Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

holidays with DC without the other parent

67 replies

mantlepiece23 · 18/12/2022 10:05

COL and all that, been looking at holidays for next year. Havent booked anything yet but really need to. Am considering that from now on we try and take the kids away on our own without the other parent to cut costs. DH thinks it would be ridiculous but I dont see why. The kids will still get to go away and they are at an age when it's not so hard taking care of them on our own. Do other families go away without both parents to cut costs?

OP posts:
thelobsterquadrille · 18/12/2022 12:40

mantlepiece23 · 18/12/2022 12:36

@thelobsterquadrille so I would be happy to go to a premier inn but DH thinks that if we go as a four we basically need an apartment which is expensive. So yes, I could take them away for a night or two as could DH on his own. But as a family DH expects an airbnb or an apartment.

As is always the case on these threads, it sounds like you have a DH problem.

You say he's not really bothered about these things but when he does decide to come, he wants you to spend a fortune.

He's a parent of two. He needs to buck his ideas up IMO. You don't get to opt out of the zoo or family trips on the basis that you "can't be bothered".

mantlepiece23 · 18/12/2022 12:36

@thelobsterquadrille so I would be happy to go to a premier inn but DH thinks that if we go as a four we basically need an apartment which is expensive. So yes, I could take them away for a night or two as could DH on his own. But as a family DH expects an airbnb or an apartment.

OP posts:
thelobsterquadrille · 18/12/2022 12:31

mantlepiece23 · 18/12/2022 12:08

@FictionalCharacter saving money would enable us to have another holiday. Is it that weird? At the moment, no we wouldnt have three holidays a year

But if you were really looking to save costs, you'd cut out holidays altogether, surely, and just do day trips or maybe night away somewhere in a Premier Inn?

There's nothing remotely wrong with going out with just one parent - I did it all the time growing up and have some fab memories with just my mum (or just my dad) but presenting it as a cost cutting exercise when it means your kids will end up with three holidays a year is maybe coming across as a bit tone-deaf to some.

gliiterryballs · 18/12/2022 12:16

mantlepiece23 · 18/12/2022 12:08

@FictionalCharacter saving money would enable us to have another holiday. Is it that weird? At the moment, no we wouldnt have three holidays a year

Bless your wee heart OP.

How about one family holiday and both parents go on day trips with your twins?

It seems such a strange idea to take such huge money saving steps to give your children 2 extra holidays a year.

And yes we have done things without both parents, but not to cut costs, just be due of our family circumstances.

alanabennett · 18/12/2022 12:12

I have taken my three kids on holiday alone and had a blast! They are 14, 11 and 8 and just this summer we flew to NYC for a long weekend. It wasn't a cost-cutting measure, just that I had some time off to use before my company's year end, and my husband was busy at work. I've done similar trips before when they were younger. My only reservation would be a swimming-heavy holiday, I would not take three kids swimming alone.

mantlepiece23 · 18/12/2022 12:08

@FictionalCharacter saving money would enable us to have another holiday. Is it that weird? At the moment, no we wouldnt have three holidays a year

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 18/12/2022 12:07

mantlepiece23 · 18/12/2022 10:37

Ok, so to answer a few questions. In terms of cutting costs - we would save about 600 quid min per flight plus if DH comes then we need to get a two bed apartment somewhere whereas me and the boys could just get a studio. or even one room which halves the costs. So effectively we could save over 1-1.5k if only one of us goes with the kids and maybe have two holidays instead of one. So the adults would get the same amount of holidays away and kids get double.

We are also not talking about one holiday a year but three i.e. one with each of the parent and one with all of us for a week in the summer.

@thelobsterquadrille I am an only child and my parents both worked so I would mostly also only go holidays with one of them. So that's how I grew up and loved it.

Well that's a heck of a drop feed. You're having three holidays in a year?! Wow.

mantlepiece23 · 18/12/2022 12:02

@Wakk honestly in our case this started because DH isnt that bothered plus one of the parents gets to catch up with work or chores. We dont have any support with the kids so thats how we've always done it, basically alternated looking after the kids. So yesterday, I took them to the theatre on my own with a friend of theirs, today DH is taking them to see grandparents. Not sure DCs feel like they are missing out.

OP posts:
Wakk · 18/12/2022 11:58

mantlepiece23 · 18/12/2022 11:43

Do people really not do stuff without the other parent? To be honest we already do most leisure stuff that costs e.g. zoos, theatres, pantomimes, ice skating with just one parent and thats fine. It seems silly paying an extra 50 quid for theatre when DH isnt bothered. I think thats the reality - he isnt all that bothered about doing activities with the kids beside taking them to grandparents, local walks and free stuff.

I think that's really sad. My DCs enjoyed us both being there at the zoo etc.

user1471554720 · 18/12/2022 11:55

What if the other parent just doesn't want to go on a family holiday? Do we all just stay at home for years on end????

My dh does not like staying overnight away from home. Sometimes we go somewhere within 80km for 2 nights in the summer with dc.

We have only had 2 holidays abroad and dc are 11 and 13. It is a fight to get dh to go, I wind up paying for all myself. I resent paying an extra 1200 for an adult who doesn't really want to go.

