it and I think alot of us have these areas where we get stressed out more quickly than we should. (I have certain sound sensitivities possibly due to ADHD and noisy eating stresses me out). Once you're aware of it though it's best not to let it become an issue for your DC, you definitely don't want to let meal times become a stressful event. Sometimes just being prepared in advance that there will be mess but it will be cleaned up is enough. Alternatively don't sit where you're looking directly at her while she's eating or just put a large mat down so it's easier to tidy up afterwards. Or make it DH's job to deal with. Honestly you sound like a very self reflective person OP which is great!

Fleabigg · 18/12/2022 15:39

Middle child syndrome is a real thing. You’re comparing her unfavourably with your eldest and getting frustrated with her because you’re pregnant with a new baby who will be the youngest with all that entails. She’s 5 and it doesn’t sound like she’s doing it deliberately, give her a break.

BeanieTeen · 18/12/2022 15:35

Maybe she has gross motor difficulties? Is this a problem at school?
You know your child.
If mine makes a mess it’s because he’s being careless or pissing about so yeah I’d tell him off.
But if they genuinely can’t help it then it’s no use getting frustrated about it.

BCBird · 18/12/2022 15:34

Get her to clean up the mess herself. Could he have some plastic neat her chair that she can pick up and u can wipe down if the former not an option?

Singleandproud · 18/12/2022 15:32

@PizzaPlease7 Marks and Spencer do an easy getting dressed range which is brilliant. DD never had any difficulties getting changed but they never had long to do it for PE she also had quick changes during dance shows and these were perfect. The easy dressing shirts have velcro under the top 4/5 buttons and then normal ones on the lower part of the shirt where they can see easily and the ones on the wrist cuff are elasticated.

Silicon dress shoe laces are great from Amazon and turn any lace up shoe into slip ons, we originally used them for tap shoes but I've put them in mine and DDs shoes as they save the heels if you don't take your shoes off/put them on properly.

ForestofD · 18/12/2022 15:23

My eldest has a list of weekly chores. One is to hoover the lounge. After one go, I realised I needed to show her how to hoover as she just did the walkways.

It never occurred to her to pull the dining chairs out and hoover under the table. But equally, it never occurred to me that I needed to show her what I wanted her to do. It was then I realised that I needed to actually teach her these skills- it was the same for changing the bedsheets. I know mine are a little older than yours but the idea is the same. And believe me, it will take a fair few goes to get it even near right.😉Lots of praise, plenty of patience. Good luck!

PizzaPlease7 · 18/12/2022 15:12

RegularNameChangerVersion21 · 18/12/2022 15:09

I very much doubt she's doing it on purpose. It sounds like she's more clumsy that your older child. My eldest is a really messy eater, even at 9 years old he makes a massive mess. I remind him to be careful and have him help tidy up but I don't shame him for it. Why does the mess trigger you so much? If you find it too hard make meal times DH's job so you don't risk getting irritable.

Mess in general triggers me, I often get described as a ‘neat freak’ and I can’t stand mess/dirt/unorganized spaces. However with young DC I have obviously had to adjust the way I am. With DD’s messy eating I genuinely didn’t know if it’s normal or not for her age. I only have my older DD to compare to who wasn’t messy which is why I get frustrated at younger DD. However this thread has made me realise this isn’t her fault and I need to change, not expect her to!

OP posts:
RegularNameChangerVersion21 · 18/12/2022 15:09

I very much doubt she's doing it on purpose. It sounds like she's more clumsy that your older child. My eldest is a really messy eater, even at 9 years old he makes a massive mess. I remind him to be careful and have him help tidy up but I don't shame him for it. Why does the mess trigger you so much? If you find it too hard make meal times DH's job so you don't risk getting irritable.

PizzaPlease7 · 18/12/2022 15:09

Loving all the dog suggestions 😁we are a no pet household atm for various reasons unfortunately!

OP posts:
PizzaPlease7 · 18/12/2022 15:08

Merlott · 18/12/2022 15:03

It is frustrating but you must help her learn skills. My 5yo constantly picks at food and drops the pickings everywhere 🙄but I make him pick the bits up and into bowl/bin!

Tidying up - doesn't have to be a brush if she struggles with it. Try asking her to pick the pieces up with her fingers and put in a bowl then tip the bowl into the bin? Then wash hands etc. after.

The hair thing - must admit I'm really confused. Is there a reason you can't put it up into a bun while she eats? Or do you mean she wipes her hands on her head?!

I do put it in a bun but she always touches her hair with mucky fingers! Or slams her spoon too hard into the bowl and something will splash in her hair etc..

OP posts:
Lcb123 · 18/12/2022 15:04

She should clear up after herself, or at least help you. She’ll soon learn

Merlott · 18/12/2022 15:03

It is frustrating but you must help her learn skills. My 5yo constantly picks at food and drops the pickings everywhere 🙄but I make him pick the bits up and into bowl/bin!

Tidying up - doesn't have to be a brush if she struggles with it. Try asking her to pick the pieces up with her fingers and put in a bowl then tip the bowl into the bin? Then wash hands etc. after.

The hair thing - must admit I'm really confused. Is there a reason you can't put it up into a bun while she eats? Or do you mean she wipes her hands on her head?!

