Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have an idea you believe would significantly improve life in the UK?

508 replies

ConfusedmumUC · 17/12/2022 18:44

I’ll go first.

I can’t help but think making someone’s rent payments eligible to prove you can pay a mortgage would go a long way to housing security for so many people. And limiting the amount of properties owned by one landlord / amount a landlord can charge in rent, would also go a long way. I can’t help but think profiteering massively off of a basic need and right such as housing is really not ok.

Im sure there’s a reason why my idea wouldn’t work, feel free to put me right 😂

What’s your idea?

OP posts:
Ilovemycatalot · 18/12/2022 07:20

Make it easier to study to better yourself. A lot of people myself included would love to study for a higher income job but worry about the cost and how to support myself whilst studying as I have bills to pay and a dd to provide for.

NewPapaGuinea · 18/12/2022 07:14

Better infrastructure to get people using cars less. When you stop and observe the sheer number of vehicles clogging up towns, it’s insane!

Virginiaplain · 18/12/2022 07:12

Bring back Young Offender's Institutions so horrible little **s can be sent away from whoever they are harrassing or bullying for a year of strict rules and behaviour.

orbitalcrisis · 18/12/2022 07:04

Renationalising all services and utilities. A massive council housing building project. Making the right to safe, habitable accommodation a basic right and available to all. Free university education for all. An actual living wage as a starting point and if companies genuinely can't afford this, make it clear that the government is subsidising the company, not the employee. The company should be the one claiming benefits, filling in all the forms and going to meeting about what they are doing to make themselves financially viable and self sufficient. Electoral reform. More money on NHS and education. Close tax loop holes. Ban on non-residents owning residential property. Join the EU.

Ladyof2022 · 18/12/2022 05:31

Every aspect of our country is a total fuck up, even the basics of life such as housing, education and healthcare. Everything has been wrongly set up and is badly managed, so I have no idea where to begin to put anything right!

Ladyof2022 · 18/12/2022 05:21

WrongLife · 17/12/2022 19:15

Build a shit load of well designed, well insulated social housing such that everyone who needs it can have a house they can afford. Housing security has a significant ripple effect and would pay for itself.

heavily subside childcare - for the same reasons, eventually it pays for itself in getting people into employment.

Perhaps your social housing scheme could include a fully staffed 24 hour creche for each housing development, so women could also take shift-work and nightwork jobs.

Aintnosupermum · 18/12/2022 05:03
  1. TV license is free for anyone over 75 and who gets pension credit ‘in the household’ www.gov.uk/free-discount-tv-licence
  2. Winter fuel payment is based on your age. Income has nothing to do with it. www.gov.uk/winter-fuel-payment/eligibility
  3. I don’t need to put a figure on it. The amount of help given to OAPs over other groups is shocking. We all know why it happens, which is why it’s really important to vote. Why do OAPs get free prescriptions automatically when 8% receive more than £39k a year just from their occupational pension? Take a look at this link: www.gov.uk/government/statistics/pensioners-incomes-series-financial-year-2020-to-2021/pensioners-incomes-series-financial-year-2020-to-2021
echt · 18/12/2022 04:26

Aintnosupermum · 18/12/2022 03:39

Scandinavia is not the panacea people think it is. My ex husband is Danish and during covid I lived in denmark. It’s a xenophobic country. Their immigration policies are horrific. They were proud of anti immigration policies including the removal of Syrian refugees. The Danes are fully in favour of processing refugees in Rwanda and it was floated there first before Priti Patel ever mentioned anything in the UK. Most importantly understand their education system is terrible. Parents send their children to ‘free schools’ where you pay a top up. In essence it’s a private school. The Scandinavian countries really have the best propaganda and PR.

As for schools have a max of 15 to a class, if you look at the birth rates, since changes to benefits came in, people are having 2 children now and the decline in numbers is going to create the opportunity to do something radical like have 15 children to a class. Rather than shut schools down, I’d like to see classrooms stay open and have less children in each class. Yes it’s expensive upfront but I think these children will receive a better education and it will enable more people to train in the positions needed for our society to function.

Taxes do need to change and I think it comes from a change in money made available to those over 65. Why do they automatically get Tv license paid for, free prescriptions and money for their heating when so many of that generation have final salary pensions. So many are retired earning significant sums. They really don’t need the help. Obviously there are plenty of elderly who don’t have such funds and they of course should be helped. I can’t understand how a pension paying out £50k a year, enables any other assistance being paid until it’s shown the full amount is spent on care in the home.

