Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why on earth people still buy from puppy farms?

207 replies

hennaoj · 16/12/2022 19:38

Why oh why do people buy puppies from the likes of Kelly's Kennels and Douglas Hall Kennels?

This is where the poor puppies come from. www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-northern-ireland-32308177
Surely people know that you need to see the puppies mother before buying? Never mind the fact that these puppies won't be dna health tested.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
hennaoj · 20/12/2022 17:05

This explains why they are able to get away with it in the UK.

Lucy’s Law bans the third-party sale of puppies in England, Scotland and Wales it does not apply in Northern Ireland. This means that English businesses can register as pet shops with licences in Northern Ireland. This enables puppies to be transported to the UK using a loophole in the legislation.

OP posts:
tabulahrasa · 19/12/2022 21:51

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

A well bred dog is bred with purpose and care, by someone who cares about the health and welfare of their dogs and the puppies produced.

3 or 4 years ago you could easily get a well bred dog of lots of breeds for between £500 and £700, but, when everyone wanted a puppy during lockdown puppy farms ramped up production and prices... while good breeders held off their planned litters until they knew they’d be able to travel and access vets and stuff like that. Now they’re selling for more because they’re worried people will buy their puppies and sell them on for profit, or breed them for profit. So they’re more like 1-2k, which is still cheaper than badly bred puppies of the same breed.

People pay much more than that for dogs that are more likely to come with hugely expensive, heart breaking and life shortening health issues and more likely to come with behavioural issues that make them unsuitable as pets...

hennaoj · 19/12/2022 21:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

The dna tests for a rough collie cost approx £200, then there's the hip score test for parents at approx £250 each. There's also the cost of rearing a litter and associated vet bills e.g. ultrasound, litter eye test etc. If breeders were to sell at the amount you suggest they would be making a loss.

OP posts:
Ericaequites · 19/12/2022 21:06

@nancydroo Some of us don’t have children or a long term relationship. Having a cat makes us feel someone loves us best. My cat leads a life better than some children.

Wolfiefan · 19/12/2022 21:01

@Coucous a well bred dog is one bred from health tested parents. (Specialist tests needed for different breeds.) From a carefully matched pair. (Not a couple of pets breeding indiscriminately.) From a bitch who isn’t being bred season after season. By a breeder who cares about animal welfare, chooses owners carefully and offers support and advice.

Coucous · 19/12/2022 20:43

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

tabulahrasa · 19/12/2022 19:38

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

It’s not a rule, just me saying if you can’t afford 1k for a well bred dog, realistically you can’t afford a dog and it’s a weird argument because
badly bred dogs are usually more to buy anyway.

There absolutely are people breeding KC registered dogs who are businesses making a living from it, there are puppy farms selling KC registered dogs in fact.

KC registration does not make a good breeder, it doesn’t mean a dog is well bred, it means nothing other than a dog is registered as being that breed.

XenoBitch · 19/12/2022 19:30

bloodyplanes · 19/12/2022 08:56

Im sure being stuck in rescue/kennels for months on end really doesn't make for happy dogs! It makes for highly stressed dogs who often then develop destructive/aggressive coping mechanisms!

Decent rescues have an army of foster homes that look after dogs in their care until a forever home is found. The dogs are already in a home environment and not stressed. Any in actual kennels are still being assessed or have extra needs.
The rescue my dog is from absolutely spoils the hounds they have in their kennels. They are not pacing in circles all day and laying in their own shit.

Quveas · 19/12/2022 18:57

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

I'm not remotely a fan of the KC, or mass breeding. But your argument isn't sustainable. Which is why so many people ignore advice.

Average lifespan of a dog, across all breeds, is about 12 years. £2k is about £3 a week. How much do people spend weekly on make-up, clothes hobbies etc? Pet insurance is very expensive, and gets more so with the age of the dog. Good quality dog food is not cheap. And that's the thin edge of the age for good owners - toys, games, training, time....

I'd abolish the KC if I could. I hate their selective breeding standards. But a dog is a commitment, in time, money and so much more. People absolutely should be prepared to accept a cost. Dogs are not toys. They cost money. And the scariest thing is that people think they are cheap...

Coucous · 19/12/2022 18:25

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Quveas · 19/12/2022 18:24

To be fair, the article linked is 7 years old, and whilst puppy farming is still a problem, I do think that many people are better informed than they were.

That said - and to be clear I would never use a puppy farm - I do think rescues are often too pedantic. I'll be personal here. I'm disabled, shit mobility since 2017 ( although poor before then). I have a fabulously well trained border collie, trained by me, and a registered service dog. I have continously trained border collies since childhood and I'm 65. My current dog is from an ISDS line from one of my earliest dogs. I have a house with 2 acres of land, fenced in. My dog gets an average of 12 kilometres of exercise daily split into two walks. He's the healthiest dog my vet had ever seen. I'll leave out the mental games and all the rest...

I would be turned down by EVERY rescue agency going.

The perverse thing? I'm a volunteer for the Dogs Trust and my role, as a qualified behaviouralist, is supporting difficult adoptions!

Oher · 19/12/2022 18:06

Totally hate puppy farms, but to answer your question:

  1. Because rescue centres are way too fussy and intrusive, insisting on home inspections and refusing to let people have dogs, particularly puppies, if they have young children or haven’t owned a dog before.
  2. Because puppy farms lie. They don’t say “We are evil would you like to buy a mistreated dog” they advertise on gumtree / pets4homes with a photo of a puppy in a cute basket and say “Our beloved family dog has had her first litter, 5* homes only plz” and then you view the dog and see it ‘mum’ and only an expert would notice that the ‘mum’ is not lactating and has clearly never given birth. Happened to my friend.
tabulahrasa · 19/12/2022 17:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Good breeders aren’t breeding several times a year though.

I was talking to a couple of breeders for a breed I was interested in before I adopted my current dog, they’ve each had one litter in 3 years.

and to be dead honest, if you can’t afford to save up that much then it’s a pretty good indication that you can’t afford a dog, because my perfectly healthy not particularly large dog costs easily 1k a year, on food, insurance, vaccinations etc.

Coucous · 19/12/2022 17:16

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

tabulahrasa · 19/12/2022 12:50

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

The ones costing anything like that are almost exclusively the dodgy sources.

Nobody is buying puppy farmed dogs because they’re cheaper than well bred ones, they’re often twice the price from a puppy farm.

Good breeders are trying to get a dog for themselves that’s suitable for whatever it is they use their dogs for - they sell the extras at the going rate for that breed because giving them away or selling them cheap isn’t a good idea for dog welfare, there are lots of terrible reasons people look for cheap or free dogs. But for breeds with bigger litters that’s about 1k, smaller closer to 2k... there’s very few that’d be even close to 3k.

If they’re lucky, have a big litter and everything goes fine medically they might finish with a bit of a profit, but you’re looking at spending at least 3 to 4K to breed a litter properly, plus 8 weeks of looking after and socialising puppies, you can double or triple that cost if there’s any medical complications.

When it’s a litter bred to make money, they cut costs and charge more - because that’s how they get profit.

Coucous · 19/12/2022 11:06

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Wolfiefan · 19/12/2022 09:42

Zipps that’s really good. It’s not about what you want. It’s about what the dogs need. They want to avoid failed adoptions.

Zipps · 19/12/2022 09:37

The rescue home assess dogs into different categories such as
Can/cannot be homed with cats, other dogs etc
Need experienced owners of this breed
Must be only animal
No children under5/10/15 etc
Your lifestyle, job, how often it will be left alone/ walked etc.
It's nothing to do with how much land you have. I know someone with a small yard who rehomed two dogs a few years ago because their lifestyle, experience and everything else fitted with those dogs
It's to get a good match and to weed out the irresponsible owners.
People going in demanding "that one because it's cute", with not a thought to lifestyle, behaviour, where the animal is going to fit in aren't going to get very far and rightly so.

tabulahrasa · 19/12/2022 09:10

user175438765 · 19/12/2022 08:46

To have a dog from a rescue you have to live in a modern box which has a squarish garden with a 6 ft fence round it, our garden and various fences around it is not appropriate for this. We may meet the other criteria as we have no children or cats and are retired but probably not as we are retired so that would probably not be deemed appropriate either

Nope

i live rurally with a pretty odd garden set up, when we first moved in, I put stock fencing where there would be gaps and across the bottom of hedges and built small bits of 6ft wooden fencing to stop access to the largest bit of “garden” which is unsecured and would have cost a fortune to secure....

That’s fine, they’re not looking for you to exercise your dog in the garden, just somewhere safe they can go to the toilet.

tabulahrasa · 19/12/2022 08:59

BratzB · 19/12/2022 07:16

I think the point is they turn people who are suitable because they don't meet perfection/ have a rigid set of rules (6ft fence for a Jack Russell)

Um... not being funny but that’s a terrible example, Jack Russells can easy clear a lower fence.

@SelkieSeal

Your options re a secure garden were to either put that field on the application form as your garden, or secure off part of your actual garden. I applied for a dog once where they stopped taking applications after 600 arrived in one morning, they aren’t going to stop to work out that you’re being very exact about the word garden.

Existing animals though, yes, they are very strict about that, they quite often have very little background information about dogs and they can’t just go, yeah... should be ok, because if the dog starts attacking your other animals, not only does that dog then need removed quickly and another home found, with a new behavioural issue they need to declare, but they’ve at the very least allowed your existing animals to be stressed out too, if not injured or killed. Most rescues will only rehome with other animals if they know absolutely that the dog in question has lived with them before with no issues.

It took me 2 years to adopt my current dog because I have a cat, it’s frustrating, but that doesn’t make it wrong.

Fl0w3rYard · 19/12/2022 08:56

Cockapoos have been around since the 50s. A rescue dog is a massive gamble, far bigger than any cross breed for which you can research thoroughly breed traits to be sure you can cope with the worse.

Enormous miserable puppy farms are the extreme, there is a whole lot in between that and the other end of the spectrum. All breeders are doing it for money and many many shouldn’t be from home breeders to the supposed KC pure bred breeders. We saw a few for pure breeds advertised as such we ran for the hills.You use your common sense and research, research, research.

bloodyplanes · 19/12/2022 08:56

Thedoglovesmemore · 18/12/2022 19:10

Why should rescues lower their standard? Their focus is on dog welfare. They are dog experts and know what situations make for happy dogs who are less likely to be returned again.
we should race to the bottom because puppy farms are threatened as an alternative.

people who aren’t suitable to rescue don’t get to sulk and declare they had no choice but to go to a farm. That’s ridiculous and shows they weren’t suitable to own a dog in the first place.

Im sure being stuck in rescue/kennels for months on end really doesn't make for happy dogs! It makes for highly stressed dogs who often then develop destructive/aggressive coping mechanisms!

user175438765 · 19/12/2022 08:46

To have a dog from a rescue you have to live in a modern box which has a squarish garden with a 6 ft fence round it, our garden and various fences around it is not appropriate for this. We may meet the other criteria as we have no children or cats and are retired but probably not as we are retired so that would probably not be deemed appropriate either

SelkieSeal · 19/12/2022 07:51

I tried for over 2 years to re-home a dog via about 15-20 rescues. I live rurally in a house with land, I have older DC, one of whom is mostly home educated and I'm self employed so home most of the time.

All except one turned me down without even speaking to me because our garden isn't securely fenced - whilst this is technically true, the actual "garden" is in fact only a very small portion of our land which extends to 30 acres of meadow, orchard, and fields - all enclosed with stock-proof fencing. We are nearly a mile from a tarmacked road, and our farm backs onto a large woodland nature reserve. I tried to explain that I was happy to keep a dog on a lead to cross the garden and only let it off once in a secure field with the gate closed, but not one rescue wanted to hear it. I tried sending in a screenshot of the OS map showing where the house is and how we would be able to only let a dog loose in secure fields, but that didn't help either.

One rescue did agree to do a video home check, but then turned me down because of our existing animals (1 cat, 2 peacocks, some chickens and a few sheep).

I refused to even consider buying a dog from a breeder for a long time as I was concerned about puppy farming and also the money being asked - £1.5-2k for a puppy? Jog on!

And then a friend mentioned my search to her parents, who were breeding one litter from their working border collie (crossed with a working black Labrador). They had several homes lined up already but contacted me and said they'd let me know if anyone changed their minds. We got lucky, and for £400 (including jabs, microchip, and 4 weeks insurance) we now have the Best Dog In The World ™️, raised by people who genuinely adore her mum and took the time and care to give her the very best start. They have no plans to have another litter (in fact I think her mum has since been spayed) and every single puppy went to people they took the time to talk to, to question, to make a careful decision on. I was the only owner they didn't already know personally, but as their daughter knew me they were willing to consider us.

I'm sure I'll be told it was unethical, a backyard breeder, that if rescues deemed me and my home unsuitable I should have accepted it and remained dogless. But... she is so happy, so healthy, she truly is living her best life here with us, she gets woodland walks every day, she spends hours following us round while we are doing farm shit, she gets fed properly and always gets the broccoli stalk and has been an absolute joy to train. And, dare I say, she has brought us so much joy...

AlwaysGinPlease · 19/12/2022 07:29

@tunthebloodyalarmoff absolutely!

Thick and absolutely complicit in the abuse of the animals. I have ended friendships with such incredibly cruel and stupid people. They make me sick.