Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To think this is (yet another) bad day for women?

303 replies

Livingtothefull · 16/12/2022 18:16

On the same day that the male perpetrator is jailed for life for the particularly brutal murder of Megan Newborough, the victims of yet another murder in Kettering are named - a nurse and her two young children. A 52-year-old man has been arrested on suspicion of murder.

AIBU to be saddened, sickened and angered by this? Will it ever end, this catalogue of male violence against women and children?

OP posts:
NewToWoo · 17/12/2022 10:56

TruckerBarbie · 17/12/2022 01:59

Sorry, I think it's just an excuse to moan about men for many.

If we say two women a week are murdered and there are about 34m men in the UK, then approx 0.0003% of men are murderers.

A good way to tell if something is bigoted is to substitute a different group. So how about calling Muslims a generally homophobic group based on the fact that when surveyed approx 50% think gay people should be imprisoned?

I'll bet this would be a controversial statement, but how can we say one group are violent when 0.0003% of them kill, but not be able to say another group are homophobic when around 50% espouse homophobic views?

I don't expect a proper answer to that question tbh.

That really isn't a useful comparison at all. You are comparing opinion with action. To have a fair comparison you'd need to ask how many Muslims had beaten up or killed gay people.

Or you'd need to poll men to ask how many think women should be submissive or have domination fantasies. Compare like with like.

0.0003% doesn't include rape, domestic violence, street violence, GBH, assault, robbery, threat, stalking, coercion. Add those to the mix, the percentage grows and you will find that it is largely men who exhibit this behaviour.

PurpleButterflyWings · 17/12/2022 10:54

Arguingtomyright · 17/12/2022 09:41

In terms of murder, men are 3x more likely to be murdered than women in general.

Exactly! So why aren’t men up in arms about male-on-male violence?

Why do we stop our daughters going out and not our sons?

But these poor POOR boys/sons who are THREE times more likely to be attacked or murdered than women - if that is even true - are virtually 100 times more likely to be attacked or murdered by OTHER MEN!!! Duh! Hmm Did that not even cross your mind?!!!

WTAF is wrong with some people? @TruckerBarbie's posts are making me feel physically sick. They are obviously a MAN - or a woman who has never EVER had a man harass or stalk or her - or worse, like many women have.

I am sick to fucking DEATH of male entitlement, and men harming and maiming and abusing and MURDERING women and girls when they don't toe the line, and when they reject them, and often when they do NOTHING; they are just.... there. 'You're a woman, you're scum, you're a cunt, you're filth.... I will kill you.' Yep, some men do think this. They MUST do, otherwise, why the fuck are soooooooooo many women and girls being MURDERED by men? And abused by men, and raped by men, and physically attacked by men?

Women are not stupid, mumsnetters are not stupid, we KNOW not all men are the same, and many men would never harm a woman or child. However, whilst it's not all men, but it's nearly ALWAYS MEN. Also, I strongly believe the vast VAST majority of men have a certain amount of misogynism in them, and a certain amount of resentment towards women. Some more than others obviously. Yep, even your husband. fathers, and sons...

Most men have the 'women should be looking after house and home and the children' attitude, and are incensed when a woman is promoted above them at work. PURELY because she's a woman. Some mens resentment for women runs much deeper sadly.... But yes, it's there in most men.

I BEG you all to watch this. It was broadcast last week. Absolutely terrifying, and illustrates beautifully, the entitlement of (SOME) men and what they really think of women.

www.channel4.com/programmes/undercover-sexual-harassment-the-truth

TruckerBarbie · 17/12/2022 10:50

Here we go...

The theory that women perpetrate intimate partner violence at roughly similar rates as men has been termed "gender symmetry". The earliest empirical evidence of gender symmetry was presented in the 1975 U.S. National Family Violence Survey carried out by Murray A. Straus and Richard J. Gelles on a nationally representative sample of 2,146 "intact families". The survey found 11.6% of women and 12% of men had experienced some kind of intimate partner violence in the last twelve months, also 4.6% of men and 3.8% of women had experienced "severe" intimate partner violence.

