Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we’ve been brainwashed over Christmas.

166 replies

FabYuleLous · 17/12/2022 08:10

I’ve noticed on MN, and in real life, that people get very upset if their Christmas does not resemble a supermarket advert with 20 people, all generations, around a massive feast, all having a super time.

Seriously, how many of us have families like this. If you got 20 family members round a table, would it really be like that.

I know if I got 20 round a table of our family, it would look like this: DB1 being in a mood, as his life hasn’t turned out like my other DB. Me crying in the kitchen as I’d been manipulated into hosting and doing all the work and expense. PIL being PA to me, no present and criticising the meal and SIL giving me filthy looks throughout. On top of this my DC moaning that we have loads of people round.

I don’t think I’m abnormal.

So, seriously. Why are are all buying into this 20 people round a table, with a Hogwarts spread, bullshit?

Just to add. This year I’ve actually gone to the trouble of reading up about our traditions and customs around Christmas, and learnt things I didn’t know. We celebrate it blindly, and don’t even know why we are doing things we do.

OP posts:
FleasNavidad · 17/12/2022 12:13

There's 15 of us. I love it all, the food, the hosting, the laughter, being together, the games. You do you OP and I'll do me.

SirMingeALot · 17/12/2022 12:13

It's a mixture of both, which is why it has such blatantly obvious pagan elements and blatantly obvious Christian elements.

Oakbeam · 17/12/2022 12:08

Christmas is a Pagan festival, not Christian.

I wish people would stop peddling this crap. How man pagans do you know who celebrate Christmas, the birth of Christ? Did any ever?

Nobody knows exactly when Christ was born. Nevertheless, early Christians wanted to celebrate his birth. Since they all had December 25th free in their diaries now that they had converted from whatever they worshipped before, it was an obvious date to choose.

SpongeBob2022 · 17/12/2022 11:54

*wouldn't like this. Hate that you can't edit on MN

SpongeBob2022 · 17/12/2022 11:54

As a kid we always saw extended family at Christmas so 10ish people for lunch minimum. I loved it.

As an adult it ranges from 8 to 18 and I still love it. I don't mind if I've been brainwashed...I like the bustle of it and we all have fun.

In reality on MN and other forums I see more of wanting to have Christmas just as a small household. I'm introverted and like being at home but I really wouldn't not like this. Each to their own though.

In real life I don't know anyone who doesn't see extended family on Christmas Day and I also don't know anyone who doesn't get on well with their families.

JudgeJ · 17/12/2022 11:50

Onnabugeisha · 17/12/2022 08:37

I suppose one could speculate this if they hadn’t read the Bible…
or is this sarcasm, and I’m missing it? 😅

Or maybe just an attempt to make people smile but on MN everything has a sinister backstory!

Pismascrescents · 17/12/2022 11:45

Christmas is a Pagan festival, not Christian. The Yule Log is Pagan, the Tree is pagan. St Nicholas is Christian to be fair. I love it currently cooking orange slices and got my cinnamon to tie in a bow on the tree, just bought some golden coins.

The brainwashing but to me is definitely to do with how many presents people expect. Especially in a cost of living crisis.

We are having about 8 people just the right amount and a few games. I can’t wait! It’s been a cold and miserable winter, the kids have been sick, I’ve had to work really long hours, a few people I’ve done nothing to have randomly taken time out of their life to be horrible etc. so the run up seeing lots of groups of friends then family will be all the better.

Hushpuppy1 · 17/12/2022 11:44

The entire point of all advertising is to manipulate viewers into buying stuff. Christmas advertising is no different.

Palacepicker · 17/12/2022 11:39

Hbh17 · 17/12/2022 11:32

Absolutely correct.
Celebrating Christmas is not compulsory and we should all be able to choose what we do/don't do.
The only part of Christmas that matters is that it is a Christian festival but, sadly, so many people forget that. I dislike Christmas and generally ignore it but I do love to listen to the Festival of Nine Lessons & Carols on Xmas Eve - that is proper Christmas.
But there is somehow a tyranny that says we all have to conform to stereotypes and the whole "20 people round a family table" thing is the most ghastly and damaging stereotype of all.

You tell us we should be able to choose what we do yet you'd like to tell us that the only thing that matters is that it is a Christian festival and we are all sadly forgetting the thing that you think is important 😂I won't go into the many reasons why this is such bullshit it's been done to death - every year.
Everyone feels imposed upon - if it's not the advertisers and the retail industry it's the bloody religious zealots telling us we're not doing it right!🙄

SirMingeALot · 17/12/2022 11:38

The only part of Christmas that matters is that it is a Christian festival but, sadly, so many people forget that.

Speaking as someone who will actually be in a church over Christmas, I think this is a bit of a daft take. Christmas as celebrated in the UK is incredibly obviously a syncretistic festival. Christianity is part of it, but the celebration around the shortest day and the things we do around that time long predate it. If you only want to acknowledge the relatively recent Christian aspects of the festival, that's fine, but they certainly aren't the only things that matter.

