Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this bed cruel for the dog?

246 replies

HopingSomeoneIsAwake · 16/12/2022 08:41

I have a 9 month old dog who is perfectly house trained and has been for months. The last week or so he has suddenly started pooing in his bed overnight (he is crated because he was when I first got him and it suits him and us too for safety reasons - young children in the house etc). He can be quite anxious at times however he has started new medication (steroids) so that could be the culprit of upsetting his stomach. I know it’s not his fault but it’s actually starting to get me quite down having to do a full load of washing of his bed things every morning to then have to repeat it the day after - would it be cruel for me to take away the bedding in his crate until his stomach issues have resolved? He has never used puppy pads (went straight into the garden when toilet training) and I wouldn’t trust him not to chew them overnight anyway. He has the vets tomorrow and they are going to give him some stomach protection medications so hopefully that helps!

OP posts:
fromdownwest · 16/12/2022 11:45

He sleeps overnight in a closed crate, and has done for years.
Well natured and healthy dog

converseandjeans · 16/12/2022 11:44

I would put puppy training pads and newspapers down so it's not just the cage. Also maybe an old towel?

You could also get up and take him out during night to try to pre empt the accidents.

It doesn't sound like he's locked away in a crate in a cold garage. Could you fit crate in kitchen where there's no carpet? Then leave crate door open & newspaper down?

Moonatics · 16/12/2022 11:44

loopyb · 16/12/2022 10:37

Not sure why you're getting so much abuse for this! The fact that you've been washing his bed on a daily basis shows how much you care.

I agree with others suggesting to get up once in the night to let them out? Although frustrating hopefully it will be temporary. It can be really distressing for dogs to need to toilet in the crate as it's their safe sleeping space as well as horrible for you.

Our dog was crated for his first year and he loved it - got in there on his own accord to sleep! It's people who use it in an abusive manner that give it a bad reputation.

It's not caring to wash soiled bedding, its normal. The bedding only needs washing cos no one is letting the dog out to toilet. If they did that they most likely wouldnt need to wash the bedding any more.
Although let out a few times a night not once.

I have never crated dogs, I have no opinion either way about crates, but they are not for me or my large dogs. I have found that all my dogs(animals in fact) have found a space they claim as their own.
So my cat sleeps in a spot in the back bedroom, one dog sleeps by the back door mat and the other dog side of my bed. Once known these are the places you leave them alone. They claimed it as theirs to be left alone and thats what I do.
If they need to go out in the night they come snuffle at me until I wake up.

As for washing bedding, doesnt every dog owner have a massive stash of old towels, sheets, blankets? Just me?

mrsjackrussell · 16/12/2022 11:43

I think i would put the crate in a secure room with a hard floor and leave newspaper or puppy pads outside in a corner. They will soon get used to having the door open and will settle down.

I know you said you sleep next door and puppy won't settle.

Try for a few nights.

Floralnomad · 16/12/2022 11:43

Cages are not cages if they have open doors , they are just metal beds .

Laiste · 16/12/2022 11:36

Thought i'd add a link to Vets Bedding. I googled out of interest.

www.amazon.co.uk/Vetfleece-Non-Slip-Patterns-Vet-Orthopaedic/dp/B00IXQ7N9E/ref=sr_1_5?keywords=vet%2Bbed%2Bfor%2Bdogs&qid=1671190115&sr=8-5&th=1

Snoodsy · 16/12/2022 11:36

Plus the poor dog is trying to hold it in as hard as he can for as long as he can, knowing if he goes he will be in trouble and a bad boy, then when he finally can’t hold it another second he poops on himself in shame and then has to marinade in it.

Yes! Definitely take out his only comfort at night.

HairyMcLarie · 16/12/2022 11:34

Bedless not endless

StrawberryPot · 16/12/2022 11:33

@fromdownwest - yes but you are not using your crate as is intended. They are to all intents and purposes cages - designed to keep dogs in one place. You are leaving the cage door open so hardly the same thing as someone who locks their dog in one overnight and then for extended periods for the day.

