Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have an idea you believe would significantly improve life in the UK?

508 replies

ConfusedmumUC · 17/12/2022 18:44

I’ll go first.

I can’t help but think making someone’s rent payments eligible to prove you can pay a mortgage would go a long way to housing security for so many people. And limiting the amount of properties owned by one landlord / amount a landlord can charge in rent, would also go a long way. I can’t help but think profiteering massively off of a basic need and right such as housing is really not ok.

Im sure there’s a reason why my idea wouldn’t work, feel free to put me right 😂

What’s your idea?

OP posts:
JonahAndTheSnail · 17/12/2022 22:17

Better career advice in school and more encouraged options to leave and pursue voactional careers early on. University isn't essential for many careers and if you can start to learn a trade at 16 with some business gumption behind you, you'll likely be much better off than your contemporaries far earlier on in life.

XenoBitch · 17/12/2022 22:15

Most controversial is that I wouldn’t allow anyone to be unemployed for more than 6 months if they are able to work. There is always something you can do. Sweeping streets, pick up litter, reading to children, preparation and/or delivering meals to the elderly. If you are disabled, it shouldn’t be assumed you can’t work, with remote, part time and flexible working utilized to keep people in the workforce

There are people with degrees who are struggling to find work after 6+ months. They wont even be considered for the most menial of jobs as they would be considered overqualified.
Good luck finding someone to employ me. No references or experience to show for 12 years now. I can't "simply" work from home when my ancient work history is physical jobs that can not be done from home.

Needtoseethatbiggerpicture · 17/12/2022 22:14

ILoveeCakes · 17/12/2022 20:04

People thinking teachers would be capable of teaching "life skills".

They went to school, uni then back to school.

What a ridiculous comment. I digester a classroom till I was 40. But teachers who go straight to the classroom still do normal life - relationships, buying houses, getting credit cards having babies, cooking tea getting divorced,....why would you suggest otherwise

Florenz · 17/12/2022 22:13

The BBC should be treated no differently to Netflix, Disney Plus or Crunchyroll or any of the other streaming services. Let them live or die on their own merit, they would have to improve a lot if they want people to choose to pay for their content on it's own merit.

Devoutspoken · 17/12/2022 22:05

UBI

Devoutspoken · 17/12/2022 22:05

Ragrunners, I thought obesity caused lots of illnesses too, but just alcohol is the problem you say?

Aintnosupermum · 17/12/2022 21:34

The population has increased massively in the past 40 years and yet no housing has been built because we are ‘protecting the greenbelt’. There also needs to be limits put in place to limit the increase in rent each year to CPI, unless the landlord can prove the increase is justified due to increased costs.

Education: Limit class sizes to 15 so teachers are not overworked and students get enough attention. Pay teachers really well so the best are attracted to the field.

Taxes: The whole system needs to be reformed. Households should be able to elect to file a return as a joint return for those who are married with children under 18.

Childcare for children under 16 should be fully deductible from income. If the child is disabled, childcare should be fully deducted for as long as the child remains with the children.

Everyone should have to pay a small fee to use the NHS unless your income is low, which is determined by your tax return. Services offered by the NHS should be limited to what is absolutely necessary. If you need IVF treatment, gastric bypass, tummy tuck etc where there is a benefit to your health, should be a deduction if the fee exceeds 10% of your income.

Not paying child support should be considered child abuse. Child abusers belong in jail. Child support should be paid from gross income not net so the lower paid parent gets more of the money.

Prison, I think the solution is to identify children at risk and provide extensive support early on. I think we need to be much more willing to remove children from irresponsible parents or parents who can’t cope. A good boarding school isn’t a bad option for these kids but adoption isn’t such a bad idea when they are young. The adoption process needs to be so much more supported than it currently is. These children have really had a bad start to life and I believe investment in therapy for these children and their adoptive families is better than trying to fix the parents.

Taxes on companies who don’t offer an apprenticeship program or support employees studying at universities for their bachelor while working should have a levy of 5% applied to their income to cover the cost of society paying this bill. At 18, completing a bachelor degree at all but top programs such as research programs like many of the courses offered at Oxbridge, should be a work study program. There should be zero tuition fees for a bachelor degree and subsidized fees for anyone doing a masters.

