Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think she’s lying?

107 replies

TS45 · 17/12/2022 20:40

I have always been very close with my best friend. We went to primary and high school together, we shared uni accommodation together and studied the same course together. She’s incredibly sweet and smart, and I couldn’t imagine life without her. And that’s why I’m struggling a lot now.

Around 6 years ago, she had a simple operation she paid privately for. Whilst the operation went well, she ended up with slight nerve damage in her upper thigh. This hasn’t affected her in any way. She’s still able to work, drive, and walk. She occasionally complains of pain but this doesn’t impact her mobility in any way. Within the last three years, she has informed me that she has sued the hospital and will be receiving millions in compensation. She has been awaiting payment for the full three years which she states will be in her account ‘any time now’ .When I questioned the amount being won by her, she exclaimed that it is to cover loss of earnings. She works as a cashier in a supermarket and only took 2 weeks off for the duration. She also has not had any additional treatments, ramps, special cars, etc. She continues to live normally with zero adjustments ever having been needed.

She has begun spending excessive amounts on credit cards and always states her ‘compo will cover it’, despite it never arriving. I’m getting very concerned about her. She is thousands in debt and shows zero anxiety as she claims she’s days away from becoming a multi-millionaire anyway, despite saying this for years. I believe her behaviour is becoming reckless. Her house is currently on the market ready for when she can purchase her mansion.

I want to seek help for her but I don’t know whether she is being truthful about the amount being won or not. If she is being truthful then I risk our friendship. If she’s not being truthful, she’s going to be in very serious financial trouble. Has anyone ever won compensation before or knows anything about it to give me some insights?

Thank you

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
GLADragss · 18/12/2022 12:36

It doesn’t matter whether the friend’s claim was against the NHS or a private medical practitioner. Both would be handled as personal injury/medical negligence claims. The court would treat them the same, it’s not that private companies are liable to pay out more in compensation. It’s equally as unrealistic for OP’s friend to be paid out millions here by a private company!

The people sharing stories of NHS compensation are just giving an indication of what level of injury attracts what level of compensation. Again, the same compensation guidelines would be used with private companies. It’s all about placing the person back in the same position had the incident not occurred - not betterment

Eyerollcentral · 18/12/2022 11:21

ByTheGrace · 18/12/2022 10:26

He is elderly and it was realistically getting to the stage that he wouldn't live to see a settlement if it dragged on much longer. He is happy with the figure (and still has his foot(!)), the stress of the claim, having to travel for assessments and meetings etc was having a negative effect on his health and that of his partner. There was a point at which this was the best decision for him, I've no doubt that the insurance company were playing the long game. Obviously I don't want to say too much, as it is potentially outing.

So he decided to take a lower figure to settle now. That makes sense. It is a stressful process and claimants often have to chose whether the extra money they might get is worth another year of their life being wrapped up in this

Willmafrockfit · 18/12/2022 10:59

have you asked her what the compensation was for?

PoseyFlump · 18/12/2022 10:54

Your friend is either lying, she's mentally unwell or she's been scammed.

I don't think you have anything to lose by being firm with her and asking her out right. You care about her but you need to know the truth yourself for the sake of your friendship so you can figure out if she needs your support or whether you should walk away. I had a friend who was a liar and an alcoholic. Sometimes you have to put yourself first, you can't keep giving.

If she's been scammed the sooner she stops spending the better and your probing could help with that.

ByTheGrace · 18/12/2022 10:26

Eyerollcentral · 18/12/2022 02:08

Obvs don’t know the full picture but he was either foolhardy or badly advised to have settled a serious claim like this without a clear prognosis. No competent solicitor would have advised him to settle if there was even a hint of a possibility of amputation of the foot or if the prognosis was unclear. It may be that need for amputation is not as a result of the accident but other factors but I would think a barrister would be involved with this level of compensation and I think it v unlikely a solicitor and barrister would both fail to pick up on this?

He is elderly and it was realistically getting to the stage that he wouldn't live to see a settlement if it dragged on much longer. He is happy with the figure (and still has his foot(!)), the stress of the claim, having to travel for assessments and meetings etc was having a negative effect on his health and that of his partner. There was a point at which this was the best decision for him, I've no doubt that the insurance company were playing the long game. Obviously I don't want to say too much, as it is potentially outing.

familyissues12345 · 18/12/2022 10:18

I'd be worried too OP, if she was my friend. Worrying about something like bi polar, and is she having manic episodes

SnowlayRoundabout · 18/12/2022 09:56

Allthingsbrightandugly · 17/12/2022 20:42

What does it matter to you? In the kindest way it’s none of your business

For goodness sake, this is a good friend walking into disaster. OP is perfectly entitled to be concerned.

RunnerBum · 18/12/2022 09:56

She's been scammed. I guarantee that she's paid the "lawyers" and that she hasn't even had to attend court, right? She's not lying, she's been scammed.

Verbena17 · 18/12/2022 09:55

The only thing I can think that might have happened, is that she hasn’t told you about something that it DID affect. If the nerve damage was in her upper thigh, might it have affected her pelvic region and therefore had a serious impact on her sex life or bladder control? Something which could still allow her to work but which might impact her relationships? Could the damage in her upper thigh have affected her pudendal nerve or sciatic nerve for example?

I’m probably scraping the barrel for ideas and it does seem much more likely to be a psychological crisis your friend is having but just wondering about other possibilities.

StickofVeg · 18/12/2022 09:45

That's really worrying for you about your best friend OP. Either she is deluded and perhaps unwell or lying to you. If she hasn't asked to borrow money from you with promise of payment once her cheque arrives, I think maybe it's the former and she is a bit mentally unwell.

