Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to worry that DH would have trouble connecting with donor child

115 replies

ConfusedFrog · 17/12/2022 01:00

DH and I have recently found out we are unable to have children naturally due to DH infertility. We have started to think about alternative ways to have a family – and I am leaning towards using a sperm donor. DH has brought up adoption a few times, but I have looked into it fairly extensively and while I have huge respect for anyone who does chose to adopt, I don't think that it is necessarily the right choice for us. I have started to think about the possibility of using donor sperm - but haven't yet discussed this with DH as I'm not sure it's a path he would be interested in going down..

My worry is that DH will potentially struggle to connect with the child if it's not genetically 'his' – I really don't mean for this to offend anyone who has gone down this path, I just want to do what is right for us and any potential child and am looking to hear from others who have made or haven't made this choice.

If we did use a donor, I think it would be important to ensure that the child is aware of their origins from early on (so there are no 'surprises' that could be very upsetting later in life) – but this would mean that it would be a constant reminder to DH that the child wasn't his genetic child. I think this would be upsetting for him, especially as he is very private and doesn't want people knowing about his infertility issues (and I'm pretty sure that a child who we were open with about being a donor child would talk about this with their friends at school / family / family friends etc and it would be very much open knowledge – and I wouldn't really feel comfortable telling the child not to talk about it as I wouldn't want them to feel any 'shame' about where they came from). I also worry that DH would find it difficult if the child chose to contact the donor when they turned 18.

Has anyone else been down the donor sperm path and faced any of these difficulties? Am I completely unreasonable to think that these things could even be an issue?

OP posts:
ChrisTrepidation · 19/12/2022 13:01

@KimberleyClark That's hardly the same thing is it? The man in that situation would be free to go and find a woman who was able to have children.

It IS selfish to deny somebody their own biological child because you are not able to have one with them.

KimberleyClark · 19/12/2022 12:28

AntsGoMarchingOneByOne · 19/12/2022 11:56

On the other hand, it's the husband who has the problem of infertility, so I think it's unfair for him to deny his wife the experience of having her own biological child because of his problems.
"I can't have one, so you can't have too" is not a very loving attitude, is it?

Would you say the same about a wife who didn't want to use a donor egg - that she was selfish for denying her husband the chance of a biological child?

AntsGoMarchingOneByOne · 19/12/2022 11:59

He’s as entitled to want his own biological child as you are.

He's entitled to want it, but if he can't produce one, then what exactly he's entitled to?

AntsGoMarchingOneByOne · 19/12/2022 11:56

drpet49 · 19/12/2022 06:25

This.

On the other hand, it's the husband who has the problem of infertility, so I think it's unfair for him to deny his wife the experience of having her own biological child because of his problems.
"I can't have one, so you can't have too" is not a very loving attitude, is it?

newtb · 19/12/2022 10:38

If you go down the donor route, would it help your DH if his semen were mixed with the donor's?

ChrisTrepidation · 19/12/2022 10:32

@NotMyDayJob Makes a far more eloquent post than mine. Agree with everything they say.

ChrisTrepidation · 19/12/2022 10:31

I'm sorry to hear of your troubles op. Infertility is such a heartbreaking thing to experience.

I have four year old donor egg twins. The infertility was on my side due to premature ovarian failure. I can honestly say that it makes so difference to how I feel about my DC. I love them more than anything.

As it happens, my husband (bio dad) left when they were 15 months old. Which I suppose proves the point that you can worry about your partners feelings all you want but dont sacrafice your deepest desires for them.

I would urge you not to risk losing your chance of becoming a mum. No man is worth the sacrafice.

NotMyDayJob · 19/12/2022 10:14

@confusedfrog I'm mum to a 9 in month old donor egg baby, it's different because I carried my baby and it does help build a connection that way, but I can honestly say she feels completely like my baby and I adore her. I say she's the baby I wasn't meant to have because who would have thought she would come to be. What a miracle the twists and turns of life have been.

I would also recommend the donor conception network (membership is about £50 a year) they do a lot of peer to peer support so match you up with a family of a similar profile who can answer questions and give peer support on how they found a situation (in my case egg donation and a mixed family as I already have an own egg daughter). I'm not sure what support they offer without paid membership (they are a charity) so just wanted to mention that.

It might also be checking adoption to eliminate it as an option. If you want to carry a baby you need to be honest with your DH about that as it will cause resentment and it will fester. I know personally, it was highly unlikely I'd be allowed to adopt due to issues in my wider family, as rightly the threshold for adoption is incredibly high.

Another option is double donor/embryo adoption (we donated our leftover embryos) but if I'm honest I don't think not having a genetic link with either parent just to prove a point about pride/ equality is the right way to go. The potential children created need to be front and centre of your thinking.

Best of luck to you xx

ConfusedFrog · 19/12/2022 10:05

@KimberleyClark I'm sorry to hear that you have also been through this. It's just all so confusing and confronting and deflating... and everyone has every right to feel the way they do, and I know there's not going to be some kind of magic solution that just removes all the hurt and makes it okay for everyone... it's just really hard.

OP posts:
ConfusedFrog · 19/12/2022 10:04

@Janefx40 Thank you for sharing, and congratulations on conceiving - that's wonderful news. We are in the early stages of our journey. We have been told that DH has azoospermia, and due to some previous medical issues (which I won't go into detail about on here due to privacy) that there would be little chance of sperm retrieval. It is something I would still like to explore, but DH is not currently wanting to do this due to the very small chance of it being successful. This is something I am planning to talk to him about as I really want to explore all our options.. but I also have to respect that it is his body. It's a really difficult position to be in tbh. I have heard good things about Jonathan Ramsey, but unfortunately don't think it would be applicable in our situation (but will look into it to see, and perhaps call them to discuss so I have all the facts when talking to DH). That's lovely to hear that your friends haven't had any issues with bonding. Do you know if the children have had any qualms or misgivings about being donor children? Or is it just something that they are not too bothered about? Thank you also for sharing the Donor Conception Network – a few posters have recommended and I think I will reach out to them in the new year.x

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 19/12/2022 09:38

DH and I were not able to have children, issues on both sides. We decided against any donor gametes and chose to live childfree. YANBU to consider a sperm donor, but your DH would also not be unreasonable to not want to. Just as YANBU to not want to consider adoption. He’s as entitled to want his own biological child as you are. You really need to discuss this with him.

Janefx40 · 19/12/2022 09:28

@ConfusedFrog also I have a few friends with donor conceived children. It hasn't affected their bonding. The genetic element seems huge when you are conceiving but is a very minuscule part of being a parent - barely relevant really. Of course it is potentially relevant to the child so that is the area to consider, as I know you are. The donor conception network also have a FB page if you want to start there with your research. Xxx

Janefx40 · 19/12/2022 09:24

@ConfusedFrog I'm sorry you are going through this. We have spent years in various stages of fertility treatment but have luckily been successful at conceiving through ICSI.

I had assumed from earlier posts that this wasn't possible but if you are considering any kind of male infertility treatment and you are in the south-east (and can afford it) you should go to see Jonathan Ramsay who is the leading infertility urologist.

jonathanramsay.co.uk

He is really amazing. He saw us when we thought (incorrectly) that DH was infertile. He also saw us over zoom so you might be able to do most consultations remotely if you aren't near London. Fertility clinics generally know very little about male infertility so, depending who you saw, it's best not to take their word for it.

Also in terms of your age, yes 37 isn't young but it's also not that old in infertility terms so, unless your own fertility tests showed something alarming, yes you do have a couple of months to let this settle before you push forwards. I find it surprising how even a week or two can make a difference in accepting a diagnosis.

Best of luck x

Cuppasoupmonster · 19/12/2022 09:09

The others either insisted that donor eggs be used too so the child was not genetically related to either of them

how selfish.

ThirtyThreeTrees · 19/12/2022 09:03

This has to be really difficult for both you and your husband. When I found out I was infertile, I could get my head around not having a baby far easier than I could deal with the feelings of inadequacy & that I wasn't enough for my partner if I coudon't reproduce.

I would be very surprised if isn't having some similar thoughts. He probably needs counselling to process his emotions.

I don't envy either of you. It's a very tough road.

ConfusedFrog · 19/12/2022 07:54

@MardyMincepie That's so difficult on your nephew, but it sounds like everyone is in a better place now which is good. I did speak to a therapist who brought up this idea - but I do truly love DH and don't want to leave. I'm also soon to be 38, and absolutely hate the idea of breaking up a relationship that is otherwise fine and then rushing into another relationship with little thought just to have DC 'in time'... I don't see that ending well for anyone - especially DC. But I also don't want to end up resenting DH in time because we don't have children of our own. It's an absolutely awful situation that I wouldn't wish on anyone. It's really breaking me.

OP posts:
MardyMincepie · 19/12/2022 07:45

I do have a relative and who was infertile so his wife left him. He is my nephew, he had a bit of a breakdown but is happily remarried and his new wife didn’t want children. His ex now has two children. I think it’s the sort of discussion to have on and off over a period of months.

What you also need to remember is you have spent some time thinking about it and have now couched opinions. He will need plenty of time to give his initial thoughts. It’s quite an overwhelming question isn’t it. Very complicated.

ConfusedFrog · 19/12/2022 07:37

@verystablegenius This is something I'm hoping to look into as we are in the same situation – although we've been told it's very unlikely that it will be successful due to the causes of it, which means it's something DH is not very keen to explore.. I'm hoping that with time though we can look at this as I feel like we need to know for sure in order to consider our options properly (and if it were me in his situation I wouldn't hesitate to explore all options..) I'm so glad to hear that it was successful for you and your DW – that's so wonderful.

OP posts:
ConfusedFrog · 19/12/2022 07:20

@Organzo Thank you for replying and sharing your experience – that's great that you have decided to move forward, and I wish you all the best with your journey. I haven't looked into the donor conception network, but this sounds like a potential next step if it is something DH is maybe interested in after we speak. I definitely agree about the double donation – it was just something another poster mentioned that I hadn't even considered. Did you choose your donor from the UK or did you go overseas? I know that a lot of UK parents choose to go overseas but I haven't looked into it enough to know the pros / cons / or even reasons why yet!

OP posts:
ConfusedFrog · 19/12/2022 06:41

@FlattenedAsAPancccake Thank you for sharing your journey. This is a very similar situation to what we are in. It sounds like you were able to conceive without the use of a donor though? I didn't think we had any other options – are you able to share a bit more about how you moved forward?

OP posts:
Organzo · 19/12/2022 06:34

@ConfusedFrog Sorry for third post, I just saw you talking about double donation and wanted to add a few thoughts on that.

From the child's perspective, double donation is going to be more difficult, because they will not be biologically connected to either of their parents. I think it can lead to a sense of isolation and knowing very little about their biological heritage. It is good that it's there as an option for people who need it, but in your position, you have viable eggs, so please think very carefully about this.

We had the same issue (the 'unfairness' of a child being biologically related to me but not my DH), but double donation is a huge step just to get rid of this feeling of imbalance.

The child needs to be as much as possible at the centre of this. I say as much as possible because I believe having children is inherently a selfish act (doesn't stop us all from wanting/ needing to do it!). Deciding to have a child with no connection at all to its parents when there is a chance they could be connected to one of them just seems really sad, especially when it is only to save the feelings of the father.

Your DH's feelings are important, of course , but I feel this is something he could come to terms with over time and maybe with some therapy, talking to some donor dads etc.

verystablegenius · 19/12/2022 06:29

I know this isn't what you asked, but have your doctors considered sperm retrieval techniques? I am azoospermic, and yet thanks to the wonders of modern medicine, I have one biological child, and DW is currently pregnant with our second.

drpet49 · 19/12/2022 06:25

spirit20 · 17/12/2022 10:41

I can understand from your husbands point of view why he would feel worse if it were a doner. It would mean that you are biologically related to the child while he isn't, and that would cause a gap between the two of you, both in the eyes of the child and in his eyes. With adoption, you would be in the same boat.

This.

Organzo · 19/12/2022 06:22

ConfusedFrog · 19/12/2022 06:01

@Gymandcakes Thank you for sharing your friend's experience. From what I've researched all UK donation has to be open donation (ie. the child knows about it and they are able to contact the donor when they turn 18) now – but this sense of 'missing out' on something is one issue I am concerned about..

Yes, Donor ID is compulsory in the UK. This is a good thing. I know it's hard to imagine your child turning 18 and wanting to connect with the donor, but that is something that we have to come to terms with for the sake of the child. It is the best way and it's so much healthier than secrecy. And by the time your child is 18, you will be such a well established family unit, the donor is not going to be any kind of threat to your position as parents. It will be OK x

FlattenedAsAPancccake · 19/12/2022 06:21

Hi @ConfusedFrog

We struggled with infertility (azoospermia - so a zero count) but we were able to see the right consultant, and so we ended up with our two babies (without IVF in the end). I can’t answer questions about donor sperm, although conversations about donor sperm popped up a lot over the years.

I did want to share a couple of big things that made a difference for my DH, I hope that’s okay? One was having access to male infertility support group on Facebook. He wishes we’d taken up counselling at the time now too, although our communication is stronger than it has ever been.

Another was seeing the consultant we did made a world of difference too, because he had so many answers unlike the pathway we’d followed on the NHS.