Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have an idea you believe would significantly improve life in the UK?

508 replies

ConfusedmumUC · 17/12/2022 18:44

I’ll go first.

I can’t help but think making someone’s rent payments eligible to prove you can pay a mortgage would go a long way to housing security for so many people. And limiting the amount of properties owned by one landlord / amount a landlord can charge in rent, would also go a long way. I can’t help but think profiteering massively off of a basic need and right such as housing is really not ok.

Im sure there’s a reason why my idea wouldn’t work, feel free to put me right 😂

What’s your idea?

OP posts:
Underhisi · 19/12/2022 10:27

A school place available for every child.

whereaw · 19/12/2022 10:26

I also think that any policies have to take account of human behaviour and motivation. Eg what drives people to achieve more or work hard?

For many people it isn't the thought of doing good for society - just because that's what drives you doesn't mean it does for everyone.

For the majority of people, like all other animals, it's their offspring. Doing good and better for the future of them and their children.

I know countless people, myself included, who pre kids were pretty selfish and lost. Now that I have them I work day and night and all the hours under the sun to give them the best opportunities in life.

I'm not saying EVERYONE is like that. But many are. And we can't take the ability for people to better their children's life away without severely damaging the amount of work/ effort people put in.

Human nature is human nature. If my baby is crying and your baby is crying, I'm sorry but my innate response will be to comfort my baby.

So all the ideas that we have to improve the word have to take account of how it will drive people to act.

In my personal opinion I think people need to be given more autonomy and responsibility to better their own lives and those of their families/ children/ communities. The worst thing anyone can do is to take a victim mentality. It does no good for anyone, especially the person playing the victim.

And yes life is unfair.

Fairislefandango · 19/12/2022 10:21

Write proper textbooks for year 1 and up so teachers can spend more time teaching instead of building curriculums.

Much as I agree that teachers' workload is tough, I really wouldn't want to go back to mainly teaching from textbooks. We have textbooks, but we don't use them very much, because they are boring and get out of date fairly quickly, considering how expensive they are.

Blossomtoes · 19/12/2022 10:19

I can’t believe anyone would suggest burning books as a priority - or at all. Have we so quickly forgotten which regime last advocated that?

Ericaequites · 19/12/2022 09:58

Write proper textbooks for year 1 and up so teachers can spend more time teaching instead of building curriculums. Burn every copy of To Kill a Mockingbird and Of Mice andMen. If English youth might only read one book, it shouldn’t be a badly written American text. Copy the Australian education system. Pay teachers and nurses more so they will stay.

Annabel073 · 19/12/2022 09:38

whereaw · 19/12/2022 09:08

The thing is, there is luck in everything. Even if every baby is born with the same opportunities in life- same house, schooling, amount of money, attention from parents etc. there is still luck! Luck in how intelligent or attractive you are. Luck in how physically strong you are. Luck in the personality you're born with, your ability to see the good in things. Luck in how your brain works, how open you are to risk etc.

So if you started now with a baseline of equality for everyone, a few hundred years down the line some would have more and others less.

We can NEVER have equality. So if one child is much more attractive than all the others, should we disfigure their face to even it out a bit?

I'm all for equality in opportunities. But not equality in outcomes.

The idea that everyone works equally hard is just rubbish. It's partly based on who you are -luck - but also on how hard you work and what you do with the things you are given.

I agree with this. When I lived overseas in a low income country, I gave two of the families who had been particularly kind to me the same sum of money. One family donated the majority of this to the church and briefly enjoyed their increased status in the village while the other used it to purchase seedlings and exported the fruit with the help of a family member overseas, generating a decent income.

Notjustanymum · 19/12/2022 09:15

Rent and purchase price cap based on m2 of property, by location. Only way of removing the “asset” status of housing and returning it to utility. If it were calculated at todays prices, then frozen for 20 years, it might just revert to being affordable! (It would never work, though - but something needs to give!)

whereaw · 19/12/2022 09:08

The thing is, there is luck in everything. Even if every baby is born with the same opportunities in life- same house, schooling, amount of money, attention from parents etc. there is still luck! Luck in how intelligent or attractive you are. Luck in how physically strong you are. Luck in the personality you're born with, your ability to see the good in things. Luck in how your brain works, how open you are to risk etc.

So if you started now with a baseline of equality for everyone, a few hundred years down the line some would have more and others less.

We can NEVER have equality. So if one child is much more attractive than all the others, should we disfigure their face to even it out a bit?

I'm all for equality in opportunities. But not equality in outcomes.

The idea that everyone works equally hard is just rubbish. It's partly based on who you are -luck - but also on how hard you work and what you do with the things you are given.

JassyRadlett · 19/12/2022 08:47

DdraigGoch · 18/12/2022 23:42

Controversially, if you still smoke/vape in 2023, pay for your own NHS care. I don’t wish to work to support your death wish.

