Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friend wont discuss my concerns

111 replies

Cassie077 · 18/12/2022 11:49

Very good friend has been deflecting for many many months when I asked to spend time with her. I feel
hurt. When I told her this she respectfully had to hang up the phone. We have had times in the past we have tried to discuss and they went soso. She always thought things were mostly my fault and so about never apologized. I did. The discussions she felt upset by. At times I would feel more intense or emotional and yet I was hurting. I apologized if something was off. She seemed to think expressing feelings meant arguments. She saw me struggling and suffering for months on end as I tried to guess why she stepped back so far. Which I kept trying to talk about. She was a great helpful friend. I just couldnt have no communication on things I needed to discuss. Even if no change in the outcome. Now I am still sitting with no change on outcome after telling her this. And now without my friend as if there is no chance for us to discuss anymore. She wasnt protecting me. I needed discussion on this. I hate myself now. And am extremely depressed. I know I said the friendship couldnt continue but I said “with” lack of communication. I told her I needed her half to solve. She hasnt gotten back with me. Do I try contacting her again? Am I being unreasonable to feel hurt by no discussing and not being okay with her spending personal time with me? We saw eachother at a hobby. And she has helped with many things. I wanted 1-1 time to just sit and talk. Though we did talk on phone daily. Am I being unreasonable that I have felt I need to cut ties?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Diffuserqueen · 18/12/2022 20:29

Cassie077 · 18/12/2022 15:03

Daily contact isnt just for me. She said it would bother her if I didnt call.

I am sorry I posted this. Only because I didnt realize wanting to spend time with someone was a bad thing. I thought it was a good thing in a friendship that peor do. And I am having to defend that. 1 hour a week is what I wanted. We used to do tons together.

Op wanting to spend time with someone is not a bad thing. I think you know this and are just upset by responses.

demanding someone spends time with you , not accepting when they don’t wish to, or don’t have the time to. Trying to constantly make them justify this decision to you, making them upset, wanting them to apologise for not spending time with you, not Respecting them or their boundaries, feeling entitled to their time. Feeling entitled to their support. That’s what is a bad thing. That’s what posters are telling you.

KettrickenSmiled · 18/12/2022 20:08

annielouisa · 18/12/2022 19:59

I have lots of friends and I do not meet with them 1-2-1 for an hour a week to discuss my problems that is what a counsellor is for. Your friend had a mutual interest i.e. the hobby and she gave you friendship in relation to that. You appear to have become fixated on her as "support friend" and are asking her to rationalise her reluctance to commit to that role.

She has stepped back as you are trying to dictate the terms of the friendship just to suit your needs. Do you have a counsellor that you can discuss this friendship dynamic with?

OP, this is likely the most simultaneously compassionate but realistic post you are going to see on your thread.

I am genuinely sorry about how painful all this rumination & attemot to wrest back some kind of 'control' over the direction of your friendship must be for you. I hope you take @annielouisa's excellent advice & find some solace, wisdom, & healthy coping techniques from an experienced therapist. Possibly one well-versed in attachment issues.

Best wishes Flowers

annielouisa · 18/12/2022 19:59

I have lots of friends and I do not meet with them 1-2-1 for an hour a week to discuss my problems that is what a counsellor is for. Your friend had a mutual interest i.e. the hobby and she gave you friendship in relation to that. You appear to have become fixated on her as "support friend" and are asking her to rationalise her reluctance to commit to that role.

She has stepped back as you are trying to dictate the terms of the friendship just to suit your needs. Do you have a counsellor that you can discuss this friendship dynamic with?

Tallulah28 · 18/12/2022 19:40

Cassie077 · 18/12/2022 15:03

Daily contact isnt just for me. She said it would bother her if I didnt call.

I am sorry I posted this. Only because I didnt realize wanting to spend time with someone was a bad thing. I thought it was a good thing in a friendship that peor do. And I am having to defend that. 1 hour a week is what I wanted. We used to do tons together.

You can’t insist that someone spends an hour a week with you. That is entirely unreasonable. I would suggest getting some support and exploring why you feel you’re entitled to someone else’s time in this way.

saraclara · 18/12/2022 17:53

Think about what your calls and time together are like for your friend, and ask yourself these questions.

Is it fun for her to be around me?
Does she leave feeling buoyed up and happy for speaking to me?
Does she feel that I've listened to her?
Who spoke most during that conversation? And who was the subject most of the time?

I do wonder if your friend talks to you because she knows you need her. But that it's not actually fun, nor are the conversations light.
I wonder if you know as much about her life/day/week as she knows about yours.
I wonder if she leaves feeling like she has an extra burden on her shoulders.

