Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH thinks I should go to the gym more so I can carry my child

117 replies

Mamma5464 · 16/12/2022 14:47

My 5yo DS has SEN and PDA so it can be a struggle to be out with him - he's so close to meltdowns sometimes, so we try to keep demands low. This means carrying him about around often. I used baby and toddler carriers until he was almost 4yo.

DH is tall and strong and can manage no problem. I'm 5'2 and struggle to carry all 20kg of him for more than 5-10 mins.

DH keeps saying I should work out to carry him. This seems ridiculous to me - the amount of time I'd have to spend in the gym to carry him for slightly longer, and I'd have to keep up with him growing up.

I do have access to a basic gym and a gym membership but I hate working out on my own. I go to classes but because of work I can't make it more than once a week. I do think I should go and do more weight bearing work for my own health, but the amount of time I need to spend there, when I have a SEN child and no respite apart from husband who goes to the gym, runs and plays football 5 days a week, to make a marginal gain in muscle mass and carry him for 5 more minutes, seems like a poor use of time.

YABU - I should go to the gym so I can carry a 5yo for more than 10 mins

YANBU - the gym will make a difference

OP posts:
TimeToFlyNow · 16/12/2022 16:46

Yeah there was no way I was carrying my ds around at that age, or younger either. It's not sustainable for a start

We used a Phil and Ted explorer and back pack reigns when walking was none negotiable meltdowns or not. He was fast and had no concept of danger

I had plenty of years of sitdown on the floor and refuse to move , walking to school as a lion/monkey etc as some days that worked. Plenty of different distractions to get him moving

Your dh is being lazy carrying him around rather than trying to deal with the issues

Slidingonice · 16/12/2022 16:44

Your husband is unreasonable in his suggestion and selfish in the number of times he goes out to exercise. Lifting a heavy child could do you a lot of harm. Sod that.
I’m sorry but I pressed the wrong voting button by mistake.
YANBU.

Octo5 · 16/12/2022 16:44

This isn’t about carrying a 5 year old round though is it, it’s about being stronger or as strong as a 10+ year old as your child continues to grow.

I work with teens with SEND and they are much stronger than NT children and I absolutely work out so I am better able to protect myself and others around me.

Most of the time it’s the mental confidence of knowing that you can control them if you need to.

If your child needs to be carried or restrained then I don’t think it will hurt being fitter and as stronger.
You can do this at home if you wanted to though.

piedbeauty · 16/12/2022 16:42

MrsTerryPratchett · 16/12/2022 15:10

You need a much larger conversation about self-care, balance and time. If he gets gym, running and football, how much child-free time does he get? And how much so you get?

Once you have the same time, maybe you will choose to spend some of it working out, for you. But he's not your PT or manager so he doesn't get to assign tasks.

This!

Ivyonafence · 16/12/2022 16:40

Your DH is being a dick.

But- getting stronger is a good thing for your health and would give you some respite if DH stepped up to facilitate it.

I'd take his advice as an offer and tell him what times he'll need to be at home so you can do some classes or whatever else you would enjoy.

Colourinsidethelines · 16/12/2022 16:39

As someone who has a child with SEN as well and needs carrying, it would make sod all difference as your child grows. If my DH suggested this I’d be telling him to drop at least two of his session then to accommodate. I bet he says no. If it’s any help my DD is 5 and we use a firefly pushchair called a WeGo. It’s very good. I’d just use that when needed.

upfucked · 16/12/2022 16:34

Go to the gym more while DH pulls his weight or go somewhere else.

Would a McClaren (sp) special needs stroller be a useful alternative?

Newlifestartingatlast · 16/12/2022 16:31

He is being a self satisfied and ignorant twat - and that is putting it mildly

Show your husband the the safety tables for women to lift safely. These are based on actually scientific studies and epidemiologists.

16kg to hold at waist height on one I looked at, so you should be avoiding lifting anything over 16kg. You’d be risk assessed at work if asked to do the same thing,( or could demand it) and that would prevent you. For the sake of your future health do not routinely lift more than that guidance .

ask any district nurse who lifted or even just manually rolled patients to clean them on her rounds who is now late 70 or older- they have back problems, and can be almost crippled by a slow itterative wear on their joints by exceeding that load on a regular basis.