Smokers actually save the state money. If they lived to a ripe old age, they'd cost far more in pensions and social care. That's not to mention the stiff taxes on tobacco which mean that in practice they actually have paid for their care.

I thought that idea had been debunked?

Including the costs of lost economic activity, increased disability and far fewer disability-free years, and greater and longer reliance on health and social care during their lifetimes, the pension savings and tax don't offset it.

RamblingFar · 19/12/2022 08:26

Aintnosupermum · 19/12/2022 00:20

I really don’t like it when people think my success in life is attributable to luck. It’s not true. From a young age, about 7/8, I made sure I did all my homework as soon as I got home. I was very very average academically so knew I had to work twice as hard to get good grades.

After school I made lots of choices which helped further my career. I saved up when at university and moved to London post graduation. I worked multiple jobs, having 2-3 jobs at any time. I kept my expenses very low.

I moved abroad for my employer and realized I needed a U.S. qualification. I went back to school on evenings and weekends and got the credits needed to get my CPA license. I sat my CPA exams between the births of my first two children. It was really tough and my ex husband wasn’t the most supportive. I accomplished this without going into debt.

Speaking of it the ex… there was zero luck with that one. None of my successes were applauded. My career wasn’t supported. I wasn’t supported as the mother of our children. Yes he was working hard, but so was I. If it wasn’t for the women around me helping raise the children, I wouldn’t be where I am. It’s not luck that got me here. It’s a solid education, applying myself to my studies, prioritizing the important things first over fancy stuff, having good quality dependable childcare and eventually shaking off the husband who wasn’t pulling his weight.

What I want for everyone is support to be successful. Education, quality dependable childcare, safe housing and a proper diet are the cornerstones of being able to be in a position to make better choices. Better choices lead to better outcomes.

But to a certain degree it was still due to luck. An awful lot of hard work too, but a degree of luck. Your last paragraph sums it up. If you don't have those things in place, then it's a lot harder to succeed.

It's luck whether you end up being born in a stable home, with no disabilities, having space, light and time to do your homework, not needing to care for others in your childhood, not being homeless during your GCSEs/A levels, not being critically/long-term ill whilst establishing yourself, having a certain level of intelligence so you can study for qualifications, having a suitable school/college near enough your childhood home to attend post 16...

Like your last paragraph, I'd like to see a UK where even the unluckiest has sufficient food, heat and secure accommodation. However, I realise that no matter how hard some people strive, there is a certain amount of luck in how successful they can be. Some will always turn out on top, but I believe reducing the inequality gap for those that cannot do so through not fault of there own. For one thing, there are only so many 'good' or 'top' jobs and we still need people to fill the other jobs.

PlayIt · 19/12/2022 07:00

Ilovemycatalot · 18/12/2022 07:20

Make it easier to study to better yourself. A lot of people myself included would love to study for a higher income job but worry about the cost and how to support myself whilst studying as I have bills to pay and a dd to provide for.

@Ilovemycatalot I encourage you to take a look at apprenticeship degrees, via your employer. Employers with a £3m+ payroll bill each year, has to pay in to the apprenticeship levy**

In simple terms, it’s a tax on the business (IMO). Some companies are good at setting a learning strategy to ensure the money is spent wisely on apprenticeship schemes - but the word “apprenticeship” is lost on people in terms of it being available to those already employed. I’ve now got managers studying degree level courses (business, procurement, Continuous Improvement) funded by this levy (that we pay anyway)

You work whilst studying and dedicated 20% of the course to study (which organisation has to support you in). It’s not necessarily a day a week studying, because it tends to be evidence based and logging the things you’re doing linked to the subject matter.

**I think, but don’t quote me, smaller organisations can tap into other organisations’ levy that hasn’t been used, so even if you work for a smaller company, this could be open to you

Namenic · 19/12/2022 01:05

@Inkyblue123 - if you look at CO2 emissions per capita, China is nowhere near the worst. It’s also a bit hypocritical of the west to penalise countries which are less industrially developed and poorer. The west went through the Industrial Revolution much earlier and have had a lot of advantages.

Aintnosupermum · 19/12/2022 00:20

I really don’t like it when people think my success in life is attributable to luck. It’s not true. From a young age, about 7/8, I made sure I did all my homework as soon as I got home. I was very very average academically so knew I had to work twice as hard to get good grades.

After school I made lots of choices which helped further my career. I saved up when at university and moved to London post graduation. I worked multiple jobs, having 2-3 jobs at any time. I kept my expenses very low.

I moved abroad for my employer and realized I needed a U.S. qualification. I went back to school on evenings and weekends and got the credits needed to get my CPA license. I sat my CPA exams between the births of my first two children. It was really tough and my ex husband wasn’t the most supportive. I accomplished this without going into debt.

