Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you expect your family childcare to look after your sick child?

135 replies

Diploessence · 18/12/2022 10:22

If it’s something like covid/ Strep A/ Norovirus?

For general coughs and colds I don’t think it would matter, but for something a bit more nasty, would you expect and call upon your family childcare (e.g your mum) to look after your sick child? Would you be annoyed if they said no?

OP posts:
Fundays12 · 18/12/2022 12:50

Nope I think it’s quit selfish. If someone is working I can understand if it’s something like chicken pox which the family member has had already and the child is generally well it might be okay if the childcare provider was ok with it. If it’s just so the parent can go out and get drunk it’s downright selfish to both the family member and child. I know someone that does it frequently to an elderly relative who has serious underlying medical conditions. It’s often so they can go party and even when the child is not well enough to be anywhere but in there own bed it still happens. The elderly relative ends up sick generally after it.

Nocutenamesleft · 18/12/2022 12:37

I don’t have childcare from parents. But no. I wouldn’t send my child knowingly sick. Especially with fevers etc. in fact my mum has asked me to not take my children round if any of us are feeling hnwell

however I also have a really rare disease. Sickness bugs kill 84% of us. So I can’t be around my children when they start throwing up and if my husband is away my mum comes round. Because it’s better if she catches it than me.

life can be proper shit sometimes.

User359472111111 · 18/12/2022 12:35

It would depend:

Covid - no way
Noro - not a chance
Diagnosed contagious disease - probably but only after the infectious period had passed
Other illnesses - eg post vaccination or a bad tooth or general “poorlyness” for a baby - probably yes

And the circumstances would change my answer:
Regular childcare slot - more likely, especially if they were already there when the child showed signs of illness (probably caught it already etc)
Specially coming to help - less likely
Help in hospital (eg back up for a few hours to keep sanity allow a shower) - once child is starting to recover

SnowStupid · 18/12/2022 12:29

My DC went to my Dad 2 days pw when they were small. The care was sometimes unconventional but they were safe and loved and happy. They were fine with Grandad when ill. They considered GPs and parents interchangeable at that age, frankly. And my dad would have been offended if we thought he shouldn't have them when they were ill.

Simonjt · 18/12/2022 12:28

So you’re already using your mum for free childcare which is entitled enough, but he also wants her to look after your child when they’re ill.

Why doesn’t he want to look after his own child when they’re ill? Grandparents are great, but most children want their parents when they’re ill, not granny or grandad.

SnowStupid · 18/12/2022 12:27

Just wondering, but has there been a discussion about which GP should have your DC? It's just that if his mother has offered, but you prefer to use yours the "not much use" comment gains some context.

BeanieTeen · 18/12/2022 12:25

It’s not just about it being part and parcel of being a parent - it’s about the children themselves and what they need. Depending on your family set up of course, when they are feeling poorly surely most want mum or dad - or primary carers - looking after them, that gives them the best comfort.

susiesuelou · 18/12/2022 12:25

I refuse to feel guilt for leaving my dc safe and happy with people who love them and I know will look after them well.

Equally, I refuse to apologise for feeling that guilt 🤷‍♀️

We are all different, after all. Neither is the "right" way and no one has suggested it is. Just different yet equally valid ways of parenting.

susiesuelou · 18/12/2022 12:23

LucyWhipple · 18/12/2022 12:18

And all the ‘oh I couldn’t possibly leave my child with anyone else, they just need mummy, I couldn’t possibly concentrate on work’ etc etc really wind me up with the implication that someone who does leave their dc are less of a parent. Loads of people rely on dh & me turning up to work each day; there are direct impacts of us not being there. I refuse to feel guilt for leaving my dc safe and happy with people who love them and I know will look after them well.

I said I would feel guilty leaving her with anyone when she's sick. I'm at a loss as to how you have managed to take personal offence from that.

It's great if you don't feel that guilt! I wish I didn't trust me, would make my life so much easier! But the fact I do feel that, doesn't make me any less or any more of a parent than someone who doesn't. And I never implied it did. 🤷‍♀️

We are all different and my feeling is as valid as yours. No need for the level of defensiveness.

Survey99 · 18/12/2022 12:19

He said that looking after a sick child is part and parcel of providing childcare and she’s not much use to us if she won’t provide it when DC is ill.
**
I said that’s the wrong attitude and thah asking people to look after your sick child and put their own health at risk is selfish and entitled, but then that just sums SIL up to be honest.

So he is slating your family who have kindly offered to provide childcare and in return you are slating his who have a family childcare arrangement that works for them. You both sound lovely, is this how you always deal with your own differences of opinion, by running down others?