Men are naturally stronger than women even at same height. Their body structure carries more muscle - even the fittest female athlete has muscle strength of a pretty average fit bloke. They also find it easier to develop muscle and gain lifting strength . You’d have to spend a hell of a lot of time in gym to build weight lifting capability and maintain it to routinely lift in excess of 16kg routinely for long periods of time - and your DS is going to be steadily increasing his weight anyway and you’d never keep up.

your husband should certainly do more of the lifting - but that is a short term plan for him too. At what weight will he suddenly declare he can’t lift his son? So, you need to find other ways to comfort your child and help him feel comforted by either of you. I can’t imagine it’s good for his physical development to be carried everytime he needs emotional support (sorry if I misunderstand why you are carrying him).

the fact he goes out so often for his precious sport and leaves you with kids to look after, says a lot about the lack of empathy he shows you

NotAnotherCrisis · 16/12/2022 16:31

DH is being ridiculous.

Have you got a SEN,pushchair? Some of them go up to age 11.

Scarecrowrowboat · 16/12/2022 16:30

YANBU. Going to gym is awesome and resistance training is important and can bring masses of long term benefits but unless you are strongman/woman training (incredibly fun) it's unlikely to be massively useful in carrying a 22kg child in a most likely awkward position. I can deadlift over twice my body weight and I do not find it very helpful in carrying a child. Being tall would be much more helpful.

Nanny0gg · 16/12/2022 16:30

Mamma5464 · 16/12/2022 16:13

I would love to have this option - I think it's better to have him secured on my back than in my arms, especially as he's a wiggly leaner. There are pre-school carriers for 4+ but they are so expensive, still very heavy, and I'm not sure if DS would even go for it now - it's an expensive mistake to make (can't return it where I am, probably little resale value). Also DH is dead set against carriers too - thinks DS is too old and should be walking. Even though he carries him all over the place in his arms! He's being so unfair on this point.

Why are you taking any notice? If you're the one doing the caring and the carrying it's up to you!

You seem to have an unhelpful and unsupportive husband

Somuchgoo · 16/12/2022 16:30

Mamma5464 · 16/12/2022 16:13

I would love to have this option - I think it's better to have him secured on my back than in my arms, especially as he's a wiggly leaner. There are pre-school carriers for 4+ but they are so expensive, still very heavy, and I'm not sure if DS would even go for it now - it's an expensive mistake to make (can't return it where I am, probably little resale value). Also DH is dead set against carriers too - thinks DS is too old and should be walking. Even though he carries him all over the place in his arms! He's being so unfair on this point.

It won't solve the husband problem (though frankly I have little respect for the opinion of people who think their child is too big for a carrier, and then carry them everywhere), but what about a woven wrap? I've even seen (crazy) people carrying adults in them, and if it doesn't work then it'll be a lot easier to resell as you can use them for all ages. Or borrow one from a sling library to see if its an option.

(From someone that still carries their nearly 4yo child with disabilities, daily, and is likely to for a long time)

Nocutenamesleft · 16/12/2022 16:30

parietal · 16/12/2022 14:59

go to the gym to get a break from the kids and let DH mind them

but this is NOT the solution to caring for your child. You and DH will not be able to keep carrying him when he is 6 or 8 or 10 years. So he will have to learn to walk and walk sensibly one day. Kids learn new things more easily when young, so the sooner you start on 'teaching obedient walking' the better. That will probably mean putting up with a few tantrums and doing some close behaviour management, but much better to do that now than in 3 years time when your child is bigger and stronger and finds it harder to learn.

He’s got PDA. Have you ever known a child with PDA?

Rinoachicken · 16/12/2022 16:29

My 9yo is autistic. He has a tendency for bolting and also sitting down and refusing to walk.

I have had to find other ways of managing that (depending on the situation / environment). But I don’t carry him. I can’t. Haven’t been able to carry for any distance him much past the age of 5.

Lifting a carrying a screaming kicking thrashing child is nothing like lifting weights in the gym. It’s a moving off balance weight that can and will kick, bite and headbutt at any given moment.

Trying to carry him anywhere in that state would be dangerous for us both.

Once he starts school, even a specialist school, I can guarantee you that physically carrying him will not be something they are going to be doing.

The time for carrying him is past - you need to begin developing more appropriate long term strategies now.

