Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if I could/should get into teaching

94 replies

Whattodo182 · 17/12/2022 12:26

That really.

I'm looking for a career change, not an easy life FWIW.

I have a degree in a pretty vague humanities subject, but probably would be looking to get into history/English/social sciences teaching.

Is there a demand for these subjects? Lots of info online for funding for training but seems to be mostly science/maths. Could I take this route despite not having a relevant degree?

Any opinions/advice welcome

OP posts:
Philandbill · 17/12/2022 17:55

@EmmaDilemma5 so you're not actually a teacher then.... Our (excellent) admin staff come in after me and leave before I do so they don't actually know the hours I work each week. They do know I work every evening between 7 and 9 though as I often send emails then.
And as others have said, if it's all sunny uplands why are recruitment and retention such a problem in so many schools in so many areas?
The somewhat irritating Lucy Kellaway founded Now Teach for people who wanted to go into teaching in later life and made a big noise about how wonderful it was. Except that she couldn't hack it as a full time maths teacher and became a part time economics teacher very quickly.... There are also many teachers who work part time because full time hours are untenable with a family. Obviously if you work part time you are paid part time hours and your pension also takes a huge hit, so part time is not the panacea it is made out to be.

Chuckle94 · 17/12/2022 17:49

My partner is doing a PGCE I hope that’s right 😂 but he’s teaching science. Could you look into this if you want to teach?

Dippydinosaurus · 17/12/2022 17:49

EmmaDilemma5 · 17/12/2022 16:59

I don't know, for all those saying don't get into it... I work in a school and there are multiple teachers who have been in the professional 5-10 years who are on £40-50k in a single form entry primary school. They work 8-4.30pm most days and have PPA to do their planning and TAs who cover classes while they mark. So they don't have loads to do at home. 14 weeks holiday a year, paid. They get bit chunks of bonuses if they take on more responsibilities (which doesnt require much, planning assemblies and clubs etc).

Is it stressful? Yes. But any job paying that salary (close to home) usually is stressful.

The pay really isn't all that bad and it increases annually, despite performance, unlike lots of other roles. So you just need to stay where you are to build up a good salary.

And those in my school get a good work/life balance. They regularly have days off to go see their kids do performances or for appointments etc. Then there's the savings associated with no childcare in the holidays. And it's quite easy to work part time which isn't always possible in other sectors.

I guess it depends on what school they teach at.

I wouldn't want to do it, because I would be shattered being around kids all day. But I think, for an energetic, extraverted person, it would be a pretty good career path.

I'm sorry but do you actually work in a school. A person teaching for 5 years will be M5 at the most which is under £30k. I left teaching last year but NO teachers arrived at 8am and left at 4:30. PPA time I could plan maybe maths for the week but that's it - the rest I'd finish at home (working for free). If teachers did leave at 4:30 then they'd be leaving with 60 books to mark that evening (primary). Moving up the MPS is subject to meeting your targets (it is performance based) and is not guaranteed. It's a terrible work/life balance in term time which is most of the year - and I worked in a 'nice' school. I couldn't go to my children's nativity or sports days last year but I had to do the Christmas performance and sports day at school. It is not easy to switch to part time, even with Union help. Yes it does depend on which school as some are better than others but mine was a great school but was still awful for work life balance. It was just about manageable without children but not all when I had children

Sinthie · 17/12/2022 17:48

I enjoy teaching part time in a very good sixth form, but it’s still pretty challenging with evening work and weekend marking etc. I'm also very experienced so it’s slightly “easier”. I would never teach secondary.

Piggywaspushed · 17/12/2022 17:42

EmmaDilemma5 · 17/12/2022 16:59

I don't know, for all those saying don't get into it... I work in a school and there are multiple teachers who have been in the professional 5-10 years who are on £40-50k in a single form entry primary school. They work 8-4.30pm most days and have PPA to do their planning and TAs who cover classes while they mark. So they don't have loads to do at home. 14 weeks holiday a year, paid. They get bit chunks of bonuses if they take on more responsibilities (which doesnt require much, planning assemblies and clubs etc).

Is it stressful? Yes. But any job paying that salary (close to home) usually is stressful.

The pay really isn't all that bad and it increases annually, despite performance, unlike lots of other roles. So you just need to stay where you are to build up a good salary.

And those in my school get a good work/life balance. They regularly have days off to go see their kids do performances or for appointments etc. Then there's the savings associated with no childcare in the holidays. And it's quite easy to work part time which isn't always possible in other sectors.

I guess it depends on what school they teach at.

I wouldn't want to do it, because I would be shattered being around kids all day. But I think, for an energetic, extraverted person, it would be a pretty good career path.

There is no way anyone you work with in a one form entry school after 5 years teaching is on 50k. Unless they're the head.

There are no bonuses in teaching.

You yourself don't appear to be a teacher so I have no idea where this apparent expertise on salary comes from.

OP, what do you currently do?

Happtimescoming · 17/12/2022 17:40

@ConnieTucker interesting, maths wouldn’t be an option, I have no interest in it and am no good at it…poor kids! Honestly the thing that puts me off is the salary, I don’t mind a bit of working in the evenings, to be honest most corporate jobs especially WFH ones you end up working more than your contracted hours if you want to stay on top of things etc…BUT the difference is I’ve worked my way up and am on £60k..at my stage of life it’s hard to go back to the ‘beginning’ of a salary ladder and start again. I started on £28k in mu company 15 years ago…also, living for the holidays, I think that’s also the norm in most jobs, everyone lives for the holidays unless you are one of those rare workaholics who are truly passionate about work…and teachers get more holiday to ‘live for’. If the starting salary was about 10-15k more I could make it work, but never going to happen 🙄. I have a supportive husband but couldn’t cope with after school commitments multiple days a week, maybe when kids are older but not now. Hats off to all teaches you do a fab job!

earsup · 17/12/2022 17:35

I dont think any demand now for history or social sciences...they all want maths and physics teachers....i got redundancy about 5 years ago and then claimed pension early...i worked part time in FE college, well paid and work load was ok and had colleagues that coasted along for years doing very litte, lots of nasty managers also so i took the deal and now may do some supply work ?

Haralambus · 17/12/2022 17:30

I’m an English teacher of 29 years! Love it but term time is relentless. I broke up yesterday and as usual am now feeling ill and run down.
Do your research carefully though and if you find a good school, it can be really rewarding. It’s also relatively family friendly in the holidays at least. Hours are long in term time - I do about 60 a week. As people say, get into some schools and talk to teachers.

pompomdaisy · 17/12/2022 17:26

Husband just left secondary school teaching yesterday after 17 years. He's wrung out. He is going into FE teaching but it means a big pay cut but it's his health that counts right now! Give your head a good wobble.

Kenwoodmixitup · 17/12/2022 17:23

Run for the hills NOW

Lostinalibrary · 17/12/2022 17:22

People aren’t saying ‘no’ just because. Look at the attrition rates. The average career nowadays is less than 5 years. If teaching is the sunlit uplands, why is recruitment and retention such a problem? The older career teachers are staying because they can’t beat it for money. Earlier career teachers are leaving in droves or just not signing up at all.

I am ok where I am for now - however I’ve seen the ECT/ITT format break lots of people who are leaving teaching not to return. Why do you think the ECT wages were raised the most? This is a well known pinch point.

Doesn’t mean you shouldn’t try teaching however, as someone who is actively doing this as a new career under the new framework (not seen anyone else on this thread yet) I’m telling you it’s not quite the sunlit uplands being made out by some. Critical thinking would tell you that if you look at teacher attrition.

Orangepink5 · 17/12/2022 17:15

Philandbill · 17/12/2022 16:42

@Orangepink5 genuinely interested to know why you aren't still teaching.
@tobee OFSTED are like the sword of Damocles hanging over our heads. And they do not offer any decent support post inspection. Recruitment/ retention is very difficult so teachers at the chalk face are often covering multiple areas and those who are middle and senior leaders are also trying to paper over the cracks. It is exhausting.

I’m taking a break while my children are tiny as I am able to do I’d like to spend the time with them. When they start school I’ll go back

cansu · 17/12/2022 17:10

Orange pink
I think things have changed. Most schools finish at 3.45. In most schools I have worked in there are after school meetings twice a week until 5. It is rather incompatible with family life unless you have a spouse at home. I have been a teacher for over 25 years. It has become more demanding.

Confusedteacher · 17/12/2022 17:10

@EmmaDilemma5 the pay doesn’t increase annually automatically, you have to meet your performance management targets which are very specific.

And for most teachers PPA is a drop in the ocean in terms of planning time. Unless you’re actually a teacher I don’t think you can really comment on how much work you think the teachers in your school do in their own time.

tobee · 17/12/2022 16:59

Presumably recruitment/retention might improve if ofsted changed.

EmmaDilemma5 · 17/12/2022 16:59

I don't know, for all those saying don't get into it... I work in a school and there are multiple teachers who have been in the professional 5-10 years who are on £40-50k in a single form entry primary school. They work 8-4.30pm most days and have PPA to do their planning and TAs who cover classes while they mark. So they don't have loads to do at home. 14 weeks holiday a year, paid. They get bit chunks of bonuses if they take on more responsibilities (which doesnt require much, planning assemblies and clubs etc).

Is it stressful? Yes. But any job paying that salary (close to home) usually is stressful.

The pay really isn't all that bad and it increases annually, despite performance, unlike lots of other roles. So you just need to stay where you are to build up a good salary.

And those in my school get a good work/life balance. They regularly have days off to go see their kids do performances or for appointments etc. Then there's the savings associated with no childcare in the holidays. And it's quite easy to work part time which isn't always possible in other sectors.

I guess it depends on what school they teach at.

I wouldn't want to do it, because I would be shattered being around kids all day. But I think, for an energetic, extraverted person, it would be a pretty good career path.

tobee · 17/12/2022 16:58

Thank you @Philandbill . At the risk of derailing, I wonder how they could change ofsted and the power they have?

LovelyRachel · 17/12/2022 16:51

Where can I find a list of shortage subjects?

I work in Science / STEM x

MrsHamlet · 17/12/2022 16:48

Samjamm · 17/12/2022 16:31

How do you expect to be a Science or Maths teacher without the relevant degree?

Many non specialist teachers are found to be teaching Science and Maths, but it's only because there aren't enough of us.

It isn't fair on the kids.

Also I don't know what university or school (if you go down school direct route) would accept you onto a course without a relevant degree.

Do you have a level Maths? That's the only way I could see someone teaching secondary Maths who didn't have a degree.

8 week SKE courses exist so that people with any kind of degree can teach shortage subjects.

LovelyRachel · 17/12/2022 16:45

@Whattodo182 thanks for the thread. It's really pushed me into making a decision to retrain (and be part time asap)

Confusedteacher · 17/12/2022 16:42

I retrained as a teacher 5 years ago in a shortage subject.
pros- decent salary (compared to what I was on before at least!) holidays off with the kids, colleagues are generally lovely (teaching attracts nice people!) working with kids can be very rewarding etc etc
cons- term time is exhausting, you have to be very resilient as someone is always trying to tell you how to improve, massive workload, behaviour in every school I have worked in so far, and in every other school I hear about is really going downhill at the moment.

If you do it, go part time as soon as you can! It’s the only way to make it work, full time nearly broke me!

Philandbill · 17/12/2022 16:42

@Orangepink5 genuinely interested to know why you aren't still teaching.
@tobee OFSTED are like the sword of Damocles hanging over our heads. And they do not offer any decent support post inspection. Recruitment/ retention is very difficult so teachers at the chalk face are often covering multiple areas and those who are middle and senior leaders are also trying to paper over the cracks. It is exhausting.

ConnieTucker · 17/12/2022 16:39

Lostinalibrary · 17/12/2022 16:34

No don’t - I’m an ECT, I don’t know one person from my PGCE who is staying. We aren’t pension trapped.

We have two trainees atm. I dont see one making the year. And has already skipped the uni day more than once. Cannot cope with the workload, and the workload for them at this stage is relatively tiny. The other has already started enquiring about other roles. Not even finished one term.

ConnieTucker · 17/12/2022 16:36

Happtimescoming · 17/12/2022 16:15

This is all really interesting…I have a 1 year old and a 4 year old, and an English Lit degree along with a love of the subject/books/reading. Currently have a corporate career with an opportunity to take a large redundancy package potentially soon. I considered teaching as a) would be teaching something interesting - my courage job is boring and doesn’t inspire me. B) we have no grandparents or outside help so not having to sort childcare for the holidays for my 4 year old now she’s at school would be HUGE. It’s a struggle at the moment and I feel so guilty having to put her into holiday clubs. Also 1 year old could gonterm time hours at nursery which would save us a huge amount of money . Is it that bad??? And what would the starting salary be for an in demand subject like English? With my currenT job I often end up working evenings to get on top of things so am used to hard hours…that would be ok if I got holidays off? Talk me down!!! Haha

The main thing here is this would be a live for the holidays mentality. Wishing your life away. It is how most teachers i know live.

the problem with this is the amount of after school commitments and whether you have a solid husband. There are weekly (at least) after school meetings, parents evenings until 7 or 8 for every year group, open evening until 9pm, awards evening, random events you have to supervise, residentials. Fine if part of a couple. Difficult if a single parent as not much childcare available until the evening.

LovelyRachel · 17/12/2022 16:36

SleeplessWB · 17/12/2022 16:23

The key is all about finding the right school for you. I love my job, the kids, the sense of community in the school and wouldn't change it for the world. I get to spend all the holidays with my children which is worth so much.

Yes this is exactly what my teacher friends say!

Swipe left for the next trending thread