Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why on earth people still buy from puppy farms?

207 replies

hennaoj · 16/12/2022 19:38

Why oh why do people buy puppies from the likes of Kelly's Kennels and Douglas Hall Kennels?

This is where the poor puppies come from. www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-32308177
Surely people know that you need to see the puppies mother before buying? Never mind the fact that these puppies won't be dna health tested.

OP posts:
tabulahrasa · 17/12/2022 05:04

EddyF · 17/12/2022 01:44

So how do you buy a puppy safely? Not everyone knows this information. Is there a step by step process? If so, what is it? How do you go about searching for a puppy?

You start by looking for a breeder and then waiting for them to have a litter rather than looking for a puppy. That usually (though not absolutely always) means you’re going on a waiting list for a planned litter some point in the next year or two.

You’re looking for someone who breeds because they want a puppy from the litter to do whatever it is they do with their dogs (showing, a sport, working).

The breed club is usually the best place to start.

You research all the appropriate health tests for the breed and when you ask about them, they should not only be happy to discuss them, but will have the paperwork for them... they should want to know about your set up and some actually have questionnaires or other things like that to find out about you, but equally should be happy to answer any questions you have. They’ll also insist (sometimes with a contract) that if you ever need to rehome the puppy for any reason that you go to them first.

They’ll likely have more dogs than an average person, lol, but usually between between 5 and 7, 2 or 3 of breeding age, a couple too young and 2 or 3 too old because they’ll only breed every couple of years. Those numbers aren’t exact, but... if they’re breeding several litters a year or they rehome the dogs when they’ve finished breeding dogs then they’re big red flags and if they have loads of dogs then they’re probably kept outside and that again (with the exception of working dogs that you’d probably not want as a pet anyway) that’s a massive red flag.

They’ll usually not own the dad, because it’s hugely unlikely that they just happen to own a dog that has traits that complement the bitch. If they’ve just got two pet dogs they’re breeding for the hell of it, some people are ok with that, but it can cause potential issues for a puppy owner.

Kennel club registration is really basic, but if they’re an eligible breed they should be doing it, there’s no ok reason not to and it means you can check the health tests and the inbreeding coefficient yourself online.

MerryMarigold · 17/12/2022 04:03

XenoBitch · 16/12/2022 22:43

Probably because it is so difficult to adopt a dog

It should be difficult to adopt a dog. Dog rescues do not exist to provide people with dogs... they exist to provide dogs with homes.

When we got our dog, I had 2 10 year olds, a 13 year old and 2 cats. I couldn't find any dogs for us. I liked for several months for rescues. I ended up on the dreaded pets 4 homes, but made sure I asked a lot of questions. All the dodgy dog sellers 'disappeared' after I asked certain questions. This was before you needed a license to breed your dog even once so I found someone who had bred using their pet. The dog was a lot cheaper than the 'licensed breeders' ( I didn't even realise they are sometimes puppy farmers).

Spliffle · 17/12/2022 03:56

I think these places exist simply because rescues make it too difficult to adopt. I have a nice house, no dc and a cat flap to a private garden. Would they let me take a cat? No, because I'm not home all day. Ok then, so I went out and bought a kitten which I loved & cherished for 14yrs.

Pinkbluebells · 17/12/2022 03:36

Our Birman was a buy in via a contact of the first breeder we contacted. I saw the first breeder's house and these were all indoor cats. One reassuring sight was a very old Birman snoozing on a chair - far too old for selling or breeding. Our cat was flown in from another city and came with a list of her favourite foods - chicken and baby rice. We had to agree to getting her spayed. She has been relentlessly healthy with great teeth. I'm fairly sure this wasn't a kitten mill. We did have to wait weeks even though we didn't care about show quality.

Furries · 17/12/2022 03:03

I know only a small number have voted, but who are the 14% that say you’re being unreasonable? Please, come back and say why it’s BU.

EddyF · 17/12/2022 01:44

So how do you buy a puppy safely? Not everyone knows this information. Is there a step by step process? If so, what is it? How do you go about searching for a puppy?