I've been that friend. I was very fond of the friend who needed me and used to enjoy their company. But after a while I realised that a lot of the time, I left their company or the conversation feeling really stressed and worried about them. And also that they hadn't asked a single thing about me, and I'd not found a point in the conversation to tell them anything. And I certainly didn't feel able to share anything that was positive ir they'd feel worse.

If you manage to talk to her again, ask about her life Talk about something light or anusing. Even if it's about TV. But save your own problems for another time, when you've re-established yourself as sommeone who she actually likes to be around.

7eleven · 18/12/2022 17:35

Cassie077 · 18/12/2022 15:03

Daily contact isnt just for me. She said it would bother her if I didnt call.

I am sorry I posted this. Only because I didnt realize wanting to spend time with someone was a bad thing. I thought it was a good thing in a friendship that peor do. And I am having to defend that. 1 hour a week is what I wanted. We used to do tons together.

Oh for goodness sake. Quit the pity party and do some work on yourself 🙄

BMW6 · 18/12/2022 17:18

OP have you been speaking about hurting yourself to her? Is that why she has said she wanted to hear from you every day?

Benjieandjacksmum · 18/12/2022 16:40

I'm so sorry op you sound really unhappy. Do you have a counsellor or any mental health support at all? If not can you see your GP and get some help sorted. Some CBT or counselling would really help you. The support you need is best coming from a trained Counsellor or ideally a psychotherapist you could discuss these needs and how they could be met leaving you to have a proper real friend once you have understood how to operate true friendship. Please take care of yourself I wish you a brighter future and a very merry Christmas

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 18/12/2022 16:30

The problem with issuing ultimatums is that you have to be very, very sure you’ll get the response for which you were hoping. Your friend has essentially called your bluff. You were expecting her to fall over herself to apologise, to reassure you that she’d make more time for her from now on. But she didn’t. You gave her the option of cutting ties and she appears to have taken it.

Learn a lesson from this. Ultimatums and demands rarely earn well. In future, try to let friendships develop a little more organically rather than laying down ground rules and schedules.

Seaweed42 · 18/12/2022 15:48

The relationship sounds one-sided. She was the mother and you were the child. That's the way it's coming across. I could be wrong about that.

Maybe you put all your friendship eggs in the one basket and therefore needed her to provide you with very high levels of emotional and social support.

It can come across as needy to expect a friend to fill every emotional void you have.

The friend cannot fix every emotional wound you have.

Look at the roles between the two of you. Why are you so dependent on this friend?

Theydoyaknow · 18/12/2022 15:46

I honestly don't blame her, too needy, too intense and me me me me me me me.

No.

OooScotland · 18/12/2022 15:36

You are sorry you posted because we didn’t say what you wanted us to say.

What did you want from this thread? Something that you can show your friend as proof that she should want to give you what you demand?

The obsession with regular official meetings (speaking daily, I wanted one hour a week) to discuss your problems and wanting your friend to ‘help’ and ‘protect’ you (from what, I wonder…) look like serious issues to me. I would not feel able to cope with the responsibility of that in a friend.

She might have said something like she would worry about you if she didn’t speak to you every day but it might have just been a throwaway comment to try and placate you.

Again, just let her go. You need a therapist before a friend.

KettrickenSmiled · 18/12/2022 15:34

Do I try contacting her again?
For the love of all you hold holy - NO!
Let her come to you.

Am I being unreasonable to feel hurt by no discussing and not being okay with her spending personal time with me?
Not in the least - but you can't expect her feelings to match yours, & talking about it any further is not going to change her feelings into being ones you are more comfortable with.
I know that hurts - but it's a fact, & maybe putting energy into finding a way to deal with that internally, rather than trying to 'fix' the issue, is a better use of your time.

We saw eachother at a hobby. And she has helped with many things. I wanted 1-1 time to just sit and talk. Though we did talk on phone daily. Am I being unreasonable that I have felt I need to cut ties?
I don't know. But probably. Why so all-or-nothing?

You are at an impasse - you want to talk about what you feel is an issue, she does not.
However - you feel the only solution is to cut ties if you are not able to keep talking about the issue.
She feels the reverse - that if you keep talking at her about the issue, she needs to step back.

So if you are unwilling to keep your need to constantly discuss - (I am sorry, it's hard to work out what the issue actually is, but seems to be about you wanting more time with her & deeper conversations than she wants to have) - this issue to yourself, then yes - you need to withdraw, because painful as it is for you, she is not interested in hearing it.

Have you spent any time considering doing it her way?

Because you appear to be demanding contact frequency & intensity on your own terms without giving the same consideration to her terms.
She's clearly not comfortable with how hard you are pushing, so is sliding away because SHE DOES NOT WANT TO HAVE ENDLESS TALKS about what you want & need from her.

A daily phone call was a LOT. I'm not sure how much more you can expect - she also has a life. Problems. Feelings. She's not demanding you sit up & pay attention to them - quite the reverse, she is clearly indicating it's all got too much for her, & she wants you to stop asking to have "The Talk" like you are a pair of lovestruck teens.

If you want to keep her in your life, keep things lighter. And stop apologising, it's just a way of drawing focus bavk onto The Issue. Which she does not want to discuss. You need to actually listen to her - including the things she's NOT saying, which are essentially - "too much, too intense, can we not just re-set & have fun & lightness".

Shinyandnew1 · 18/12/2022 15:26

1 hour a week is what I wanted.

Your post is all about what you want.

BronwenFrideswide · 18/12/2022 15:26

Only because I didnt realize wanting to spend time with someone was a bad thing. I thought it was a good thing in a friendship that peor do.

Wanting to spend time with someone is not a bad thing, dictating how that time is to be spent and what for is.

Your post are all about you, what you demand, what you need/want, how you deem your friend should be. Your friend has agency of her own, she is not obliged to dance to your tune.

DucklingDaisy · 18/12/2022 15:22

Cassie077 · 18/12/2022 15:03

Daily contact isnt just for me. She said it would bother her if I didnt call.

I am sorry I posted this. Only because I didnt realize wanting to spend time with someone was a bad thing. I thought it was a good thing in a friendship that peor do. And I am having to defend that. 1 hour a week is what I wanted. We used to do tons together.

I think, probably, you unloaded too much on her. People with depression can be pretty hard for others to support. It seems unfair to say that, but the supporters are humans too, with their own lives and issues. It can really drag you down shouldering someone else's burdens on top of your own.

You said she was a good, helpful friend. Can you think of many things that you helped her with?

I also think it's relevant that it was you who was calling every time, whatever she told you about appreciating it.

ArcaneWireless · 18/12/2022 15:19

An hour a week is still a lot to ask of someone when it is one sided and sad.

It is a good thing only when you share good times and it is a reciprocal friendship. Otherwise, sadly, it is a chore.

Ackity · 18/12/2022 15:17

Sage396 · 18/12/2022 11:59

That sounds quite intense for a friendship. I don't have any friends I regularly (or ever to be honest) have arguments with. I've stepped back from a friendship before when it became emotionally exhausting; maybe she's doing the same. I think it's time to back off and if the friendship doesn't recover then that's okay - that happens sometimes.

Same.

Remona · 18/12/2022 15:15

You still don't get it, do you?

I am sorry I posted this.
The only reason you're sorry is that you haven't had the answers you expected. You expected everyone to be on your side and agree that your friend was out of order and it hasn't panned out that way.

I didnt realize wanting to spend time with someone was a bad thing.
It's not. Nobody has said it is. But placing demands on someone and their time is. We all lead busy lives and a friendship is a two way street.

1 hour a week is what I wanted.
It may have been what YOU wanted, but it's clearly not what she wants. Again, friendship is a two way street. If anyone said to me that they expect a call every day and one hour a week, I'd tell them to fuck off. Life isn't like that. She can't provide the commitment you expect or think you deserve. Can you not simply appreciate the friendship for what it is? Honestly, you are really lucky to have someone to speak to every day. I don't have that. You run the risk of losing it if you don't back off.

LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 18/12/2022 15:12

Spending time together is good... if you both want it.

Not wanting to spend time with someone is allowed. Friends don't feel time together as an obligation.

Why do you think that she doesn't want 1 2 1 time with you?

diffandproud · 18/12/2022 15:11

I'm sorry but you sound very clingy and needy. Where is the fun stuff in this relationship?? Do all your conversations have the need to be doom and gloom and deep. People get drained from that

gothmothtime · 18/12/2022 15:10

She doesn't want to be friends anymore op.

You can't force someone to be your friend.

Beautiful3 · 18/12/2022 15:06

Please don't be upset when I say, this relationship sounds far too intense. You also sound like very hard work. I'd step back and be grateful for any further interaction.

Whattodo182 · 18/12/2022 15:04

Cassie077 · 18/12/2022 12:48

That she wasnt spending personal time with me. And was not allowing me to discuss why.

Me me meeeeeee

What do YOU bring to HER?

AnneLovesGilbert · 18/12/2022 15:04

Are you in love with her?