Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

4yo daughter calling strangers fat

236 replies

Twobirdsinatree · 16/12/2022 20:13

I think I might be overreacting here but this has really upset me and I dont know how to handle it at all.
My 4yo daughter has started calling strangers fat in a derogatory way.
Today we were in the doctors waiting room and she walked over to a young woman who was very obese and said 'you are a fat chungus, look at the fat chungus' and laughed. I was absolutely mortified. She has not heard this from me or her father. I am overweight myself and I would never in a million years call someone fat as an insult or comment on anyones weight in front of my daughter.. or at all! I also try not to criticise my own appearance in front of her.
I apologised to the woman and told my daughter that it was rude to comment on peoples appearance because it might hurt their feelings and if you dont know that person you dont know what might hurt them so dont say anything at all about their body.
shortly after that i went outside to speak to my son.. my mum was with my daughter.. and as I came back in I heard her doing it again! So I got a little angry with her and said 'no dont do that'
After the appointment the woman was still in the waiting room and as we walked out the door my daughter started saying 'fat chungus fat chungus' !!

When we got home I tried to talk to my daughter about it and tried to reason with her and ask her why she said that, and she said 'I dont like fat chungus its yuk, I dont want to see fat people at the doctors' I tried to explain to her how sad saying that might make someone feel but she didn't seem remotely moved she just kept saying that it was yuk and she didn't want to see it.
It really shocked me.

Am I unreasonable to be very worried or is this just a normal phase I should chill out about?
My son is older and he never did anything like this. He was naughty/cheeky of course sometimes but he always seemed to naturally understand about caring about other peoples feelings and not being nasty.
I'm finding it hard to get my daughter to understand.

Just so as to add any relevant information my daughter is on SEN register at the moment and has traits of ADHD I think.. altho not extreme. Apparently at school she cares very little about authority or what she's supposed to do and can be a bit ungovernable!
She has also just gone on the brown inhaler which contains steroids which could possibly be effecting her?
Also shes had a bit of upheaval because her grandad, my dad dropped dead unexpectedly a couple of months ago and he lived abroad so I went away for a month to help my mother who is disabled (he was her carer) sort everything out.. and my mother has now come back to live with us so I can take over her care and is sharing a room with my daughter..
She was quite close to her grandad.

Does anyone have any advice about how I should be reacting to this behaviour? Am I overreacting? Is she just unsettled at the moment and it will pass or do you think there's something I'm not doing right?

OP posts:
HintofVintagePink · 17/12/2022 07:01

So strange as ‘fat chungus’ is an expression I’ve started hearing at 5 year old DC’s school. It seems to be used about animals or squishy cartoon characters though, certainly not people. I’ve discouraged it because in our house calling anyone a name isn’t allowed; derogatory weight connotations aside.

The poor lady. I’m glad you didn’t try and force and apology from your child in front of her; if you can’t get her to sit in a chair it would have been mortifying for the lady if you got into a battle of wills trying to make your child apologise.

knittingaddict · 17/12/2022 07:01

RunLolaRun102 · 16/12/2022 21:03

Fat Chungus is from YouTube. Shit like that is why YouTube is banned in my house. Stop her screentime or heavily supervise it.

Banned in our house too. Had a stand off with my grandson over it last week. His mum has also banned it. Grandchildren not happy, but it's not like there aren't a load of alternatives these days.

Kezla · 17/12/2022 07:00

My son (8yo) actually has ADHD and has just lost his dad from a very brutal form of cancer... He is also on a brown inhaler for asthma.
There is no way in hell he would EVER walk up to someone and say that.
They have either picked it up from school, youtube or maybe heard the way you or other family members talk and have copied it.
Instead of making excuses as to what medical issue your child has to speak that way to other people, maybe look a bit closer to home.
They need to be disciplined for that kind of behaviour and attitude.

knittingaddict · 17/12/2022 06:52

HappierTimesAhead · 16/12/2022 20:44

She is a 4 year old child. You are the disgrace.
Honestly, everyone is giving the OP such a hard time. Her small child is still learning and developing.

