Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have an idea you believe would significantly improve life in the UK?

508 replies

ConfusedmumUC · 17/12/2022 18:44

I’ll go first.

I can’t help but think making someone’s rent payments eligible to prove you can pay a mortgage would go a long way to housing security for so many people. And limiting the amount of properties owned by one landlord / amount a landlord can charge in rent, would also go a long way. I can’t help but think profiteering massively off of a basic need and right such as housing is really not ok.

Im sure there’s a reason why my idea wouldn’t work, feel free to put me right 😂

What’s your idea?

OP posts:
jetadore · 18/12/2022 12:29

Include commuting time in contracted working hours.

Cattenberg · 18/12/2022 12:23

RamblingFar · 18/12/2022 03:21

There's still the incentive, you'd still be able to earn a lot more. The highest hourly age can still be set at multiple times the lowest hourly wage, and still reduce inequality. However, currently there are certain sectors and workers being paid far, far, far in excess of their worth to society.

Also, I think an awful lot of people fail to accept that some of the poorest paid jobs in the the UK are actually some of the ones with the worse working conditions. They may be low-skilled, but not necessary low-stress, low responsibility or un-essential. Some jobs there are very few rungs up from entry level, however we really rely on the experienced workers in those jobs. It's fine encouraging people to better themselves and rewarding the best. However, we still need people to fill all the types and levels of jobs we have. We need people to understand that some people will work just as hard as others all their lives, but not see the monetary success of others. That doesn't mean their jobs are not some of the most valuable to society.

Some of the lower paid professional jobs are also haemorrhaging workers and unable to recruit enough replacements due to the way workers are treated and the poor salary as compensation.

There is no reason that any full-time worker should be hungry, cold or in unsecure housing. We are one of the biggest and wealthiest economies in the world. We need our workforce. We'd be far happier and productive if we met the basic living needs of all our workers and their families, currently that's not happening. A few have more than they'll ever need and an increasing number do not have enough for the basics.

Completely agree. It was interesting to watch Undercover Boss and see just how many CEOs struggled to do an entry-level job at their own company. Many would have been sacked on capability grounds. Minimum wage jobs might not require specialist qualifications, but that doesn’t mean they are easy.

meetmynewusername · 18/12/2022 12:11

VladmirsPoutine · 17/12/2022 19:10

  • Education should be 100% free at all levels for all subjects.
  • Landlords should be extremely curtailed.
  • The minimum wage should be enough to live a quality of life in which you aren't scrimping a penny here and a penny there to buy bread and milk.

hear hear

Vimto1 · 18/12/2022 12:03

@YankeeDad yep, a tax on wealth rather than income and at a higher rate for high value individuals was my first suggestion.

The point around achieving equality is really key. The inter-generational transfer of wealth is only entrenching the class system and leading to further inequality. One way to tackle this would be to look at inheritance rules.

YankeeDad · 18/12/2022 11:57

@Vimto1

I fully agree that we need more effective taxation of wealth, unearned income, and gains. Right now a multimillionaire living on capital gains, dividends and interest will normally pay a much lower overall tax rate on their annual gains&income, compared to the overall tax rate paid by a midlevel professional working full time. That just makes no sense.

On the other hand, inheritance tax can and will be avoided in various ways if it is set at an extreme rate, plus it arbitrarily penalises children who are unlucky by having their parents die when they are young. One reason why some people choose to work hard at providing goods and services for others, is to give their children opportunities they may not have had themselves. Unless we want to prohibit all inequality, introduce full communism, and use force and coercion to get people to work, it’s important for people to have choices around how much of their life energy they devote to earning money, and how they use the money, and that must include helping their own children and other relatives. In parallel, in order to increase fairness and have a functioning society, we need to tax people progressively.

However, a 100pct inheritance tax is not taxation but rather confiscation, and the fact of being arbitrarily timed to the often unpredictable moment of one’s own death would drastically reduce the motivation to work and to save. It would penalise primarily those who are unlucky enough to die unexpectedly when they are between middle aged snd approaching retirement age but not yet retired (=typically the age range when personal wealth peaks).

A modest annual wealth tax, on the other hand, could be designed to tax people in proportion to their current ability to pay, and it would put a brake on the ability of the most wealthy to keep growing that wealth gap, without disproportionately penalising the family members of people who die unexpectedly. It would probably also raise more than an inheritance tax from the wealthy elderly, who currently can give much of their wealth to their children and avoid any wealth or inheritance tax if they then survive for another 7 years.

