Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we’ve been brainwashed over Christmas.

166 replies

FabYuleLous · 17/12/2022 08:10

I’ve noticed on MN, and in real life, that people get very upset if their Christmas does not resemble a supermarket advert with 20 people, all generations, around a massive feast, all having a super time.

Seriously, how many of us have families like this. If you got 20 family members round a table, would it really be like that.

I know if I got 20 round a table of our family, it would look like this: DB1 being in a mood, as his life hasn’t turned out like my other DB. Me crying in the kitchen as I’d been manipulated into hosting and doing all the work and expense. PIL being PA to me, no present and criticising the meal and SIL giving me filthy looks throughout. On top of this my DC moaning that we have loads of people round.

I don’t think I’m abnormal.

So, seriously. Why are are all buying into this 20 people round a table, with a Hogwarts spread, bullshit?

Just to add. This year I’ve actually gone to the trouble of reading up about our traditions and customs around Christmas, and learnt things I didn’t know. We celebrate it blindly, and don’t even know why we are doing things we do.

OP posts:
WimbyAce · 17/12/2022 10:07

BabyFour2023 · 17/12/2022 10:04

For some of us, 15-20 is close family.

Yeah true, similar for me but we won't see each other same day. We see one side Christmas day and one side boxing day.

BabyFour2023 · 17/12/2022 10:04

WimbyAce · 17/12/2022 10:02

I get what you mean, the adverts with loads of people dropping in and big spreads of food. Normally only about 7/8 of us together at Christmas. Close family only, I wouldn't want to spend it with my extended family!

For some of us, 15-20 is close family.

BabyFour2023 · 17/12/2022 10:03

Palacepicker · 17/12/2022 09:51

And feel for those who have the big family experience - it’s al surface and full of back biting manipulation and passive aggressive behaviour that they feel compelled to put up with “because it’s Christmas” I feel massively relieved not to have to take part!

It makes me sad this must be your experience to have these views. Passive aggression? Manipulation? Having to put up with it?
this is in no way reflective of many families at Christmas and it’s quite sad that you have this type of family. I can assure you; many of us are far from manipulative and passive aggressive to our families. Mine is very, very happy and we love our massive family Christmas’.

WimbyAce · 17/12/2022 10:02

I get what you mean, the adverts with loads of people dropping in and big spreads of food. Normally only about 7/8 of us together at Christmas. Close family only, I wouldn't want to spend it with my extended family!

Loachworks · 17/12/2022 10:02

I have this on both sides of my family and have had them both together in the past when I was well. Now I choose what Christmas looks like and it's always a great time.
I think it might be relevant that we open our home and so do they, several times a year and there is only love towards each other. The only family group that would take advantage is SIL and they run businesses that opens Christmas Day so that problem is easily solved.
When I see the MN trope of making an appointment to visit family and setting up Christmas with people you never stay with for the rest of the year I think you're looking for trouble. If someone wants a quiet one or are going away that doesn't matter either. There seems to be so much pressure to get it right but there is no right or wrong. x

TheaBrandt · 17/12/2022 10:01

It’s not the adverts though. Haven’t you read your Dickens?! We basically have a similar Christmas to the one my grandparents had as children so not really getting what tv ads have to do with anything!

5foot5 · 17/12/2022 10:00

Andsoforth · 17/12/2022 08:30

I have a theory that on that first Christmas the reason that M&J ended up in a stable, when they had gone to his hometown was that her in laws were being horrible. And the reason he didn’t leave her at home and go by himself was because her family were shunning her (apart from Elizabeth who had her own messy marriage problems)

So imo, playing multi generational happy families around the Christmas table is just unchristian.

No it was their own silly fault really for not booking somewhere in good time. Everywhere is so busy at this time of year.

Yarrawonga · 17/12/2022 09:59

Both my husband and I have quite big families and we all get on, so 12 or 14 for Christmas dinner is not unusual, including some who belong to religions that don’t celebrate Christ.

MajorCarolDanvers · 17/12/2022 09:56

Sorry about your family.

Some families are nice and get on. Our la does.

Palacepicker · 17/12/2022 09:51

Stunningscreamer · 17/12/2022 09:47

I think the hardest thing for people who don't have that happy family experience is that it starts in September with all the advertising and the stuff in the shops. I know the shops have to do it because it's their most lucrative time but it does make it harder for people who don't have that harmonious family.

I think it's wonderful for those who have big, happy families. I'm so jealous of them and don't begrudge it. But I do feel for people who have to put up with enforced jollity, or who have to do all the work, or those that would love to have people around but don't have the loved ones through no fault of their own. And the amount of noise round it and the fact it goes on for so long does make it hard for those people.

And feel for those who have the big family experience - it’s al surface and full of back biting manipulation and passive aggressive behaviour that they feel compelled to put up with “because it’s Christmas” I feel massively relieved not to have to take part!

sashh · 17/12/2022 09:50

I just ignore it.

But a few years ago my dad was about to turn 80. I managed to get about 30 people from various parts of the country in tot he same pub without my dad knowing what was going on so I don't mind big gathersings.