2bazookas · 18/12/2022 15:02

Give her a plastic bib with a gutter to catch the bits,

or
Get a spaniel or labrador...you'll never have to clean food off the floor again.

disabilityama · 18/12/2022 15:00

Another vote to look up dyspraxia. Or ADHD or any of the others, thinking about myself and siblings and what we've been diagnosed with, ADHD with no motor issues also made for messy eating. Not that this in itself means she definitely has xyz condition, just something to think about. I'm not going to rub in the "don't huff at her for making a mess" because I think you've accepted that now, but it is true.

I learned to ride a bike at the normal time, ish - maybe 5 or 6? But I never really improved after that and I was still riding like a 7 year old at 15 (and older I just stopped practising once I was an adult lol). I also learned how to tie my laces fairly early and my fine motor skills were neat but never sped up and I eventually tested as having a clinically significant slower writing speed despite being legible. And I played an instrument to pre-conservatoire level, but still couldn't catch a ball or run in a straight line, or copy from a whiteboard in class by 18. Point is, it's a varied disorder and you don't have to hit all the possible criteria to be diagnosed.
Maybe she could have some different cutlery to help, if she's grown out of toddler cutlery you can get adult and junior specialised cutlery, although they are expensive (I developed an illness as an adult and I've spent a tenner on each item of cutlery, but worth it for the independence!). You could present it as something to help her because you care about her, rather than as "baby" cutlery because she can't do stuff

PizzaPlease7 · 18/12/2022 14:57

ForestofD · 18/12/2022 14:54

You said she made more mess when she tidied up. But tidying up is a skill to be learnt like everything else. She will make mistakes while learning that skill. That's natural.

Yes I definitely need to be more patient otherwise I guess she’ll never learn and I’ll only have myself to blame for not teaching her!

OP posts:
PizzaPlease7 · 18/12/2022 14:56

YellowTreeHouse · 18/12/2022 14:40

YABU. Regardless of the issue, you should never lose your cool with a child. You’re not teaching her to be tidier by shouting at her.

Never lose your cool with a child? You either don’t have children or are Mary Poppins. Everyone loses their cool with their DC at some point in life 🙄

I also made it clear I don’t shout at her.

However, fully accept that I shouldn’t even be getting frustrated at her as it’s something she can’t help at the moment and will be changing my attitude and behaviour towards the mess she makes.

OP posts:
ForestofD · 18/12/2022 14:54

You said she made more mess when she tidied up. But tidying up is a skill to be learnt like everything else. She will make mistakes while learning that skill. That's natural.

PizzaPlease7 · 18/12/2022 14:52

Rainbow1901 · 18/12/2022 14:18

Is your daughter actually concentrating on eating? By that can she see the TV which could be distracting her?
Kids can be messy - whatever they happen to be doing!

I occasionally allow screen time whilst eating but it doesn’t make a difference, whether she’s watching something or not the messiness is the same.

I think the natural consequence route will have the most effective outcome in the long run, even if it is time consuming and a pain in the arse! But definitely realised it’s totally unreasonable of me to get frustrated by something she’s obviously not able to control yet.

OP posts:
Goldbar · 18/12/2022 14:52

I wouldn't get annoyed with her but I would make her clean up after herself (or at least help me do it) until the area was completely clean. Even if it took ages. The reality of life is that if we're messily-inclined, we have to either take more care or spend ages cleaning up after ourselves (or annoy other people by leaving mess for them!) - I don't think she's too young to start learning this.

YellowTreeHouse · 18/12/2022 14:40

YABU. Regardless of the issue, you should never lose your cool with a child. You’re not teaching her to be tidier by shouting at her.

maddiemookins16mum · 18/12/2022 14:30

WickedWangoCard · 18/12/2022 14:12

You got lucky with your first, I'm afraid. Children are generally messy up until 7/8 and it's annoying!

Encourage her to be more careful though, by all means. Just enjoy that your oldest isn't the same!

I disagree. I’ve never known children over the age of approx 4 make a really bad mess when eating. 8 year olds making a real mess is pretty unusual.

Hopeyoursproutsarealreadyon · 18/12/2022 14:30

Get her a little hand held vaccum cleaner!

Stressedmum2017 · 18/12/2022 14:27

I know it's really annoying. My 7 year old the other night kicked over 2 cups of orange juice that were on the coffee table, went all over sofa, floor, rug then I stupidly left her with a tub of pringles she was snacking on whilst sat on the sofa. Well 5 minutes later it was as if she'd crushed up 2 handfuls and chucked them round the room. It was ridiculous. Think it's more annoying because at 2 you expect the mess like that, by the the time they are in primary school, not so much. All you can do is train them to clean up after themselves, only thing that lessons the irritation lol.

Bonheurdupasse · 18/12/2022 14:26

PorridgewithQuark · 18/12/2022 13:02

Don't get cross, just give her the brush and dustpan and send her to change her top and put the dirty one in the wash basket herself. Natural consequence - she learns and you don't crawl under the table picking up food.

She could be dyspraxic or could just be messy, but even if she is dyspraxic learning to clean up after herself is perfectly appropriate as long as it's a consequence without anger attached, not a punishment. If 7 year old sister occasionally makes a mess obviously she should clean up after herself too - equal treatment without value judgement.

This OP.
Don't treat it as a punishment, just a (set in stone) natural consequence.