Hbh17 · 17/12/2022 11:32

Absolutely correct.
Celebrating Christmas is not compulsory and we should all be able to choose what we do/don't do.
The only part of Christmas that matters is that it is a Christian festival but, sadly, so many people forget that. I dislike Christmas and generally ignore it but I do love to listen to the Festival of Nine Lessons & Carols on Xmas Eve - that is proper Christmas.
But there is somehow a tyranny that says we all have to conform to stereotypes and the whole "20 people round a family table" thing is the most ghastly and damaging stereotype of all.

Dello · 17/12/2022 11:24

We have a lot of Christmases with 20 people, I love it (don’t usually cook).

This year will be 14 people.

It’s a feast!

I don’t understand why people get swept up in new “traditions” they complain about doing - just don’t!
eg elf on shelf, Christmas Eve boxes, Christmas pyjamas, Christmas cups, winter Christmas decorations eg penguins! Christmas jumper days, Christmas nights out. All crazy IMO

Butchyrestingface · 17/12/2022 11:22

So, seriously. Why are are all buying into this 20 people round a table, with a Hogwarts spread, bullshit?

I don't know ANYONE who subscribes to this myth. Don't think many modern homes could accommodate 20 people round a table.

ILoveeCakes · 17/12/2022 11:18

My family don't look like the ones in modern ads, so I couldn't replicate them even if I tried!

Be the change you want to see. You have Christmas as you want it and don't be told what to do by the TV. It's not like the big companies want the best for you - they just want your money. Oh and to push certain agendas down your throat.

MsSquiz · 17/12/2022 11:13

Last year my SIL cooked for 16 people on Christmas Day. We all sat around 2 tables joined together and had an amazing time.

So yes, for some people it is very much real.

We also have our own traditions in each household, and as family together. You celebrate Christmas Day however you want to

DuchessofSandwich · 17/12/2022 11:05

I love hosting christmas and there will be 9 of us. Growing up we also had christmasses with grandpa or an aunt and her family coming over. I love hosting christmas so maybe that helps because I'm genuinly happy whennthey accept my invitation.

ITSSSSCHRISTMASSS · 17/12/2022 11:04

I feel it’s on par with the big multi generational summer holidays, like it’s expected that 3/4 generations of families all holiday together. Nip, I’m happy just the 5 of us over Christmas and the same on holiday.

Reasonablereasonableness · 17/12/2022 11:03

@Girasoli I wonder if that would be seen as ok if he were female though?

I recall years ago coming off and NHS nightshift and cooking a Christmas dinner for 12 people. Madness!

This year I am not doing it at all.

lollipoprainbow · 17/12/2022 11:03

Nobody's bragging

Oh they are

TheOGCCL · 17/12/2022 11:02

It’s definitely a manipulative time of year and potentially hard on people who don’t have a traditional family set up of which there are many and which society doesn’t seem to acknowledge. I think as long as people realise we are being conditioned a little bit and don’t go mad and get into loads of debt chasing a fantasy. Personally I just pick and choose what elements to go with. There are no decorations up in my house and not sure there will be, or if there are it will be very minimal. I don’t send cards but graciously accept any given to me, if that’s what others want to do. I think Christmas is for young kids, who are still full of awe and wonder and who can’t buy things they want.

I do think winter in the UK would be bleak without Christmas in the middle. I love the lights and the carols and the time off and chance to reset. There’s something for everyone, we don’t all have to do everything.

JamSandle · 17/12/2022 10:56

proveit · 17/12/2022 10:51

I know what you mean.

Also, all of the Adverts saying "It's Christmas, eat all you can, feast on this, that and the next thing", then, come January, guilt tripping everyone into "Get to the gym, you fat bastards, you need a beach body now!" I'm like, what, you were telling me to stuff my face just last week!

It's so true 🤣

Fairislefandango · 17/12/2022 10:56

As an only child from a broken home, some of these humble brags about your 25 person extended family blissful “chaotic” Christmas are a bit tone deaf, especially as a response to OPs thread. Congratulations, you actually have the hallmark Christmas Day! Not sure how that’s meant to make anyone feel better.

Nobody's bragging - they are just answering the OP. People shouldn't post threads asking for views (especially on AIBU) if all they want is nodding and agreement. Nobody is being nasty, they are just disagreeing with the OP's view that everyone is brainwashed, and giving their own experiences.

HootOwlStrikesAgain · 17/12/2022 10:54

Everyone does it differently. For us it is all about a multigenerational get together to celebrate family but then we don't have a huge family: there will be 8 of us, with the family who don't live with me and my children staying with us for several days. But if they were horrible to be around we wouldn't do that! Do whatever makes you happy. Xmas Smile

SirMingeALot · 17/12/2022 10:51

WandaWonder · 17/12/2022 10:45

We don't do any of that, it is not mandatory

Same. Christmas actually is more about gatherings for us. But different strokes etc.

proveit · 17/12/2022 10:51

I know what you mean.

Also, all of the Adverts saying "It's Christmas, eat all you can, feast on this, that and the next thing", then, come January, guilt tripping everyone into "Get to the gym, you fat bastards, you need a beach body now!" I'm like, what, you were telling me to stuff my face just last week!

Swipe left for the next trending thread