No. At 4 any child with normal development should understand that it's rude and that you never comment on someone's appearance so negatively and nastily.

My grandson asked me why I had a fat stomach when he was 3. I told him it was rude to do that and he's never done it again. It shouldn't take more than that, but if it does then you keep reinforcing better behaviour. I don't expect children to be perfect, but certain things are non negotiable.

We need to be teaching children how to treat the people around us with respect and not accept ongoing rudeness, especially when it upsets those around us.

SomethingOriginal2 · 17/12/2022 06:48

Twobirdsinatree · 16/12/2022 23:09

@JoyBeorge she wasn't wandering around... we were on the same row of chairs as this woman.. she literally just stood up and took like two steps forward so she was standing in her eyeline.. she wasn't even that close and she was just stood still. I didnt think anything of it coz she wasn't invading personal space and she's never said anything like that before so I did not expect it.
I dont try and make her sit on a chair because thats a battle I dont have strength for ive already said they suspect she has adhd.. but she wasn't treating the place like a playground she was just stood there.

You need to make your kid sit in their chair. You can't just let her walk about.

Obviously things are difficult and I'm sorry for the loss of your dad. But there seems to be a lot of battles you don't have the energy for. It was really really bad, and you just talked to her about it and even when she reiterated that she doesn't care and repeated it you just left it?

You really needed to be very firm, you need to very firm , you're just letting them walk all over you.

Virginiaplain · 17/12/2022 06:31

She's four - not 14 - empathy isn't automatically there in a human - young dcs can be very cruel.
Posters are overdoing it imv. If the OP had said this has gone one for weeks there would be some justification but it only happened twice, in a public place where it's hard to punish severely without risk of SS being involved.

PAFMO · 17/12/2022 06:24

Bepis · 17/12/2022 05:50

I would never recommend insulting a child on their looks to make them see how it feels. That is awful and abusive.

Quite an apt username really.

OP- I was one of the first people to reply yesterday. And there's been a lot of good advice and some truly appalling advice since then (see above) plus a heavy smattering of "she's only 4 she'll grow out of it" and "lots of other stuff going on"

The other stuff, hard though it is, needs to be removed from this particular situation.

Yes, 4 year olds say some horrific things WHEN THEY DON'T REALISE THEY ARE BEING OFFENSIVE. My own daughter pointed and loudly said something at a woman on a bus once whose appearance was very specific and something she hadn't seen before.

She did it once.

The fact that yours continued means the consequences weren't enough. If this isn't nipped in the bud, you'll be called into school because she'll do it there. And then the consequences will be taken out of your hands.

At 4, and socialising at school, she is old enough to know what being cruel to other people is.

And keep her away from non age appropriate shit on YT and elsewhere.

Bepis · 17/12/2022 05:50

AbsolutelyFuckingSick · 16/12/2022 22:49

Oh my you really need to get a hold on this. Your dd has picked this up from somewhere unattended YouTube
I can't begin to imagine how that woman felt. Actually, that's a lie. The only time I'm in the gp waiting room is to discuss my mental health and I'm fat because of the medication I take. That comment, albeit from a bratty four year old, would have floored me.
I'm a huge fan of tough love. My dd would not be going anywhere nice, and we would be having a lot of conversations about kindness. If this didn't work, put it back on her. Does she have wonky teeth, weird hair etc make her see how unpleasant it is

I would never recommend insulting a child on their looks to make them see how it feels. That is awful and abusive.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 17/12/2022 05:49

FiveShelties · 17/12/2022 04:32

I doubt the woman in the waiting room will laugh about it one day.

It was an awful thing she said OP, but it does sound like you have more than enough on your plate at the moment and I hope things get easier for you.

