Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why on earth people still buy from puppy farms?

207 replies

hennaoj · 16/12/2022 19:38

Why oh why do people buy puppies from the likes of Kelly's Kennels and Douglas Hall Kennels?

This is where the poor puppies come from. www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-32308177
Surely people know that you need to see the puppies mother before buying? Never mind the fact that these puppies won't be dna health tested.

OP posts:
meetmynewusername · 18/12/2022 02:09

I didn’t really mean to start a debate about whether crossbreeds are healthier or not, maybe I’m right about that and maybe I’m wrong.

The main thing I think, as far as the OP goes, is that if you want a labradoodle or a cavapoo or whatever, as many many kind and responsible prospective dog owners do, it’s extremely difficult to know which breeders are ethical, you really just have word of mouth and your own judgement to go by.

Furries · 18/12/2022 01:49

One of the worst cross breeds I saw was a Rottweiler and chihuahua mix - WTF thinks that’s a good idea? Poor blooming dogs.

Other pp have got it right - the sentiment is so often “I want a dog, so shall get one however I can”. So few people seem to research breed traits, requirements, etc.

Lots of people seem to think that small dogs are easy. They often require more work/input/training/exercise than large/giant dogs.

tabulahrasa · 17/12/2022 20:21

@Buildingthefuture

“You opened your post with the statement that people who are “into” dogs will only go for pedigrees.”

I didn’t, I said they’re anti crossbreed because they’re anti bad breeding, not because they’re pro pedigree.

I own a mongrel btw, literally no clue what he is as the rescue never saw either parent and every puppy in the litter grew up to look slightly different.

There is though absolutely a place for ethical breeders, it’s just that unfortunately they’re pretty rare and they really aren't breeding crosses.

isadoradancing123 · 17/12/2022 20:12

Maybe they dont know how to source a breeder, also a breeder will be more expensive

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/12/2022 20:04

On top of all the other reasons...

Because it is FAR far easier to find a puppy farm that looks clean, makes the process simple, no hurdles to jump through etc..

Than it is to find a reputable, quality breeder, who will make people jump through hoops of fire.

If you don't even know what you're looking for, it is easy to go for the first most obvious option and a clean commercial kennels with several breeds to choose from SEEMS reasonable to most people buying their first or even subsequent dog.

Buildingthefuture · 17/12/2022 20:02

@tabulahrasa You opened your post with the statement that people who are “into” dogs will only go for pedigrees. You literally could not be more wrong. I agree that these trendy mixed breed dogs (cavapoo/cocker poo, whatever) are an excellent way for shitty breeders to get round breeding rules and could have problems. And there is no such thing as a “hypoallergenic” dog. But those of us who are really, truly, “into” dogs, give not a shiny shite about “breed”. We take on dogs that need a home, irrespective of breed. And, we so often end up paying for the surgery/treatment that dog needs, because the original “owner” didn’t do their research/couldn’t afford it/ didn’t care. I have, and always have had, a house full of dogs. Almost 40 dogs in 20+ years. I don’t regret it for one single minute and they give me back a thousand times what I could ever give them. My entire social circle is the same. You name the breed and we’ve had one, or a cross. All rescue and all needing a home after some irresponsible asshat wouldn’t or couldn’t give them what they need. I would suggest you spend some time in dog rescue….it will be eye opening for you.

EddyF · 17/12/2022 19:33

tabulahrasa · 17/12/2022 05:04

You start by looking for a breeder and then waiting for them to have a litter rather than looking for a puppy. That usually (though not absolutely always) means you’re going on a waiting list for a planned litter some point in the next year or two.

You’re looking for someone who breeds because they want a puppy from the litter to do whatever it is they do with their dogs (showing, a sport, working).

The breed club is usually the best place to start.

You research all the appropriate health tests for the breed and when you ask about them, they should not only be happy to discuss them, but will have the paperwork for them... they should want to know about your set up and some actually have questionnaires or other things like that to find out about you, but equally should be happy to answer any questions you have. They’ll also insist (sometimes with a contract) that if you ever need to rehome the puppy for any reason that you go to them first.

They’ll likely have more dogs than an average person, lol, but usually between between 5 and 7, 2 or 3 of breeding age, a couple too young and 2 or 3 too old because they’ll only breed every couple of years. Those numbers aren’t exact, but... if they’re breeding several litters a year or they rehome the dogs when they’ve finished breeding dogs then they’re big red flags and if they have loads of dogs then they’re probably kept outside and that again (with the exception of working dogs that you’d probably not want as a pet anyway) that’s a massive red flag.

They’ll usually not own the dad, because it’s hugely unlikely that they just happen to own a dog that has traits that complement the bitch. If they’ve just got two pet dogs they’re breeding for the hell of it, some people are ok with that, but it can cause potential issues for a puppy owner.

Kennel club registration is really basic, but if they’re an eligible breed they should be doing it, there’s no ok reason not to and it means you can check the health tests and the inbreeding coefficient yourself online.

Thank you. Much appreciated.

PeopleAreTheWorst · 17/12/2022 19:26

I live quite locally To KK. I can spot one of their puppies a mile away. They are always scared of the world. It's horrific.
I've spoken to people and told them to avoid places like that but often they don't care. They've decided they want a puppy and will not wait. I hate people.

tabulahrasa · 17/12/2022 19:25

Buildingthefuture · 17/12/2022 19:09

@tabulahrasa that is utter, unadulterated horse shit. Purists my eye. A cross breed (or mongrel) is so often FAR healthier than an over bred “pedigree”. Almost 50% of pedigree daschunds have to have spinal surgery and have you LOOKED at a “pedigree” GSD, Pug, French Bull Dog, Bull Dog (add the names of so many different “breeds”) So many just cannot live normal lives, with normal walks or changes in temperature without significant surgical intervention. Do your research, because those are FACTS!!!

But you don’t automatically get rid of the health issues by cross breeding.

Cross a pug or frenchie or anything else like that and it might be healthier, but it might not - because those issues are not a single gene that you can breed out by crossing with an unaffected dog.

Some of the most common crosses are between dogs that share the same health issues, so they’ve just as much chance of getting them as if they were pedigrees.

The way to improve health is to carefully breed healthy functional dogs that have passed health tests, something that is very very rare with people breeding crosses.

The fact that some breeds are in a terrible state and shouldn’t be being bred from if you’ve any ethics doesn’t automatically make a labradoodle, cockapoo, jug or whatever cross is currently popular any healthier than it would have been if the breeder had bred 2 random untested pedigree dogs, in fact that what they are doing, they’re breeding 2 random untested pedigree dogs together, just not of the same breed.

There are some breeds that could benefit from outcrossing, but they’re not the ones people are commonly crossing.

OoooohMatron · 17/12/2022 19:24

Shannith · 16/12/2022 21:01

This 100%

It's like their is a cruelty blindness. Your cute puppy farm puppy came from a bitch who spends her life in a cage.

A bitch who was a cute puppy once but is now used literally to produce as many puppies of any breed/cross that currently reaches the highest price.

She has about 5 litters before she's broken and no more use to them - where if she is extremely lucky she'll get passed into a rescue but most likely killed. And I don't mean put down at a vets.

That's the reality of puppy farming.

Expensive, unhealthy (physically and mentally) dogs born out of torture or other dogs.

My friend has a rescue who spent her life in a cage being forced to breed on a puppy farm before being rescued. It's horrible.

Suzi888 · 17/12/2022 19:13

Buildingthefuture · 17/12/2022 19:09

@tabulahrasa that is utter, unadulterated horse shit. Purists my eye. A cross breed (or mongrel) is so often FAR healthier than an over bred “pedigree”. Almost 50% of pedigree daschunds have to have spinal surgery and have you LOOKED at a “pedigree” GSD, Pug, French Bull Dog, Bull Dog (add the names of so many different “breeds”) So many just cannot live normal lives, with normal walks or changes in temperature without significant surgical intervention. Do your research, because those are FACTS!!!

I agree with buildingthefuture.

Buildingthefuture · 17/12/2022 19:09

@tabulahrasa that is utter, unadulterated horse shit. Purists my eye. A cross breed (or mongrel) is so often FAR healthier than an over bred “pedigree”. Almost 50% of pedigree daschunds have to have spinal surgery and have you LOOKED at a “pedigree” GSD, Pug, French Bull Dog, Bull Dog (add the names of so many different “breeds”) So many just cannot live normal lives, with normal walks or changes in temperature without significant surgical intervention. Do your research, because those are FACTS!!!

hennaoj · 17/12/2022 15:48

Menopants · 17/12/2022 08:57

But you can say the same about most farmed animals. Every seen footage of a pig farm?

You don't buy a pig and bring it into your home, you are buying the meat. There is also a choice of better produced meat that is free range/higher welfare.
You run a risk buying a farmed puppy temperament wise, a huge risk if you have small children. There's also the very big vet bill risk. The risk of a dog that is going to be hard to live with. You minimise those risks greatly by buying from a reputable breeder or going to a good rescue.

OP posts:
hennaoj · 17/12/2022 15:29

meetmynewusername · 17/12/2022 12:39

Well I don’t have a dog, but if I decided to get one I would have the following issues:

rescue:
*don’t know the background and wouldn’t want to risk them around kids.

breeder:

  • don’t want a pure bred dog because I believe they suffer more health issues, and I fancy a crossbreed in terms of size, temperament, coat and exercise needs. I know dog purists don’t agree with ‘designer dogs’ but let’s face it they are popular for a reason.

So then I would struggle to know where to buy a dog from because crossbreeds aren’t in the kennel club are they and they aren't working ot show dogs, so it’s very difficult to know where is legit.

You left with working dog breeders, a few do cross breeds such as sprockers. I know a lady who is crossing Rough collies with welsh sheepdogs and hers will be very good but definately need a proper job!

Pure breds can be very healthy, especially if health tested via dna. You know what you are getting with a purebred, with a cross breed it could take more after one parent than the other. The coats on doodles can be an absolute nightmare to groom.
Temperament wise I wouldn't touch a farmed puppy with a barge pole, you'd have absolutely no idea on the father or mothers temperament.

OP posts:
xyhere · 17/12/2022 14:38

All of the above, but also...

"It's just a dog."

...usually from parents who've bought their kids a dog after promising it to get some kind of cooperation from the children in question.

Otherwise known as "wilful and deliberate ignorance".

As for the breed question...we only have rescue dogs, but specifically Chihuahuas and Akitas, because we have lots of experience with them and they generally have very breed-specific needs (both in terms of health and socially). And there are tons of them in rescues, because people get them as cute puppies and have absolutely no idea what they're doing, so they end up abandoned when they're out-of-control adolescents/adults.

Therellbenobutterinhell123 · 17/12/2022 14:27

I accidentally bought from a puppy farmer. We had correspondence for weeks beforehand including video calls, met at a "naice" family home with kids present, our puppies "mum" and siblings were there, we saw paperwork and healthchecks etc. We were given a contract, blanket smelling of "mum" and puppy food and milk that she said puppy was settled on.
Imagine my horror a year later when I see this woman "exposed" on Facebook as being a puppy farmer and that it was all a front, it was someone else's house that was used and paperwork was faked!
I had never bought a dog before and maybe I was naive but I honestly thought I'd done due diligence. The only red flag I had at the time was that when I went to bank transfer the money, my banking app said the name on the account didn't match. She explained this as she'd just got married and not changed it yet. As I was cautious, she said to first just transfer 1p so she could check it was the right details. She then showed me her phone to confirm it was the right account before I transferred the rest.
Luckily, our dog is now 3 and is physically and psychologically healthy but I realise most aren't.

StellaAndCrow · 17/12/2022 14:15

tabulahrasa · 17/12/2022 13:11

People that are into dogs don’t dislike cross breeds because they’re purists, they dislike them because most of them are badly bred... and because there’s rarely any point to having them over one of the original breeds.

Cross breeding doesn’t get rid of many health issues and careless breeding can cause more. Things like size, coat, temperament, coat and exercise needs are less predictable with a cross - what you’re doing is basically playing roulette with every trait from both breeds.

and... they’re a puppy farmers wet dream, get a load of bitches of any breed you fancy and a make poodle and voila hundreds of thousands of pounds worth of puppies that you can tell people any old rubbish about, like that they’re hypo allergenic and have hybrid vigour.

Yes, one of those sites often has in the crossbreeds' descriptions "so the puppy has the best characteristics of both breeds!"
How can they know? They could just as easily have the worst characteristics of both parent breeds.

StellaAndCrow · 17/12/2022 14:13

A colleague got a puppy from what she believed was a legit place - it was hundreds of miles away, when she got there she had suspicions, but took the puppy anyway.
"If it was a puppy farm, I was rescuing it anyway".

Which obviously isn't the point. I see the worn out breeding females that end up in rescues.

StellaAndCrow · 17/12/2022 14:10

hennaoj · 16/12/2022 22:40

Because they come from a huge farm in Fivemiletown, Ireland, both of the ones I have mentioned have breeding dogs in that farm. Kelly's Kennels have 900 breeding dogs over there.

Thank you Henna - wow, that's awful.

FOJN · 17/12/2022 13:50

VegMam

Already discussed, read the thread.

VegMam · 17/12/2022 13:48

I hope anyone (rightly) outraged about puppy farms shows the same compassion towards other farmed animals whose only end to their suffering is a brutal slaughter.

burnout1993 · 17/12/2022 13:43

It’s definitely fed by a culture of convenience and wanting something immediately. I’m sure this time of year adds more problems to the mix and would be wary of any ‘breeder’ putting in their advert any mention of being ready for Christmas (which I have seen before).

I volunteer for a rescue and see so many times various things which probably fuel this awful practice such as people expecting a rescue dog for free or next to nothing, wanting it immediately or expecting it to be completely trained. People have complained about having to make the effort to fill out adoption questionnaires before to check their lifestyle matches the dog. When you advise there isn’t a dog that fits their criteria yet and go back to them when there is, you often get the response that they just quickly bought a puppy.
People are quick to complain about rescues but there are lots of amazing ones who will consider children and other circumstances, it’s again, just being prepared to do your research and being bothered to make some
effort. These type of people are the same ones who want to give up a dog soon after because it’s hard work to train, they’re moving house or having a baby now and ‘we don’t have time to meet their needs’.

Rescues have saved dogs from awful cruelty and need to be sure they’re going to be loved and cared for, than to risk that again.

I always gauge a good starting point as a breeder almost interviewing you about your life and what you can offer the dog. They don’t come across too keen straight away.
Knowing what a mum dog should look like after birth and how the puppies interact with her, rather than just a clean and perfectly healthy dog they don’t know and have no interest in. A willingness to put a contract in place and aftercare like wanting to see photos of the dogs growing up and evidence that they have kept a puppy before or plan to (some of this only apparent after the sale admittedly).

Tuilpmouse · 17/12/2022 13:30

@Winterscomingagain

Does the government need to tell us that keeping hundreds of breeding dogs locked up to breed throughout their productive years is wrong. That tying a bitch in a breeding stand to effectively be raped repeatedly is wrong?

No, but it's not unreasonable to expect Government to enact laws and regulations to stop abuses, and to properly police it.

Toomanysleepycats · 17/12/2022 13:22

I think it’s all the reasons posted but also due to manipulation by the sellers who will say anything to put the buyers mind at rest.

I think unless you have specifically looked up the red flags on buying from bad breeders, the ‘blarney’ from the sellers will keep them hooked.

The sellers will have a convincing story of why they can’t meet the mother, or need to meet in a car park. Some people find it very hard to say things like, “no, I won’t meet in a car park, or why do I need to pay by cash?”

The sellers will understand all the psychological tricks and foibles to fool people wanting to make such an emotional purchase.

Yes, my first thought might be to say they are thick. But people who aren’t cynical old gits like me, get fooled and taken advantage of by others all the time.

tabulahrasa · 17/12/2022 13:11

meetmynewusername · 17/12/2022 12:39

Well I don’t have a dog, but if I decided to get one I would have the following issues:

rescue:
*don’t know the background and wouldn’t want to risk them around kids.

breeder:

  • don’t want a pure bred dog because I believe they suffer more health issues, and I fancy a crossbreed in terms of size, temperament, coat and exercise needs. I know dog purists don’t agree with ‘designer dogs’ but let’s face it they are popular for a reason.

So then I would struggle to know where to buy a dog from because crossbreeds aren’t in the kennel club are they and they aren't working ot show dogs, so it’s very difficult to know where is legit.

People that are into dogs don’t dislike cross breeds because they’re purists, they dislike them because most of them are badly bred... and because there’s rarely any point to having them over one of the original breeds.

Cross breeding doesn’t get rid of many health issues and careless breeding can cause more. Things like size, coat, temperament, coat and exercise needs are less predictable with a cross - what you’re doing is basically playing roulette with every trait from both breeds.

and... they’re a puppy farmers wet dream, get a load of bitches of any breed you fancy and a make poodle and voila hundreds of thousands of pounds worth of puppies that you can tell people any old rubbish about, like that they’re hypo allergenic and have hybrid vigour.