Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have an idea you believe would significantly improve life in the UK?

508 replies

ConfusedmumUC · 17/12/2022 18:44

I’ll go first.

I can’t help but think making someone’s rent payments eligible to prove you can pay a mortgage would go a long way to housing security for so many people. And limiting the amount of properties owned by one landlord / amount a landlord can charge in rent, would also go a long way. I can’t help but think profiteering massively off of a basic need and right such as housing is really not ok.

Im sure there’s a reason why my idea wouldn’t work, feel free to put me right 😂

What’s your idea?

OP posts:
Mozero · 18/12/2022 15:21

Palacepicker · 18/12/2022 14:57

So you tax based on where someone lives as opposed to where some one works.
What about someone who lives up North but works at home for a London based company?
What about someone basing their company up North but all their employees live down South working from home?
Someone lives up North but travels south and stays in a hotel through the week (the business pays - this often happens)
Wealthy people usually have their second homes already bought - so no penalties for them. What do you do about in between areas?

I think my aim with this one rather large but important change would be to effectively shift the population of the UK away from London and to other regions where people desperately need more investment, income, and jobs, and those people in the South desperately want to own a home and raise a family.

University leavers who grow up in the North also leave their hometowns for London, never to return unless it's the Christmas period and so this economic benefit to the region is lost forever, as is the much-needed council funding based on a lower and aging population.

Obviously, infrastructure needs to be heavily invested in as we are operating off of frankly, Victorian-era transport that hasn't really been updated for over a century and we aren't going to get anywhere with cars alone.

DdraigGoch · 18/12/2022 15:17

Frabbits · 18/12/2022 10:57

You do realise that the UK isn't just England?

There is enough spare land, suitable for building in the UK to build more houses. This is a fact.

The only stupid thing here is your inability to grasp that.

Yes, I'm well aware that the UK isn't just England, thanks. The reason that I referred to England is that land use statistics are compiled separately for each nation and I wasn't going to spend hours aggregating the statistics.

The UK is the most overcrowded large economy in Europe. This is a fact, and it's not sustainable.

Mozero · 18/12/2022 15:11

Palacepicker · 18/12/2022 14:57

So you tax based on where someone lives as opposed to where some one works.
What about someone who lives up North but works at home for a London based company?
What about someone basing their company up North but all their employees live down South working from home?
Someone lives up North but travels south and stays in a hotel through the week (the business pays - this often happens)
Wealthy people usually have their second homes already bought - so no penalties for them. What do you do about in between areas?

Firstly, I appreciate the discussion.

  • I'd tax based on somewhere someone lives, yes. Do not be under any presumption, we do not currently tax based on where someone works. We tax on how people work (self-employed, IR35, full time), but definitely not where they work.
  • If someone bases their company up North and have all their employees working from home who live down South, that would effectively hit the crux of the matter at its heart - talent in the south is expensive. If you want full-time employment, then you will have to pay more for it.
  • Consultants in the South who work freelance under IR35 in this hypothetical northern start-up would also have to pay more on their tax individually to the state.
  • Northern Based London-bound commuters are 9 times out of 10 consultants who work privately for London firms, bringing home massive sums (3x-5x) compared to the UK annual salary. Most likely they'd fall into quite a nice postcode for their hard work and would pay a lovely postcode-based income tax based on that. If a business pays for this travel for a consultant then it's considered a benefit so I would classify them as an employee and charge them a much higher Class 1 NIC based in London.
  • Wealthy people do have their second homes already bought but my thinking is about long-term in an era where short-termism is rife. The aim is to stop buying-to-let as a practice in hopefully 10-15 years and give the housing sector time to build more homes in places that were not affordable/desirable but now suddenly are due to tax rates being adjusted for different boroughs.
Palacepicker · 18/12/2022 14:57

Mozero · 18/12/2022 14:45

The biggest thing would be to adjust tax based on county lines (or London boroughs) so the North has a chance to make more money, attract more investment and retain more talent.
The South becomes less attractive for those looking to get jobs further from home. For example, I would suggest Basic Rate Income Tax in an SW1 postcode to be 25%, whereas M18 would pay 13% for the same rate.
To enforce this, I'd also give HMRC powers to prosecute those who commit fraud to dodge these taxes. Social housing and Universal Credit get reduced tax rates nationwide, if at all.
I would encourage employers to consider these areas where employment is cheaper with reduced Class 1 National Insurance rates to reduce costs overall (<10% instead of 13.8%).

The policy would be reviewed mandatorily every year during the budget and would hopefully become a major part of the tax environment in the UK. It would be reported on by the OBR alongside population movements to show the country how it is changing year on year (house prices, employment figures, crime, education).

This would of course create issues with billionaires moving to far parts of the UK to avoid paying as much tax, but then add a few stricter housing policies in such as an increase in Stamp Duty on second homes from 15% (over £1.5m) to 75% and you're laughing.

But nobody wants to touch tax. Political suicide.