CloudBusted · 18/12/2022 11:57

GreenTeaPingPong · Yesterday 19:07
Set up excellent and widely available gold-standard treatment for addictions, including the trauma underlying them.

This would decrease the sum of human misery, as well as massively reduce crime and homelessness.

Good point. I’d add in to focus services on early years to reduced ACEs and developmental trauma in the first place.

Fund it through properly taxing the wealthy. I mean taxes on assets and wealth rather than just income. The unequal distribution of wealth is obscene in the UK at the moment. That inequality leads to higher crime and poorer mental health (for the haves and have nots).

Cattenberg · 18/12/2022 11:50

Here in UK we have BTL LLs as a form of investment as state pension is so poor, MPs vote down min standards & we have children even dying in damp and mouldy houses.

More than a few MPs are landlords, yet these same MPs are allowed to vote against raising standards. The system is corrupt.

Chillyweather · 18/12/2022 11:48

To qualify for a new passport everyone has to pick crops in the fields for a fortnight. Not convinced by the ethics and air miles of flying in exploited workers from Indonesia and south America

MarshaBradyo · 18/12/2022 11:38

Vimto1 · 18/12/2022 11:23

Because they didn't chose to be born to you? It's pure chance and your hard work also has an element of luck?

What makes your kids more deserving than anyone else's?

People who do want to pass on to their dc would just go. It gets more difficult to raise taxes from those who receive but not pay.

Atm it’s easy to gift the whole amount to charity if the idea is repellent. So those who do think 100% tax could easily do that.

Blossomtoes · 18/12/2022 11:33

abcdefghijkml · 18/12/2022 11:15

Why shouldn't my children benefit from my hard work?

I don’t know about you but the majority of our assets (our house) are thanks to property price inflation. Nobody worked for that money or ever paid any tax on it.

Alexandra2001 · 18/12/2022 11:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What a vile attitude, calling for people in the UK to be put to death.

So you'd want someone convicted of shoplifting 3 x to be executed.

Tories really do want us to go back to the 1830s.

No liberal in you, just hate & stupidity.

Vimto1 · 18/12/2022 11:23

abcdefghijkml · 18/12/2022 11:15

Why shouldn't my children benefit from my hard work?

Because they didn't chose to be born to you? It's pure chance and your hard work also has an element of luck?

What makes your kids more deserving than anyone else's?

abcdefghijkml · 18/12/2022 11:15

DrLecter · 17/12/2022 20:01

Yes to the 100% inheritance tax. It is obscene that some people whose parents die are made for life while others are left with a bill. We are always being told we live in neoliberal capitalism - let's have a bit of actual meritocracy and the individual as the unit of society.

Why shouldn't my children benefit from my hard work?

Pumperthepumper · 18/12/2022 11:13

DolphinWars · 18/12/2022 11:08

You’re right.
Ds had such a difficult time with all his teachers, apart from one amazing one, that it’s difficult to not blame them!

I definitely think a different structure to schooling - more outdoors where available - forest school activities, and more exercise would help pupils who struggle.

Making classrooms a little more formal and less of a sensory nightmare would help as well.

Definitely. Flexible seating, adaptable timetables and low-level changes like easy-grip pencils or coloured paper to write on also make a massive difference.

Nospringchix · 18/12/2022 11:12

ghjklo · 17/12/2022 19:07

elect a different govt

Yep, this. Totally. One that actually gives a shit about ordinary people.

DolphinWars · 18/12/2022 11:08

Pumperthepumper · 18/12/2022 10:53

I agree too Dolphin, although I wouldn’t put the blame solely on teachers. It’s the result of SEN provision being cut to the bone, with a huge number of kids being failed in mainstream school. Also punishments in schools is hideous, and like you say, doesn’t work.

You’re right.
Ds had such a difficult time with all his teachers, apart from one amazing one, that it’s difficult to not blame them!

I definitely think a different structure to schooling - more outdoors where available - forest school activities, and more exercise would help pupils who struggle.

Making classrooms a little more formal and less of a sensory nightmare would help as well.

DolphinWars · 18/12/2022 11:04

“A big problem with our current system is lack of incentive to work, certainly to work to capacity. If you can work a couple of days a week and get various top ups and fringe benefits by keeping your earned income low enough, there can be little incentive to work harder or longer or in a role with more responsibility if you'll lose the tops ups. There won't be enough differential in what you end up with to make it worth your while.”

