Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH thinks I should go to the gym more so I can carry my child

117 replies

Mamma5464 · 16/12/2022 14:47

My 5yo DS has SEN and PDA so it can be a struggle to be out with him - he's so close to meltdowns sometimes, so we try to keep demands low. This means carrying him about around often. I used baby and toddler carriers until he was almost 4yo.

DH is tall and strong and can manage no problem. I'm 5'2 and struggle to carry all 20kg of him for more than 5-10 mins.

DH keeps saying I should work out to carry him. This seems ridiculous to me - the amount of time I'd have to spend in the gym to carry him for slightly longer, and I'd have to keep up with him growing up.

I do have access to a basic gym and a gym membership but I hate working out on my own. I go to classes but because of work I can't make it more than once a week. I do think I should go and do more weight bearing work for my own health, but the amount of time I need to spend there, when I have a SEN child and no respite apart from husband who goes to the gym, runs and plays football 5 days a week, to make a marginal gain in muscle mass and carry him for 5 more minutes, seems like a poor use of time.

YABU - I should go to the gym so I can carry a 5yo for more than 10 mins

YANBU - the gym will make a difference

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LordEmsworth · 17/12/2022 05:22

Herejustforthisone · 16/12/2022 21:42

My response was tongue in cheek. Well done for noticing. Oh, wait.

Touche 😁

Herejustforthisone · 16/12/2022 21:42

LordEmsworth · 16/12/2022 21:09

Errrr... well I do, but also yes it is a deliberately ridiculous response. Well done for noticing.

My point is that OP's husband is being unhelpful. He is trying to get her to do something because he thinks she should, with no regard to (a) the feasibility (b) the actual usefulness or (c) the fact that he is one of the barriers. He isn't looking at the problem or trying to help solve it, he's being unhelpful and patronising. I actually would not do the above, but I wouldn't put up with someone lecturing me with such complete obliviousness.

But yeah, I love a coffee after a heavy workout, thanks.

My response was tongue in cheek. Well done for noticing. Oh, wait.

LordEmsworth · 16/12/2022 21:09

Herejustforthisone · 16/12/2022 19:58

This is a ridiculous response. Who wants a coffee after a heavy workout?

Errrr... well I do, but also yes it is a deliberately ridiculous response. Well done for noticing.

My point is that OP's husband is being unhelpful. He is trying to get her to do something because he thinks she should, with no regard to (a) the feasibility (b) the actual usefulness or (c) the fact that he is one of the barriers. He isn't looking at the problem or trying to help solve it, he's being unhelpful and patronising. I actually would not do the above, but I wouldn't put up with someone lecturing me with such complete obliviousness.

But yeah, I love a coffee after a heavy workout, thanks.

ThereIbledit · 16/12/2022 20:08

Take back some of your husband's leisure time and go to this new gym I've heard about. It's called Costa, and the most effective thing to lift is lots of reps of a white hot chocolate.

Herejustforthisone · 16/12/2022 19:58

LordEmsworth · 16/12/2022 14:50

Well yes, training at the gym with a specific focus will make you stronger.

All you need to do is get your husband to tell you which of his gym sessions he's going to give up, to allow you to go. 5 would be fab but you could compromise on 3. Make sure you need enough time for a coffee afterwards, recovery is important. If he declines then smile and say, well there's not much I can do without your support on this one, it's a shame you're not willing to help.

This is a ridiculous response. Who wants a coffee after a heavy workout?

amonsteronthehill · 16/12/2022 18:54

Your DH doesn't get to call all the shots when it comes to you taking your DS out. If you want to try a larger pushchair because that will be more sensible and safer for you, the order the pushchair. Your DH doesn't have to use it and can be as disdainful as he likes, but he doesn't get to make all the decisions, especially those that affect you.

Bronzeisthecolour · 16/12/2022 18:32

Slightly off topic but contact wheelchair service for a larger buggy for your child if SEN you should qualify.

Soothsayer1 · 16/12/2022 18:27

just another selfish man who treats his wife like a servant🙁

AnotherEmma · 16/12/2022 18:07

Your husband is being very unreasonable on several counts.

  1. Not listening to you about the issues you have listed on this thread and presumably many others; I'd be furious about that and don't see how there is respect and a partnership if he stubbornly refuses to see your point of view and your right to a say in parenting and other decisions. In being so dismissive, he is actually controlling because he is preventing you from finding solutions to suit you (eg carrier or pushchair for older/heavier child - if you want to use one he shouldn't stop you).
  2. using depression as carte blanche to do sport/socialising for hours multiple times a week. I've had MH issues myself and I know how beneficial it is to exercise and socialise, but as the mother of a child who I suspect is neurodiverse (but frankly even if they were neurotypical) I am realistic about how much time I have for that stuff.
  3. Pressuring you to go the gym. Fuck that. He should be encouraging you to do what you want but should also recognise what PPs have said which is that as a woman you realistically can't and shouldn't lift your child.

You are being unreasonable to let your husband get away with all that and to refer to your job as respite (although I know what you mean, my job feels like a break from parenting! It's not time for me though)

GrimsbyOrangePippin · 16/12/2022 18:04

I do an aqua class which has aqua dumbells which with the right exercises provide more resistance against the water. We do it to upbeat pop and rock music. You might enjoy this. Kind on my joints which have some problems and I did it during rehab for a specific injury too. I tell the instructor and between us we adapt for suitability. I can do way more work in the pool than on dry land. I then go in the spa and have a relaxing gentle swim.