Nanny0gg · 16/12/2022 16:29

Mamma5464 · 16/12/2022 14:47

My 5yo DS has SEN and PDA so it can be a struggle to be out with him - he's so close to meltdowns sometimes, so we try to keep demands low. This means carrying him about around often. I used baby and toddler carriers until he was almost 4yo.

DH is tall and strong and can manage no problem. I'm 5'2 and struggle to carry all 20kg of him for more than 5-10 mins.

DH keeps saying I should work out to carry him. This seems ridiculous to me - the amount of time I'd have to spend in the gym to carry him for slightly longer, and I'd have to keep up with him growing up.

I do have access to a basic gym and a gym membership but I hate working out on my own. I go to classes but because of work I can't make it more than once a week. I do think I should go and do more weight bearing work for my own health, but the amount of time I need to spend there, when I have a SEN child and no respite apart from husband who goes to the gym, runs and plays football 5 days a week, to make a marginal gain in muscle mass and carry him for 5 more minutes, seems like a poor use of time.

YABU - I should go to the gym so I can carry a 5yo for more than 10 mins

YANBU - the gym will make a difference

More to the point is why is your husband absent so much and leaving it to you?

Rinoachicken · 16/12/2022 16:19

You both need to find a way for safer walking. There are many adults with severe LD who are bolters etc (I know, I used to work in this sector) - not a single one was carried, it’s ridiculous.

Im not saying it’s easy, but carrying him really really is not the solution.

Zooeyzo · 16/12/2022 16:16

My autistic boy is 4 and around 20 kg but very tall and a fast runner. I go to the gym for strength training and fitness and it makes a big difference. I can carry him for 30 minutes piggyback or pick him when he's upset and fighting to get away with no problem.
I found the gym has really improved my mental wellbeing as well. It lifts my mood considerably and I'm calmer with my son
Honestly take him up on the offer.

BadBear · 16/12/2022 16:15

As someone who lifts heavy weights at the gym, I can tell you that this is not the best solution. Yes, you will be stronger but it's slightly different picking up a 45kg db or squatting 100kg on a barbell to carrying a wriggling child around who is only going to get bigger. Even if you did strongwoman training, it's still not the best way forward. Mind you, you mind want to grab the opportunity and do it for your own health!

Mamma5464 · 16/12/2022 16:13

Somuchgoo · 16/12/2022 15:55

Maybe still just a carrier? Much more viable than just carrying him in your arms.

I would love to have this option - I think it's better to have him secured on my back than in my arms, especially as he's a wiggly leaner. There are pre-school carriers for 4+ but they are so expensive, still very heavy, and I'm not sure if DS would even go for it now - it's an expensive mistake to make (can't return it where I am, probably little resale value). Also DH is dead set against carriers too - thinks DS is too old and should be walking. Even though he carries him all over the place in his arms! He's being so unfair on this point.

OP posts:
Mamma5464 · 16/12/2022 16:05

Unicorn2022 · 16/12/2022 15:22

I had to do strength training as my disabled child got older and I had to physically lift him from dangerous situations or where he didn't want to leave somewhere. I learnt a fireman's lift too.

In the last few years I've had to also train to be able to run after him and restrain him now he is a teenager and much stronger than I am.

Thanks, I'll look into different kinds of strength training that I'll enjoy.

OP posts:
Devoutspoken · 16/12/2022 16:04

I carry kids as part of keeping fit as well as going to gym but your dh sounds like a cf

BabyOnBoard90 · 16/12/2022 16:03

I don't see the big deal. Going to gym is great for your well-being, which has a cascade benefit for your household.

Me and my partner routinely encourage exercise, especially when we don't feel like it.

Circumstances notwithstanding, there is always an excuse not to workout

whynotwhatknot · 16/12/2022 16:01

its not going to benefit long term when hes taller than you is it

TheShellBeach · 16/12/2022 16:00

Does anyone else not understand the voting?

Both options seem to say the same thing to me.

Mamma5464 · 16/12/2022 15:59

I know but it feels like respite! 😓 I have a chance to go away, somewhere quiet, and to think and do something different. I sympathise with DH who when I'm done, just wants to hand DS over for the rest of the evening. So I can't really say no to all the workouts. But I don't have any time for me either.

The football is a pain. It's always miles away and takes hours. But he gets to socialise a bit, which he doesn't have time for otherwise.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread