Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we wouldn’t be having as many strikes if we weee under Labour government?

66 replies

lurkinglittleladybug · 17/12/2022 07:14

I find all these strikes we are having in our country quite worrying. Especially the NHS nurse and paramedic strikes. I support them fully and think they deserve a fair wage…

But can’t help but think there wouldn’t be all these strikes or at least if there were they would be resolved quicker and therefore fewer strikes if we were under Labour government right now?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tontostitis · 17/12/2022 19:51

I sort of agree, a large part of this round of strike action is an attempt to bring down the Gov. That wouldn't happen in the short term with a Labour Gov but as Sir Kier says the demands are unreasonable and no government, Labour, Conservative or Coalition has a magic money tree. After two years of a pandemic with rising inflation and recession looming any Gov giving even half way decent payrises linked to inflation will find itself in trouble in the long run.l and will have to say no. Will strikes be back with a Labour Gov?

mumda · 17/12/2022 19:42

www.nhsconfed.org/articles/is-nhs-awash-with-cash

Though to be honest when I was reading the word salad job for over 100k I have to wonder how much could be saved from the NHS if someone took some pruning sheers to it and had a serious look at the accounting (Time is spent adding up money owed by other areas which is then not claimed back or adjusted, and the sheer number of jobs which seem to have very little benefit to patients)

Valeriekat · 17/12/2022 19:33

LlynTegid · 17/12/2022 07:18

Yes I think would be the case. Though the Tories will then say 'what about the winter of discontent in 1979'.

Just what I was going to say. This is nothing compared to then (yet)
The Unions ran the Labour Party and their demands were insatiable.
It didn't end well for British manufacturing and heavy industry.
Unfortunately Union Members have not been well served by their Unions.

Boomboom22 · 17/12/2022 15:23

Just to note public sector pensions are not paid from a pension pot although a nominal figure of a pot is used on statements, they are calculated on career average and paid from general taxation, as are teachers.
If pay had not been so eroded over the years we would not be here. But the pensions point is relevant to why rishi doesn't want to negotiate.

dolor · 17/12/2022 13:56

Hahahaha

Labour are tories wearing red. It wouldn't be any better. Maybe if we'd have been allowed Corbyn it would be better, but be was purposely destroyed. Don't be so naive.

Clavinova · 17/12/2022 13:53

helford
Wales can only spend what the Govt gives them

They can choose what to spend the funding on.

From the article in my link -
Asked if he [Starmer] thought the Welsh Government was right to give a smaller increase to the NHS this year in Wales than the NHS in England is receiving...

HRTQueen · 17/12/2022 13:32

there certainly would be more compromises

and Labour can not fix wrong doings over night so yes likely to still be strikes but not as many

helford · 17/12/2022 13:30

Florenz · 17/12/2022 13:17

The NHS is a massive money pit, there are far too many people working there doing nothing of value, there is no organisation at all, too many different departments, computer systems, etc etc. The pensions are ridiculous and are actually paid for by everyone else, not by the NHS workers, whatever they say. If it's paid for by themselves out of their wages which are paid for by everyone else, that is no different to it being paid for by everyone else directly.

I would reorganise the NHS from top to bottom. Scorched earth policy. Literally rip it up and start again and create a modern health service, instead of the one we have at present which is basically a 1940s health service with some very superficial bells and whistles to make it seem modern.

How will you treat existing patients and new ones whilst you rip the NHS up?

I'm interested to know as you obviously have extensive experience in the NHS, at Trust, management and frontline to make such an assertion that "too many people do nothing of worth"

I also would like to know your experience of rolling out replacement IT systems, the issues these cause, how you would run new and existing IT systems along side each other, how you would cut over without data loss or disruption and most importantly the costs involved.

JassyRadlett · 17/12/2022 13:30

A Labour government wouldn't have had a Brexit referendum and, even if they had, wouldn't have had their Brexit negotiations dictated by the most extreme free marketeers. So we wouldn't be facing up to the hit to public finances that comes from a permanent 5% reduction in GDP.

Could Keir Starmer fix the issues tomorrow if he won power? No. The Tories have made such a total mess that it will take years and years to fix the impact of underinvestment and low pay that is so fuelling our problems now.

helford · 17/12/2022 13:21

Not much point talking about pay with someone who doesn't know what they are talking about

I'd have thought the reason is obvious, it stops the strikes!

DdraigGoch · 17/12/2022 13:18

helford · 17/12/2022 13:02

Wales can only spend what the Govt gives them, they have no means to raise funds for any extra pay rise, unlike Scotland or England so of course they have strikes.

Aren't our nurses, rail and ambulance staff also on strike?

Starmer would talk pay to the nurses, pausing all strike action, seems a no brainer unless you want a strike?

Growing calls on Tory back benches (& media) to reopen pay talks, i assume their constituents aren't as right wing as some on MN.

I predict Sunak will be forced into a U turn before Xmas & will refer back to pay review body and or talks on pay.