Since 1975, numerous other empirical studies have found evidence of gender symmetry in intimate partner violence. For example, in the United States, the National Comorbidity Study of 1990-1992 found 18.4% of men and 17.4% of women had experienced minor intimate partner violence, and 5.5% of men and 6.5% of women had experienced severe intimate partner violence.[48][49]

In England and Wales, the 1995 "Home Office Research Study 191" found that in the twelve months prior to the survey, 4.2% of both men and woman between the ages of 16 and 59 had been assaulted by an intimate.[50]

The Canadian General Social Survey of 2000 found that from 1994 to 1999, 4% of men and 4% of women had experienced intimate partner violence in a relationship in which they were still involved, 22% of men and 28% of women had experienced intimate partner violence in a relationship which had now ended, and 7% of men and 8% of women had experienced intimate partner violence across all relationships, past and present.[35]

The 2005 Canadian General Social Survey, looking at the years 1999–2004 found similar data; 4% of men and 3% of women had experienced intimate partner violence in a relationship in which they were still involved, 16% of men and 21% of women had experienced intimate partner violence in a relationship which had now ended, and 6% of men and 7% of women had experienced intimate partner violence across all relationships, past and present.[36]

The 1975 National Family Violence Survey found that 27.7% of intimate partner violence cases were perpetrated by men alone, 22.7% by women alone and 49.5% were bidirectional. In order to counteract claims that the reporting data was skewed, female-only surveys were conducted, asking females to self-report, resulting in almost identical data.[52]

The 1985 National Family Violence Survey found 25.9% of IPV cases perpetrated by men alone, 25.5% by women alone, and 48.6% were bidirectional.[53]

A study conducted in 2007 by Daniel J. Whitaker, Tadesse Haileyesus, Monica Swahn, and Linda S. Saltzman, of 11,370 heterosexual U.S. adults aged 18 to 28 found that 24% of all relationships had some violence. Of those relationships, 49.7% of them had reciprocal violence. In relationships without reciprocal violence, women committed 70% of all violence.

In 1997, Philip W. Cook conducted a study of 55,000 members of the United States Armed Forces, finding bidirectionality in 60-64% of intimate partner violence cases, as reported by both men and women.[55]

The 2001 National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health found that 49.7% of intimate partner violence cases were reciprocal and 50.3% were non-reciprocal. When data provided by men only was analyzed, 46.9% of cases were reported as reciprocal and 53.1% as non-reciprocal. When data provided by women only was analyzed, 51.3% of cases were reported as reciprocal and 49.7% as non-reciprocal. The overall data showed 70.7% of non-reciprocal intimate partner violence cases were perpetrated by women only (74.9% when reported by men; 67.7% when reported by women) and 29.3% were perpetrated by men only (25.1% when reported by men; 32.3% when reported by women).[56]

The 2006 thirty-two nation International Dating Violence Study "revealed an overwhelming body of evidence that bidirectional violence is the predominant pattern of perpetration; and this ... indicates that the etiology of ipv is mostly parallel for men and women". The survey found for "any physical violence", a rate of 31.2%, of which 68.6% was bidirectional, 9.9% was perpetrated by men only, and 21.4% by women only. For severe assault, a rate of 10.8% was found, of which 54.8% was bidirectional, 15.7% perpetrated by men only, and 29.4% by women only.[57]

In 2000, John Archer conducted a meta-analysis of eighty-two IPV studies. He found that "women were slightly more likely than men to use one or more acts of physical aggression and to use such acts more frequently. Men were more likely to inflict an injury, and overall, 62% of those injured by a partner were women."[58] By contrast, the U.S. Department of Justice finds that women make up 84% of spouse abuse victims and 86% of victims of abuse by a boyfriend or girlfriend.[59]

From 2010 to 2012, scholars of domestic violence from the U.S., Canada and the U.K. assembled The Partner Abuse State of Knowledge, a research database covering 1700 peer-reviewed studies, the largest of its kind. Among its findings:[63]"

- More women (23%) than men (19.3%) have been assaulted at least once in their lifetime.

- Rates of female-perpetrated violence are higher than male-perpetrated (28.3% vs. 21.6%).

- Male and female IPV are perpetrated from similar motives.

- Studies comparing men and women in the power/control motive have mixed results overall.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domestic_violence_against_men#:~:text=The%20theory%20that%20women%20perpetrate,Straus%20and%20Richard%20J.

