Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband unhappy with me putting DD to sleep

59 replies

teomama · 17/12/2022 19:28

DD (11 months) is a bit of a troublesome sleeper and we had a sleep trainer over for her. She recommended leaving her to cry it out for certain periods of time and then pick her up and reassure her. Tonight my OH was putting her to bed and timing the slots. She was screaming hysterically, so I went in, gave her a cuddle and let her have a little milk. She went down in about 5 mins.

My husband is mad at me. He said we paid lots of money for the sleep trainer, and said I am undermining him as a father, and not letting him follow through with the sleep training. He threatened he'd not get up at night and soothe her because it's my fault I don't let her cry and rush in.

That's not true though - but sometimes she gets to a point where she can't calm down by herself and I need to intervene. I refused to listen to him and now we're not speaking. AIBU?

OP posts:
Figgypuddin · 20/12/2022 20:37

I don't think undermining is the most important thing if one parent can see the child is distressed and needs help. In other circumstances maybe you could have said to him this isn't working so he could pick up baby for a cuddle. (Instead of it being him ignoring, you rescuing). But in reality your milk was probably needed to settle the baby.

It's not really possible to have a regrouping conversation when DD needs comforting so I don't think you were unreasonable to step in.

I also don't think you did anything wrong to try something and then realise it's not for you/not working for DD. Worse to stick to it knowing she is distressed.

Saxiee · 20/12/2022 20:29

All this talk of undermining... What do you do if both parents will not/ cannot agree? If he wants to carry on with the training and OP doesn't, what do they do? Surely one way or the other someone doesn't get their way and is undermined.

teomama · 20/12/2022 20:13

In all honesty, sleep trainer advised nothing should be followed if we're uncomfortable with it. I followed the 1 minute, 2 minute etc rule for quite a long time and only went in as I noticed the baby gets more and more irritated.

OP posts:
Margo34 · 19/12/2022 20:20

panko · 17/12/2022 19:36

Your instincts kicked in. Follow them.

Absolutely..

coconutpie · 19/12/2022 20:18

YABU for getting a sleep trainer in the first place. Crying it out is awful. Listen to your instincts. Babies don't know how to "self-soothe", they are babies!!

Valeriekat · 19/12/2022 19:48

No but they have a well established training protocol and millenia of practice. Sleep training from an "expert" seems to be a bit like something my great grandmother would have told me to do and every child IS different

JKDcot · 19/12/2022 18:42

I did exactly the same thing with our now 2 year old. We got a sleep trainer in and I couldn’t follow the recommended approach.

you know what, babies are not robots. Some nights they need comforting and if it helps and you can settle her then by all means you should. My husband was angry too but I believe you have to compromise and sometimes you just have to follow your instinct

LadyTwinkle · 19/12/2022 16:19

You did the right thing. Babies cry to communicate and you responded. I imagine being alone in big dark room can be pretty scary at 11months old. It's natural for her to want her mum and for you to want to comfort her. Babies have different sleep patterns to adults and it's unfair to brand her problem sleeper because she doesn't sleep like an adult. Fair enough you paid for a sleep trainer and you decided their methods weren't for you. You don't have to soldier on with something that's not working and causing de-stress just because you paid for it. You're a good mum because you comforted your child and stood up to your husband on her behalf. This won't be for ever as your daughter gets she will sleep better as she gets older. Don't forget a baby who feels secure will grow into a secure adult.

DiaDeLluvia · 19/12/2022 16:07

@Valeriekat to be fair there are lots of things we can do
without having had direct experience of it. I doubt most midwives and obstetricians have given birth to hundreds of babies, but they have studied and observed birth. I presume a sleep trainer does similar.

Valeriekat · 18/12/2022 17:39

How does one become an expert in sleep training such that they get paid to give advice?
Have they had 100s of babies themselves?

Eyerollcentral · 17/12/2022 22:03

Seems a bit like you are determined you are right. You said you went in tonight after the baby cried for five mins only. Was this the first night you tried it? I don’t understand what the point in posting this was tbqh? Long story short yes you have been totally unreasonable to your husband and ps it’s his baby too

teomama · 17/12/2022 21:04

Thanks all. The sleep trainer advised to message her if her method doesn’t seem to work well - which it doesn’t. My baby only gets more and more wired. I’ve reached out to her and in the meantime, try to calm the baby.

OP posts:
Milesty1 · 17/12/2022 20:49

I could never do cry it out so in that regard YANBU. Also he is acting like a toddler threatening not to do night times. However I slightly get why your DH is annoyed to spend money on a sleep trainer and then you ignore the advice. Perhaps you should have researched their methods and whether you’d be happy carrying them out before paying. On the other hand maybe you were desperate and we are allowed to change our minds. Try and communicate and remember; this feels like a lifetime but they will eventually sleep through the night. I was comforting mine all the way through the night and we are almost out of the other side now.

darjeelingrose · 17/12/2022 20:48

If you wanted to stop the method, you needed to have a conversation with him about it first. It's not a unilateral thing, is it? It can't be, you are both the parents, you paid for a sleep trainer, you are having second thoughts, but you need to talk to him about it, otherwise you are undermining him.