She might. We'll never know. OP doesn't need to go round and round over it. Her DD is 4.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 17/12/2022 05:48

Afreshstar · 17/12/2022 03:50

Huh? Are you saying she’ll one day look back on this fondly and laugh about the time her kid insulted an obese young woman sitting by herself and clearly so humiliated she pretended to ignore it?

Yes. Move on.

Marchitectmummy · 17/12/2022 05:37

Why didnt you discipline her? There wss no consequence for her behaviour. Worry less about the source of the phrase and work on teaching your child how to behave. She disobeyed you repeatedly, that is the bigger issue.

CocoLux · 17/12/2022 04:45

You need to ban YouTube completely for both your children. It's a shitty influence as this episode seems to show. And the chat about hurting feelings clearly isn't cutting it; bad behaviour needs consequences.

FiveShelties · 17/12/2022 04:32

Mumtobabyhavoc · 17/12/2022 00:33

Please let it go now. You cannot go back in time. You have far more important things to concern you. Really. One day you will laugh about the time that.... 🌹

I doubt the woman in the waiting room will laugh about it one day.

It was an awful thing she said OP, but it does sound like you have more than enough on your plate at the moment and I hope things get easier for you.

squidgybits · 17/12/2022 03:50

What is she watching? on youtube or wherever? If she likes ryans world, I find them extremely rude and bad example to kids

Afreshstar · 17/12/2022 03:50

Mumtobabyhavoc · 17/12/2022 00:33

Please let it go now. You cannot go back in time. You have far more important things to concern you. Really. One day you will laugh about the time that.... 🌹

Huh? Are you saying she’ll one day look back on this fondly and laugh about the time her kid insulted an obese young woman sitting by herself and clearly so humiliated she pretended to ignore it?

Topseyt123 · 17/12/2022 03:30

That should say I would have been very upset.

Topseyt123 · 17/12/2022 03:02

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 16/12/2022 23:27

Please take this with a pinch of salt as I don't know if it's appropriate for the SEN you mention.

If one of mine had done this - the first time would have been an apology from me, a comment to the child like "everyone is different. It is rude to comment like that". Second time would have been an extremely sharp "stop saying rude things right now and apologise to this lady. You DO NOT comment on people's bodies". Once I got home a sit down conversation about where this language has come from, why I don't want to raise a mean little girl, and why these things hurt feelings.

She's 4. Still little, for sure, but old enough to know when she's being nasty.

That's what I think too.

OP, I'm probably one of those people your DD might have called a fat chungus. My weight problems are an extremely sensitive issue for me and are influenced by other medical issues.

I wouldn't have been very upset at your daughter spouting such bile even if she is only four. I might even have mentioned it to staff and wanted her removed from the waiting room if she continued it (which it sounds like she did) without you taking effective action.

You need to come down like a ton of bricks on this shit before she insults someone who perhaps doesn't control their reactions well. If she's out to provoke it reaction then she might just get more than she is bargaining for.

BabyOnBoard90 · 17/12/2022 00:44

Would be hard not to give a light spanking

Mumtobabyhavoc · 17/12/2022 00:33

Twobirdsinatree · 16/12/2022 21:48

@Mumtobabyhavoc thankyou thats a really kind thing to say. Im glad someone understands. It is incredibly stressful trying to cater to so many needs at once. I always feel someone is getting let down and today it seemed like my daughter (and that poor woman in the waiting room) because how has this managed to happen?

Please let it go now. You cannot go back in time. You have far more important things to concern you. Really. One day you will laugh about the time that.... 🌹

Shol · 17/12/2022 00:16

It doesn’t matter that the insult she chose was fat. It matters that she is deliberately insulting others (adults!!) for fun, in front of you, repeating the behaviour after you objected, laughing about it, and that you have not found an effective consequence to make her want to change her behaviour.

My three year old majorly pissed me off once. Got a three month screentime ban: no ipad, no tv. It was VERY hard on me but every single time she asked for screen I said “No because you did XYZ and that was very bad.” She didn’t do it again I can tell you.

