Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why on earth people still buy from puppy farms?

207 replies

hennaoj · 16/12/2022 19:38

Why oh why do people buy puppies from the likes of Kelly's Kennels and Douglas Hall Kennels?

This is where the poor puppies come from. www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-32308177
Surely people know that you need to see the puppies mother before buying? Never mind the fact that these puppies won't be dna health tested.

OP posts:
userxx · 17/12/2022 07:46

I knew someone who bought a pup from Kelly's kennels, as much as I tried to tell them how fucking ignorant and stupid they'd been, they just couldn't see it. Puppy's farms and their welfare just aren't on some people's radar.

LakieLady · 17/12/2022 07:45

dolor · 16/12/2022 22:19

It's because they're arsholes

Yes, arseholes who lack the self-control to do their research, find a reputable breeder, put their name on the waiting list and wait for the right puppy to become available. They want a puppy and they want it now, and if they could get one from a supermarket while picking up bog roll and baked beans they'd probably do that.

I swear some people put a lot less thought and research into buying a puppy than choosing their next car.

When I wanted a puppy of a specific breed, that I had researched extensively, I waited 18 months for the right one, and drove 220 miles to pick the one I wanted from the litter.

When I wanted a second one, I did another 200+ mile trip to a "reputable" breeder. When I got there, the place was immaculate, but the dogs were in runs in the garden except for the bitch that had had the puppies. They were in a outbuilding, spotlessly clean, warm and cosy, but I went right off the set-up when the breeder showed me the treadmill they used to exercise the dogs. They lived in the middle of nowhere on the edge of a moor, ffs! That was a well-regarded show breeder, too.

Needless to say, I didn't get a puppy from them, but lucked in a few months later when a breeder whose values I really respected unexpectedly had a puppy available because the person who was going to have her had developed some serious health issues. That puppy became the most fantastic dog, and was my devoted companion for nearly 18 years.

I'm too old for another puppy now, but am considering getting an older dog, maybe one that's retired from showing.

fanjosaysi · 17/12/2022 07:44

If you are happy to acquire a dog bred in horrifically cruel conditions just because you WANT one then you probably shouldn't have a dog at all. In fact I think it would mark someone out as an incredibly unsuitable dog owner.

Exactly

Can't believe people are basically saying 'don't judge, some people can't afford it!' As if that justifies enabling dogs to be treated so deplorably

Ignorance is the only acceptable excuse (and even that's pushing it with all the publicity there's been). If you think 'adoption is hard' is a reason to actively choose a puppy farm dog then you should not have any pet.

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 17/12/2022 07:42

I think these places exist simply because rescues make it too difficult to adopt

Years ago I used to frequent the doghouse on here. Every time someone posted saying 'no rescue will rehome to us', I would find out where they lived and provide details of small local rescues who were much more open to taking individual circumstances into account. People never went down that route. Either because they just would not wait for the right pup, or because they actually knew that with both parents working full time and having 4 children under 10 that they didn't really have the ideal set up for a puppy....it's virtually always a case of we want a puppy and we will go get one now. No thought and no care for the suffering animals.

mostlydrinkstea · 17/12/2022 07:40

We found the breeder of our Maine Coons by asking our vet. It turned out that there was someone on his list who showed them and was starting to breed them. We had three cats from her. All three were 'slight seconds' but we knew what we were getting. The first was a crossbreed MC moggie as she was as testing out whether she could cope with raising kittens in the house. That stunning bundle of fluff lived for 16 years. The second was a pedigree MC but pet quality. She succumbed to cancer at 14. She was a typical MC who would play fetch with paper balls.

We waited for nearly three years for one in a specific colour that my husband really wanted. The kitten had a really tough start in life and although he was show quality the breeder wanted him to go to a family home. She knew we would love him. He was always a bit odd. She had moved by then so we collected him at a service station with lots of giggles from us and her as it looked so dodgy but we had become friends. My children have very happy memories of visiting her and her cats in the biggest cat playground ever that her husband had created in their garden.

She isn't breeding anymore. There are good breeders out there but it costs money and you have to wait.

TheyreOnlyNoodlesMichael · 17/12/2022 07:38

Because they really don't care. They trot out 'excuses' but it's really just as simple as they don't care. We want a dog. We don't care that actually we probably aren't at the right stage for a dog. We will go buy one.

FOJN · 17/12/2022 07:37

I think these places exist simply because rescues make it too difficult to adopt.

I can't interpret this as anything other than an admission that when it comes to animals some people have no shame in putting their wants before an animals needs.

It's harder to adopt a baby than a dog or a cat and the pain of not being able to have children is arguably more intense than not being able to have a dog but no one would condone locking women in cages in dark sheds to breed them for profit and then transporting the babies in buckets to the place of sale, hoping that your profits aren't affected by too much "stock" dying en route.

Owning a pet is a want not a need. You are not an animal lover if you will turn a blind eye to animal cruelty to get what you "want".

You do not have a human right to own a pet.

BertieBotts · 17/12/2022 07:36

I've never had a dog, but DH wants one. If I wanted to get one, I wouldn't know where to start. I've just googled "puppies for sale" which I'm sure will lead me straight to a load of puppy farms. But they look fine - I wouldn't be able to tell at first glance there's anything wrong.

I can't even see any with waiting lists, so I'm not sure that's a helpful sign? I wouldn't know what breed of dog I want, so I wouldn't be able to start from a breed search.

When FIL died, the family went on Pets4Homes and picked up a dog for MIL within a couple of days. According to DH that is what they do in their family.

(Not actually looking right now before you shout me down).

Tuilpmouse · 17/12/2022 07:35

I think people understandably assume that if the puppy comes from a licensed farm that conditions will therefore be adequate, not amazing perhaps, but not cruel either... so their conscience is clear.

If conditions are as bad as those on here are saying, it's either a matter for law enforcement (ie terms of license aren't being adhered to) or the law needs tightening and MPs need to be lobbied (easy win for an MP to champion such a cause) - I'd be happy to lobby if this was the case.

stayathomer · 17/12/2022 07:35

I wasn’t saying about people with dogs. Somebody above said it’s probably the people who shop in Primark.

user2859453 · 17/12/2022 07:29

some people buy from Primark because they have no choice, they can’t afford to spend huge amounts. Sad but true.

They shouldn't be getting a dog then

stayathomer · 17/12/2022 07:26

To add analogies- people buy clothing from Primark even after the deaths of some who make their clothes, people will go on holiday to places where women are very ill-treated (see recent thread on Morocco) or to places where being LGBT is illegal, for example.
some people buy from Primark because they have no choice, they can’t afford to spend huge amounts. Sad but true.

user2859453 · 17/12/2022 07:26

It will be the same type of people that shop at places like Primark

Buildingthefuture · 17/12/2022 07:25

@MilkyYay if you don’t like dogs, I would assume you haven’t been very involved in dog rescue? Please don’t peddle the crap about rescue dogs having “issues”. Yes, some do, and there are some that will never be suitable to be rehomed, but most just need a bit of TLC and to learn that actually, not all people are horrid. There are also lots that have no issues, but because they aren’t cute puppies or a silly designer breed, they get overlooked.

stayathomer · 17/12/2022 07:23

While I absolutely do not agree with puppy farms etc I think there’s a lot of people on this thread who were very lucky getting their animals. We were years trying to get a dog. We were constantly offered unsuitable breeds from dogs trust and other rescues We simply wanted a friendly breed to be part of our family. Add in us end I’d up with cats and things got more difficult. Finally we bought a puppy from a site that sells anything and everything. That site has since stopped selling animals but we have the love of our life and our little man has the best life. Great adopting worked for the adopt don’t shop brigade but sadly in our experience it’s only for single people with no kids that have the time, knowledge and experience to help deal with huge breeds or extremely nervous dogs

LlynTegid · 17/12/2022 07:22

The first reply said it all.

To add analogies- people buy clothing from Primark even after the deaths of some who make their clothes, people will go on holiday to places where women are very ill-treated (see recent thread on Morocco) or to places where being LGBT is illegal, for example.

user53852098 · 17/12/2022 07:18

There is a dog section on here

Buildingthefuture · 17/12/2022 07:10

Because, IME, people have one of two attitudes when it comes to getting a dog:

  1. what can this dog do for me
  2. what can I do for this dog

Far too many people want a dog simply because they want one, not because they know they can provide a good home for 15 years. And, many people want (and teach their children to want) immediate gratification. So yes, I could go out today and buy 10 dogs if I wanted. And getting a rescue is a longer process. You have to be home checked, sometimes wait until a suitable dog comes up etc.
It is NOT impossible to get a rescue if you have children, harder of course (and rightly so) but not impossible. I’ve placed loads of puppies and occasionally older dogs, with children under 7 over the years. With rescue centres being as overwhelmed as they are, I do not understand why people keep breeding. And yes YOU might want a (insert the name of any breed here) but none of the dogs in shelters WANT to be there or asked to be bred. They have been badly let down by people and I for one prefer to be a person that steps up to help, rather than a person who adds to the problem.

MilkyYay · 17/12/2022 07:10

Rescues have a high proportion of poorly socialised dogs with "issues", and often are hugely picky about who can have a dog. I don't personally like dogs but plenty of families with children want one & there is often simply nowhere else they can go to get a dog.

Orangesare · 17/12/2022 05:52

In the past people often had a bitch who would have one litter. They weren’t breeders and health checks wouldn’t be done and one bitch would be kept to continue the line and later bred from again. No expense would be spared on health care because it was their much loved bitch.
Now it’s considered really bad to have an occasional litter and many people do want to buy without health checks from a pet or small working home. So it leaves expensive breeders and puppy farms or rescues.

MargotChateau · 17/12/2022 05:35

@Notaligned I hope you also reported the puppy farm and the conditions you witnessed to the local council and animal welfare charities, rather than just encourage more breeding by buying a half dead dog?

WhaleInAManger · 17/12/2022 05:31

Puppy farm puppies are not cheap puppies. They are a business and charge the 'going rate' or close to it. Sad though that concept is.

Cheap puppies tend to come from someone who's knocked their bitch up with their mate's dog. Irresponsible maybe but not cruel on the scale of farms.

MargotChateau · 17/12/2022 05:30

@Msgrieves “ Not everyone is middle class and settled and can afford the amount of money it takes to own "ethically". They still want a dog, they can buy a dog, so they will”.

If you can’t afford a dog ethically, you shouldn’t own one!! Why should someone’s desire to own a dog, outweigh the need for a dog to be bred responsibly for health and temperament and the bitch to have a happy life and not be overbred. Good breeders vet the homes their dogs go to, and take them back if the dog owners circumstances change. Half the issue with all the idiots I see with untrained dogs in the parks atm, is idiot owners with breeds that are out of their experience level and who don’t bother to put the work in to train for the dogs and others safety and happiness.

(I currently don’t own a dog because even though my job is okayish, I have a shared backyard that isn’t securely fenced, and I can’t afford a dog sitter, insurance etc, and I’ve spent a lifetime fostering and would love to own again, but I’m not selfish enough to do that at the expense of the dog).

Henrysmycat · 17/12/2022 05:17

Please! When I hear Bullcrap about “not everyone can afford a proper breeder dog and they don’t want a rescue dog.”
Really?
What kind of sick attitude is this?
I want it and I want it now.
Some people here need a serious look in the mirror. If they think making an animal suffer because their spoilt little Jayden or Billy wants a dog, they need their head checked.
unbelievable.

drpet49 · 17/12/2022 05:16

maranella · 16/12/2022 19:48

Bottom line OP - because they're ignorant and selfish and they don't actually care where it comes from.

This. They don’t care about it what is right or wrong. All they care about is themselves and what they want.