I also love hosting, my health doesn't allow me to do that much these days, but I used to regularly do 5 course meals.

turkeyboots · 17/12/2022 09:49

Yanbu. If I had all the inlaws and my family round, I'd be feeding 23 people. Not sure I could get them in the house and certainly don't have enough chairs or tables! And that totally ignoring the potential for rows.

PearlclutchersInc · 17/12/2022 09:49

It's always been that way from the happy ending in A Christmas Carol onwards.

For what it's worth I love my family dearly but we're all very different personalities and being together for more than a couple of very sober hours is beyond us. So we just don't do it.

We do get together but at a less pressured time. There are other ways to show each other that you care.

Stunningscreamer · 17/12/2022 09:47

I think the hardest thing for people who don't have that happy family experience is that it starts in September with all the advertising and the stuff in the shops. I know the shops have to do it because it's their most lucrative time but it does make it harder for people who don't have that harmonious family.

I think it's wonderful for those who have big, happy families. I'm so jealous of them and don't begrudge it. But I do feel for people who have to put up with enforced jollity, or who have to do all the work, or those that would love to have people around but don't have the loved ones through no fault of their own. And the amount of noise round it and the fact it goes on for so long does make it hard for those people.

hellycat · 17/12/2022 09:46

I agree with you. It's all the 'having people' that causes the stress.

Generally speaking, do people want to be 'had round' on Christmas Day? A divorced or widowed mum or dad, certainly, who would be alone otherwise, but I have NEVER seen the sense of inviting a couple, or another entire family. Wouldn't it be less stressful if we just kept CD slightly atomised, and did the socialising before and after? I know many childless people feel pressurised to be 'had round' by their married families and hate sitting there in someone else's house all day on CD as the uncle or aunt who has nowhere else to go. They'd rather just go for a bloody hike or sit at home alone eating baked beans.

mondaytosunday · 17/12/2022 09:46

The traditional family Xmas is usually portrayed as a disaster waiting to happen! But I've had the occasional extended family meal and it's been fine, though far prefer it in my own home.
What I don't understand is the idea we are partying all month long, and feel bad if not. Even in my free and easy single no kids days it was perhaps the work do, a friends dinner party and maybe a neighbourhood drinks thing. That's it.

Bbq1 · 17/12/2022 09:42

We have a small family especially since my lovely dad and mum in law passed away. There's just me, Dh, ds and my mum on Christmas Day. I see dsis, dB and dh's uncle just before or just after Xmas Day. We have a lovely day just the 4 of us and enjoy the meal, sharing presents and being together. Christmas is a very personal thing that we all enjoy and celebrate differently. As for the adverts... Well, adverts aren't going to show 2 people at a table celebrating quietly are they?They need big groups to show off their food. 20 people around a table is a massive exaggeration. The big groups usually consist of around 10 people. At the end of the day, adverts are just adverts. They aren't real life.

Babdoc · 17/12/2022 09:41

If people are daft enough to be either upset or manipulated by adverts, that’s their problem.
The celebration of Christ’s birth involves a church service at midnight on Christmas Eve and/or on Christmas morning.
Anything else - family dinners, turkey, presents, a tree - are optional extras.
If you enjoy a big gathering, have one. If not, don’t. Simple.
Personally, I enjoy carol singing round the village, going to the Watchnight service, laughing at the cute Sunday school kids doing their nativity play in church, and having family time with my lovely DDs and their partners. I do a lot of cooking in advance, and everyone mucks in to help on the day. It’s whatever you want to make it.

Ladysodor · 17/12/2022 09:35

This has been the case for years.

dementedma · 17/12/2022 09:33

We have never had an extended family Christmas as people are widely scattered. I have 4 siblings and none will be here this year. Sis usually comes but is having Christmas on her own in London this year. Dd2 is having Christmas with her partner so it will just be dh,me and 2 adult kids plus elderly mum. Thats plenty for me. I hate crowded houses and lots of noise.
As a pagan I will enjoy celebrating the Solstice on my own just as much too.

underneaththeash · 17/12/2022 09:30

Fairislefandango · 17/12/2022 08:42

Also I agree with pp that the narrative on MN seems to be that the best Christmas is to stay at home in your pyjamas and not go and visit extended family. And obviously that's absolutely fine if that's what makes you happy!

That would be a shit Christmas, you can do that any Sunday.

I like hosting and having everyone there. We don't have 20 for Christmas, but we do on the 27th and I kist borrow an extra table from the local village hall.

Pothoswithasparkle · 17/12/2022 09:27

It's not tv who is doing that imho.
I just don't get why brits have to have the Christmas done in the most stressful way possible tbh and why it's just 1 day when Christmas is 3 + the period around.

Of course it will be stressful if you try to stuff literally all relatives, all traditions, presents and food into like 8 hour window!

Ylvamoon · 17/12/2022 09:26

Supermarkets need to sell those gigantic turkeys!

Ifailed · 17/12/2022 09:25

I have never lived in a house which could accomadate 20 people, certainly not all in the same room they just wouldn't fit. Come to think of it, I've never lived in a house with more than 6 dinning chairs.

FancyFanny · 17/12/2022 09:22

Everyone I know wants to have as few as possible to cook dinner for whilst still having a nice time. 6-8 is perfect. Any more is a hassle.