I’m currently not working, I am my ds’s carer, single mother, relying on benefits.

I want to work, but am terrified of losing the flexibility I currently have to be able to attend all the meetings and appointments, and be there for ds as and when he needs me.
I will have to start working fairly soon, and I wish I could just work full time, earn enough to pay my bills. But I can’t. If I work more than 10 hours a week I lose carers allowance, more than 16 hours I lose income support, and in my precarious position - a family life that can and does implode or explode as ds reacts to normal life events.
Universal Basic Income would allow me to work (and I do want to work!) without the fear that everything’s going to spectacularly blow up in my face.

ClydeFrog · 18/12/2022 10:59

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Snufkinhastherightidea · 18/12/2022 10:58

Communism

Frabbits · 18/12/2022 10:57

DdraigGoch · 18/12/2022 01:48

It is a stupid comment. You realise that the other 90% of land in the UK isn't some barren wasteland? Most of it is agricultural land which we depend upon for food (or would you prefer that we just deforest more of Brazil and import food from there?).

Would you like to know just how much land in England isn't used by humans for one purpose or another? 0.2%

You do realise that the UK isn't just England?

There is enough spare land, suitable for building in the UK to build more houses. This is a fact.

The only stupid thing here is your inability to grasp that.

AuxArmesCitoyens · 18/12/2022 10:57

@DolphinWars absolutely. One of my favourite quotes is by Victor Hugo: open a school, close a prison.

Pumperthepumper · 18/12/2022 10:53

I agree too Dolphin, although I wouldn’t put the blame solely on teachers. It’s the result of SEN provision being cut to the bone, with a huge number of kids being failed in mainstream school. Also punishments in schools is hideous, and like you say, doesn’t work.

ClydeFrog · 18/12/2022 10:51

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

DolphinWars · 18/12/2022 10:49

Virginiaplain · 18/12/2022 07:12

Bring back Young Offender's Institutions so horrible little **s can be sent away from whoever they are harrassing or bullying for a year of strict rules and behaviour.

Many if not most young offenders have undiagnosed special needs. ADHD, ASD etc.

A big change I would make would be to the education system - apart from a handful of specialised schools that are nigh on impossible to get into, schools tend to be one size fits all, focus on academic subjects, discipline that doesn’t work (if the same children are repeatedly in isolation or detention it’s not working), pressure to perform well in tests and exams from an early age. It doesn’t work for so many children, then many of them (boys in particular) end up in the prison system.

Identify the children who struggle in school at an early age. Stop treating them as naughty no-hopers (my autistic son was treated like this, even when he was diagnosed - teachers didn’t like him so didn’t want to support him, even with an EHCP college pushed and pushed him to the point where he’s dropped out). Channel them in other ways that engage them. Teach trades, reopen colleges which had courses for 14+ year olds (there are a few left, but so many more disenfranchised students would benefit from them).
I’m convinced the only reason my son isn’t off the rails and in and out of prison is because I took him out of school and did what needed to be done - but not every parent is in the position to do that.
Ds has a string of teachers behind him who wouldn’t even try to understand his diagnosis, who completely and utterly failed him. Every single one of them could have made a difference to ds and others like him, for free, low effort, just get a basic understanding of the disabilities in question, stop labelling children, who need help, naughty, disruptive, stop sitting them next to quiet girls hoping that they’ll sort them out.
The whole school system actively fails every single youth who ends up in the prison system.

MsPrism · 18/12/2022 10:49

There are some really great ideas on here, especially for proper dignified care for the elderly (and independent living) and convalescent homes too. This would take so much pressure off of hospital beds, and also from the people who normally have to give up work to look after their elderly relatives.
I would be happy to pay more tax knowing that our old people are looked after.

My wish is that I would like more companies to operate like John Lewis/Waitrose, and make their employees partners. It would give people working there more incentive to do a good job, and pays decent annual bonuses to everyone who works there.

I would also love a return to free university education, with paid apprenticeships for non-degree roles. If we have an un-skilled workforce we should train people for the roles we have.

All new builds should have solar panels and excellent insulation and all city center office buildings should have them too.

My personal wish is that people stop being so snarky to people online - it's quite unpleasant and really not necessary.

Swipe left for the next trending thread