Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you expect your family childcare to look after your sick child?

135 replies

Diploessence · 18/12/2022 10:22

If it’s something like covid/ Strep A/ Norovirus?

For general coughs and colds I don’t think it would matter, but for something a bit more nasty, would you expect and call upon your family childcare (e.g your mum) to look after your sick child? Would you be annoyed if they said no?

OP posts:
Diploessence · 18/12/2022 10:42

SnowStupid · 18/12/2022 10:37

I think you're taking unnecessarily harsh line with SIL, who you obviously don't like. If MIL is happy it's all good. Remember MIL is doing something selfless for her child. That's what comes naturally as a parent, it doesn't stop because children become adults.

DH is being thoroughly unpleasant about your parents too though, although is that because he feels his mum and sister are being attacked?

Taking a harsh line? Im not saying it to her am
I? There is lots of other stuff that I could post that illustrates her selfishness and entitled attitude but that’s not for this thread.

Yes it is between her and her mother, but the problem
is my husband sees that model as normal and now expects it of my mother and will most likely be po faced if she declines a bout of Covid/ Noro.

OP posts:
RunnerBum · 18/12/2022 10:40

DuplicateUserName · 18/12/2022 10:36

Oh it's a SIL bashing thread? You could've just said so in your OP 😁

This is strictly between you and your mum. If you baby is unwell you obviously tell her and leave the decision up to her.

Much like your SIL does with her mum I expect.

This. OP clearly just wanted to be nasty about SIL - it's tiresome and I can see why SIL doesn't like her.

OP, if you don't want to send your child to childcare when they're sick then don't - there's no question or dilemma here.

NimrodNimroy · 18/12/2022 10:40

My mum took DD1 when she had just recovered from COVID - she had just started brightening up when DH and I tested positive and started to feel dreadful.

She also took her for two full days (not overnight) when DD took Bronchiolitis but it was my first week back to work from maternity leave.

My DM insisted on taking her on both occasions, even though I had terrible mum guilt. All other instances of sickness DD has always stayed with me.

Remaker · 18/12/2022 10:40

Dear god your husband sounds so heartless. Your mum is presumably providing free childcare but she’s ‘no use’ if she doesn’t want to risk becoming sick? That’s a horrible attitude.

A mild cold/regular virus thing is fine (though I would give them the option to cancel) but I’ve seen my mum seriously ill for weeks after catching the flu from my niece and I would never intentionally expose her to that risk.

Ivyonafence · 18/12/2022 10:39

Absolutely not.

Incredibly selfish IMO.

Diploessence · 18/12/2022 10:39

DuplicateUserName · 18/12/2022 10:36

Oh it's a SIL bashing thread? You could've just said so in your OP 😁

This is strictly between you and your mum. If you baby is unwell you obviously tell her and leave the decision up to her.

Much like your SIL does with her mum I expect.

Well it’s a SIL and DH bashing thread really! Because I think they’re mentality is selfish and warped and was wondering whether I was actually the one BU.

OP posts:
MogTheForgetableCat · 18/12/2022 10:38

Wow, so providing free childcare for most of the time when they're healthy is no use to you?!

catandcoffee · 18/12/2022 10:38

He's in for a shock when your child starts nursery/ school.

Also when children are very ill they only want Mum or Dad.

susiesuelou · 18/12/2022 10:38

Shinyandnew1 · 18/12/2022 10:35

He said that looking after a sick child is part and parcel of providing childcare and she’s not much use to us if she won’t provide it when DC is ill.

WTF?!

Does he know how nurseries and childminders operate?!

Evidently he does not. 🤣

SnowStupid · 18/12/2022 10:37

Diploessence · 18/12/2022 10:33

SIL asks MIL (I’m fact I think expects!!) to look after DN’s if they’re ill. Doesn’t matter what with it seems and MIL has been ill from it before.

My DM will be providing childcare for us soon and I said to DH that I wouldn’t feel right asking her to look after DC if they were ill, unless it was something minor like a temperature/ snuggle/ cough etc.

He said that looking after a sick child is part and parcel of providing childcare and she’s not much use to us if she won’t provide it when DC is ill.

I said that’s the wrong attitude and thah asking people to look after your sick child and put their own health at risk is selfish and entitled, but then that just sums SIL up to be honest.

He seems to think all grandmothers should be martyrs like MIL and be prepared to be sick if they’re going to provide childcare.

DF is vulnerable though and so even on just that note I would feel guilty asking.

Trying to see if his view is warped or mine is.

I think you're taking unnecessarily harsh line with SIL, who you obviously don't like. If MIL is happy it's all good. Remember MIL is doing something selfless for her child. That's what comes naturally as a parent, it doesn't stop because children become adults.

DH is being thoroughly unpleasant about your parents too though, although is that because he feels his mum and sister are being attacked?

susiesuelou · 18/12/2022 10:37

He said that looking after a sick child is part and parcel of providing childcare and she’s not much use to us if she won’t provide it when DC is ill. ...being a parent and we all have to take time off work to do it.

Fixed that for your DH. 👍🏻

Kevinnn · 18/12/2022 10:36

Only at the point that they weren't contagious, it's not fair to pass the bugs on to other people. Bad enough it spreads through the household.

GrazingSheep · 18/12/2022 10:36

He said that looking after a sick child is part and parcel of providing childcare and she’s not much use to us if she won’t provide it when DC is ill.

What did you say when he said this about your mother??

DuplicateUserName · 18/12/2022 10:36

Diploessence · 18/12/2022 10:33

SIL asks MIL (I’m fact I think expects!!) to look after DN’s if they’re ill. Doesn’t matter what with it seems and MIL has been ill from it before.

My DM will be providing childcare for us soon and I said to DH that I wouldn’t feel right asking her to look after DC if they were ill, unless it was something minor like a temperature/ snuggle/ cough etc.

He said that looking after a sick child is part and parcel of providing childcare and she’s not much use to us if she won’t provide it when DC is ill.

I said that’s the wrong attitude and thah asking people to look after your sick child and put their own health at risk is selfish and entitled, but then that just sums SIL up to be honest.

He seems to think all grandmothers should be martyrs like MIL and be prepared to be sick if they’re going to provide childcare.

DF is vulnerable though and so even on just that note I would feel guilty asking.

Trying to see if his view is warped or mine is.

Oh it's a SIL bashing thread? You could've just said so in your OP 😁

This is strictly between you and your mum. If you baby is unwell you obviously tell her and leave the decision up to her.

Much like your SIL does with her mum I expect.

Shinyandnew1 · 18/12/2022 10:35

He said that looking after a sick child is part and parcel of providing childcare and she’s not much use to us if she won’t provide it when DC is ill.

WTF?!

Does he know how nurseries and childminders operate?!

susiesuelou · 18/12/2022 10:35

He said that looking after a sick child is part and parcel of providing childcare and she’s not much use to us if she won’t provide it when DC is ill.

He seems to think all grandmothers should be martyrs like MIL and be prepared to be sick if they’re going to provide childcare.

Wow.

Diploessence · 18/12/2022 10:35

Sorry for all the typos!

OP posts:
TheLittlestLightOnTheXmasTree · 18/12/2022 10:35

Jesus! He sounds vile

Diploessence · 18/12/2022 10:33

SIL asks MIL (I’m fact I think expects!!) to look after DN’s if they’re ill. Doesn’t matter what with it seems and MIL has been ill from it before.

My DM will be providing childcare for us soon and I said to DH that I wouldn’t feel right asking her to look after DC if they were ill, unless it was something minor like a temperature/ snuggle/ cough etc.

He said that looking after a sick child is part and parcel of providing childcare and she’s not much use to us if she won’t provide it when DC is ill.

I said that’s the wrong attitude and thah asking people to look after your sick child and put their own health at risk is selfish and entitled, but then that just sums SIL up to be honest.

He seems to think all grandmothers should be martyrs like MIL and be prepared to be sick if they’re going to provide childcare.

DF is vulnerable though and so even on just that note I would feel guilty asking.

Trying to see if his view is warped or mine is.

OP posts:
Goatsanddogs · 18/12/2022 10:32

I am a grandparent and have my GD 4 days a week. I would want to have her if she were ill if it lessened the stress on my daughter. I am
hopefully healthy and at 57 young enough to recover from anything I might catch. My priority is my daughter and granddaughters health.

susiesuelou · 18/12/2022 10:32

No because we have no local family support so don't have that option. If our dc are sick it's on DP or I to be off work, just the way it is. And tbh I wouldn't expect a family member to take my infectious vomiting child anyway, even if they did live closer, for 2 main reasons: 1) I wouldn't want to infect their entire household as that's selfish, and 2) I know my DD would only want her mum or dad if she felt that bad so the guilt would crush me.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 18/12/2022 10:30

I've asked my mum before when my baby has had fevers that lasted fow a few days, the doctor had said it was viral and none of us caught it, as they didnt seem that ill and it was a lot of time off work

I would never ask for a sickness or diarrhoea bug, as I think it's a horrible thing to inflict on someone else. And I know my parents feel the same way

Recently my child had likely strep and was on the first day of antibiotics and my parents offered to help and I said no as it seems quite contagious

SnowStupid · 18/12/2022 10:28

My parents always insisted they should have them rather than DH or I miss work. Obviously I could have said no, but they were very insistent. They were young and fit when DC were small though. I would put my foot down now.

WombatStewForTea · 18/12/2022 10:28

My DD accidentally gave my mil COVID. We had tested her and she was negative in our defense. Both parents have offered to have her with a normal stomach bug but actual noro I wouldn't risk it.
Strep A is fairly common and being made to be a bigger thing than it actually is

RunnerBum · 18/12/2022 10:27

It obviously depends - I can't stand when people create threads without giving any information on the scenario at hand and so can't actually get any real answer from anyone.

  • Is the childcare so you can work or go on the lash?
  • Is the relative vulnerable in any way?
  • Is it regular childcare or a one-off?
  • Is the relative doing you a favour or do they want to spend time with the child?
  • Does the child feel well in themselves?
  • Does the child feel better elsewhere or when at home?
  • Does the illness disrupt how the childcare usually takes place (i.e. if the relative would usually take them to swimming club but now can't)?
  • Do they need to administer medications or seek medical care?
  • Are they set up to do so, can they drive etc?
  • Is the child contagious? Are other children there (i.e. cousins) who might get ill?

Everyone will attempt to answer but without this information, it's just a shot in the dark.