Most controversial is that I wouldn’t allow anyone to be unemployed for more than 6 months if they are able to work. There is always something you can do. Sweeping streets, pick up litter, reading to children, preparation and/or delivering meals to the elderly. If you are disabled, it shouldn’t be assumed you can’t work, with remote, part time and flexible working utilized to keep people in the workforce.

titbumwillypoo · 17/12/2022 21:33

DdraigGoch
The BBC isn't really the same. You can opt out of paying for it, as I have.
Which is true, but while the law allows fines for watching ANY live channel it could be argued that it is publicly funded and therefore a "Government department" I'd abolish the license fee, fund it out of general taxation and make it subject to rule 1

DandelionPockets · 17/12/2022 21:24

girlfriend44 · 17/12/2022 21:17

How's that going to be funded?

Have you missed the point of this thread? How is any of it funded...this is just a wish list.

DdraigGoch · 17/12/2022 21:19

Frabbits · 17/12/2022 21:12

I don't disagree that the planet, as a whole, is overpopulated.

The solution to that, however, is not making having a place to unaffordable for the people who have, y'know, already been born.

I wasn't suggesting making it unaffordable, just allowing people to voluntarily lay down their lives for the national benefit if they so choose. See here:

More seriously, we need to work to extend female emancipation to the developing world. Educating women so that they can have a purpose beyond childrearing has long been a surefire way of reducing birth rates.

girlfriend44 · 17/12/2022 21:17

DandelionPockets · 17/12/2022 19:05

Free childcare.

Would help with so many things.

How's that going to be funded?

buckingmad · 17/12/2022 21:14

Make private dental, health care and school payments tax deductible.

Private users are freeing up NHS/state school resources for those that can’t afford to go private.

Frabbits · 17/12/2022 21:12

DdraigGoch · 17/12/2022 21:08

At what cost to the environment?

Nah, we need to depopulate. With that in mind (and given the problems associated with an aging population), I would like to propose lifting all bans on tobacco advertising. That'll reduce life expectancy and boost tax revenue. Problem solved.

I would however put in a ban on anyone smoking within 100 clear yards of myself, because I can't stand the stench.

I don't disagree that the planet, as a whole, is overpopulated.

The solution to that, however, is not making having a place to unaffordable for the people who have, y'know, already been born.

NewToWoo · 17/12/2022 21:11

Chaneg the law so companies aren't legally obliged to put shareholder profits above customer value and staff conditions but the opposite: good pay and conditions for staff, fair price, then if there's any profit left over, it goes in dividends. I can't believe it is a legal obligation effectively to be greedy, exploitative and shoddy.

Ramblingnamechanger · 17/12/2022 21:10

Stop pandering to narcissist males, who are intent on destroying womens rights . Find people in govt who are not incompetent.

DdraigGoch · 17/12/2022 21:09

titbumwillypoo · 17/12/2022 21:02

▼ Gary Lineker - £1,350,000-£1,354,999
▼ Zoe Ball - £980,000-£984,999
▼ Steve Wright - £450,000-£454,999
▲ Stephen Nolan - £415,000-£419,999
▲ Fiona Bruce - £410,000-£414,999
▼ Huw Edwards - £410,000-£414,999
▲ Vanessa Feltz - £400,000-£404,999
▲ Scott Mills - £400,000-£404,999
▲ Greg James - £390,000-£394,999
▲ Ken Bruce - £385,000-£389,999
▼ Lauren Laverne - £380,000-£384,999
▲ Naga Munchetty - £365,000-£369,999
➤ George Alagiah - £325,000-£329,999
BBC director general's 16.6 per pay rise is “tone deaf and an insult” to staff. Tim Davie's rise – worth £75,000 and taking his pay to £525,000
I'm sure with more digging i could find a better list. The point is it's public money, if there is a fair cutoff then people can choose public service or they can choose the private sector.

The BBC isn't really the same. You can opt out of paying for it, as I have.

DdraigGoch · 17/12/2022 21:08

Frabbits · 17/12/2022 21:00

Do you realise how tiny a % of the UK is actually built on?

There is plenty room to build houses so everyone who ever needs one could have one affordably.

At what cost to the environment?

Nah, we need to depopulate. With that in mind (and given the problems associated with an aging population), I would like to propose lifting all bans on tobacco advertising. That'll reduce life expectancy and boost tax revenue. Problem solved.

I would however put in a ban on anyone smoking within 100 clear yards of myself, because I can't stand the stench.