HairyMcLarie · 16/12/2022 11:33

Ignore the nonsense here about crates being cruel. They aren't as you know. Being endless is a pretty harsh though.

Our dog is no longer crated but has her bed spots and she was recently on high dose steroids. She would pee and poo while asleep in her bed without even realising. It's an unfortunate side effect of those horrid drugs.

We covered her comfy beds in waterproof sheets, then pee pads and a cosy old towel on top. She was nice and comfy but it meant we could whip away the towel, bin the pee pads and the bed stayed clean. we were washing towels everyday but we didn't mind. As her dose lowered she stopped the messing immediately.

Poor pup. They'll be down on the dose soon as they can't stay on a high dose for long and this will be a distant memory.

StoppinBy · 16/12/2022 11:32

KangarooKenny · 16/12/2022 08:43

Yes, that would be cruel, especially with it being so cold. But then I think crates are cruel.
Fleece blankets are easy to wash and dry.

Crates are not cruel when used properly.

My dog had surgery 6 weeks ago now, she has had to be kept on crate rest to allow proper healing.

As she was already crate trained it made things so easy, she wasn't stressed, she rested and she's due to start getting back to normal life this week.

Without crate training this would have been a very difficult 6 weeks for her.

Crates not used properly can certainly be cruel.

OP, my suggestion would be to pick up a heap of old blankets and sheets to make a soft surface in the crate and throw them out as needed. Using no bedding would be very unfair on him. If you can open the crate area up with a playpen I'd do that too to try to keep the crate and bedding clean.

Chocolatelabradorsarethebest · 16/12/2022 11:32

What a horrible OP and I feel very sorry for their dog. Also concerned for their children, what does she do when they have an upset stomach? Lock them in a room with just rubber sheets on the bed and no other bedding as she can’t be bothered to wash bedding?

ScrollingLeaves · 16/12/2022 11:31

ScroogeMcDuckling · Today 11:24
he’s worked out how to open the hallway window and from first light he is leaning/looking out the window.

That is wonderful!

fromdownwest · 16/12/2022 11:29

KangarooKenny · 16/12/2022 08:43

Yes, that would be cruel, especially with it being so cold. But then I think crates are cruel.
Fleece blankets are easy to wash and dry.

Crates are far from cruel if used correctly. Mine sleeps in a crate.
We have one in the living room that is left open, and when he is tired, scared or anxious he puts himself into it.
They see them as a safe space, and the cruelty is misunderstood.

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 16/12/2022 11:25

@HenPenJen1789 you're right of course, my dogs have had diahorrea on steroids, and I was told to ring the vet and check if I should continue because sometimes the upset stomach can be more of a risk to their health than the original illness the steroid is meant to treat. The OP has only had this problem for a week or so which makes her response even more shocking. She should have been on to the vet the first time it happened asking for advice, this shouldn't still be happening.

CrownTheTurkey · 16/12/2022 11:24

Of course it's cruel. That's like you sleeping on your bedroom floor with no coverings. Would you be happy to do that??
Stop thinking about yourself and think about your poor dog.

ScroogeMcDuckling · 16/12/2022 11:24

SpanielSprint · 16/12/2022 09:47

I’m a vet - YABVU and I think it’s quite concerning that you are even considering this to be honest. Your are asking for pressure sores and the poor dog will be very cold and uncomfortable. When my dogs were young puppies and not yet reliable overnight I used to place the crate with doors open in a large puppy pen with newspaper or puppy pads down for them to use if necessary. It would be very unusual for a dog to mess its bed deliberately.

If for whatever reason this isn’t an option for you then look into waterproof dog beds (I have one for my car boot as it copes better with mud etc) or vet bed which is at least quick and easy to launder.

But really it’s not ideal having a dog of this age shut all night in a crate. Dogs aren’t like us, they are not designed to just sleep overnight for 8 hours straight. It’s normal behaviour for them to get up frequently and potter around, and you are preventing this.

Thank you for the advice about them pottering about at night.