Kids don’t care about “you hurt my feelings” or “that made me sad”. They know that their behaviour did this, that’s precisely why they are behaving badly, to feel that thrill of power. You need them to associate the bad behaviour with intense regret, only then will the behaviour change. You don’t have to go over the top (and don’t shoot yourself in the foot by taking away exercise / social time) just have clear rules such as ‘be polite to others’ and clear consequences for breaking them such as ‘no TV this week’.

Good luck! It’s a total pain, but the earlier you do it the easier it is. If you did this at age three it would have been easier but doing it now is MUCH easier than doing it at 7…

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 16/12/2022 23:27

Please take this with a pinch of salt as I don't know if it's appropriate for the SEN you mention.

If one of mine had done this - the first time would have been an apology from me, a comment to the child like "everyone is different. It is rude to comment like that". Second time would have been an extremely sharp "stop saying rude things right now and apologise to this lady. You DO NOT comment on people's bodies". Once I got home a sit down conversation about where this language has come from, why I don't want to raise a mean little girl, and why these things hurt feelings.

She's 4. Still little, for sure, but old enough to know when she's being nasty.

LunaAndHerMoonDragons · 16/12/2022 23:26

Twobirdsinatree · 16/12/2022 21:26

@YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot unfortunately our bedroom in the attic is not suitable for the children at all because the roof leaks and causes black mould (which I do stay on top of but sometimes it can just appear overnight) no way id let the kids sleep in there long term
Shes always been like that about sleeping in her own bed in her own room.. if we go anywhere like to a hotel or holiday let or friends house.. she will not sleep at all during the night.
I'm just going to persevere with my sons room.. it hopefully won't be forever just until my mum gets proper accommodation

My Autistic DS is very like this about his bedroom, we had to get him a bigger bed and it wouldn't fit in the same spot and it took him a long time to get used to it. Have you considered if there's anywhere downstairs for a bed to go for your Mum? Save carrying her and DD could have her space back. Or could the bunks go in DDs room and DS sleeps in their too? It's a tough situation all round. At 4 Id be telling them those comments hurt people but I wouldn't be expecting that to cause empathy and to stop them repeating it. It's more shutting it down, so if she says she doesn't like to see Chungas (not sure if that's right spelling) at the doctor, don't try and make her feel empathy tell her she's not allowed to say it and that if she does you will leave an activity, or if it's the doctors and you can't leave xyz will happen. The more immediate the consequence the better. Remind her on the way somewhere what will happen if she calls some fat or a chunga. That would be leave if it's something she enjoys, time out/removal of a privilege if it's a necessary appointment, it's individual what works. You could also remind her that if she keeps saying this then you won't be able to take her out to fun places because she's hurting people by calling them names. Consistency and repetition. Remind before, praise a lot during or immediately after outings if she hasn't said it.

PurpleButterflyWings · 16/12/2022 23:24

CheesenCrackersmm · 16/12/2022 22:25

she walked over to a young woman who was very obese and said 'you are a fat chungus, look at the fat chungus'

I never knew that something could be vastly insulting but also hilarious at the same time.

Thanks OP you made my evening.

Sorry I have no constructive advice though but it probably came from one of her friends.

WTAF? Confused

Afreshstar · 16/12/2022 23:21

FrostyFifi · 16/12/2022 23:01

I never knew that something could be vastly insulting but also hilarious at the same time

There's a young woman who at best probably went home utterly humiliated and in tears and at worst won't want to leave the house again. Yeah how fucking hilarious.

Yeah its very sad, i can imagine she went home humiliated and if her obesity is linked to inactivity , staying inside more is probably the last thing she needs.

Twobirdsinatree · 16/12/2022 23:12

@FTY765 I would never say that dont worry. Because it also gives the idea people get fat because they gorge on sweets.. which is not the case. I dont use food as punishment... altho I must admit I've used cake as a bribe as a last resort before sorry!

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread