Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you expect your family childcare to look after your sick child?

135 replies

Diploessence · 18/12/2022 10:22

If it’s something like covid/ Strep A/ Norovirus?

For general coughs and colds I don’t think it would matter, but for something a bit more nasty, would you expect and call upon your family childcare (e.g your mum) to look after your sick child? Would you be annoyed if they said no?

OP posts:
Barney60 · 18/12/2022 11:35

Your husband sounds charming!
I look after my grandchild , i would NOT go even if i was expected (which they wouldn't) for anything more than a cold or flu, a child needs his mum or dad under those circumstances.
But from the other side my daughter would not leave her child if very poorly with anyone else bar her husband, she would not be able to concentrate on her job properly. I realise some employers are more understanding than others, but employees surely expect a small amount of absentees from staff having sick children.

Mariposista · 18/12/2022 11:32

My gran looked after me every time I was ill as a child (not that often). I never killed her with any of my childhood bugs! Mum was a single parent and had to work, and this was the day before adults got all precious about getting ill. (Never remember my gran ill bar the odd cold)

hellycat · 18/12/2022 11:26

No, why would you want anyone to catch Covid or Noro?! They can be horrendous conditions in the elderly. They can actually result in more pressure on hospitals if they are really severe. I do know that it is bloody awful to have to look after sick children when you are sick yourself -it is the absolute pits tbh - but infectious bugs have to be contained within the home.

amonsteronthehill · 18/12/2022 11:25

Riskofbeingsued · 18/12/2022 11:06

Interesting to read the responses.
I work at a GP surgery and the amount of vitriol we receive if any of our doctors/nurses are off to look after their sick children and appointments need to be cancelled or we have fewer appointments to offer is very unpleasant.
I suspect there's some cognitive dissonance here and people would also be annoyed if their children's teachers were off for a week to look after their child.

You're absolutely right.

I've been cancelled on by my GP/Dentist these past two years for flu, covid, sick children, and fellow teaching staff is constantly struggling to care for their own ill children. The bugs are constant right now. And wow do parents complain.

I'm probably more sympathetic because of my position ... they're parents, too. And teachers/support staff parents are frequently the 'lower paid' professional in their households (in my circle), so they are the ones who most likely need to take the time off to look after their ill children.

the real problem is there is no supply/agency cover for GPs, dentists, teachers, etc ... when they can't come in, everything gets cancelled. Because the budgets don't allow for cover AND/OR there's no one available anyway.

TurquoiseBeach · 18/12/2022 11:25

I wouldn't feel comfortable doing that.

NiceParkingSpotRitaThanksJanet · 18/12/2022 11:24

I voted YANBU but I'm not actually sure which way the voting was supposed to be as it looks like I'm in the minority with the vote but not the comments!

I would definitely not expect my mum to look after my sick child. Having said that, she does look after my one year old a couple of day a week and he has had one thing after another recently! She's had him if he's just been getting over something or it's been a runny nose, bit of a cough etc but anything more than that and my partner or I would be staying off work. Aside from anything else, poorly children (especially little ones) want their primary caregiver when they're poorly. I also wouldn't want to risk my mum catching anything. I realise however I m lucky as my employer does recognise paid carers leave. I know some don't.

Your husband sounds quite unpleasant in his way of talking about his mother who will be providing free childcare!

VioletLemon · 18/12/2022 11:24

Oh no, he's wrong. Looking after the unwell, I'll child is the job of the parents.

If you're lucky enough to have someone in the family to offer to help with childcare it's important to respect them and appreciate it. Also be mindful of their health, how unfair and selfish.

I hear quite a few people speaking in a rather ungrateful way when DM/DPIL can't do extra childcare, on top of looking after 5 young children they can't have overnights........ Hmmm mm.

DomPom47 · 18/12/2022 11:22

I would ask my mum. She doesn’t have any underlying health conditions and to be perfectly frank she would be offended if I didn’t call on her for help if I needed it. I am very lucky in that my mum and dad for that matter, will do their best to help out where they can. Chicken pox a few years back was one example. I couldn’t get time off work for 5 days, my mum came during the day and looked after my daughter until there was scabs and it was no longer infectious and could go back to school.

amonsteronthehill · 18/12/2022 11:21

*y DM will be providing childcare for us soon and I said to DH that I wouldn’t feel right asking her to look after DC if they were ill, unless it was something minor like a temperature/ snuggle/ cough etc.

He said that looking after a sick child is part and parcel of providing childcare and she’s not much use to us if she won’t provide it when DC is ill.

Your DH is seriously deluded; it is most definitely NOT part and parcel of providing childcare. Every childcare, nursery, preschool, school setting I know will send that child right home. Where they belong. So they don't infect the other children in care, nursery, school, etc.

LindaEllen · 18/12/2022 11:17

WombatStewForTea · 18/12/2022 10:28

My DD accidentally gave my mil COVID. We had tested her and she was negative in our defense. Both parents have offered to have her with a normal stomach bug but actual noro I wouldn't risk it.
Strep A is fairly common and being made to be a bigger thing than it actually is

How on earth would you know the difference between bugs? How come so many people think they're virologists these days?

gogohmm · 18/12/2022 11:15

Depends on them, my mum would have when mine were small but she was a young grandmother

GrazingSheep · 18/12/2022 11:15

About - not avoid.

OhChristmasTreeOhChristmasTreeFaLaLa · 18/12/2022 11:15

My parents do childcare for us, covid, d+v anything very contagious that makes you very unwell they absolutely don't look after them. There's no point anyway as they'd not be able to look after them when they get it anyway, so it's far better for them to stay away and avoid getting it in the first place. This is a mutual agreement, I'd never ask and they'd refuse anyway.

GrazingSheep · 18/12/2022 11:15

I feel sympathy for your mother and your mother in law. Talk avoid being used.

susiesuelou · 18/12/2022 11:13

Riskofbeingsued · 18/12/2022 11:06

Interesting to read the responses.
I work at a GP surgery and the amount of vitriol we receive if any of our doctors/nurses are off to look after their sick children and appointments need to be cancelled or we have fewer appointments to offer is very unpleasant.
I suspect there's some cognitive dissonance here and people would also be annoyed if their children's teachers were off for a week to look after their child.

No cognitive dissonance here. If people need to be off with sick children then they need to be off! It's life as a parent. After taking a total of the equivalent of around 2 weeks off work this year between DP and I with our sick toddler who's managed to pick up every single bug going since starting at nursery, I understand this only too well! I've had eyes rolled at me at work by colleagues for rushing out yet again to collect her, partner has had comments made etc..... tough. It's life as a parent.

My perspective is likely different because we have literally no family to rely on, not one person. Those who do don't realise how lucky they are. But even if I did, there's no chance I'd leave my sick child to someone else. It's not fair.

containsnuts · 18/12/2022 11:11

Not unless it was a genuine emergency.
I worry that on the off chance the 'cold' goes on to cause DM a chest infection/pneumonia for example, then I'm down a baby sitter a lot longer than just that day.

PingPongMerrilyWithPie · 18/12/2022 11:10

I think be careful of judging before you have tried it. At face value, no of course you can't expect. But when you have had a child catch illness after illness, you're running on empty with zero A/L left, you have a big work deadline and are desperate to win a bid to keep 12 of your team employed next year... in real life if you're conscientious, or under pressure at work, as most of us are, then sometimes it doesn't feel like much of a choice and it's proportionate to ask. I know my mum has had my sick child once or twice and it had been a huge help.

Of course people can also be entitled CFs. But judging someone else before you've been in the situation yourself is a bit like judging your friends for letting their toddler watch TV, before yours is even born.

RewildingAmbridge · 18/12/2022 11:08

I think it depends, I would never expect and let DM/MIL know when DS is unwell as they both provide regular childcare, DM still works so I'd be worried about her then begging time off work, however she worked in childcare and ran a nursery for 25 years so get immune system is very hardy! She's also quite dismissive and says oh don't be silly I'll be fine if course I'll have him. She even offered when he had COVID but I said no. My mum is early sixties, fit and active.
MIL I would with normal illness, but she's not great in an emergency and can be a bit irregular with giving medication etc (in the past when he's had anti biotics) so if DS was very ill one of us would have him. He has gone there this weekend with a cold and a slight temperature we told get in advance and were more than happy to keep him home. FIL has sent us pictures including a couple of thermometer ones and he's actually much better and they've had a nice weekend. She's also only sixty very fit, active, horsey, gym goer and is retired.
If we had older grandparents who weren't as robust I'd feel differently.

HerMajestysRoyalCoven · 18/12/2022 11:08

YANBU but way more people think like your DH than are posting here. I’ve a friend who works in a nursery and she has a daily nightmare with parents dosing kids up on calpol, sending them in absolutely chocka with infection, and then refusing to come and collect because they need to work and they’re sure if more calpol is given…….

A lot of people are really selfish these days.

Shinyandnew1 · 18/12/2022 11:07

It sounds like you’ll have a situation where you have a sick child, you don’t want to send them to your mum but he does and so it will ALWAYS be you that has to take time off work. Some children are ill a lot…

Riskofbeingsued · 18/12/2022 11:06

Interesting to read the responses.
I work at a GP surgery and the amount of vitriol we receive if any of our doctors/nurses are off to look after their sick children and appointments need to be cancelled or we have fewer appointments to offer is very unpleasant.
I suspect there's some cognitive dissonance here and people would also be annoyed if their children's teachers were off for a week to look after their child.

TumbleFryer · 18/12/2022 11:05

You keep your child at home if they are contagious, regardless of the type of childcare you are using. If you were using a nursery and you sent a sick child in they would call you to come and collect them. It’s not fair on the staff or the other children.

Floralnomad · 18/12/2022 11:05

The point in your case @Diploessence , is that your husband needs to understand that your mum will be acting like a child minder would - you wouldn’t send a sick child to a child minder so you don’t send it to your mum . If his mum is happy to look after sick kids that is her business .

Q2C4 · 18/12/2022 11:05

No I wouldn't but my mother will happily look after my nephew when he's ill (even if that means my kids can't go to hers on the same day). Drives me insane.

kimchifix · 18/12/2022 11:04

Looking after sick kids is not part of childcare. No Nanny I've ever had has worked if the children are sick - mainly because they also look after other children, but this is usually something worked out in a contract. Are you going to be paying your DM for this service? Unless your mother lives in the same household and will be exposed to the family bugs anyway I think it's an unreasonable expectation and unfair on everyone. Your DH sounds rather entitled to your mother's time and like he couldn't care less about her health. I hope she's got her head screwed on and lays down some ground rules about what she will and will not do & that you both respect that.