Winterscomingagain · 16/12/2022 23:54

hennaoj · 16/12/2022 22:40

Because they come from a huge farm in Fivemiletown, Ireland, both of the ones I have mentioned have breeding dogs in that farm. Kelly's Kennels have 900 breeding dogs over there.

It may be useful to clarify that this breeder is in Northern Ireland and is fully licenced by the local council, Fermanagh and Omagh district council.
It would be useful to look at the level of standards required for licencing. I believe there's a further planning application in at present to extend the farm.

ErrolTheDragon · 16/12/2022 23:33

User135792468 · 16/12/2022 23:30

@Gonnabegrandma @ErrolTheDragon @FOJN thank you for your replies. We won’t be looking for another couple years. We have an older cat who would be incredibly stressed by having a puppy in the house so we will wait for now. It’s just something I’ve wondered but I’ve heard a lot about puppy farms and it worries me for when the day comes.

When and if you do start looking for a puppy/dog, plan on it taking months not weeks (and certainly not days!).

User135792468 · 16/12/2022 23:30

@Gonnabegrandma @ErrolTheDragon @FOJN thank you for your replies. We won’t be looking for another couple years. We have an older cat who would be incredibly stressed by having a puppy in the house so we will wait for now. It’s just something I’ve wondered but I’ve heard a lot about puppy farms and it worries me for when the day comes.

ErrolTheDragon · 16/12/2022 23:16

Xpost .

Gonnabegrandma · 16/12/2022 23:16

As for finding decent breeders go y on fog shows or fog clubs . Look up on line the breed clubs for the breed you want . They can put you in touch with the right breeders . I am kennel club registered and accredited but so are so many puppy farmers !!! Unfortunately kennel club registration doesn’t mean that much in the way of good breeding practices . Talk and meet people look on Facebook most breed club have pages

ErrolTheDragon · 16/12/2022 23:14

User135792468 · 16/12/2022 23:00

Genuine question - please don’t jump on me. If looking online for breeders, how do you know the difference between the genuine breeders and the puppy farms? Is the Kennel Club a reliable place to look as they list registered breeders?

Not 100% reliable, but that and/or breed clubs would be better than random name found elsewhere. The KC site has (well... it had when we were looking for our last dog ~17 years ago but I can't imagine it wouldn't still be there and maybe even better) a lot of good advice on choosing a dog and finding a breeder - what questions to ask, what to look for when you visit, what they should be asking prospective buyers etc.

FOJN · 16/12/2022 23:12

User135792468

The Kennel Club and all the major animal charities have guidance pages on what to look for. I have linked to the Kennel club because you asked about them but to be honest I'm not a fan and I think they have played a major role in the increase in dogs bred for appearance rather than health with their ridiculous "breed standards".

I apologise to the reputable breeders of South Wales in advance but I would not buy a puppy from anywhere in that area as it seems to be ground zero for UK puppy farms.

If you are thinking of buying a puppy then the dog house would be a good place to ask for advice.

I would never judge anyone for asking for advice about buying a dog, it's a minefield and you just don't know about the warning signs or dirty tricks of shitty breeders until you ask.

www.thekennelclub.org.uk/getting-a-dog/are-you-ready/finding-a-good-breeder/avoiding-puppy-farmers-and-irresponsible-breeders/

Gonnabegrandma · 16/12/2022 23:11

I have a show kennel and we breed carefully when we want a new show dog . We don’t over charge we do all health tests puppies are bred and kept in our bedroom then kitchen with their mother aunts 👵 ms ect until it’s time fir them to leave . We ask lots of questions and meet prospective owners . However often we ring people on our waiting lists to be told oh we got bored waiting and found a such and such cross in the internet !!!!! Drives me mad but the public don’t seem to want to be educated !!!!

User135792468 · 16/12/2022 23:00

Genuine question - please don’t jump on me. If looking online for breeders, how do you know the difference between the genuine breeders and the puppy farms? Is the Kennel Club a reliable place to look as they list registered breeders?

XenoBitch · 16/12/2022 22:43

Probably because it is so difficult to adopt a dog

It should be difficult to adopt a dog. Dog rescues do not exist to provide people with dogs... they exist to provide dogs with homes.

hennaoj · 16/12/2022 22:40

StellaAndCrow · 16/12/2022 22:15

I've looked at one of the sites mentioned above - how can they possibly have so many different breeds/crossbreeds of puppies all "available now"?

Because they come from a huge farm in Fivemiletown, Ireland, both of the ones I have mentioned have breeding dogs in that farm. Kelly's Kennels have 900 breeding dogs over there.

OP posts:
KarmaStar · 16/12/2022 22:37

Because they want to turn the other way and pretend all is well.
because they want a cute ball of fluff and don't care.
Because they are too lazy to make full enquiries.
adopt don't buy!

FOJN · 16/12/2022 22:36

Notaligned

20 years ago...no social media...not easy to access guidance to help people avoid ending up at a puppy farm...puppy farms nowhere near as prevalent as they are now.

These are all differences between then and now. People can easily access the information they need to choose better breeders now.

Probably because it is so difficult to adopt a dog

If you are happy to acquire a dog bred in horrifically cruel conditions just because you WANT one then you probably shouldn't have a dog at all. In fact I think it would mark someone out as an incredibly unsuitable dog owner.

Findyourneutralspace · 16/12/2022 22:29

Lots of judgement here but I don’t think it’s always obvious. There’s a grey area - well meaning people who have had a litter, aren’t professional/registered breeders but nonetheless love the pups. Mum can be seen but the ‘breeder’ isn’t registered, they just had a family pet and decided to breed off them with a stud or another friend’s pet.
I think there’s a lot more of this than breeding machines kept in a dingy kennel - although that also happens.
I don’t think people always realise.

Cherrysoup · 16/12/2022 22:22

People hate waiting and they want the ‘in’ breed and don’t care that it’s brachycephalic and won’t be able to breathe/run like all dogs ought to be able. They don’t care about the origins, they just want the cute puppy RIGHT NOW. They can’t be arsed to research, they want it NOW and cover their eyes when they realise it’s not a normal family breeder (and don’t really care, they just want the puppy). They don’t ask about the temperament or how many litters the bitch has had because they just don’t care enough. Even the regulatory body is worse than useless. They couldn’t give a fuck, so why should a bog standard member of the public care?

dolor · 16/12/2022 22:19

It's because they're arsholes

XenoBitch · 16/12/2022 22:18

Because they want a puppy NOW.

No thought as to approaching a legit breeder and being on a waiting list.

Puppy farm pups are cheap, readily available, but still come with a whole host of health problems. Their poor mum will end up in rescue herself after a while.

StellaAndCrow · 16/12/2022 22:15

I've looked at one of the sites mentioned above - how can they possibly have so many different breeds/crossbreeds of puppies all "available now"?

Notaligned · 16/12/2022 22:10

We accidentally got a dog from a puppy farm about 20 years ago, so before social media. Educated, Middle class family, so sorry we don't meet the "poor and thick" criteria many on here would tar us with.

The dog was for my grandmother, who had fallen in love with the idea of a Bichon frise. We thought we were buying from a licensed breeder and when it became apparent it was a puppy farm we tried to walk away. By this point my dog who was with us was trying to revive an unconscious puppy by licking her, we couldn't pull her away and ended up buying this half dead puppy because we didn't know what else to do and couldn't leave this poor little thing.

We lay her in the back of the car with my dog convinced there would be a dead puppy by the time we got home. She ended up rallying and became my grandmother's best friend and comfort for 15 year and beloved by us all.

I loathe puppy farms, I'd never advocate for them, I don't believe we all have the right to own dogs - but I wanted to share why some people might end up with a puppy farm dog - I'm sure I'm not the only one.