Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we’ve been brainwashed over Christmas.

166 replies

FabYuleLous · 17/12/2022 08:10

I’ve noticed on MN, and in real life, that people get very upset if their Christmas does not resemble a supermarket advert with 20 people, all generations, around a massive feast, all having a super time.

Seriously, how many of us have families like this. If you got 20 family members round a table, would it really be like that.

I know if I got 20 round a table of our family, it would look like this: DB1 being in a mood, as his life hasn’t turned out like my other DB. Me crying in the kitchen as I’d been manipulated into hosting and doing all the work and expense. PIL being PA to me, no present and criticising the meal and SIL giving me filthy looks throughout. On top of this my DC moaning that we have loads of people round.

I don’t think I’m abnormal.

So, seriously. Why are are all buying into this 20 people round a table, with a Hogwarts spread, bullshit?

Just to add. This year I’ve actually gone to the trouble of reading up about our traditions and customs around Christmas, and learnt things I didn’t know. We celebrate it blindly, and don’t even know why we are doing things we do.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheaBrandt · 18/12/2022 23:56

It’s an ancient festival intended to cheer people up in midwinter - it pre dates Christianity. Doesn’t matter at all how many you are surely just nice to have break from the norm at a dark time of year however you spend it.

MrsKrankyPants · 17/12/2022 21:19

Nope just us and the kids. When MIL was alive, she spent most with us.

We have a very lovely relaxing day.

Fremdschämen · 17/12/2022 21:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

mackthepony · 17/12/2022 21:16

I completely agree. Most people seem to think this about life in general and especially social events I. E. Family dinner should look like a group of incredibly beautiful Italians sat outside having a Mediterranean feast with various chubby infants adorably eating bowls of rigatoni or whatever. Or American style Martha Stewart affair with pecan pie, grits and Gravy etc

Instead they're miserable in the rain in Milton Keynes or wherever

Oakbeam · 17/12/2022 21:11

And the let us not forget Prince Albert's contribution to the traditional British Christmas

The Christmas tree? Apparently, it wasn’t him that introduced them to Britain, it was Queen Charlotte, also German, around 1800.

HaggisWurst · 17/12/2022 17:15

Growing up, I spent Christmas with my mum, my auntie, two cousins, uncle and gran. Not quite 20 people but still 4 adults and 3 children, it was loud and noisy and great fun. Now we alternate every 2 years and still have Christmas with my mum, uncle, auntie, two cousins. My gran is no longer with us and I now bring along DH and DS (as of next year DS2). At mils, it is just DH, DS, MiL and myself as bil never wants to come and mil/fil are divorced. I find it quite boring really (Xmas goes up the 24th, we swap presents, have homemade pizza and that's it really) but of course would never say that out loud as I try my best to respect it's just done differently and there are aspects I like (such as the board games). But even DH prefers our mad family Christmas at my family. This year, it's just me, DH and DS in our own home due to me being 35 weeks pregnant and not wanting to travel but still, I'm looking forward to it! It'll be nice to just be at home and spend the days baking and playing with DS/spending time with DH before the baby comes.

Tangled123 · 17/12/2022 17:00

I think religions started as a way for the rich and powerful to distract, manipulate and control the masses to act a certain way. Christmas is just an extension of that.
I never did the big extended family meal at Christmas (my mum’s family is too big and my dad’s was too far away) and didn’t even know people did that until my 20s.
I think it’s really good people get time off work together, but I wish it was in summer when the weather was better.

HootOwlStrikesAgain · 17/12/2022 16:52

WestwardHo1 · 17/12/2022 16:09

The only part of Christmas that matters is that it is a Christian festival but, sadly, so many people forget that.

It's a pagan midwinter festival actually. Hence the lights and the holly etc

Yep. Jesus wasn't even born in December. That was one of the earlier examples of cultural appropriation. 🤣 There's always been a midwinter festival for many thousands of years. Some people renaming it for their religion doesn't mean other people are no longer allowed to celebrate it as has always been the tradition.

Girasoli · 17/12/2022 16:49

Reasonablereasonableness It would in our family, the year I was really stressed doing a Masters and the year I had horrible morning sickness I was just expected to turn up to my parents house and get fed.

WestwardHo1 · 17/12/2022 16:09

The only part of Christmas that matters is that it is a Christian festival but, sadly, so many people forget that.

It's a pagan midwinter festival actually. Hence the lights and the holly etc

WestwardHo1 · 17/12/2022 16:08

WimbyAce · 17/12/2022 10:02

I get what you mean, the adverts with loads of people dropping in and big spreads of food. Normally only about 7/8 of us together at Christmas. Close family only, I wouldn't want to spend it with my extended family!

Only 7 or 8!!

This year it's just me and my mum. I'm divorced, she's widowed, I don't have kids - couldn't have them.

Christmas can be really hard.

KimberleyClark · 17/12/2022 15:53

Butchyrestingface · 17/12/2022 11:22

So, seriously. Why are are all buying into this 20 people round a table, with a Hogwarts spread, bullshit?

I don't know ANYONE who subscribes to this myth. Don't think many modern homes could accommodate 20 people round a table.

Or seat 20 people in the living room.

Legallypinkish · 17/12/2022 15:32

We used to all go to my mums for Christmas. I have 5 siblings and there are numerous grandchildren. Probably 18-20 at the dinner table, little kids crying, dinner never ready until a ridiculous hour, arguments over who was supposed to be doing what. Honestly it was absolute chaos. Then the whole rigmarole of packing all the presents up that we’d taken there to open, putting tired kids in the car and having to drive home. About 8 years ago we decided to do Christmas at home and if anyone wants to visit Boxing Day or after they can. So much less stress!

thecatsmum12346 · 17/12/2022 15:30

yes you are very blunt. I was trying to be supportive.

Fairislefandango · 17/12/2022 15:24

The only part of Christmas that matters is that it is a Christian festival but, sadly, so many people forget that.

Of course they don't forget it. They just choose to celebrate Christmas in a non-religious way because they are not Christians but have grown up with the festival being part of their cultural heritage. Just as I imagine that many other festivals in different countries and cultures around the world which started off as religious ones (or pagan ones piggy-backed by religions) continue to be widely celebrated even after many or most people no longer believe in the deities.

SaturnaliaCalling · 17/12/2022 14:47

And the let us not forget Prince Albert's contribution to the traditional British Christmas.

Wonnle · 17/12/2022 14:46

NibbledSwitch · 17/12/2022 09:21

Christmas is just lies to support capitalism!

It's obscene, it's wasteful

Smiling families, bountiful feasts!

The adverts don't show all the packaging that ends up in landfill

Or show people literally dying of cold because they can't afford to heat thier houses, whilst thier neighbours decorate the outside of thier houses with lights, lazers and inflatable reindeer

It's all fucking madness!

But hey ... if you don't indulge now they can't sell you self loathing in the new year when diet plans and weigh loss products will be shoved down our necks!

I find the whole thing crass and obscene tbh

Totally agree with this

SaturnaliaCalling · 17/12/2022 14:39

SirMingeALot · 17/12/2022 12:13

It's a mixture of both, which is why it has such blatantly obvious pagan elements and blatantly obvious Christian elements.

Don't forget Saturnalia. It also often ties in with Hannukah. It's an equal ops midwinter festival of human resistance against the elements with extra lights.

ReluctantLondoners · 17/12/2022 13:52

TheaBrandt · 17/12/2022 10:01

It’s not the adverts though. Haven’t you read your Dickens?! We basically have a similar Christmas to the one my grandparents had as children so not really getting what tv ads have to do with anything!

It's interesting people mentioning Dickens starting all this

Did anyone listen to the program on radio 4 yesterday about "how Santa stole Christmas"? It was quite interesting. How films like It's a Wonderful Life and Miracle on 34th Street are the modern replacement for A Christmas Carol in America; a Christmas morality tale. But they cleverly make it so that capitalism is still A Good Thing in the movies. You get good capitalists and bad capitalists in the movies whereas in Dickens the capitalist Scrooge is the bad guy. They were saying this is incredibly clever marketing to make sure people don't stop spending!

