Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry with dh

91 replies

Fantafilledfuckers · 16/12/2022 11:18

5 kids. I do school prep and run 99% of time. DH on rare day off so I asked him to bring them. 5 mins after they should have left, I’m frantically trying to get them all out and he tells me to calm down and that my shouting isn’t helping the situation. I don’t think I was shouting but I was definitely being urgent as they were late. He comes home, tells me again that shouting doesn’t motivate the kids to leave on time. Fair enough. When they’re late and not moving it’s often what I resort to. My bad.
He then tells me that he’ll take kids to school on Monday while I stay in bed to show me it can be done without shouting. I told him he was being very arrogant and haven’t spoken to him since.

OP posts:
Inertia · 16/12/2022 13:48

I think you move on from being cross( annoying though it is when someone adopts a tone that condescending with you!) , and let him organise Monday morning while you enjoy a lie in.

That means he does ALL the organising. All the packed lunches, who’s in uniform, who’s got a non-uniform day and needs a pound, who needs to take treats for Christmas party day, who finishes early, who takes in toys for toy day, secret Santa presents…

larkstar · 16/12/2022 13:39

I would also add - check your blood pressure and read up on how you might well be stressing yourself more than you ought to - is it worth it? Try not to let anyone spoil your day - your kids will grow up remembering a very stressed out mother. You need to look at what your kids can do for themselves and if your partner can do something to help. There's a lot of sh!t going on in life ATM - so what if your kids are late - I think they will get some grief from school and maybe that will motivate them to get their act together.

JauntyJinty · 16/12/2022 13:24

Shouting at a child and shouting to make sure your heard above the noise of a busy house are 2 very differnt things

OPs made it clear she meant the 2nd, I think @YellowTreeHouse has got stuck on the idea of it being the first

NaturalBae · 16/12/2022 13:20

Paq · 16/12/2022 12:48

@YellowTreeHouse calm down with the amateur diagnosis that OP has irrevocably damaged her kids!

I agree. Try not to take diagnosis of your family personally, from pp who do not know you or your family. You posted for advice/comments so you’ll receive posts from pp who don’t agree with you and pp who do.

Hats off to you for managing school runs for five DC without regular help from your DH/their Father.

America12 · 16/12/2022 13:18

Can any of the kids get their own stuff ready ?
@YellowTreeHouse do your kids never need telling more than once ? I just don't believe that.

DontSpeakLatinInFrontOfTheBooks · 16/12/2022 13:04

Whether what he’s said is true or not, you’ve got your hands full and it stings when someone arrogantly states the obvious like that.

However, make sure he follows through with his offer on Monday. Stay in bed, don’t help him out at all and make sure you’ve not prepped anything at all. If the outcome is a success and he pulls it together without anyone yelling, he’s proven he should definitely be pulling his weight in the mornings more than he currently does. If it all goes to shit you get to feel a teeny bit smug. Win win imo.

Enjoy the lie in!

DoormatBob · 16/12/2022 13:02

GerbilsForever24 · 16/12/2022 11:29

I think you should take him up on this. In my experience, if DH has to sort kids alone, he does a fairly good job. But if I'm around, it's like he forgets everything and so unless i do it, it doesn't get done and then I land up rushing around grabbing waters and lunches and trying to get them out the door. And then I turn into the shouting one and everyone thinks I'm horrible. Which I guess I understand.

So take him up on his offer and stay away. And if he forgets anything - it's his problem to go back and sort it out.

This is me. I crumble when DW is hovering.

DW is chaotic, and when I'm doing something I feel like there is a constant negative chirping. Don't forget this, have you done that. Feels like one of those SAS programmes where DW role is just to pile pressure and doubt on me!

I am the opposite and have every task in my head, sorted and planned exactly. There are things I ask DD to do whilst I make breakfast, then things I do whilst she's eating.

DW is also the 'boss' in the house so DD will ignore me in her presence thinking she doesn't have to do something unless mum says so. This in turn looks bad on me but when DW isn't there she will do what I ask.

I also leave later than DW because she has a massive faff in the car for 5 minutes before leaving, no idea what she's doing Facebook.

I'm on Team DH, I hope he nails it!

BatsAtHome · 16/12/2022 13:00

YellowTreeHouse · 16/12/2022 12:41

I think this is where you’ve been going wrong all this time. I didn’t call you an abusive mum either.

There’s a difference between labelling the behaviour (shouting is abuse) and saying someone is abusive. Similarly with children, a child may display behaviours you attribute with being naughty, but that doesn’t make them a naughty child.

I suspect your children are too old now. Foundations must be laid when they are babies and toddlers. 0-4 is a critical time for parenting and if you miss that window it’s almost impossible to change.

Your attitude here, jumping straight from 0-100 with “so I’m just shit, abusive” etc etc displays exactly what I mean and why I don’t think you would be able to cement any foundations without some serious work, which would require a lot of research and work on your part.

You shouldn’t have got to the stage where “there are only so many times you can ask nicely” then resort to shouting. It isn’t about asking nicely repeatedly, it’s about having the foundations in place so that isn’t necessary.

If you have to ask more than once then the right parenting structures are not in place.

@YellowTreeHouse
My children are really, really great but I struggle to get them to do what I've asked at certain times. I definitely, definitely have to ask more than once (ready for bed, teeth brushing etc.) - it's one child more than the other, he reminds me of me at 9, a deep thinker, maybe a daydreamer even. Anyway, I don't shout. What can I do and what did I not do when they were 0-4? I've obviously missed something out along the way and I wonder if I've hampered some independence. Can I gently rectify this? You sound like you know what you are talking about.

Fantafilledfuckers · 16/12/2022 12:59

YellowTreeHouse · 16/12/2022 12:41

I think this is where you’ve been going wrong all this time. I didn’t call you an abusive mum either.

There’s a difference between labelling the behaviour (shouting is abuse) and saying someone is abusive. Similarly with children, a child may display behaviours you attribute with being naughty, but that doesn’t make them a naughty child.

I suspect your children are too old now. Foundations must be laid when they are babies and toddlers. 0-4 is a critical time for parenting and if you miss that window it’s almost impossible to change.

Your attitude here, jumping straight from 0-100 with “so I’m just shit, abusive” etc etc displays exactly what I mean and why I don’t think you would be able to cement any foundations without some serious work, which would require a lot of research and work on your part.

You shouldn’t have got to the stage where “there are only so many times you can ask nicely” then resort to shouting. It isn’t about asking nicely repeatedly, it’s about having the foundations in place so that isn’t necessary.

If you have to ask more than once then the right parenting structures are not in place.

Ah right thanks @YellowTreeHouse for pointing out in so much detail where I’ve gone wrong and how difficult it will be to change, now that I’ve missed the critical window. Of course you’re calling me a shit mum ffs.
Perhaps rather than continuing to rip me apart, you could share how getting out in the morning works in your house? And what happens if your child/children don’t do what they’re asked when you ask them, given you have the “right parenting structures” in place?

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 16/12/2022 12:56

Fantafilledfuckers · 16/12/2022 12:06

I get it@YellowTreeHouse I’m a shit, abusive mum for shouting at my kids to get ready in the morning. What approach works for you when they won’t do what you ask and you need to be somewhere by a certain time? And there’s 5 of them.

Don't take anything that poster says to heart OP.

Knittedfairies · 16/12/2022 12:49

Enjoy your lie-in. You're in prime position now; either her realises how hard it is to get 5 kids out of the door at the same time, so you must need a break from doing it, or, he finds it so easy he won't mind taking his turn to do it. Win win I'd say.

Fantafilledfuckers · 16/12/2022 12:48

DoraSpenlow · 16/12/2022 12:40

Trust me, if it got to the stage where Mum shouted if we were taking our time getting ready for school or whatever, you bloody shifted yourself.

My lovely Mum, I miss you so much.

💐

OP posts:
Paq · 16/12/2022 12:48

@YellowTreeHouse calm down with the amateur diagnosis that OP has irrevocably damaged her kids!

FangsForTheMemory · 16/12/2022 12:43

I’d tell him he’s doing it for the whole of next term!

BatsAtHome · 16/12/2022 12:42

Shouting doesn't help and just ends up with stressed kids going sadly into their busy day.
All the hurrying and panicking can muck up their fight or flight responses.
Their father has every right to comment on the situation.
It's probably guilt making you feel defensive and angry at him.
Sit down with DH and discuss how he can help to make the situation work in the long term. One perfect show from him on Monday means nothing, the kids will be in a different mode because Daddy is driving them to school!
All 5 kids will have different support requirements to get ready in the morning. Work out what those are and how you can BOTH help make it all happen.
Do as much prep as possible the night before - with DH involved!
Get everyone up earlier and give them something fun to do before leaving the house which they can only do once they are fully ready.
Get everyone a star chart. Being ready to leave on time = 1 star. Tally up stars to work towards a reward.

YellowTreeHouse · 16/12/2022 12:41

Fantafilledfuckers · 16/12/2022 12:11

Ok..You did say I was an abusive mum though: Just because it isn’t physical (spitting) or the abuse is worse doesn’t mean it isn’t abuse.
So, can you answer my question of what approach works for you when they won’t do what you ask and you need to be somewhere by a certain time?

I think this is where you’ve been going wrong all this time. I didn’t call you an abusive mum either.

There’s a difference between labelling the behaviour (shouting is abuse) and saying someone is abusive. Similarly with children, a child may display behaviours you attribute with being naughty, but that doesn’t make them a naughty child.

I suspect your children are too old now. Foundations must be laid when they are babies and toddlers. 0-4 is a critical time for parenting and if you miss that window it’s almost impossible to change.

Your attitude here, jumping straight from 0-100 with “so I’m just shit, abusive” etc etc displays exactly what I mean and why I don’t think you would be able to cement any foundations without some serious work, which would require a lot of research and work on your part.

You shouldn’t have got to the stage where “there are only so many times you can ask nicely” then resort to shouting. It isn’t about asking nicely repeatedly, it’s about having the foundations in place so that isn’t necessary.

If you have to ask more than once then the right parenting structures are not in place.

DoraSpenlow · 16/12/2022 12:40

YellowTreeHouse · 16/12/2022 11:21

YABU. Being stressed, “urgent” and shouting doesn’t help. It’s not going to motivate them and all it does is show them you’re out of control and teaches them verbal abuse is an acceptable behaviour.

It isn’t.

Trust me, if it got to the stage where Mum shouted if we were taking our time getting ready for school or whatever, you bloody shifted yourself.

My lovely Mum, I miss you so much.

RampantIvy · 16/12/2022 12:37

I used to have to remind DD several times to get ready for school. I can't imagine the stress of doing that with four extra children lies down in a darkened room at the thought of having five children

liarliarshortsonfire · 16/12/2022 12:33

JauntyJinty · 16/12/2022 11:22

I can see why it's annoyed you, but he's handed you the perfect revenge!

Just enjoy your lay in on Monday and let him crack on and see how hard it is! If you usually prep the night before I'd leave that part and let him struggle - usually I'd worry about the kids being late but last day before Christmas I doubt they'll be doing much anyway

This in bucket loads

Fantafilledfuckers · 16/12/2022 12:32

EndlessRain1 · 16/12/2022 12:19

OP, I end up shouting sometimes too. There's only so many times you can ask someone nicely to brush their teeth/ put on shoes/ find their tie or whatever before you 1) run out of time and 2) get fed up. But I also recognise it's not a good way to start the day - for me or the kids.

I think if my DH said similar to yours I would be upset too, but mainly because I would know he was right. I guess the key is figuring out how to make mornigns betters/ reduce the need to shout. I know when I am more organised it helps A LOT. So does reducing screen access in the morning.

It's not really fair to blame the fact you have many children for the issue, I get it's a contributor to the chaos an stress, but that's hardly their faqult.

Yes! There really are only so many times you can ask nicely. Especially when you’re trying to make breakfast, packed lunches, find gloves, reading books etc.

Everyone seems to be in agreement. Also that shouting is not nice and a shit way to start the day for you and kids.

So, tips to reduce shouty mornings so far from this post are

  • being organised the night before ( I really try to be!)
  • limit screens (we never have them on in morning)
  • let them be late and learn from that

Please share any others 🙏

OP posts:
Octo5 · 16/12/2022 12:30

Also remember that DH is going to be extra calm and with it if he thinks you’re watching him.

If he does a good job then let him do it more often.

Octo5 · 16/12/2022 12:29

Seems a bit of an over reaction on your part.

Giving someone the silent treatment is also seen as a form of abuse on MN.

Let him do it on Monday and pick up some pointers of how it can help you next time.

It’s always easy to pick out peoples mistakes and I’m sure they’ll be things that DH does that you think you could do better.

There is no point in shouting in the mornings as it makes everyone stressed but sometimes yelling to hurry up as they’re going to be late does happen and it’s not the end of the world.

Myself and DD both have ADHD so will do everything but get ready sometimes, so I set the clock 5 minutes fast and make sure we’re ready 5mins before we actually need to be.

I will calmly give a 20 minute warning and then a 10 and 5 minute one so if they’re taking too long it’ll hurry them up without too much stress from me.

I hate being stressed in the morning as it affects my day, so I TRY and stay calm for myself just as much as my DC.

Paq · 16/12/2022 12:22

I agree with your DH but he's BU to leave you to do 90% of the parenting. That's got to change.

I'm also in favour of letting children be late if they're faffing about and not cooperating. It's good learning for them.

Enjoy your lie in!

Shoxfordian · 16/12/2022 12:20

Must be nice to be married to a parenting expert 🙄

Make sure you do stay in bed on Monday and do nothing to help him, let him show you how it’s done - he sounds like a knob

EndlessRain1 · 16/12/2022 12:19

OP, I end up shouting sometimes too. There's only so many times you can ask someone nicely to brush their teeth/ put on shoes/ find their tie or whatever before you 1) run out of time and 2) get fed up. But I also recognise it's not a good way to start the day - for me or the kids.

I think if my DH said similar to yours I would be upset too, but mainly because I would know he was right. I guess the key is figuring out how to make mornigns betters/ reduce the need to shout. I know when I am more organised it helps A LOT. So does reducing screen access in the morning.

It's not really fair to blame the fact you have many children for the issue, I get it's a contributor to the chaos an stress, but that's hardly their faqult.