I have always worked fulltime, I am surrounded by colleagues who DO go abroad annually and I felt so depressed when dcs were small and we went years without a holiday. I am 50 years of age, life is going by. If dcs were a bit older I would take them without dh, not to listen to the moaning about going etc. For now I can't leave him out as it looks like an insult. I pay for resort hols in Spain with half board, I research daytrips etc and dh still finds something to moan about

mantlepiece23 · 18/12/2022 11:54

Personally the prospect of a week just focusing on my work with DH and the twins sounds lovely. I work in a career where you can always do more and honestly the thought of just being able get some work done and maybe go out in the evening to see friends would be amazing.

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 18/12/2022 11:46

In your situation seems reasonable, also if you were going to visit relatives or people who are really only your friends.

YellowTreeHouse · 18/12/2022 11:45

mantlepiece23 · 18/12/2022 11:43

Do people really not do stuff without the other parent? To be honest we already do most leisure stuff that costs e.g. zoos, theatres, pantomimes, ice skating with just one parent and thats fine. It seems silly paying an extra 50 quid for theatre when DH isnt bothered. I think thats the reality - he isnt all that bothered about doing activities with the kids beside taking them to grandparents, local walks and free stuff.

There’s a difference between doing solo activities without the other parent, either because they’re working or just don’t fancy it, and going on an entirely separate holiday without them.

That is odd and I think it shows something lacking in your family.

mantlepiece23 · 18/12/2022 11:43

Do people really not do stuff without the other parent? To be honest we already do most leisure stuff that costs e.g. zoos, theatres, pantomimes, ice skating with just one parent and thats fine. It seems silly paying an extra 50 quid for theatre when DH isnt bothered. I think thats the reality - he isnt all that bothered about doing activities with the kids beside taking them to grandparents, local walks and free stuff.

OP posts:
YellowTreeHouse · 18/12/2022 11:38

YABU. You’re a family, not single parents. You go away as a family or not at all.

Or you do multiple cheaper holidays but as a family.

HairyToity · 18/12/2022 11:38

Never out of choice. Just get a static by the coast, and all of you go.

mantlepiece23 · 18/12/2022 11:36

So the actual convo was started by me suggesting that he takes DC away at Easter by himself. I would love a week at home without DH or DTs around. So it really isnt about me wanting to horde all the holidays.

Basically this is the first year that we have to go in the holidays, DH hasnt engaged in the costs of travelling during school holidays - was horrified at how much it cost but was equally horrified with the prospect of DTs having to go in clubs and paying for that. Hence my suggestion that he takes them away at Easter, the kids can go away for three weeks in the summer (with DH and I having an overlapping week) and me taking them away another time.

If we dont go away - the kids never leave our area. We live locally to both sets of grandparents, no relatives anywhere else in the UK. Both DH and I thought it would do kids some good to go somewhere else

OP posts:
RunLolaRun102 · 18/12/2022 11:23

As he has limited time with the kids on holidays - he should be the one to go on holiday with them to build memories. You could then do local stuff.

Burgoo · 18/12/2022 11:17

@mantlepiece23 Also why don't you stay at home and he go with the child(ren)? It's your idea after all. I am sure, based on your lack of concern, you wouldn't mind if the kids don't remember good holidays without you. After all, they still get to go away right?

Burgoo · 18/12/2022 11:16

If your husband can't get time off work and/or doesn't mind then fine. Though personally I see holidays as family time, where we get to actually be together outside of the monotonous misery that is everyday life. As others have said, it is about memories and building up that bank of nostalgia that we all need. Nothing beats going back to a childhood holiday location, and it wouldn't feel right if people were missing from my memories.

If you can't afford it, cut a holiday.

Appleblum · 18/12/2022 11:13

Eh? Surely the point of a family holiday is for the whole family to spend time together?

I'd look for a cheaper destination if you can't afford it.

zingally · 18/12/2022 11:08

A "family holiday" without the whole family seems very weird to me! The whole idea of a family holiday is to share those memories together.

I remember one UK holiday we went on, when I was maybe 9 or 10, where we had to leave my dad behind at the last minute because he'd hurt his back, and just couldn't face it. We ended up taking my grandad along with us instead. And while we loved having grandad there, it just wasn't the same, thinking about dad home alone.

IScreamAtMichaelangelos · 18/12/2022 10:51

I take the DC away individually by myself, as does DH. 1:1 time is rare and precious, we value it highly!

gliiterryballs · 18/12/2022 10:50

We are also not talking about one holiday a year but three i.e. one with each of the parent and one with all of us for a week in the summer.

I think you need to claw yourself back to reality.

Have one holiday or even 2 but cost cutting by leaving a person out so your DC can have 3 holidays?

Can't work out of this is a weird attempt at a stealth boats or if you genuinely think your DC are missing out by not having 3 holidays a year.

GerbilsForever24 · 18/12/2022 10:49

i don't think taking the kids away alone is weird. But I do think it's a bit odd to do it purely as a money saving exercise. I mean, if you have more annual leave entitlement, then sure, you take the kids away and Dh stays home working but to actively choose to holiday separately is odd.

And like a PP, me and DH have taken individual children away for a few days for specific reasons - a sporting or cultural event, practicalities of different school terms /childcare needs etc. I'm also probably going to take them away with a friend next year and let DH stay home as he'd rather die than do a group holiday!