One minute our dog is asleep on our rug in the bedroom, then he’s on the hall, then he’s in the kitchen for a drink, I’ve had to stop putting the bleach blocks/harpic things in the toilet cos he drinks from the toilet if the lid is left up.

he’s worked out how to open the hallway window and from first light he is leaning/looking out the window.

yet when he goes to the vet, (he was a regular a few years ago) they put his toys in his cage and apparently he was as good as gold, although at home, he sleeps on the rugs - only the really fluffy ones.

ScrollingLeaves · 16/12/2022 11:24

As well as chicken and rice to settle his tummy, those economy bags of frozen white fish are useful. They are thin filets so you can just boil one from frozen when you need it.

mum11970 · 16/12/2022 11:23

Whilst I don’t think sleeping without blankets is cruel I would try and section the dog in a small area of the kitchen with an open cage whilst he can’t hold his poo rather than have him shut in. Sectional dog pens aren’t hugely expensive but a baby fireguard would probably work in the corner of a room if you have one

HenPenJen1789 · 16/12/2022 11:23

I haven’t read the whole thread, sorry, but Just to say my dog did this (wee and poo overnight) when he was on steroids, but the issue resolved when he came off them. Hope he’s ok.

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 16/12/2022 11:22

Crates are not cruel if they are used correctly. What is cruel is shutting a dog, with an upset stomach, in a crate, with no bedding in sub zero temperatures. and a vet has come onto the thread to confirm this, but that doesn't suit the OP does it.

Why didn't you post this in the Doghouse thread OP? You'd get even worse there I can assure you. A dog is a living creature with needs and feelings, just like a toddler at that age. They are hard work, you need to watch them, you need to get up with them in the night and let them out if they are unwell. But its clear to anyone on here you are entirely concerned with convenience for yourself and your "young children" - so why get a dog? If you are that concerned about hygiene for these poor young children? Did you not realise a dog shits? You need vet pads and probiotics, you can get a paste from the vet and/or use a little bit of probiotic yoghurt easily available in a supermarket.

People like you are never in the wrong. About anything, let alone a dog's welfare. Your responses drip with contempt.

Suzi888 · 16/12/2022 11:22

Yes it’s bloody Baltic.
Crates ok for training if you have a
chewer or what you have you, agree they’re for people who just can’t be bothered long term. Chuck them in the crate, at least own it, they’re for human convenience if the dog is locked in. This one gets the bonus of lying in his own shit. Jesus wept.

Snoodsy · 16/12/2022 11:22

Of course it is cruel, for fuck sake. It is disgusting that you would want your (I would say family member but your poor dog is clearly not that) dog to sleep encaged on a cramped plastic slab away from all human contract. I hope your post is not in good faith. Sleep on your tile floor tonight and get back to me.

Do you have him on new food? This could cause a disruption in bowel habits. If not, take him to the vet and find out what’s wrong with him. This type of unusual behavior is vet-worthy. He’s not pooping himself because he enjoys sleeping in his shit. In the meantime take him outside an extra time during the night.

Ch3wylemon · 16/12/2022 11:21

As multiple PP have said dogs hate pooing where they sleep.
They also like to pop in roughly the same spot.

You need to end the association with pooing and the crate.start by cleaning and disinfecting it as thoroughly as you can.

Then you need to teach him to poo somewhere else. He will choose to pop as far as he can from his crate, for example the corner diametrically opposed to it. Line this corner with puppy pads and leave the crate door open.

Take him out late at night. Sleep with your door open Every time you hear him get up - you get up to check on him. If he has made a mess let him out, clear up and lay clean pads. It will mean a few nights poor sleep for you, but he will stop pooing in his bed. And once his stomach is better you can sleep easy again.

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 16/12/2022 11:20

Get the dog to the vet ASAP and see if you can get something for his tummy. No animal wants to toilet in their own bed. We used to have a very naughty cocker spaniel who would frequently eat things he wasn't supposed to and then end up with an upset stomach (not in his bed though) and we would give him poached chicken and plain boiled rice - small, frequent meals - until it settled. God I miss that dog. Our vet advised us to do the poached chicken when our cat had an upset stomach last year too, plus give her the water out of the poaching pan to drink.