I don't know how true it is, but it was an interesting theory and they had some experts in marketing who talked about it, so I'm sure it holds some water at least

proveit · 17/12/2022 13:50

FIL and MIL have the perfect house to host Christmas. It's 6 bedrooms, all with en-suite. Plenty of living areas. They are only late 60's and very fit. But they never offer to host. They just expect to be hosted by one of their adult children, none of whom have a house big enough to accommodate the whole family, so there are never any Christmassess spent as a whole. I just don't get it?

JassyRadlett · 17/12/2022 13:13

I do take the point about simmering family tensions, etc etc. We're very lucky that we all genuinely like each other and get along so that large family gatherings are low stress.

I do remember that for years, my mother would work incredibly hard to try to prevent arguments between my grandfather and his sister. One of us would be on great-aunt duty, the other on grandpa duty to try to keep them apart, because my mum didn't want Christmas spoiled.

One year she finally gave in and listened to my dad's advice (it was his side of the family) and just decided to stop trying to keep the peace. It was brilliant. Massively entertaining yo watch them having a good old ding-dong about fifty year old gripes while the rest of us (including my long-suffering grandmother) chatted about other stuff or occasionally just sat back and watched the show.

My mother used to hate hosting Christmas. She adores it now.

whatkatydid2013 · 17/12/2022 13:11

We don’t have 20 most years but our Christmas is probably very like the typical adverts. This year we are doing multiple things
In next 30 mins I have 10 kids (ages 2-9) & some of their parents coming round. Kids will decorate mini Christmas cakes, bake cookies and do crafts. Parents will drink wine, chat and give kids a hand as needed
Christmas Eve friends and my brother/sister in law are coming for dinner here, Christmas Day we are at my mums with all the inlaws (husband’s dad/sister/bil/our nephew/nieces and one of the niece’s boyfriends, brothers parents in law) & our Ukrainian guests. There will be 14 adults and 4 kids. We’ve done it before and it’s fantastic but my parents have a big house and it’s comfortable to manage 20 for a sit down meal and up to more like 40 for a casual get together within a buffet. We do stuff like that fairly regularly through the year. It’s not everyone’s cup of tea but some people love to have a family get together

JassyRadlett · 17/12/2022 13:08

Oakbeam · 17/12/2022 12:08

Christmas is a Pagan festival, not Christian.

I wish people would stop peddling this crap. How man pagans do you know who celebrate Christmas, the birth of Christ? Did any ever?

Nobody knows exactly when Christ was born. Nevertheless, early Christians wanted to celebrate his birth. Since they all had December 25th free in their diaries now that they had converted from whatever they worshipped before, it was an obvious date to choose.

If Christians didn't want Christmas or Easter to be linked to secular or pagan traditions and incorporate secular or pagan celebrations and rituals, they shouldn't have co-opted secular and pagan festivals as part of the PR campaign to convert people to Christianity.

Almost inevitable that it would eventually come full circle and the Christian aspects become overshadowed.

As ye sow, etc etc.

JoyeuxNarwhal · 17/12/2022 12:31

yesforone · 17/12/2022 10:42

Oh i forgot the Elf on the shelf, X mas eve boxes, pajamas. It's hilarious really how we've been suckered into spending all this.

Again, "we" haven't been suckered in. Never done Christmas Eve boxes or elf on a shelf. In my immediate circle of friends/family I don't know of any who do the elf thing actually.
We do get new pyjamas every year, but they're not matchy matchy for Instagram or novelty Christmas ones. Have had this since I was a child.

NewToWoo · 17/12/2022 12:30

I like bringing the family together at Christmas. We haven't for several years, but even though it is stressful and all the emotional mindfuckery comes out, it is also lovely for all the cousins and siblings to get together, for the oldies to sit around reminiscing about their student days, for the teens to sneak outside for a vape they think no one has noticed and give advice to the younger ones about love, uni, work etc. I love all that. DFiL telling terrible jokes, DS snogging his boyfriend blatantly behind DFiL's back because he doesn't understand 'the gays'. It is all a bit Dickensian and exhausting but I'd be sad if we never have one of those chaotic family Christmases again. It's all a bit calm and genteel if there's just teh four of us.

Swipe left for the next trending thread