Welsh rail staff aren't on strike. TfW have agreed a deal with all four unions. Network Rail staff employed in Wales are on strike but they're employed by the UK government.

Florenz · 17/12/2022 13:17

The NHS is a massive money pit, there are far too many people working there doing nothing of value, there is no organisation at all, too many different departments, computer systems, etc etc. The pensions are ridiculous and are actually paid for by everyone else, not by the NHS workers, whatever they say. If it's paid for by themselves out of their wages which are paid for by everyone else, that is no different to it being paid for by everyone else directly.

I would reorganise the NHS from top to bottom. Scorched earth policy. Literally rip it up and start again and create a modern health service, instead of the one we have at present which is basically a 1940s health service with some very superficial bells and whistles to make it seem modern.

DdraigGoch · 17/12/2022 13:15

Diffuserqueen · 17/12/2022 12:50

I reckon he could,,,,

How?

Clavinova · 17/12/2022 13:11

Nurses have said they will call off the strike IF Govt will talk about pay... just talk..

RCN general secretary Pat Cullen claimed two or three times on Thursday night's Question Time that the starting salary for a newly qualified nurse in central London was £27,000 - it's £32,466 (inclusive of Higher Cost Area Supplement). Not much point talking about pay with someone who doesn't know what they are talking about.

helford · 17/12/2022 13:02

Wales can only spend what the Govt gives them, they have no means to raise funds for any extra pay rise, unlike Scotland or England so of course they have strikes.

Aren't our nurses, rail and ambulance staff also on strike?

Starmer would talk pay to the nurses, pausing all strike action, seems a no brainer unless you want a strike?

Growing calls on Tory back benches (& media) to reopen pay talks, i assume their constituents aren't as right wing as some on MN.

I predict Sunak will be forced into a U turn before Xmas & will refer back to pay review body and or talks on pay.

Clavinova · 17/12/2022 13:02

April 2022

Clavinova · 17/12/2022 13:01

Devolved governments can only work with the resources allocated to them under the Barnett formula

May 2022

Labour leader Keir Starmer has defended Welsh Labour's record on the NHS in Wales despite the Labour-led Welsh Government giving health services a smaller funding increase in Wales than the NHS in England is receiving.

www.walesonline.co.uk/news/politics/put-labours-record-funding-nhs-23600620

Needtoseethatbiggerpicture · 17/12/2022 12:53

Hasn't Kier Starmer said the 19% pay rise for nurses is unaffordable? If that's what they are going for they'd be striking regardless of who was in government

Under a Labour government we would not have seen the unprecedented levels of under investment in the NHS, education, and all,other areas of public spending. Nor would we have likely seen the very real decline in wages in these sectors - teacher’s salaries in real terms are down over 20% since 2010.

So whilst I agree 19% is unaffordable, the fact that we have professional people with high levels of training and an absolute need for those people to ensure a functioning society, demanding such a pay rise, we need to look further back and consider why we have arrived at this point. It wasn’t inevitable.

MarshaBradyo · 17/12/2022 12:52

SeenAndNot · 17/12/2022 12:48

Labour government in Wales. We are significantly more in a mess than England when it comes to the state of the NHS. All our nurses etc are striking. Yet our government is spending £20million on new road signs that’s going to cause travel hell.

We have to get over this idea that Labour are better. They aren’t.

Wales puts me off Labour even more

MarshaBradyo · 17/12/2022 12:51

It would damage Starmer though. He’s can get away with Lynch yelling at him from sidelines when he’s in opposition. No hope if in charge.

Labour got trounced in 70s so the idea they can weather it better isn’t the case. Unions expect more and they get tied up in that.

Re formula yes I’ve heard that before, however glad to see Welsh nurse didn’t buy it, taxes can be used and pay per head is higher anyway.

Diffuserqueen · 17/12/2022 12:50

DdraigGoch · 17/12/2022 12:43

Starmer doesn't appear to be supportive of the strikes so I don't see why everyone thinks things will magically change for the better when Labour get in.

He couldn't do any worse.

I reckon he could,,,,

Diffuserqueen · 17/12/2022 12:50

Yes op, cos labour didn’t suffer with Strikes. 😂

SeenAndNot · 17/12/2022 12:48

Labour government in Wales. We are significantly more in a mess than England when it comes to the state of the NHS. All our nurses etc are striking. Yet our government is spending £20million on new road signs that’s going to cause travel hell.

We have to get over this idea that Labour are better. They aren’t.

DdraigGoch · 17/12/2022 12:43

Starmer doesn't appear to be supportive of the strikes so I don't see why everyone thinks things will magically change for the better when Labour get in.

He couldn't do any worse.

Peacelily38 · 17/12/2022 12:37

Starmer doesn't appear to be supportive of the strikes so I don't see why everyone thinks things will magically change for the better when Labour get in.
I also don't see too much of a difference between Labour and Conservatives anymore.

We have an ineffective government and an ineffective opposition.
Its no wonder why it's such a mess.

Swipe left for the next trending thread