XenoBitch · 17/12/2022 21:06

Ragruggers · 17/12/2022 20:20

Charge drunks who call ambulances and get taken to hospital because they can’t control how much they drink,also those who DNA medical appointments without a good reason.It is hard enough getting an appt for those who would attend.

A lot of my A&E admissions are due to alcohol, but also combined with MH issues.
How would you make the distinction between the two?
I was always told that if you are drunk, you are vulnerable, so still entitled to help.

Greendiamonds · 17/12/2022 21:04

Carers allowance to be higher and not be considered taxable

ScreamingFrog · 17/12/2022 21:03

DdraigGoch · 17/12/2022 20:37

I'd actually scrap inheritance tax (I've got no personal investment in this, my parents don't own enough to cross over the threshold for paying it). It's not really fair to expect people to sell grannies treasured possessions because they can't otherwise afford the tax bill, especially when the income used to buy them has already been taxed once. Instead I'd make granny's assets count for Capital Gains Tax, so that if/when you do liquidate them you are taxed on the income those assets earned if they appreciated since she bought them.

I'd roll CGT and Dividend tax into Income Tax, with the same rates and thresholds - I've never seen a good reason for capital gains or dividends getting their special low-tax status. They're income, like any other.

50p tax rate should come back, but I'd undo the clawback of the personal allowance that causes a 60p marginal rate.

Merge NI and Income Tax. There seems little point these days in keeping them separate. On the theme of simplification, I'd also remove the menagerie of tax allowances and exceptions.

A basic level of child maintenance should be payable, whatever the reported income of the father. It shouldn't matter if you work cash-in-hand to hide your income, or have 13 other kids to divide it between; if you spread your seed, you should still pay a basic subsistence level for each and every child. If you do earn more, then the courts could agree a higher payment. Non-payment should result in penalties - I believe that some states in the US will withhold your driving licence if there are arrears.

I’d vote for you.

Florenz · 17/12/2022 21:03

There needs to be more planning for the long-term future instead of just kicking the can down the road for future generations to deal with. The population needs to be reduced, not increased. There should be strict limitations on who is allowed to have children and how many children they are allowed to have. The aim should be to have more people who contribute more than they receive, and fewer people who just take, take, take, all their lives, with no thought given to anyone else.

Cattenberg · 17/12/2022 21:02

Increase NHS per capita funding to the amount spent by France or Australia. Or we could aim even higher and spend as much as Belgium, the Netherlands, Germany or Switzerland.

Ban MPs from voting on any legislation which relates to their own financial interests. Merely declaring any conflict of interest is not enough.

titbumwillypoo · 17/12/2022 21:02

▼ Gary Lineker - £1,350,000-£1,354,999
▼ Zoe Ball - £980,000-£984,999
▼ Steve Wright - £450,000-£454,999
▲ Stephen Nolan - £415,000-£419,999
▲ Fiona Bruce - £410,000-£414,999
▼ Huw Edwards - £410,000-£414,999
▲ Vanessa Feltz - £400,000-£404,999
▲ Scott Mills - £400,000-£404,999
▲ Greg James - £390,000-£394,999
▲ Ken Bruce - £385,000-£389,999
▼ Lauren Laverne - £380,000-£384,999
▲ Naga Munchetty - £365,000-£369,999
➤ George Alagiah - £325,000-£329,999
BBC director general's 16.6 per pay rise is “tone deaf and an insult” to staff. Tim Davie's rise – worth £75,000 and taking his pay to £525,000
I'm sure with more digging i could find a better list. The point is it's public money, if there is a fair cutoff then people can choose public service or they can choose the private sector.

DdraigGoch · 17/12/2022 21:02

Blossomtoes · 17/12/2022 20:50

Nobody in Government can earn more than 20x minimum wage £385, 000 a year is more than enough for someone in public service

I’d be stunned if anyone in the public sector earns anything like that now.

Network Rail is public sector, their board of directors are mostly on £300k+, with Andrew Haines on £585k. CEOs and CFOs of a number of other organisations reporting to the DfT and BEIS are also on £300k+. It's also worth looking at what some of the part time officials get, pro-rata some are on very handsome rates.

I'd set the threshold much lower though. 5x the lowest earner (pro rata).

Frabbits · 17/12/2022 21:00

Florenz · 17/12/2022 20:55

What happens when all the houses fill up? Build even more houses? What happens when there's no more room?

Do you realise how tiny a % of the UK is actually built on?

There is plenty room to build houses so everyone who ever needs one could have one affordably.