As she is your best friend could you probe a bit deeper? Ask her about it how she sued them, who she used as the lawyer, say things like "but surely there is a limit for payouts?" and just sound her out more and see how far you get. Failing that do you know someone in her family you could talk this over with? But I have to agree it does sound really concerning. However - to protect yourself do not lend her anything!

Yerroblemom1923 · 18/12/2022 09:41

She sounds bipolar and like she's having a phase of mania. She's out of touch with reality. She needs proper help.

CharityShopChic · 18/12/2022 09:41

It doesn't matter if the op was NHS or private. Medical negligence claims are about putting you back in the situation you would be without the negligent act. So paying for loss of earnings, adaptations you might need to your home, physio, travel expenses. And a smaller amount for emotional distress.

And in order to get ANY compensation you have to prove negligence in the first place - that the doctor did not do something, or did something, that a reasonable other doctor would not have done. There are risks will all procedures and that is why you are asked to sign to say you accept the risks.

Pascor · 18/12/2022 09:38

Allthingsbrightandugly · 17/12/2022 20:42

What does it matter to you? In the kindest way it’s none of your business

What a bizarre and extremely unkind attitude. What is wrong with you?

Haveahappyholiday · 18/12/2022 09:38

I know someone who believed he would get hundreds of thousands for a work injury and he went on about it for years. He eventually got about £40k. Maybe they are led to believe it could be a lot more and they pin all their hopes on the life changing amount that’s coming their way.

I don’t think it would help if you said anything.

ElspethTascioni · 18/12/2022 09:36

@Willmafrockfit

the 3 year limit only applies to issuing your claim - starting it with the courts - complex claims often then take a lot longer from that point onwards.

Shefliesonherownwings · 18/12/2022 09:35

Hi Op, I’m a lawyer and also received compensation two years ago for medical negligence. To put it into context, our DD died (she passed away during labour) and it was found her death was avoidable. We received thousands in comp, not millions.

Some of the compensation we received was for my lost earnings as I had months off work afterwards and I had to provide a lot of evidence to support that including letters from my employer. As a lawyer I knew there would need to be lots of evidence needed for actual losses. For example we had to provide a detailed breakdown of all the things we’d bought for DD so we could claim that back. In addition I had a psychiatrist assessment for mental anguish and future costs such as ongoing counselling. There was much much more to it of course and so many investigations and proof had to be provided.

I have to say I think your friend is being untruthful. Whilst our case was ongoing, I looked up compensation levels and read a lot of case law and it would be so unlikely she would get millions for what sounds like a minor consequence from her op. As another example, my dad lost the sight in one eye due to a mistake during a cataract op which has affected his day to day life and he also got thousands, not millions. Our case was also settled in a year so for hers to take three years means it will either have gone all the way to court or she’s lying. Sorry.

saleorbouy · 18/12/2022 09:26

Payments in the millions are usually to support the life long care after medical negligence. As your friend is mobile, working a suffering relatively minor symptoms in comparison to some patients I don't believe she'll be awarded millions, maybe 10's of thousands at the most.
If she has taken the no win no fee route she will also be losing some 'compo' to the legal team too.
You are right to be concerned for her though.

IncompleteSenten · 18/12/2022 09:08

MulledWineAndMingePies · 18/12/2022 06:49

People keep mentioning the NHS.

But the operation was private and not through the NHS.

Surely she wouldn't be suing the NHS for something she organised privately?

No she wouldn't be.
Op said she paid to go private, I think people missed that and are assuming NHS.

Dreamwhisper · 18/12/2022 09:01

I know we shouldn't armchair diagnose but her reckless and impulsive behaviour, extending as far as to put her house on the market, couple with the belief in this "multi million win" seems to indicate some kind of mania to me, often seen in conditions like BPD.

I know someone who gets periods on mania and his are linked to religion, but he gets ridiculously hyped up and sure of himself and preaches to others about how he's discovered the truth, is so deliriously happy etc.

I would be extremely concerned about her mental health especially if she has DC.

prh47bridge · 18/12/2022 09:01

She is certainly deluded if she thinks she will get millions in compensation, assuming there is no more to the injury than you have described. At most it will be a low four figure sum.

Willmafrockfit · 18/12/2022 08:57

is she selling her house because she is in so much financial trouble?

Coffeetree · 18/12/2022 08:52

Dacadactyl · 17/12/2022 21:01

Could you approach it from the angle that you're scared the lawyers might be taking advantage of her? Maybe just say "I am concerned that because your payout is taking so long to process, that the lawyers might be stringing you along. Unless you have the money in the bank, I really do think you'd be wiser to hold off on any purchases, just in case".

Yes this. If she's not previously shown herself to be delusional, is it possible that she's being preyed upon by someone unscrupulous? Either an actual lawyer or an "agent".

I would recommend sitting her down and kindly saying that things arent really adding up and you're concerned that she's exposing herself to significant loss.

But honestly I would say that once to her, and then distance myself.

Goodywhoshoes · 18/12/2022 08:37

TheShellBeach · 18/12/2022 00:04

Why does she work as a cashier in a supermarket if she's got a university degree?

I have a BA (hons)
I worked in a supermarket for 15 years @TheShellBeach because the security and the hours suited my family life with a disabled husband and child.

HTH.

BlandSoup · 18/12/2022 08:27

Allthingsbrightandugly · 17/12/2022 20:42

What does it matter to you? In the kindest way it’s none of your business

Because she’s her friend? Of course it matters to her.

AcerbicColleague · 18/12/2022 08:27

I don't know, one of my friends sued and was awarded 350k...