  1. Over 65s do not automatically get their TV licence paid
  2. Over 65s do not automatically get the Winter Fuel payment
  3. "So many, etc" Care to put figure on that?
Iflyaway · 18/12/2022 04:23

Or we could aim even higher and spend as much as Belgium, the Netherlands, Germany or Switzerland.

In the Netherlands you pay over a hundred Euros a month for obligatory health insurance even if you hardly ever go the the GP. You also have the first 285(?) to pay yourself a year. I have family living there. The health care is excellent.

Aintnosupermum · 18/12/2022 03:39

Scandinavia is not the panacea people think it is. My ex husband is Danish and during covid I lived in denmark. It’s a xenophobic country. Their immigration policies are horrific. They were proud of anti immigration policies including the removal of Syrian refugees. The Danes are fully in favour of processing refugees in Rwanda and it was floated there first before Priti Patel ever mentioned anything in the UK. Most importantly understand their education system is terrible. Parents send their children to ‘free schools’ where you pay a top up. In essence it’s a private school. The Scandinavian countries really have the best propaganda and PR.

As for schools have a max of 15 to a class, if you look at the birth rates, since changes to benefits came in, people are having 2 children now and the decline in numbers is going to create the opportunity to do something radical like have 15 children to a class. Rather than shut schools down, I’d like to see classrooms stay open and have less children in each class. Yes it’s expensive upfront but I think these children will receive a better education and it will enable more people to train in the positions needed for our society to function.

Taxes do need to change and I think it comes from a change in money made available to those over 65. Why do they automatically get Tv license paid for, free prescriptions and money for their heating when so many of that generation have final salary pensions. So many are retired earning significant sums. They really don’t need the help. Obviously there are plenty of elderly who don’t have such funds and they of course should be helped. I can’t understand how a pension paying out £50k a year, enables any other assistance being paid until it’s shown the full amount is spent on care in the home.

ConsuelaHammock · 18/12/2022 03:29

License to have children .

RamblingFar · 18/12/2022 03:21

LondonQueen · 18/12/2022 02:01

How would UBI work, surely there's no incentive for me to work a high stress, high responsibility job if I could go and flip burgers for the same money but no stress and no responsibility?

There's still the incentive, you'd still be able to earn a lot more. The highest hourly age can still be set at multiple times the lowest hourly wage, and still reduce inequality. However, currently there are certain sectors and workers being paid far, far, far in excess of their worth to society.

Also, I think an awful lot of people fail to accept that some of the poorest paid jobs in the the UK are actually some of the ones with the worse working conditions. They may be low-skilled, but not necessary low-stress, low responsibility or un-essential. Some jobs there are very few rungs up from entry level, however we really rely on the experienced workers in those jobs. It's fine encouraging people to better themselves and rewarding the best. However, we still need people to fill all the types and levels of jobs we have. We need people to understand that some people will work just as hard as others all their lives, but not see the monetary success of others. That doesn't mean their jobs are not some of the most valuable to society.

Some of the lower paid professional jobs are also haemorrhaging workers and unable to recruit enough replacements due to the way workers are treated and the poor salary as compensation.

There is no reason that any full-time worker should be hungry, cold or in unsecure housing. We are one of the biggest and wealthiest economies in the world. We need our workforce. We'd be far happier and productive if we met the basic living needs of all our workers and their families, currently that's not happening. A few have more than they'll ever need and an increasing number do not have enough for the basics.

MarshaMelrose · 18/12/2022 03:20

Elect meeeeee!

Swimmingistoocold · 18/12/2022 03:17

Childcare costs should be free or at a minimum be fully tax deductible.

scrap stamp duty and increase council tax to compensate. Stamp duty massively reduces our ability to always live in a house that meets our housing needs by disincentivising downsizing etc.

build more.

ensure full inheritance tax on house price gains - this is untaxed income.

increase the basic rate of tax. This is how Scandinavian countries can afford progressive policies. They are paid for by everyone.

merge NI into income tax and set divided rates at the same rate too. Would stop a lot of anti avoidance/ IR35 nonsense.

expand social care / reintroduce convAlescent homes to ensure hospitals are used efficiently.

FelicityFlops · 18/12/2022 02:52

Renationalise energy providers, energy should not be based on speculation
Adopt an insurance and risk-based health system with appropriate premiums
Pass legislation to ensure that multi-nationals pay the appropriate tax on their in-country profits
Revive skilled trades such as butchery, carpentry etc.
Impose high import taxes on non-UK, non-seasonal produce to encourage a return to local, seasonal eating
Tax supermarkets that mainly sell packaged, highly-processed foodstuffs
Automate processes around passport renewal and DVLA so that human intervention is only required for exceptions
Reform higher education to return it to being free for all, but with fewer places, since throwing the doors wide ooen does not appear to have had the desired effect
Impose compulsory enery efficiency measures on all new builds and investigate the options for subsidising enery-savings' measures for existing structures
Create allotments in all communities
Facilitate provision of work-based childcare that is either free or at low cost, for example a % of money earned

HappyMackerel · 18/12/2022 02:44

Universal Basic Income

ConfusedmumUC · 18/12/2022 02:44

Left the thread for a few hours and now all the UK’s children are homeless orphans, tax is at 100%, crack is legalised and Rees Mogg is upside down in a bin in the corner. Carnage!