NeedToChangeName · 17/12/2022 10:47

TruckerBarbie · 17/12/2022 10:33

But it's also situational. You don't have regular heated arguments with your boss like many couples do.

@TruckerBarbie

Many people have unreasonable bosses, but dont shout at them, for fear of losing their job. Of course we can all contain our temper when we really want to

You appear to suggest that it's understandable /acceptable for disagreements between couples to escalate to abuse

We may have to agree to disagree on that

Naunet · 17/12/2022 10:47

TruckerBarbie · 17/12/2022 10:43

What's the point of having a discussion based on unnaccurate facts?

Please explain what inaccurate facts were in the OP.

Prettybutdumb · 17/12/2022 10:45

TruckerBarbie · 17/12/2022 10:43

What's the point of having a discussion based on unnaccurate facts?

It’s based on *inaccurate *type of people. Bye

TruckerBarbie · 17/12/2022 10:43

What's the point of having a discussion based on unnaccurate facts?

Prettybutdumb · 17/12/2022 10:42

VinoDino · 17/12/2022 10:41

Asking again, why do you feel the need to state this in a thread where women want to discuss male violence towards them?

Why don't you start your own thread about how poor men are being persecuted at the hands of women?

And a separate website, please. Get tf out of here and let us speak our truth in peace.

VinoDino · 17/12/2022 10:41

TruckerBarbie · 17/12/2022 10:32

Thing is, outside of the approx 0.0003% of men that murder, the rest is less clear. More recent studies suggest that men massively under report DV and that when you ask women if they've ever hit their partner the number is higher than the number of men who'll admit they've been victims.

This was discussed recently at length so I'll try and find the thread.

Asking again, why do you feel the need to state this in a thread where women want to discuss male violence towards them?

Why don't you start your own thread about how poor men are being persecuted at the hands of women?

Velvian · 17/12/2022 10:40

@NeedToChangeName , I agree that there is a definite element of righteousness (delivering warranted punishment) and entitlement. Loss oss of control is perhaps a separate element.

Prettybutdumb · 17/12/2022 10:39

TruckerBarbie · 17/12/2022 10:33

But it's also situational. You don't have regular heated arguments with your boss like many couples do.

If ‘couples’ have these arguments, why is it generally men who escalate it to violence and not women? Men are also violent towards their elderly parents, children - any vulnerable parties. Why don’t woman regularly grab a pan and crack their stupid skulls open?

Naunet · 17/12/2022 10:34

TruckerBarbie · 17/12/2022 10:32

Thing is, outside of the approx 0.0003% of men that murder, the rest is less clear. More recent studies suggest that men massively under report DV and that when you ask women if they've ever hit their partner the number is higher than the number of men who'll admit they've been victims.

This was discussed recently at length so I'll try and find the thread.

Why? This thread is about male violence, why is that so uncomfortable for you? Why do you need to minimise and pretend women are just as bad? It’s kind of fascinating to watch a woman desperately try to bury her head in the sand over this issue, I can’t help but wonder what drives someone like that. Bizarre.

TruckerBarbie · 17/12/2022 10:33

NeedToChangeName · 17/12/2022 10:31

@Velvian but these abusive men could control their tempers, if they wanted. they dont assault their mums,sisters or bosses

Abuse stems from control and entitlement, not inability to regulate emotions

But it's also situational. You don't have regular heated arguments with your boss like many couples do.

viques · 17/12/2022 10:32

Pumperthepumper · 17/12/2022 10:02

How would you suggest we get men onside?

Surely “good” men should be onside already . “Good “ men know what the score is because “ good” men live in our communities and see and hear how women are treated and “good” men should be able to recognise abuse when it happens.

So it is not up to women to get “good” men onside, the “ good” men should be doing that for themselves , by calling out the behaviour by other men that they know is unacceptable, by teaching their sons , nephews, pupils about respect, by challenging the “bad” men and making it clear that aggressive language , actions and attitudes towards women are unacceptable wherever they occur be it homes, schools, workplaces, colleges, sports grounds, pubs, transport, places of worship, community and communal spaces.

VinoDino · 17/12/2022 10:32

@OlympicProcrastinator and to add:

It's only 0.00000000000353% of the wonderful male population of a whole who actually murder women so what's the problem?!