Beautiful3 · 16/12/2022 17:51

No that's just silly. You'll ruin your back and knees. I'd research pushchairs for children with disabilities, as they hold a heavier weight.

Soothsayer1 · 16/12/2022 17:48

who goes to the gym, runs and plays football 5 days a week
I hope you get an equal amount of time to focus on yourself and invest in your wellbeing?

tarheelbaby · 16/12/2022 17:47

I agree with all PPs who recommend a SEN pushchair. Your DS might like the familiarity of it - a safe place to retreat when he feels stressed. My DD2 who is not SEN or PDA felt that way and rode in the buggy until she started school!

No one should be trying to carry a 5yo, much less a wriggly, distressed one and your DH is completely unreasonable to suggest otherwise. And it's not at all unreasonable for SEN children to use a pushchair as long as is helpful for them.

JulieMarooley · 16/12/2022 17:43

Surely lifting and carrying your child will gradually make you stronger in exactly the right places, why bother going to a gym to lift up other heavy objects? Seems inefficient!

Sounds like you are perhaps at your natural limit anyway.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 16/12/2022 17:39

FavouriteDogMug · 16/12/2022 15:01

Personally I think you might hurt yourself if you try to carry him when he is too heavy for you. If you lift weights you have to do it with good form to avoid injury, but if you are lifting and carrying a child for long periods you are not likely to keep up the good positioning the whole time. So if he is a bit heavy now it may be better to look for an alternative to carrying him, rather than trying to increase your strength.

Exactly this.

I am a powerlifter.

I also have a toddler.

I can pick weights up with excellent form. My wriggly, sticky, slimy, floppy SEN almost-4 year old isn't stiff and rigid like a weight nor is he ergonomic.

I'm also 5 foot tall.

Picking kids up isn't ever going to be done in good form, so your husband is speaking out of his arse.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 16/12/2022 17:32

Make sure that your gym membership includes swimming, steam room, sauna and jacuzzi. Then use them after a workout or instead.

It'll be worth it.

SarahSissions · 16/12/2022 17:30

by time you’re strong enough to carry an extra 5kilos your kid will have put on 10. Ridiculous

although feel free to tell your husband you’re going to the gym and go and enjoy a glass of wine or a movie each week

Mamma5464 · 16/12/2022 17:28

Thanks all. I've spoken to DH and he's apologised for haranguing me about not going to the gym. I've agreed I'm going to try other classes like HIIT add I've booked one for next week.

I'm never going to convince him that weightlifting won't help with carrying though just because it works for him. I pointed about that him being a man makes it easier to put on muscle and of course he's taller. He just doesn't listen to me about this kind of stuff once he has it in his head - has been like this ever since DS was born - health stuff, DS' disabilities which he was in denial about. He will listen to professionals, doctors, nurses, therapists. I have to ask leading questions sometimes, so they will say things I already know but in front of DH to make him listen. But yeah that doesn't matter - I'll be responsible for my own health, look after my back and spine, and limit carrying as much as I can - and yes maybe it means more meltdowns and time to get places.

OP posts:
Heronwatcher · 16/12/2022 17:20

Your DH sounds like a twat. Even if you worked out 5 days a week I don’t see how you could manage a 5yr old AND do anything else, plus it sounds the least enjoyable thing ever. Plus when will it end- when he’s 14? You’ve already put your own body through carrying a child and giving birth- maybe it’s his turn now. It sounds to me as though he is minimising the issues your DS has and thinking of the first solution which makes his own life easier, even if it makes yours much harder.

MarvelMrs · 16/12/2022 17:19

You should go to the gym in the evenings to get an extra hour away from your husband’s ridiculous opinions.

CherryBomb87 · 16/12/2022 17:18

This is the most ridiculous thing I've ever heard. When does it stop? At what point do you stop carrying your little one? When your back breaks? When they're 21?

Seaweed42 · 16/12/2022 17:15

Women should not be picking up and carrying 20kg weights around.
You'll bust your pelvic floor very quickly doing that.
You'll end up with a prolapse.
You can't carry him. Bring the stroller if it's too far to walk.
He's 5. You cannot be carrying him any more.
This gym thing is a complete red herring.

MooBugz · 16/12/2022 16:53

Gym is good to go for your own mental health and well being but not sure about the lifting a growing child.

My son is 6 and has special needs and used to lift him a lot of the time for comforting him but when I was pregnant I had to change things. Could you check in with an OT and get a special needs buggy? We have one and this has helped so much for going out.

Substitute the lifts for cuddles is another thing I found helped with mine. Good luck!

Confrontayshunme · 16/12/2022 16:50

I am a TA who does weights at home 4-5 times a week, and I can lift heavy, but it is still not advised for any adult in our setting to move children over age 4 because of the risk of injury. We need two adults for a larger child who has SEN and our practice is to move him to a sitting position only if absolutely necessary, but otherwise, we cannot physically carry or hold him down. You will need to find new strategies for behaviour management as he gets bigger. Some councils have courses which can help with this.

TabithaTittlemouse · 16/12/2022 16:46

What does he suggest for when your ds is 12, 20, 30?

Swipe left for the next trending thread