Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ditch these bits of Christmas

156 replies

PupInAPram · 18/12/2022 10:30

This year, with the agreement of my adult children whom I'll spend Christmas with, we are ditching: presents, tree, decorations, home cooked Christmas dinner (we have booked dinner out), Christmas cake.

We are keeping, special food treats, booze, board games and party games, many many fairy lights.

YABU Christmas should not be meddled with
YANBU Grown up households should pick the bits they like.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Avalavalanche · 24/12/2022 22:43

FourChimneys · 22/12/2022 23:13

babdoc What name would you approve of for atheists, humanists, people of non-Christian religions etc to use?

You seem keen to police our language so please let us know what we are allowed to say.

Don't mind babdoc, she had a neep hatred and bitterness towards atheists. It's quite sad.

OnceAgainWithFeeling · 23/12/2022 11:52

BellePeppa · 23/12/2022 08:15

I love food, I can’t relate at all to not wanting anything on Christmas Day. Even if I spent it alone I’d make myself a roast dinner of sorts.

That’s just conditioning though.

Fish pie Xmas was probably my favourite Xmas meal yet. Closely followed by the curry we had in Tenerife a few years back.

I didn’t eat a single mince pie last year. Nothing bad happened. 😂

BellePeppa · 23/12/2022 08:15

Wishawisha · 19/12/2022 08:55

Oh I’m not sure that’s fair .. I’m just not really a foodie and could take or leave most meals really.

I enjoy the whole thing of course - sitting down together with carols in the background, pulling crackers, lighting the Christmas pudding .. I just will politely decline all the meat, the Christmas pudding, mince pies, Christmas cake.. etc. My DC actually quite like a lot of it though. DH doesn’t expect me to eat it.

In my dream Christmas on my own in my twenties that I never got I don’t think I would have served myself a single “meal” all day.

And it’s not even just Christmas Day. I’m at home then with DH and that’s fine - he doesn’t force feed me Turkey and bread sauce.. It’s all the visiting. Often you’re served up with a mini Christmas dinner or if not it’s mulled wine with mince pies and panetonne ..

I love food, I can’t relate at all to not wanting anything on Christmas Day. Even if I spent it alone I’d make myself a roast dinner of sorts.

FourChimneys · 22/12/2022 23:13

babdoc What name would you approve of for atheists, humanists, people of non-Christian religions etc to use?

You seem keen to police our language so please let us know what we are allowed to say.

BellePeppa · 22/12/2022 20:38

Babdoc · 18/12/2022 18:37

A lot of PPs seem to have misunderstood my earlier comment, and also are trying to claim that they celebrate a “non Christian” Christmas.
Let me clarify.
If you are Christian, you celebrate Christmas - the commemoration of the birth of our saviour.
If you are pagan, you celebrate Yule. And yes, it does go further back historically.
If you are atheist, you celebrate a winter bank holiday.
For those of us actually celebrating Christmas- aka the mass of Christ, the feast of the Nativity- only the religious components are essential. All the commercial crap is optional, and you only do whichever bits you like, enjoy or can be bothered with.
For atheists, the commercial stuff is all they have, plus the chance to spend time off with families, but again, don’t do the bits that exhaust you or you don’t enjoy. But I don’t see how you can call it Christmas, when for you it has nothing to do with Christ - the whole reason for the festival in the first place!

I’m an athiest. I call it Christmas because I’d sound like a twat saying happy bank holiday. I hate the commercial side of it and keep it fairly minimal. I wasn’t going to deprive my children of having christmases because I don’t believe. All the family get together (we actually get on pretty well), we have a nice time and lots of food etc. I’m not going to sit in a joyless household on Christmas Day because I’m not religious.

whattodo1975 · 19/12/2022 09:21

Nobody under 70 ever wants christmas cake anyway.

ThreeblackCats · 19/12/2022 09:19

This year it’s just me and DH at home. We are going out on Christmas Eve for food, a really lovely gastro pub. We have our trees up inside and our outside decorations but not much else.
Christmas Day we will have a cold buffet and spend the day nibbling rather than cooking, cleaning and washing up.
So a very different kind of Christmas Day. The only difference is, we didn’t feel the need to ask social media if we as adults could do what suits us. You do you @PupInAPram you do not need anyone’s permission to do Christmas as you see fit. You want beans on toast then you do that. Have a great Christmas.

mateysmum · 19/12/2022 09:11

@upfucked
There is something ironic about someone making money by writing about their new non commercial lifestyle or maybe I mean hypocritically.

Bit like people leaving their royal lifestyles behind and then making money by non stop whining about it!🙄

upfucked · 19/12/2022 09:06

mateysmum · 19/12/2022 09:03

There's some woman who writes for the Telegraph who has moved to France and has proclaimed that "Christmas is better in France", moaning about how in London she was over busy and had too many traditions which she admitted to choosing and adding to herself. Then waxing lyrical about how much simpler and better French Christmas is. But she could have made exactly the same choices in London, nothing to do with it being in France.

YANBU Do what you want, ditch the things that give you stress. This commercial idea of the "perfect" Christmas is rubbish. Enjoy OP.

There is something ironic about someone making money by writing about their new non commercial lifestyle or maybe I mean hypocritically.

mateysmum · 19/12/2022 09:03

There's some woman who writes for the Telegraph who has moved to France and has proclaimed that "Christmas is better in France", moaning about how in London she was over busy and had too many traditions which she admitted to choosing and adding to herself. Then waxing lyrical about how much simpler and better French Christmas is. But she could have made exactly the same choices in London, nothing to do with it being in France.

YANBU Do what you want, ditch the things that give you stress. This commercial idea of the "perfect" Christmas is rubbish. Enjoy OP.

Wishawisha · 19/12/2022 08:55

Goodgrief82 · 19/12/2022 08:10

Does your dh know? How the heck can he enjoy Christmas lunch knowing that his wife absolutely “hates” what she’s eating? 😐

Oh I’m not sure that’s fair .. I’m just not really a foodie and could take or leave most meals really.

I enjoy the whole thing of course - sitting down together with carols in the background, pulling crackers, lighting the Christmas pudding .. I just will politely decline all the meat, the Christmas pudding, mince pies, Christmas cake.. etc. My DC actually quite like a lot of it though. DH doesn’t expect me to eat it.

In my dream Christmas on my own in my twenties that I never got I don’t think I would have served myself a single “meal” all day.

And it’s not even just Christmas Day. I’m at home then with DH and that’s fine - he doesn’t force feed me Turkey and bread sauce.. It’s all the visiting. Often you’re served up with a mini Christmas dinner or if not it’s mulled wine with mince pies and panetonne ..

drpet49 · 19/12/2022 08:12

No decorations or tree? Sounds shit to me

Goodgrief82 · 19/12/2022 08:11

Surely Christmas food is rather…. Varied?!

Goodgrief82 · 19/12/2022 08:10

Wishawisha · 19/12/2022 08:08

We have super traditional food at Christmas because my DH loves it and insists on it (and does 99% of the cooking). If it was just me I’d scrap most of the Christmas food.

I love the tree, but I’d get a small one.

I know this sounds very sad but I’ve always been disappointed that I never got a Christmas on my own to do it all my own (low key) way. Prior to DH and DC - who are young so obviously doing the whole Christmas thing feels quite important - I always went back to my parents for Christmas .. I was always hoping I’d have a legitimate reason to avoid it one year.

It’s not that I hate Christmas. I love the fairy lights and Christmas music and Christmas TV I just hate the Christmas food so much.

Does your dh know? How the heck can he enjoy Christmas lunch knowing that his wife absolutely “hates” what she’s eating? 😐

Wishawisha · 19/12/2022 08:08

We have super traditional food at Christmas because my DH loves it and insists on it (and does 99% of the cooking). If it was just me I’d scrap most of the Christmas food.

I love the tree, but I’d get a small one.

I know this sounds very sad but I’ve always been disappointed that I never got a Christmas on my own to do it all my own (low key) way. Prior to DH and DC - who are young so obviously doing the whole Christmas thing feels quite important - I always went back to my parents for Christmas .. I was always hoping I’d have a legitimate reason to avoid it one year.

It’s not that I hate Christmas. I love the fairy lights and Christmas music and Christmas TV I just hate the Christmas food so much.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 18/12/2022 21:34

Ha! Exactly why I will miss out that step!

Looking forward to trying that. Thanks!

BeyondMyWits · 18/12/2022 20:03

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 18/12/2022 18:33

Beyond** does that really work?!! Amazing if so.

Thanks 😊

> adds pud to tomorrow's Aldi list <

Oh yes... you can even do the whole flambé thing if you want... pour some warm brandy over and set it alight whilst still in the frying pan... though one memorable year I set fire to the net curtains and singed my hair - but we don't talk about that....😁

HappyOnions · 18/12/2022 19:16

@Allergictoironing Just reread my post and realised it sounded a lot ruder than I meant, apologies. Should have opened "That's sort of my point" rather than "You've missed my point" (my point being that early British Christians didn't appropriate Yule customs from the pagans, they were the same people, maintaining their own customs).

Always4Brenner · 18/12/2022 19:06

The Yule winter solstice celebrations predate Christian tradition and I’m Christian I love history and have gone back to Holly garlands berries pine cones for my decorations I do have a tiny tree lent to me for this year my base has gone so couldn’t put mine up. Will get new one next year.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 18/12/2022 19:06

It's just me and DD - no family to spend Christmas with. We've never done board games, Christmas Eve boxes, elf on the shelf or matching pyjamas. I do her a stocking. We usually have a tree but I haven't done one this year. DD has never helped to decorate it, so I thought sod it. It's too much ££ and another job I could do without!

We have Christmas dinner, never bothered with Christmas cake or Christmas pudding. We tend to just chill out with chocolate treats after dinner.

It's all very low key. I don't really like Christmas. I find it a very lonely and depressing time of year. Roll on January!

HootOwlStrikesAgain · 18/12/2022 18:57

Allergictoironing · 18/12/2022 18:47

the whole reason for the festival in the first place!

But Christ's birth ISN'T the whole reason for the festival in the first place. It may be for you and most other Christians, but for others it's the a festival for the other reasons you suggest. People tend to call it Christmas, because that's a name that we all recognise as meaning this year end festival. It's only in very recent years that referring to Yule or even Solstice didn't get me blank looks, so I would use a term that people knew.

ISTR there were screams when some cities decided the term "Christmas" wasn't inclusive for those of other religions and wanted to call the festival by a generic name e.g. Winterval.

Exactly!!

HootOwlStrikesAgain · 18/12/2022 18:56

*preceeded!

🤣

HootOwlStrikesAgain · 18/12/2022 18:54

Babdoc · 18/12/2022 18:37

A lot of PPs seem to have misunderstood my earlier comment, and also are trying to claim that they celebrate a “non Christian” Christmas.
Let me clarify.
If you are Christian, you celebrate Christmas - the commemoration of the birth of our saviour.
If you are pagan, you celebrate Yule. And yes, it does go further back historically.
If you are atheist, you celebrate a winter bank holiday.
For those of us actually celebrating Christmas- aka the mass of Christ, the feast of the Nativity- only the religious components are essential. All the commercial crap is optional, and you only do whichever bits you like, enjoy or can be bothered with.
For atheists, the commercial stuff is all they have, plus the chance to spend time off with families, but again, don’t do the bits that exhaust you or you don’t enjoy. But I don’t see how you can call it Christmas, when for you it has nothing to do with Christ - the whole reason for the festival in the first place!

This is all fixated on the fact that Christians renamed it. Most people don't care what it's called and it isn't connected to religion for them, it's just the midwinter festival that always existed, with lights and family and feasting etc. If you wish to attach a religious meaning to it then nobody cares, but don't complain that other people don't. History is very clear that it long proceeded Christianity and it will probably long outlive it as well.

CaptainMyCaptain · 18/12/2022 18:50

SingaporeSlinky · 18/12/2022 10:33

Of course you can do what you like. You have the agreement of your family, so why does it matter what anyone else thinks?

This. Do what you like. Don't do it at all if you don't want to.

Allergictoironing · 18/12/2022 18:47

the whole reason for the festival in the first place!

But Christ's birth ISN'T the whole reason for the festival in the first place. It may be for you and most other Christians, but for others it's the a festival for the other reasons you suggest. People tend to call it Christmas, because that's a name that we all recognise as meaning this year end festival. It's only in very recent years that referring to Yule or even Solstice didn't get me blank looks, so I would use a term that people knew.

ISTR there were screams when some cities decided the term "Christmas" wasn't inclusive for those of other religions and wanted to call the festival by a generic name e.g. Winterval.