TruckerBarbie · 17/12/2022 10:32

Thing is, outside of the approx 0.0003% of men that murder, the rest is less clear. More recent studies suggest that men massively under report DV and that when you ask women if they've ever hit their partner the number is higher than the number of men who'll admit they've been victims.

This was discussed recently at length so I'll try and find the thread.

NeedToChangeName · 17/12/2022 10:31

Velvian · 17/12/2022 10:04

I think we do need to start laughing at these male perpetrators. The infantilisation of women is a large part of the problem, yet the elephant in the room is the temper tantrums of many men. The inability to regulate their emotions sufficiently to keep their hands and abusive mouths to themselves.

@Velvian but these abusive men could control their tempers, if they wanted. they dont assault their mums,sisters or bosses

Abuse stems from control and entitlement, not inability to regulate emotions

OlympicProcrastinator · 17/12/2022 10:28

These threads are always like MRA flying monkey bingo. Women come together on what (at least used to be) a predominantly female site to discuss male on female violence. These days we have the predictable;

NAMALT,

Women, black people, Muslims, (bring in any other oppressed group you fancy) do X,Y,Z for distraction & derailment.

“You are all crazy / hysterical feminists”

“Do some research / educate yourself”

“This discussion isn’t centring mens feelings and that’s a really bad thing”

Women talking about male violence makes them ‘men haters’.

Pretty much a full house today.

Arguingtomyright · 17/12/2022 10:20

There's a very deep rooted narrative in human psyches that make us belive that men are valuable not as people but as tools and women are valuable not as people but as child bearers. Therefore men are expendable and women need locked away and protected.

Where is your proof that men are seen as expendable?

Or that men are not seen as people? The over representation of men in media and politics indicates this is not true.

It’s such a vague claim to make, that men are viewed as expendable, without any evidence to back it up.

Naunet · 17/12/2022 10:14

And what do men like to do when invading another country? Lots of rape of course, even of 4 year old children.
www.express.co.uk/news/world/1710021/russia-soldiers-rape-sexual-assault-children-ukraine-justice

VinoDino · 17/12/2022 10:11

So you have to experience something personally for you to understand the problem and impact of such a thing. Right 😂

Oh how I would love to live so simplistically! Bless you.

Naunet · 17/12/2022 10:09

TruckerBarbie · 17/12/2022 10:06

Exactly.

When posters say 'we' need to do something about the plight of women in Afghanistan/Ukraine/etc, who do you think they mean? Men of course.

And who is it creating problems in Afghanistan and Ukraine? Can you bring yourself to say men for that question too, or would the truth there be too mean?

OlympicProcrastinator · 17/12/2022 10:09

I knew it wouldn't take long. 😂 Because a woman could never disagree with a feminist (even though over 90% aren't feminists

No, because a woman would share our mutual experience and wouldn’t minimise it as scaremongering. And label women who come together to discuss male violence as ‘feminists’
when nobody has made that claim.

Then had a little strop because we didn’t speak in a way that would centre mens feelings in the conversation.

Onnabugeisha · 17/12/2022 10:08

TruckerBarbie · Today 10:04
That’s why I and so many simply accept that a certain level of murder and mayhem as part of life.

But it's not part of your life unless you're one of the 0.0003%. I don't accept cancer as part of my life because I don't have cancer.

Well it is, because violence in society affects everyone. It ripples outwards from the victim to their family to friends to colleagues to neighbours and so on.

TruckerBarbie · 17/12/2022 10:06

Onnabugeisha · 17/12/2022 10:04

Yes this is true. Our society is still very violent because we also still want men capable of killing if necessary. Russia invading Ukraine…where would Ukraine be if there were not men and women (but mostly men), capable of killing other human beings? They’d be part of Russia.

So as a society, we are not truly invested in eliminating violence or the capability for it. We fear that pacifism will make us weak and therefore be conquered again.

So we dont raise boys to be men who cannot kill. We just don’t. And we accept a bit of infighting and murder as the lesser of two evils.

Not saying this is right. But this is our society. And movies still worship the “action hero” where the only thing that has really changed is there are now a good number of “action heroines” racking up dead “bad guys” over the course of a film.

Exactly.

When posters say 'we' need to do something about the plight of women in Afghanistan/Ukraine/etc, who do you think they mean? Men of course.

Swipe left for the next trending thread