I love it, please continue…

OP posts:
DuchessDandelion · 18/12/2022 02:17

Vote out the Tories

And put Boris, Rees Mogg and Farage in adjacent bins.

LondonQueen · 18/12/2022 02:05

Vimto1 · 17/12/2022 19:59

@Simonjt no, it would have left them reliant on support from the state if they didn't have personal wealth.

A 100% inheritance tax could fund a robust welfare and social system that could support people properly and regardless of the wealth of their parents.

But sure, let's continue to perpetuate a class system where only the children of the wealthy get a leg up - that'll help solve inequality

So if my husband dies, me and my two children would be made homeless and reliant on the state, there's no way I could afford to pay half of the value of my house in tax, let alone his other assets. You're mad.

LondonQueen · 18/12/2022 02:01

How would UBI work, surely there's no incentive for me to work a high stress, high responsibility job if I could go and flip burgers for the same money but no stress and no responsibility?

ImustLearn2Cook · 18/12/2022 01:56

I can’t help but think making someone’s rent payments eligible to prove you can pay a mortgage would go a long way to housing security for so many people

@ConfusedmumUC I’m not in the UK but I’ve been recently thinking about this a lot. My rent has increased so much in the last couple of years that I am paying weekly rent that is significantly higher than most people I know who have a mortgage are paying on a weekly basis.

But I think that it really isn’t just about whether you can make the mortgage repayments. I think it’s about maintaining class and status.

I think it’s time to rethink how much we value status and being more important than the next person. Maybe we need to shift more towards egalitarianism.

Climate change is affecting the whole world and one of the things that’s holding us back from making a real difference is the very rich want to stay the very rich. Their excessive wealth brings them more opportunities and helps them to keep believing that they are more important and above most other people.

The world would be a better place if we abandoned status and classism.

LondonQueen · 18/12/2022 01:55

FourChimneys · 17/12/2022 19:34

Build thousands of small two up, two down houses in rows, rather than all the 4 and 5 bed houses on large plots going up everywhere. Then a lot more people could afford to buy.

Mandatory litter picking for everyone who is able bodied.

All dogs on leads unless in designated dog fields.

More support for childcare and young families.

2 up 2 downs do not work for most families. there's a reason they stopped building them!

LondonQueen · 18/12/2022 01:51

Florenz · 17/12/2022 19:00

Put all criminals in prison and keep them there for a long time.

So if I accidentally go 35 in a 30 zone (making me a criminal) I should be imprisoned for the rest of my life?

DdraigGoch · 18/12/2022 01:48

Frabbits · 17/12/2022 23:27

It wasn't pointless and trite.

I was replying to a comment saying there is no room to build enough houses.

There is. Clearly. Only about 10% of land in the uk is actually built upon.

Maybe try reading next time and putting stuff into context.

It is a stupid comment. You realise that the other 90% of land in the UK isn't some barren wasteland? Most of it is agricultural land which we depend upon for food (or would you prefer that we just deforest more of Brazil and import food from there?).

Would you like to know just how much land in England isn't used by humans for one purpose or another? 0.2%

DdraigGoch · 18/12/2022 01:43

OnSecondThoughts · 17/12/2022 23:13

I know this is easier said than done, and it probably wouldn't/couldn't happen in practical terms, but I keep thinking if we could somehow divide the UK into two sections (or even create two new countries), and have one section rejoin the EU and have a governnment that goes along with that and has the sort of policies which pro-EU people seem to favour (which seems to be socialist, big-state, big public sector, high taxes etc), and the other section be full-on Brexit (and have a generally free-market, small-state, low tax sort of government typically favoured by Brexiters), and everybody gets government funding to move into the sector they wish to live in. That way everyone (or most people) get to live in the sort of UK they want, instead of all this divide-and-rule, divisions that we have right now. And then after say 25 years they could compare the economies etc and say for sure which sector was the best to live in.

You aware of the issues with Northern Ireland at the moment? Multiply that 100 fold if you're dividing each county by how they voted. It'd be like Bosnia, where the internal border runs along where the frontline was when the civil war ended, no logic to it and lots of exclaves.