LucyWhipple · 18/12/2022 12:18

And all the ‘oh I couldn’t possibly leave my child with anyone else, they just need mummy, I couldn’t possibly concentrate on work’ etc etc really wind me up with the implication that someone who does leave their dc are less of a parent. Loads of people rely on dh & me turning up to work each day; there are direct impacts of us not being there. I refuse to feel guilt for leaving my dc safe and happy with people who love them and I know will look after them well.

LucyWhipple · 18/12/2022 12:16

My DP didn’t do regular childcare for us but instead offered to be our emergency care. They got it because they both worked when we were small, so they know how important that back up is to working parents. This was pre-covid but they always had the DC for any kind of illness (& usually managed not to catch it themselves).

Since covid they’ve been a bit more reluctant but now they’ve had covid themselves & were ok have said they are happy to have them again if needed (but our dc are older now so it’s less needed anyway).

PIL have also had dc when ill - the only thing they won’t do is sickness bugs & that’s fair enough.

We’re very lucky to have that support but would never expect it, and are always grateful for it. All DP are under 70, fit & well & retired so that has all contributed to them being able to help us.

amonsteronthehill · 18/12/2022 12:06

Imagine OP's husband also expects the childcare to be 'free'.

Twat.

skyeisthelimit · 18/12/2022 12:02

My mum only looked after DD once a fortnight, but if DD was ill I stayed home with her. I would never want her to pass anything on to my parents. Why would you spread a stomach bug around more people?

or if they have a high temperature and are really unwell, they just want their mum/dad, why would you dump them on grandparents when they need their own bed and home.

SIL is very selfish and your DH doesn't sound much better.

susiesuelou · 18/12/2022 12:01

NeedAHoliday2021 · 18/12/2022 11:49

I always find it weird that many contracts say time off for sick dc - until you can arrange alternative childcare… who is this magical childcare? (Apart from op’s mum).

Yep! I always think the same!

"Time off for dependents in an emergency until an alternative can be arranged" or similar. Yeah, hang on... let me just get my completely fictional non-existent emergency back up childcare on speed dial right away. 🙄

Fucks sake. 😂

whynotwhatknot · 18/12/2022 12:00

no its not part and parcel of childcare yu cant send them to school with a virus so why should you send them to a relative

his whole family have no sense-whats the point of them"" oh i dont know theyre only your parents

oakleaffy · 18/12/2022 11:49

Mariposista · 18/12/2022 11:32

My gran looked after me every time I was ill as a child (not that often). I never killed her with any of my childhood bugs! Mum was a single parent and had to work, and this was the day before adults got all precious about getting ill. (Never remember my gran ill bar the odd cold)

Probably your grandmother had had all the infections you had as a child.

Adults can become very ill with chicken pox if they didn’t catch it as a child.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 18/12/2022 11:49

I always find it weird that many contracts say time off for sick dc - until you can arrange alternative childcare… who is this magical childcare? (Apart from op’s mum).

PrimarilyParented · 18/12/2022 11:48

My mom offers and does have my DS, but I’m a lone parent and a teacher so if I don’t show up to work then lots of other kids get let down too. Also I have limited sick pay and as the only earner in the house not getting paid could leave us in dire straits. It’s a sh**, lose-lose situation but my mom offers and means it so yes when my DS is sick she does have him. He adores her and it’s the next best thing to it being me looking after him.

Brefugee · 18/12/2022 11:45

He said that looking after a sick child is part and parcel of providing childcare and she’s not much use to us if she won’t provide it when DC is ill.

your DH is a knob. It isn't your mother's job to look after your child full stop so it's kind of her to offer.
when your child is sick, it's on you and DH, and you need to make sure that he steps up as much as you will be expected to.

oakleaffy · 18/12/2022 11:44

If something that could infect others, Strep A or Norovirus- Definitely NOT.
That is down to the parent/s to do.

Dello · 18/12/2022 11:41

No I really wouldn’t want them to be ill but it really depends on

  • if it’s something that typically affects adults mildly or severely
  • how they are
  • how contagious child is
  • how sick child is
  • what other options I have
Burgoo · 18/12/2022 11:40

My mother-in-law looks after our little one even when she (the baby) is ill. If it were something infectious then of course not, though colds and the like aren't so much of a problem.

She is in a vulnerable position (had a stroke) but still wants to see her grandchild and frankly the quicker we can shuffle her off the better! yes I am kidding, she is an absolute life-saver and a wonderful grandmother. She even (with half sight) walked in the snow to the play group recently with my baby because she didn't want my baby to miss out!

Mycatsgoldtooth · 18/12/2022 11:39

No

susiesuelou · 18/12/2022 11:37

But from the other side my daughter would not leave her child if very poorly with anyone else bar her husband, she would not be able to concentrate on her job properly.

I'm the exact same. If she's sick and she's not with either me or her dad I feel anxious and panicky.