Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we’ve been brainwashed over Christmas.

166 replies

FabYuleLous · 17/12/2022 08:10

I’ve noticed on MN, and in real life, that people get very upset if their Christmas does not resemble a supermarket advert with 20 people, all generations, around a massive feast, all having a super time.

Seriously, how many of us have families like this. If you got 20 family members round a table, would it really be like that.

I know if I got 20 round a table of our family, it would look like this: DB1 being in a mood, as his life hasn’t turned out like my other DB. Me crying in the kitchen as I’d been manipulated into hosting and doing all the work and expense. PIL being PA to me, no present and criticising the meal and SIL giving me filthy looks throughout. On top of this my DC moaning that we have loads of people round.

I don’t think I’m abnormal.

So, seriously. Why are are all buying into this 20 people round a table, with a Hogwarts spread, bullshit?

Just to add. This year I’ve actually gone to the trouble of reading up about our traditions and customs around Christmas, and learnt things I didn’t know. We celebrate it blindly, and don’t even know why we are doing things we do.

OP posts:
Forfrigz · 17/12/2022 08:57

I think what OP means is it's silly to compare how Christmas is for us to the idealised version but as we know that's always the case. I believe at Christmas you should make an effort to see family even if you don't get on. Night not be everyone's view and yes it might be awkward if you do it but for me I would feel bad if I didn't at least try to see them and wish them a merry Christmas. Doesn't mean I'd slave all day to cater for them all at once, mind. I think most families have their own traditions and ways of doing Christmas and yes a lot of the time it won't look like the adverts but behind the adverts and most people's ways are just simply showing good will to one another.

Palacepicker · 17/12/2022 08:57

We've recently moved to the same city as the inlaws. Dd wanted the big family Christmas, I have put my foot down and said no - there are so many tensions in the family, bickering over whatsapp - it sometimes feels like we're in an episode of Eastenders - no way I want that scene played out in my house any day nevermind at Christmas.
I grew up with horrific Christmas Days - alcoholic parents, tensions, arguments - so my idea of a perfect Christmas is low key, no fuss and no relatives. I'd cancel the event if I could and I have tried but dh and the kids objected.🙄

HotMummaSummer · 17/12/2022 08:52

There will be 9 around our table, maybe 11 if elderly grandparents decide to come. My parents, my sister and her boyfriend, one of my oldest friends and her son and me with my 2 kids. My sis wants to do all the cooking as she loves cooking! We all get on great and will have a lovely time in sure ☺️
My husband, on the other hand, is working nights in A&E over Christmas so we are visiting his parents this week and even getting and early Christmas dinner and some presents too. Of course, many adverts don't show the staff on the Nightshift on Christmas day but it's just one of those things. My kids are young anyway and we'll have many more together!

LlynTegid · 17/12/2022 08:51

One of the responses to difficult times is to make more of celebrations, holidays etc, and in general there has been the upscaling of such events (think stag/hen weekends or weeks away instead of a night out as an example). Christmas is no exception, on top of the last two where they were restricted or people could not travel to be together.

Cakeandcardio · 17/12/2022 08:51

My Granny used to host 19 every year. It was amazing and she was (still) the best cook I've ever known. She seemed to make it all come together effortlessly - choice of two soups, whole turkey and all the trimmings and a pudding. They were great days and I feel sorry my son doesn't have that. But that's what I was always used to. I haven't been brainwashed by advertising - it's just something a lot of people do or did have.

Octo5 · 17/12/2022 08:50

I did do an assembly at school about what a ‘real’ Christmas looks like.

Some people have large families with lots of food and presents but most live with 1 parent or no siblings.
Many will not have large amounts of food or presents.

Some open their presents first thing in their PJs, some have to dress up and wait until a certain time in the afternoon.

Everyone is different and there is no right or wrong way to do it but it’s important not to guilt trip others for the way they do theirs.

BabyFour2023 · 17/12/2022 08:50

Wonnle · 17/12/2022 08:47

It's always been the same , spend loads of money on stuff and get enough food to last a month at least all for one day .Then spend months paying it off on the credit card

By doing this you will all have the "perfect" christmas that everyone else has .

One word "BOLLOCKS!" to that

You shouldn’t be putting Christmas on a credit card. Why are you getting into debt for one day?

Wonnle · 17/12/2022 08:48

TheaBrandt · 17/12/2022 08:44

Nah. Thinks it’s your family. We will be 10 on Xmas day then 20 on Boxing Day. They are all lovely and pitch in so it’s lovely.

Sounds like my idea of hell .

Computersaysno123 · 17/12/2022 08:47

I've never felt pressure to do anything. Last yeah just me and my kids and DH same this year. I'll see my family over the period but the day is mine and no one has ever really cared what we do. Love my family and did a 20 people one the Xmas before lockdown so not against it, fancied it that year but don't always

Octo5 · 17/12/2022 08:47

TV is fake.

SM is fake.

Do whatever makes you happy.

I don’t think TV/SM is the problem.

It’s the family (usually mothers or MIL) who guilt trip people into doing stuff they don’t want to, just because ‘it’s Christmas’.

The threads have been full of mostly women who are dreading Christmas because they’ve been manipulated into doing something they don’t want to do.
I think this is a much bigger issue than the TV adverts.

Wonnle · 17/12/2022 08:47

It's always been the same , spend loads of money on stuff and get enough food to last a month at least all for one day .Then spend months paying it off on the credit card

By doing this you will all have the "perfect" christmas that everyone else has .

One word "BOLLOCKS!" to that

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 17/12/2022 08:46

Well I love spending time with my family and I love hosting, and cooking, at any time of the year, so we do buy in to what you see on the adverts but I don't feel like the adverts have brainwashed me because we do it all year round

TheaBrandt · 17/12/2022 08:44

Nah. Thinks it’s your family. We will be 10 on Xmas day then 20 on Boxing Day. They are all lovely and pitch in so it’s lovely.

MamaFirst · 17/12/2022 08:44

I voted YANBU because I agree with your sentiment, most families are definitely not like that though some people will absolutely sacrifice their actual happiness to maintain that image and ideal. But I don't think most people do expect that advert 'perfect' Christmas in reality, I actually find it refreshing to see on here how many people do Christmas their own way.

We have Christmas just us and its perfect to me. I am a sucker for a tradition though and feel they make the magic, in my family.

pd339 · 17/12/2022 08:43

Congratulations on getting your first glimpse of the matrix - the more you look the more you'll realise that every single aspect of our lives is (to some extent) controlled by companies seeking to make profit from us. Be careful though, once you realise and become a cynic, there's no going back!

Fairislefandango · 17/12/2022 08:42

Also I agree with pp that the narrative on MN seems to be that the best Christmas is to stay at home in your pyjamas and not go and visit extended family. And obviously that's absolutely fine if that's what makes you happy!

Judgyjudgy · 17/12/2022 08:42

I've been more saddened by all the threads obsessed with gifts, this seems to be what is most important to many people Xmas Sad

Fairislefandango · 17/12/2022 08:40

As much as i feel genuine sympathy for people who have awful or difficult family members, adverts are not to blame for that, and it would be wholly unreasonable to expect them to try and advertise their products by depicting miserable, arguing families.

KimberleyClark · 17/12/2022 08:40

It will be 5 of us round the table on Christmas Day - me, DH, DB, SIL and DN - plus a big dog underneath it. No surviving parents and no other siblings on either side. Boxing Day we just relax and host no one.

Christmascandycane · 17/12/2022 08:39

I was talking about this to someone the other day.

You are correct. If getting together with everyone is so much fun, we would do it throughout the year (if you do then this does not apply).

Any excuses of work or life getting in the way is exactly that - an excuse.

You have never failed to manage time for holiday or days out, weddings etc. This all evidences that if it was truly enjoyable, people would do it throughout the year.

The truth for many is that we are trying to engineer, force and replicate an ideology that has been sold to us over and over.
The happy ending on movies when they are all gloriously sharing dinner and enjoying each others company. Images by retailers that if you buy their goods and assemble the people and goods, you will acquire the dream and gain positive memories.

The truth is often that you are bringing together a bunch of people that feel obligated to be around each other and expect them to be polite and jolly.
Let's face it, there is enough posts on here before and after Christmas that evidences that people just get on each others tits when they bring their nuclear family and join it with extended.

We repeat this process annually hoping that whilst enduring the shit show, we can experience a few positive moments to validate us doing it and convince ourselves it is true.

It's a load of toads bollocks.

Mamamia7962 · 17/12/2022 08:39

Christmas advertising is no different to any other. Christmas is about families getting together so of course the adverts are going to show large families having a wonderful time.
Summer holiday adverts usually show mum, dad and 2 children (one of each) having a fabulous time. Adverts like this do not show the reality of life. The majority of people know this.

Girasoli · 17/12/2022 08:37

We wouldn't have 20 in the UK (not enough relatives!) but there's usually 8 or 9 of us.
Christmases in Italy its been close to 20 a few times (if all the abroad relatives are visiting my gran the same year)

I love Christmas but we all chip in, not just the women (DBro doesn't really but he is an NHS shift worker so we are just happy if he can turn up that year)

Onnabugeisha · 17/12/2022 08:37

Andsoforth · 17/12/2022 08:30

I have a theory that on that first Christmas the reason that M&J ended up in a stable, when they had gone to his hometown was that her in laws were being horrible. And the reason he didn’t leave her at home and go by himself was because her family were shunning her (apart from Elizabeth who had her own messy marriage problems)

So imo, playing multi generational happy families around the Christmas table is just unchristian.

I suppose one could speculate this if they hadn’t read the Bible…
or is this sarcasm, and I’m missing it? 😅

panko · 17/12/2022 08:37

Lockdown christmas was quite relaxing for us even though it was sad not spending LO's first Xmas with wider family.

Heatherbell1978 · 17/12/2022 08:36

I end up doing all the hosting over Xmas and Boxing Day which I hate. Complex situation of two sets of divorced parents and me having kids whereas my 3 brothers don't and are single and would never consider (or be capable of..) hosting. Thankfully DH enjoys cooking and hosting so I don't have to carry the full load. But I think once we're over the Santa years we'll bugger off over Xmas instead.