So you tax based on where someone lives as opposed to where some one works.
What about someone who lives up North but works at home for a London based company?
What about someone basing their company up North but all their employees live down South working from home?
Someone lives up North but travels south and stays in a hotel through the week (the business pays - this often happens)
Wealthy people usually have their second homes already bought - so no penalties for them. What do you do about in between areas?

Andante57 · 18/12/2022 14:51

Snufkinhastherightidea · 18/12/2022 10:58

Communism

Can you enlarge on this?
Communism as practised in the Soviet Union?
Would you prevent people from leaving the country or encourage friends, family and neighbours to report anyone for speaking against the regime?

Mozero · 18/12/2022 14:45

The biggest thing would be to adjust tax based on county lines (or London boroughs) so the North has a chance to make more money, attract more investment and retain more talent.
The South becomes less attractive for those looking to get jobs further from home. For example, I would suggest Basic Rate Income Tax in an SW1 postcode to be 25%, whereas M18 would pay 13% for the same rate.
To enforce this, I'd also give HMRC powers to prosecute those who commit fraud to dodge these taxes. Social housing and Universal Credit get reduced tax rates nationwide, if at all.
I would encourage employers to consider these areas where employment is cheaper with reduced Class 1 National Insurance rates to reduce costs overall (<10% instead of 13.8%).

The policy would be reviewed mandatorily every year during the budget and would hopefully become a major part of the tax environment in the UK. It would be reported on by the OBR alongside population movements to show the country how it is changing year on year (house prices, employment figures, crime, education).

This would of course create issues with billionaires moving to far parts of the UK to avoid paying as much tax, but then add a few stricter housing policies in such as an increase in Stamp Duty on second homes from 15% (over £1.5m) to 75% and you're laughing.

But nobody wants to touch tax. Political suicide.

LlynTegid · 18/12/2022 14:23

Not putting clocks back to GMT in winter. For the majority of people an hour of daylight in the afternoon is more useful than one in the morning, and I think it would reduce road crashes and SAD.

anniegun · 18/12/2022 14:14

Tax inheritance as income, including where wealth is transferred when the parents are still alive
It is insane that vast estates have passed between generations since the Norman conquest

JuvenileEmu · 18/12/2022 14:14

cheshirecatssmile · 18/12/2022 10:02

@FourChimneys

Mandatory litter picking for everyone who is able bodied

That is what community service should be about like they do in America. But we are too soft.

One that people may not agree with , but migrants or whatever people call them, . Instead of the tax payer paying millions to keep them in hotels etc
Give them a national insurance number and let them on their way. Let them get a job and pay their own way.

Litter picking shouldn't be seen as a punishment, it should be taught as a basic respect for your environment that everyone does.

woodhill · 18/12/2022 14:12

@funtycucker

Yes it's natural to want to help your family

funtycucker · 18/12/2022 14:11

Vimto1 · 18/12/2022 14:07

Wow, the only reason you're able to 'work hard' is down to luck. Maybe if we all actually recognised that every child deserves a good start we'd start tackling inequality.

And stealing from those who have worked hard to give to those who don't have will just encourage those who are lazy to remain so

helford · 18/12/2022 14:09

funtycucker · 18/12/2022 14:02

Exactly. I work hard to provide for MY family, not some family who may have no intention of ever working. Why should other people reap the benefits of my hard work.

Crime, simple as, unequal societies have a lot of crime.

The poor will take your wealth from you and it you continue down the road of ever greater punishments i.e death penalty, as a pp wants, all that will happen is they will kill you to get what you have.

Look at the USA or South Africa.

Vimto1 · 18/12/2022 14:07

funtycucker · 18/12/2022 14:02

Exactly. I work hard to provide for MY family, not some family who may have no intention of ever working. Why should other people reap the benefits of my hard work.

Wow, the only reason you're able to 'work hard' is down to luck. Maybe if we all actually recognised that every child deserves a good start we'd start tackling inequality.

Willyoujustbequiet · 18/12/2022 14:05

To force feckless fathers to pay child maintenance and support their children.

I would make it a stigma like drink driving and remove driving licences, passports etc.. I would make it a reasonable amount, not the pittance it is for most atm. I would also give powers to include all the self employed, unearned income, property etc... and both parents should be equally responsible for childcare.

funtycucker · 18/12/2022 14:02

woodhill · 18/12/2022 13:56

Absolutely

Exactly. I work hard to provide for MY family, not some family who may have no intention of ever working. Why should other people reap the benefits of my hard work.

boboshmobo · 18/12/2022 13:56

@ConfusedmumUC I've been saying this for years .. you should be able to get a 100% mortgage for less than your rent payments if you can prove you haven't defaulted for a set amount of years!

It would solve all housing problems !

Seems easy to me , no doubt someone else will tell me why it won't work but my very large 4 bed house is cheaper than the rent on a flat we rent out which is bonkers ( obviously I know why etc but it's still madness )

woodhill · 18/12/2022 13:56

Talaforniababe · 18/12/2022 08:52

The 100% inheritance tax idea is so stupid. It would mean no one had a reason to strive. One of the reasons I work hard in a professional job is to make sure my daughter has several hundred thousand when I die. If I thought that wouldn't happen, I would just say 'fuck it', go on the dole and rent. I want my money to go specifically to my child, not any other Tom, Dick and Harry. You'll find that most home owners feel the same.