Speaking of it the ex… there was zero luck with that one. None of my successes were applauded. My career wasn’t supported. I wasn’t supported as the mother of our children. Yes he was working hard, but so was I. If it wasn’t for the women around me helping raise the children, I wouldn’t be where I am. It’s not luck that got me here. It’s a solid education, applying myself to my studies, prioritizing the important things first over fancy stuff, having good quality dependable childcare and eventually shaking off the husband who wasn’t pulling his weight.

What I want for everyone is support to be successful. Education, quality dependable childcare, safe housing and a proper diet are the cornerstones of being able to be in a position to make better choices. Better choices lead to better outcomes.

Cattenberg · 18/12/2022 23:48

What about passive smoking though? Also, there’s the economic cost of family members giving up work to care for a relative with COPD, cancer or a limb amputation.

DdraigGoch · 18/12/2022 23:42

Controversially, if you still smoke/vape in 2023, pay for your own NHS care. I don’t wish to work to support your death wish.

Smokers actually save the state money. If they lived to a ripe old age, they'd cost far more in pensions and social care. That's not to mention the stiff taxes on tobacco which mean that in practice they actually have paid for their care.

user1497207191 · 18/12/2022 22:42

mellicauli · 18/12/2022 22:18

I think everyone should pay national insurance contributions at the same level. We all use the national health service. So no discounts for self employed people or over 60s. We saw during the pandemic that self employed people DO get benefits from the state, so there's no justification for the discount.

I think that capital gains, dividends and interest from savings should be taxed at the same rate as . Capital gains when you sell your primary residence should also be taxable.

I also think that squirreling tax away in tax havens should be discouraged more rigorously.

Then we can use the extra money to properly fund the education, social care and health.

We’ll 3 million DIDNT get furlough nor SEISS grants, so presumably those excluded should get a NIC refund?

user1497207191 · 18/12/2022 22:40

mellicauli · 18/12/2022 22:18

I think everyone should pay national insurance contributions at the same level. We all use the national health service. So no discounts for self employed people or over 60s. We saw during the pandemic that self employed people DO get benefits from the state, so there's no justification for the discount.

I think that capital gains, dividends and interest from savings should be taxed at the same rate as . Capital gains when you sell your primary residence should also be taxable.

I also think that squirreling tax away in tax havens should be discouraged more rigorously.

Then we can use the extra money to properly fund the education, social care and health.

There certainly should be nic on property income such as buy to let’s or air bnb - no reason at all why not as many people regard it as a business.

mellicauli · 18/12/2022 22:18

I think everyone should pay national insurance contributions at the same level. We all use the national health service. So no discounts for self employed people or over 60s. We saw during the pandemic that self employed people DO get benefits from the state, so there's no justification for the discount.

I think that capital gains, dividends and interest from savings should be taxed at the same rate as . Capital gains when you sell your primary residence should also be taxable.

I also think that squirreling tax away in tax havens should be discouraged more rigorously.

Then we can use the extra money to properly fund the education, social care and health.

Cattenberg · 18/12/2022 22:10

NEmama · 18/12/2022 17:35

Make council tax the same throughout the country. And band based on last sold price. It's a joke at present

Council tax is indeed a joke. Around here, every village pays a slightly different rate. And in my town you can find four-bedroom houses in Band A and two-bedroom flats in Band D.

My street has a row of identically-built houses. Most are Band C, but a few which have since been extended, are Band D. Fair enough. But if you live in one of the two houses which happened to look a bit run down in 1995, you’re in luck. They’re indistinguishable from the rest of the street now, but they were put in Band B and that’s that!

Annabel073 · 18/12/2022 20:53

What a really sad view of the world and our species.

Why is it sad to acknowledge that some humans are highly creative, resourceful and hard working while others are lazy and happy to take from others?

Vimto1 · 18/12/2022 20:28

Annabel073 · 18/12/2022 20:24

My point is that all kids deserve "the best possible start in life" - do you disagree?

In a perfect world, yes, but it's just not realistic because human nature will ensure that inequality always exists.

What a really sad view of the world and our species.

How does your approach get us closer to that perfect world?

We can and should strive to achieve what we think is right. Not make the problem worse because 'it'll never happen'.

TheMatriarchy · 18/12/2022 20:27

Reform child support legislation and investigatory powers. Disgraceful the number of NRPs funnelling cash through businesses, driving new luxury cars and not paying a penny for their children.

Annabel073 · 18/12/2022 20:24

My point is that all kids deserve "the best possible start in life" - do you disagree?

In a perfect world, yes, but it's just not realistic because human nature will ensure that inequality always exists.

titbumwillypoo · 18/12/2022 20:17

Controversially, if you still smoke/vape in 2023, pay for your own NHS care. I don’t wish to work to support your death wish.

Obviously you'd include people who drive in that?

Pumperthepumper · 18/12/2022 20:17

Or if they fall while skateboarding?

Or if they get brain damage falling off a unicycle?

Or if they suffer burns while cooking something unhealthy?