Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend wont discuss my concerns

111 replies

Cassie077 · 18/12/2022 11:49

Very good friend has been deflecting for many many months when I asked to spend time with her. I feel
hurt. When I told her this she respectfully had to hang up the phone. We have had times in the past we have tried to discuss and they went soso. She always thought things were mostly my fault and so about never apologized. I did. The discussions she felt upset by. At times I would feel more intense or emotional and yet I was hurting. I apologized if something was off. She seemed to think expressing feelings meant arguments. She saw me struggling and suffering for months on end as I tried to guess why she stepped back so far. Which I kept trying to talk about. She was a great helpful friend. I just couldnt have no communication on things I needed to discuss. Even if no change in the outcome. Now I am still sitting with no change on outcome after telling her this. And now without my friend as if there is no chance for us to discuss anymore. She wasnt protecting me. I needed discussion on this. I hate myself now. And am extremely depressed. I know I said the friendship couldnt continue but I said “with” lack of communication. I told her I needed her half to solve. She hasnt gotten back with me. Do I try contacting her again? Am I being unreasonable to feel hurt by no discussing and not being okay with her spending personal time with me? We saw eachother at a hobby. And she has helped with many things. I wanted 1-1 time to just sit and talk. Though we did talk on phone daily. Am I being unreasonable that I have felt I need to cut ties?

OP posts:
codehelp · 18/12/2022 13:07

You sound like a stalker OP.

Leave her alone.

Newwardrobe · 18/12/2022 13:06

How often have you sat and listened to your friend? How often have you helped her ? Maybe she just hasn't got the emotional energy to give any more of her time to you.

Schoolchoicesucks · 18/12/2022 13:04

Do you have other close friends? Do you help this friend or is it usually her helping you? Do either or both of you have relationships or families?
Sometimes friendships go through phases of being less intense and more casual catch ups through shared hobbies. Sometimes they recover the closeness, sometimes not. Some people like to analyse friendships for clarity of where they stand, others prefer to let their actions speak for them.

Your friends actions are telling you she needs some space. You can choose to listen to this and respect it or to keep pushing at it.

You haven't mentioned your friends wants or needs at all.

I would back off OP, let her know you are there, see her when you do your hobby, listen to what her actions and responses are telling you about what she needs from the friendship.

leeloo1 · 18/12/2022 13:02

@Cassie077 - it may be hard for you to understand. but she doesn’t owe you meetings or an explanation and if you’re honest you can probably look back at your last interactions and work out for yourself why she doesn’t want to spend time with you.

When you think about the last times you met with this friend, how much did you learn about them? How much did you help them? What did you offer them? Were there some laughs, or was it a quite intense discussion of how your needs have to be met?

Some people are uplifting to be with, you spend time with them and have fun, feeling lighter and happier both during and afterwards. When you talk they listen and put positive spins on things or offer practical or emotional support, but also you need to listen when they talk and offer this in return.

Were your meetings with her like this?

Some people are less like this. When you talk they don’t listen - either blocking what you say by not properly engaging, or turning the conversation back to themself all the time. - they’re self absorbed and have a negative mindset. It doesn’t make them bad people, but it’s a negative and draining experience to be with them.

Do you feel there’s any element of your relationship that was like this?

For everyone’s sense of well-being they need to set boundaries on relationships that protect them. If your friend talked to you on the phone everyday then that’s a lot already and (hopefully) she was happy to do that. She doesn’t ‘owe’ you meeting up in person and nor does she ‘owe’ you a meeting so you can tell her off.

WomanhoodIsABirthright · 18/12/2022 13:00

Cassie077 · 18/12/2022 12:48

That she wasnt spending personal time with me. And was not allowing me to discuss why.

Jesus christ.

JoyBeorge · 18/12/2022 12:53

People are not duty bound to spend time with you or enter into endless discussion if they don't want to. Friendships can't be controlled like this. It does all sound a bit demanding. I probably wouldn't speak to you either if you were making demands that I had to discuss what you wanted to discuss.

Cassie077 · 18/12/2022 12:48

That she wasnt spending personal time with me. And was not allowing me to discuss why.

OP posts:
DuplicateUserName · 18/12/2022 12:47

Sorry I meant to add, it can be very difficult helping someone who suffers with depression.

Not everyone is cut out for that.

DuplicateUserName · 18/12/2022 12:45

'She was a great helpful friend' and then 'she has helped with many things'.

Maybe she doesn't want to help you anymore because she feels it's too draining, but just doesn't want to come out and say that to you?

I think you just need to back off now and leave her be.

TheFormidableMrsC · 18/12/2022 12:45

This is too much. I couldn't be friends with somebody as intense as you. Friendship shouldn't be this hard work and she doesn't owe you anything at all! I think you need some counselling to unravel your feelings because you will continue to spoil friendships if you carry on like this. I can't imagine speaking daily to any of my friends let alone expecting this level of commitment. It's not normal.

heldinadream · 18/12/2022 12:44

Are you both quite young? I think I felt like this about people in my twenties, now I look back and think it's terrible that I so wanted other people to be what I wanted them to be instead of appreciating them for who they were.