Absolutely

lieselotte · 18/12/2022 13:55

roarfeckingroarr · 18/12/2022 09:55

Mine would be free - or heavily subsidised for everyone - quality childcare. It would do so much to give choice back to women.

I definitely think that childcare for the first child should be tax-deductible.

There's a debate to be had about second and subsequent children because we have to consider if increasing the population at a time of climate crisis is a good thing.

lieselotte · 18/12/2022 13:44

abcdefghijkml · 18/12/2022 11:15

Why shouldn't my children benefit from my hard work?

Why do you want them to wait until you're dead to benefit? IHT is a tax on hoarding, spend/give away your money earlier and you won't pay any or much less.

100% is extreme but I'd like to see lower thresholds and fewer loopholes for the elderly. There obviously needs to be provision made for people who die younger and leave dependant children.

Vimto1 · 18/12/2022 13:25

Annabel073 · 18/12/2022 12:55

Realistically, how much do you think people care about anyone else's children? The actions of the majority clearly demonstrate the answer is very little.

And maybe thats the really issue we need to fix

Newwardrobe · 18/12/2022 13:09

I think the breakdown of family units with strong morals and work ethic , love and support has a lot to do with things.

titbumwillypoo · 18/12/2022 13:06

I borrowed this from the book "How to do welfare" by Chris Worth (available on Amazon) where he suggests a UBI of £12,500 per adult per year. He gets the net cost down to 58 Billion. It makes for an interesting read.
www.amazon.co.uk/How-do-Welfare-Chris-Worth/dp/1912795299/ref=sr_1_1?crid=3CO56NDKO5JJ9&keywords=how+to+do+welfare&qid=1671368741&sprefix=how+to+do+welfare%2Caps%2C143&sr=8-1

There are 46.4m British citizens over 18 in the UK. Around 3.7m overseas; call it 50m. So the total bill is £625bn. More than double the current welfare bill of
£265bn. And total tax receipts were only £690bn. At first glance, this throws UBI under a train. But remember: UBI is an income, not welfare. And income
has economic benefits beyond government assistance. So let’s work out what it really costs, using the UK as an example. The answer is surprising.

  1. Replacing other welfare Easy targets first. UBI replaces all other welfare.
Housing benefit, Working Tax Credits, the State pension, unemployment benefits, Universal Credit, Statutory Sick Pay, Maternity Allowance, marriage allowances, everything. Because even among families receiving more than one of these, few rack up anything like the benefits cap of £26,000. And UBI adds up to £25,000 for a two-adult household. This takes £265bn off our £625bn figure straightaway. We’ve already improved our cost calculation by nearly half, to £360bn. And we’ve barely started.
  1. Replacing tax allowances
Next, recall that UBI replaces the taxable allowance: the first part of everyone’s income before tax kicks in. With no tax allowance, the actual tax take from people’s earnings goes up. There are 30m earners in the UK. Even accounting for income tax alone, that’s another sixty billion to pay for UBI, reducing its net cost to £300bn. But UK tax includes other taxes: National Insurance, payable by both employees (the part you see on your payslip) and employers (the part you don’t, because it’s added to your gross income by your employer first.)

This swings in another bucketload of cash: about £1,500 in employee NI on the first £12,500 of your salary, and another £1,725 by your employer. (Yes, NI
is huge.) Another £96bn in the pot, without any changes to the existing tax system. There are further benefits up the earnings scale, since higher tax rates
effectively kick in earlier: another £7bn or so. The net cost of UBI is down further, to £197bn. Less than the UK government has committed to various foreign wars, bank bailouts, or viral pandemics in a single year. And we’ve still got plenty of headroom.

helford · 18/12/2022 12:56

Better funded social care. Return of convalescent facilities, as a halfway house

No staff, its a MW job and seen as such, no one aspires to go into care, change that, open up EU workers to come here again.

Cut down middle management in the NHS and have more staff on the floor

NHS needs more and better management, where do medical staff come from?

Scrap HS2. No one wants it

No, change it to a normal line, UK doesn't need Hi speed but it does need capacity.

Cheaper childcare get people into work

Bells on! UK has most CC in Europe, why?

Annabel073 · 18/12/2022 12:55

Vimto1 · 18/12/2022 11:23

Because they didn't chose to be born to you? It's pure chance and your hard work also has an element of luck?

What makes your kids more deserving than anyone else's?

Realistically, how much do you think people care about anyone else's children? The actions of the majority clearly demonstrate the answer is very little.

Toddlerteaplease · 18/12/2022 12:33

Better funded social care. Return of convalescent facilities, as a halfway house.
Cut down middle management in the NHS and have more staff on the floor.
Scrap HS2. No one wants it.
Cheaper childcare get people into work.