Thefaceofboe · 17/12/2022 20:46

Yeah I agree with him. When you decided to sleep train you must have known you would have some challenging nights but you need to be consistent, you’ve probably just confused her more.

Dishvtidyxtkep · 17/12/2022 20:38

you aren’t being unreasonable.

I figure that if adults would prefer to fall asleep next to someone then a baby would too.

Some adults also need help getting down from being upset so it makes sense that babies would too.

I think of it in a would I like that and if the answer is no then there’s a 98% chance the baby won’t like it either.

My son who is now 19 months was THE WORST sleeper, to the point where I would actually cry with him. He would go to sleep around 8, wake up at 10 and cry until 11:30; fall asleep, wake up at 1:30 and scream until 4:30/5am, wake at 6am and being his day. This went from about 10 months until 17 months and I very nearly went insane.
Leaving him to cry didn’t work he would just go for hours (and it broke my heart), going and giving a cuddle then coming back didn’t work either. I just sat next to his cot for hours at a time while he tried to fall asleep and now finally at 19 months we do a story, one cuddle and he lays in his cot and falls asleep. He also now settles himself in the night too (only started happening in the last month or so). Way better sleeper than his brother.

My partners son who I met at 17 months old was left to cry it out and come back in 2 minutes/5 minutes etc etc is now 5 years old. I am yet to meet a 5 year old as bad at sleeping as he is. If he wakes up for whatever reason he can’t get himself back to sleep and will lie and cry, he also can’t get himself to sleep and sits in this state anxiety that he’s going to left alone. This isn’t the case for all babies obviously - this is the only child I’ve known well enough to comment on.

You’re the mother. You know best. The sleep trainer doesn’t know your baby, isn’t familiar with your baby, doesn’t know their habits, doesn’t know how they calm down. If it feels wrong to you then don’t do it.

Babies will outgrow most things, when I was a preschooler I used to have night terrors and would scream, squat, pee on the floor and then continue screaming, cry for about half an hour then go back to sleep as if nothing had happen. I don’t do this anymore - but my mum thought I’d never get over it (I did this every night for about a year between 1:30 and 3:30am).

But she’s a baby, only 11 months I’m 98% sure she will outgrow bad sleeping. (I’m solely basing this on having a real life demon during the night for 9 months).

whynotwhatknot · 17/12/2022 20:22

what was the point in payung a professional when you dont want to do it

how long had she been crying for before you went in

AnnaBegins · 17/12/2022 20:08

She's a baby, she cries to communicate. You were right to settle her. It seems like she needed milk and a cuddle. If that works, i.e. responding to her needs and not leaving her to scream, then for heaven's sake don't leave her to scream.

tiggergoesbounce · 17/12/2022 20:08

DiaDeLluvia · 17/12/2022 19:32

Whatever training method you use, consistency is key. You’re sending your child mixed messages. If you can’t do it as advised because you find it too distressing, that’s totally fine but it’d be kinder to your baby to give up entirely than sometimes come to her comfort and sometimes not.

I completely agree with this.

You need to decide if you cope with that training method, if you cant its fine, I personally couldn't do it, but you need to be consistent in your method of choice.

VimFuego101 · 17/12/2022 20:07

Oojamaflipp · 17/12/2022 19:33

People have mixed feelings on the cry it out method, but regardless of your feelings on it, your husband is right that you paid for advice, agreed to implement the advice and then you disregarded what he was trying to do. I would be annoyed too.

If you don't agree with the method, fine, but you need to talk to him about it and you both need to be in the same page.

This, exactly. Why did you pay for the sleep consultant if you weren't committed to following their advice?

AnneLovesGilbert · 17/12/2022 20:02

You’re both unreasonable. What’s with the incessant threads on here the last few days of people leaving their babies to cry. You know it’s not working, stop doing it.

Judgyjudgy · 17/12/2022 19:58

DiaDeLluvia · 17/12/2022 19:32

Whatever training method you use, consistency is key. You’re sending your child mixed messages. If you can’t do it as advised because you find it too distressing, that’s totally fine but it’d be kinder to your baby to give up entirely than sometimes come to her comfort and sometimes not.

This. Consistency is key, otherwise just give it up as ita confusing to your child

Shoxfordian · 17/12/2022 19:57

Yabu to undermine the advice you’ve been given and not stick to it, especially as you’re paying for the advice

Hugasauras · 17/12/2022 19:56

I think you either want to do the sleep training thing or you don't. Personally I wouldn't pay money just for someone to tell me to do controlled crying, which is what this sounds like, in the first place. But if you're going to do it then you should really stick to it or find another method that you can both work with.

Notimeforaname · 17/12/2022 19:55

YANBU for settling your baby but YABU for undermining their father’s parenting.

He IBU for threatening to not soothe her at night.

destress, regroup and come up with a plan that suits all three of you.

First reply says it all.