And when I say twenties, I think in many ways I was very immature.

Friends need to be not as dependent as this on each other. It's too much.
But I hope you're ok and your friendship could survive this.

Sodullincomparison · 18/12/2022 12:43

I have a friend of over twenty years who sends messages like this. I just don’t reply any more as it has sucked all the oxygen out of the friendship.

I will give my friends anything in the world but life is too short for friendships which bring conflict.

iRun2eatCake · 18/12/2022 12:36

Take the hint...she doesn't want the same level of intensity scrutiny of a friendship like you do

pastypirate · 18/12/2022 12:34

Sounds like you want to go on at her about x and y and she's said no. I don't blame her.

cansu · 18/12/2022 12:31

You sound very intense. I would not want a friendship to be hard work like this.

Pterrydactyl · 18/12/2022 12:28

This all sounds very intense.

For whatever reason, it sounds like your friend is either not able, or not willing, to provide the level of support that you want from her. I’d guess that this may be part of the reason why she’s been taking a step back from your friendship.

Its not unreasonable to feel upset when friendships dwindle, but if she wants to take a step back - and from what you’ve written, it seems clear that she does - then you pushing for more contact and more discussions about what’s gone wrong, is unlikely to help. I’d give her a bit of space for now.

Bard6817 · 18/12/2022 12:23

People have a lot going on, not just you.

I like to say we all have a patience cup, and It gets filled by your own troubles and sometimes, other people need to try and fill yours too, as it stops their cup from running over. Once it runs over, that’s when people break…. People know when their cup is nearly full usually, but not always. I’d never blame someone for protecting their own cup. I do blame those that dump their woes on others without regard for the other.

MuckyPlucky · 18/12/2022 12:20

Your ‘concerns’ are that she’s distancing herself. That should speak for itself. The more you push at her to ‘discuss these concerns’ the more she’ll want to distance herself. You’re doing the exact thing she’s pissed off about.

You sound incredibly hard work, and very troubled. Your poor friend has a life of her own to attend to, and you’re hounding and trying to constantly draw her in to your drama.

Please, leave her in peace. And please consider therapy for your over-intense reactions to perceived relationship slights. It could really improve your life and future relationships.

spookymarmite · 18/12/2022 12:20

It sounds like this person doesn't want to be friends with you.

MintJulia · 18/12/2022 12:17

Way too intense. Your friend has every right not to want to discuss something. If you raise a topic and she fends it off, don't pursue it. Change the subject.

She is not your counsellor.

Bigdamnheroes · 18/12/2022 12:17

You sound bloody hard work and the friendship very one sided.

It's all about what you need, not what she needs, which, from the sounds of it, is to move on from this bullshit, not keep dragging it up every 5 minutes for long intense discussions.

And frankly, what you need isn't her problem. If you need to go through it all in such exhausting detail pay a therapist to listen to it.

Leave her alone for Christ's sake, she is done with it and clearly doesn't want to be your friend anymore. Not that I blame her, you're coming across very self obsessed.

Remona · 18/12/2022 12:16

Sometimes the more we push, the more people resist.

Let it go. She’s made it crystal clear that she doesn’t want to discuss this and you are making matters worse by forcing the issue. Small wonder she has taken a step back.

Not everything in life needs to be analysed to within an inch of its life.

MadameMinimes · 18/12/2022 12:15

I think you just need to accept that the friendship has come to an end. You gave an ultimatum and said that you couldn’t continue the friendship unless she agreed to change. She has clearly decided that she’d rather let the friendship end than fit in with what you wanted.
It’s time to move on. I mean this gently but you sound very intense and she possibly found it all a bit much.

Alibabasonethief · 18/12/2022 12:14

Sage396 · 18/12/2022 11:59

That sounds quite intense for a friendship. I don't have any friends I regularly (or ever to be honest) have arguments with. I've stepped back from a friendship before when it became emotionally exhausting; maybe she's doing the same. I think it's time to back off and if the friendship doesn't recover then that's okay - that happens sometimes.

Yes this. I don’t mean this harshly but everyone’s emotions are their own to deal with. If someone is treating you in a way that is not meeting your needs it is up to you to 1) try to fix it which you did but then 2) accept the reality that it can’t be fixed and put boundaries in place to protect your mental well being.

Your friend is persistently putting emotional boundaries in with you which you are failing to recognise. She cannot do what you need from her and you need to address these issues elsewhere. Your response to this to me suggests that you have had experiences of this in the past that this situation is triggering it might be worth exploring that with a therapist.

KitchiHuritAngeni · 18/12/2022 12:11

You spoke daily and still had a go at her for not spending time with you?

Now you have said you wish to cut ties with her if she doesn't spend more time on you and she has leapt at the chance.

She did a lot for you by the sound of it, and instead of thanking her you've criticised her for not doing more.

Being this fixated on one friendship, and expecting this much emotional support from one person isn't normal op.